News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Myths about Diabetes by calibas on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:26PM (#21962417)
I hate that they begin with "No, you don’t get it from eating too many sweets." Then later they admit that Type 2 diabetes risk is greatly increased by an unhealthy diet.

So you can get diabetes from an unhealthy diet, like a diet with too many sweets.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by sithlord on Sunday January 05, 2020 @01:32PM (#21962940)
You dont get diabetes from eating "too many sweets". If you have a disposition to type 2 diabetes, and you eat too many sweets, then sure the symptoms are more likely to show sooner.

A quit google, shows that ~40% of americans are obese, and around 9% of americans have type 2 diabetes. If eating poorly lead to diabetes (and didnt just expose the symptoms) then those numbers would be much closer.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by nradov on Sunday January 05, 2020 @01:51PM (#21963083)
More than a third of American adults have prediabetes. The A1c dividing line between prediabetes and full Type 2 diabetes is essentially arbitrary. Eating too many sweets is absolutely a proven risk factor.

https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/basics/prediabetes.html

Re:Myths about Diabetes by everfree on Sunday January 05, 2020 @02:14PM (#21963230)
> You dont get diabetes from eating "too many sweets". If you have a disposition to type 2 diabetes, and you eat too many sweets, then sure the symptoms are more likely to show sooner.

I don't think this is really a useful distinction. If you eat a lot of sugar and "get diabetes", i.e. it becomes clinically significant, then it would be just as correct to blame your sugar intake as to blame your genetics.

It's quite known that sugar intake is strongly correlated with diabetes: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3584048/

Re:Myths about Diabetes by sithlord on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:52PM (#21965172)
I dont think anyone is arguing that sugar intake isn't correlated with type 2 diabetes surfacing. But, that same person would start showing eventually regardless, just may not be as soon.

People with type 2 diabetes, genetically, have trouble removing glucose from cells, this is a fact, eating too much sugar, means that the cells become full sooner, and the body shows that it can't deal with it.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by gowld on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @08:24AM (#21979657)
When it shows matters a lot. I hope my diabetes shows after I die.
Re:Myths about Diabetes by Kye on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:31PM (#21962460)
This kind of false attribution is how we got a market full of "low fat" foods packed with sugar. It seems like "don't eat too much sugar" should be a harmless, practical abstraction, but people will go off and eat a diet that still leads to type 2 diabetes while avoiding obvious sugars. And missing non-obvious ones.

For example: A "healthy" serving of plain corn flakes with a serving of plain milk has lots of sugar in it. Foods can have low added sugar, or low some-kind-of sugar, and still lead to type 2 diabetes. Focusing on sugar will lead to the same health disaster that came from focusing on salt or fat.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by gowld on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @08:28AM (#21979679)
Your example is still high sugar.

The anti fat crusade was a marketing lie sponsored by sugar /corn syrup manufacturers.

No one's confused into thinking sugar is good, they just like eating junk food.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by ng12 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:28PM (#21962435)
It's explained in the article:

> Type 1 diabetes develops as a result of genetic risk and an unclear trigger; it’s not caused by eating sugar — or anything else... The story for Type 2 diabetes is a bit more complicated.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by calibas on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:32PM (#21962472)
That explains the difference between Type 1 and Type 2. I made sure to be clear which type I was talking about though.
Re:Myths about Diabetes by adrianmonk on Sunday January 05, 2020 @03:10PM (#21963700)
They say, "Too much sugar, per se, won’t give you diabetes."

The "per se" makes it plenty clear (to me at least) that their point is that sugar does not DIRECTLY cause diabetes.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by calibas on Sunday January 05, 2020 @03:35PM (#21963871)
I'm not following this logic, we don't know what the direct cause of diabetes Type 2 is, but there's evidence it's linked to sugar.

What this means is that you can't authoritatively state that sugar is the cause of diabetes. It does not mean that sugar has been proven to not be the cause.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by sithlord on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:56PM (#21965191)
type 1 diabetes - beta cells (which create insuling) in the pancreas get destroyed by autoimmune disease)

type 2 diabetes - cells that hold glucose are resistant to insulin produced by the body.

As in, Sugar almost certainly doesn't cause type 2 diabetes but causes the symptoms to surface because of the inability to remove the excess glucose from the cells.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by calibas on Sunday January 05, 2020 @11:20PM (#21966413)
None of that actually answers what causes insulin resistance to develop in type 2 diabetes. You can't claim that sugar "almost certainly" isn't the cause.
Re:Myths about Diabetes by dghughes on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:33PM (#21962478)
If you have diabetes you crave sweets due to having diabetes. Sugar doesn't cause diabetes.

You eat food because you are hungry. Food doesn't not cause hunger.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by calibas on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:37PM (#21962516)
By all means, tell me what causes Type 2 diabetes then. The actual science is unclear, but it's linked to your diet.
Re:Myths about Diabetes by projektfu on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:56PM (#21964798)
Cats get a diabetic syndrome that is very similar to type 2 diabetes. Almost all healthy cats are fed the same basic nutrients. There is usually no added sugar in a cat's diet. Diabetes doesn't select for cats that only ate particular brands of cat food. Most housecats get fat but do not get diabetes. Changing the diet helps but insulin is often necessary for treatment (as cats' pancreases can get exhausted). There are theories that feeding a high-fat low-carb diet may reduce the incidence of diabetes in cats but it hasn't been tried on a scale large enough to know.

Metabolic syndrome is definitely multifactorial and causation is difficult to establish. Not saying you're wrong, but nobody has ruled out its causes.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by skohan on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:53PM (#21962674)
Yes - I mean if diet doesn't contribute to diabetes, then why has there been a correlation between obesity, type 2 diabetes incidence, and increased sugar and simple carbs in the standard American diet?

I am not an endocrinologist, but the idea that habitual abuse of the body's insulin system causes a pathology in that system - at least in vulnerable individuals - is much more plausible than the idea that we're all getting diabetes from the water or something and that's why we're drinking soda and eating unhealthy foods.

If there is some plausible alternate theory, or some contradicting evidence I would be very interested to hear it.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by calibas on Sunday January 05, 2020 @01:03PM (#21962757)
In my opinion at least, the science is clear. The human body isn't built for large amounts of heavily processed foods, and consuming them in excess causes a whole spectrum of health issues.

This is all made worse because health science is heavily influenced by the same industries that profit enormously off of processed foods.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by gowld on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @08:33AM (#21979728)
"Heavily processed" is not a scientific term.

People don't eat boxes (but perhaps they should, because the actual danger in processed foods is removing fiber.)

Fruit juice is terrible but not heavily processed.

Sugar is not heavily processed.

Baking cakes and deep frying everything at home is not heavily processed.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by toast0 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @02:19PM (#21963263)
If you have type 2 diabetes, and your diet is not high in carbs/refined sugar, you may never experience significant symptoms and never seek diagnosis or treatment.

If you then add refined sugar to your diet in a big way, you would likely start seeing symptoms, and might seek diagnosis and claim eating lots of candy caused diabetes, but it could have already been there.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by skohan on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:17AM (#21966956)
Can you provide any evidence that diabetes precedes dietary changes?

My understanding is that there’s a pretty clear well-understood progression from obesity to pre-diabetes (which is measurable in terms of resting blood glucose, but usually not symptomatic) to diabetes. Insulin resistance is also reversible to some extent via dietary changes.

So I am having difficulty understanding how it could be that diabetes would proceed dietary changes in this scenario.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by toast0 on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:46AM (#21967336)
If a person were insulin resistant (type 2 diabetes), but did not consume a lot of carbohydrates, how would you know they were insulin resistant?

Their blood sugar (fasting or otherwise) would most likely look fine, and you wouldn't subject them to a glucose tolerance test, because it's unpleasant to drink the glucose solution, and you have to sit in the lab for two hours before the second blood sugar test --- you wouldn't do that for an apparently healthy person.

If they changed their diet, and began to show symptoms of diabetes, and led to a diagnosis of type 2 diabetes, would you say the change in diet caused the disease?

If glucose tolerance tests were regularly administered to (apparently) healthy people, we could have some data or anecdotes about people having good insulin response, then changing their diet and no longer having good insulin response as 'eating too much candy gives you diabetes' suggests.

I 100% agree that there's a correlation between obesity, increased carbohydrate content in diets, and increased diagnosis of insulin resistance. I'm just not convinced that there's a correlation between those things and insulin resistance. I suspect that without the increased carbohydrates, many people would have asymptomatic insulin resistance and go undiagnosed -- after all, dietary changes are a preferred treatment once insulin resistance is diagnosed.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by skohan on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:22AM (#21967515)
Do you have any evidence behind what you are saying, or is this pure speculative reasoning?

> Their blood sugar (fasting or otherwise) would most likely look fine, and you wouldn't subject them to a glucose tolerance test, because it's unpleasant to drink the glucose solution, and you have to sit in the lab for two hours before the second blood sugar test --- you wouldn't do that for an apparently healthy person.

Why do you think this test is never performed on apparently healthy individuals? Do you think they never established a baseline for these tests using a large number of healthy individuals?

Re:Myths about Diabetes by toast0 on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:49PM (#21973141)
How about this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2603306/#S3titl...

> These findings suggest that the vast majority of Pima Indians susceptible to diabetes were already developing the disease in the early years of the study, and the increasing obesity in youth combined with a nearly 4-fold increase in the frequency of exposure to diabetes in utero [7] simply shifted the onset of diabetes to younger ages in the most susceptible individuals [6].

This wording suggest to me that while diet (and changes in diet), can change the onset of diagnosis, it does not cause the disease, it's a trigger for the disease in people that are susceptible.

This is a big difference in my mind, because it can change blanket advice of 'don't eat too much candy or you'll get diabetes', into 'if you're susceptible to (type 2) diabetes, don't eat too much candy or you'll show symptoms of diabetes'. The first option undermines trust in the advice giver, because there are many examples of people who eat too much candy and don't get diabetes; the second example isn't super actionable, because it's hard to know if you're susceptible, but a history of diagnosis in your family or other genetic grouping is a sign.

This is the same with the blanket war on obesity as a health risk. A large portion of the comorbidity with obesity comes from type 2 diabetes; but the distributed health advice is that all persons with obesity have higher risks, despite evidence that persons with obesity but not type 2 diabetes have pretty similar risks to those without both obesity and type 2 diabetes.

Re:Myths about Diabetes by bobjob on Sunday January 05, 2020 @01:03PM (#21962755)
Genetics and to much body fat(you do not have to be overweight for that).
Re:Myths about Diabetes by chiefalchemist on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:41PM (#21962562)
It would be more accurate to say: You eat because you feel hungry. That feeling of hunger can be influenced by what you eat. Tweak your hormones (e.g., insulin) the wrong way and you end up feeling hungry even if you don't actually need to eat.

Long to short, yes food can (indirectly) cause hunger.