News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by ebg13 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:09PM (#21982680)
> The price of domains should trend down. not up.

Why? The value of a dollar goes down over time, but the value of a domain does not.

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by gmiller123456 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:59PM (#21983333)
>The value of a dollar goes down over time.

Value and Cost are very different things. ICANN is a governing organization, and once they're allowed to extract funds greater than what it costs them to operate, just means they're abusing their power.

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by DailyHN on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:15PM (#21982762)
I'd bet Moore's law has outpaced inflation.

The value of high-demand domain names should increase on the secondary markets. But, the price of unregistered names should be decreasing.

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by Tepix on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:21PM (#21982846)
It's not about the value of the name, it's about the cost of running a TLD.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by jandrese on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:35PM (#21983016)
The cost of running the system is trivial.

Domains are more like real estate. They can become almost arbitrarily expensive on the global market because they represent a somewhat exhaustible resource of phrases that people can actually remember.

As with any system where you have private resource owners controlling a basic need you should expect corruption and abuse of the customer base. From Water Barons to Landlords to Cable/Broadband companies the pattern repeats itself time and time again. This is why we have regulated industries.

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by vxNsr on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @04:09PM (#21984879)
But the governing org shouldn't be the one extracting that value. their job is govern and to some extent regulate. anything else is outside their domain.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by jandrese on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:32PM (#21985852)
If not the governing org then who? It's not in the public interest to facilitate or encourage rent seeking. To the extent that price differences are inevitable in a market based system (where we assume the party most worthy of a domain is the one willing to put the most money into acquiring it), it only makes sense that the money be used for the public good.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by lostlogin on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:30PM (#21982942)
Who gives a TLD it’s value? I don’t think it’s ICANN.