News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by iamaelephant on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @01:49PM (#21929716)
I very strongly disagree with #3. Machine learning has not yet proved its value outside of a handful of key areas (image recognition, voice recognition/synthesizing, etc). I think it's entirely possible we'll look back on today as a kind of machine learning mania. I certainly believe there is plenty of room to build sustainable businesses without a machine learning asset (and the associated data collection), and it's in no way "table stakes for every tech company, large and small".
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @01:57PM (#21929772)
You're wrong. Machine Learning is driving all of the ad placement on major ad platforms, personalization on all top social/media apps, search ranking for google, translation, speech recognition, finance, fraud detection.

In the next decade it will start taking over computer graphics, medicine, manufacturing, surveillance, hardware / software and every other aspect of our lives.

EDIT: for people who are downvoting me, here are some examples of how machine learning is and will transform our lives:

1. 3D graphics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlgLxSLsYWQ Andrew Price doesn't have a technical background but does a decent job summarizing some of the ways deep learning will transform computer graphics. Soon all of the mocap, character design and animation will be driven by deep learning systems.

2. Computer Architecture and Traditional Software: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTpKWOuzOxc There's a ton of recent research showing that you can use machine learning to beat human crafted heuristics in hardware, scheduling, compiler design and query planning.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by eitland on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:09PM (#21929841)
> Machine Learning is driving all of the ad placement on major ad platforms, personalization on all top social/media apps, search ranking for google,

Yep, and the results are hilarious or tragic depending on how you look at it:

We keep getting ads for the thing we bought yesterday, ads for dating sites after we got married and had kids (continously, for ten years despite my utter lack of interest), search results keep getting worse[0], obvious spammers keep on spamming in social media (seriously, it seems a simple regex filter could have done a better job to reduce crypto scamming in replies on Twitter than whatever was there last time I checked.)

[0]: some people will always claim it is because black hat SEO is so much worse, but that doesn't explain why Google sometimes can neither understand doublequotes nor the verbatim option anymore. That is not the result of black hat SEO but of sloppy maintenance, and I guess so is a number of other problems.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:23PM (#21929917)
> We keep getting ads for the thing we bought yesterday, ads for dating sites after we got married and had kids (continously, for ten years despite my utter lack of interest), search results keep getting worse[0], obvious spammers keep on spamming in social media (seriously, it seems a simple regex filter could have done a better job to reduce crypto scamming in replies on Twitter than whatever was there last time I checked.)

That's because in a lot of cases they're optimizing for the wrong metrics, as in maximizing their revenue instead of your utility.

There's way more content on the web than there was in the early 2000s, most of it in form of "content marketing" and explicitly attempting to game the system.

If you look at recent results from TREC, it's pretty clear that machine learning provides a large boost over the traditional retrieval systems, on any metric that you want to optimize.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by OnlineGladiator on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:55PM (#21930142)
> That's because in a lot of cases they're optimizing for the wrong metrics, as in maximizing their revenue instead of your utility.

What? How do they maximize their revenue by spending money on ads the users actually laugh about for how bad their targeting is?

Based on what I know about machine learning - it almost always gives great short-term results, and it almost always fails to deliver the expected long-term results. What's worse is this comes with the weirdest most indecipherable bugs that pop up more and more over time. Unless you have a large enough database to show statistical errors that are negligible (something like 99.9999% precision or recall, depending on your metrics), you should assume it will break in ways you cannot possibly predict. And even then, you might be using the wrong training data without even realizing it.

I'm not saying ML is bad, although I am saying it is ridiculously overhyped. I'm saying ML is still nascent enough nobody really knows how a lot of edge cases will shake out, simply because there are too many edge cases to test before putting it into production.

It's not hard to find examples of ML algorithms gone wrong even for sites like Amazon.

https://gizmodo.com/amazon-prime-day-glitch-let-people-buy-1...

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:02PM (#21930201)
Recommending something you bought before is probably a much better bet than showing you random items from their huge catalogue.

You can have a system that generates them a ton of cash while making mistakes in some cases, outliers are inevitable and feedback loops in recommender systems can lead to such issues. Amazon wouldn't deploy these systems if they didn't move the needle.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by OnlineGladiator on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:09PM (#21930245)
Nobody is saying the ML algorithm (or any algorithm) is expected to be perfect.

> Amazon wouldn't deploy these systems if they didn't move the needle.

This is an appeal to authority that Amazon executives are immune to making mistakes. They could have bad metrics. They could have bad incentives encouraging managers to make poor decisions (basically this describes everything wrong with Google today). They could be incompetent. They could be focused on short-term gains at the expense of long-term gains because it maximizes their personal net wealth and they can just jump ship in a few years.

Again, nobody is saying ML algorithms are worthless. I just don't believe (and have lots of reasons based on personal experience I won't go into) that they are 10% as useful as the industry wants you to believe.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:21PM (#21930322)
I'm saying that they have systems in place to measure the impact of the code that they put in production on their bottom line and if those recommendations didn't move their profit margins in the right direction they wouldn't be using them.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by eitland on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:39PM (#21930462)
> I'm saying that they have systems in place to measure the impact of the code that they put in production on their bottom line

There's a story, and I think it was (re)posted here recently about a series of MBAs all optimizing the cost of the burger bums by removing seeds until there are three seeds neatly laid out at the top.

It might be measurable all the way but at some point it becomes ridiculous. For me that time was some months ago. For the rest of Internet they might manage to reduce the quality once or twice more before it becomes obvious.

This is my way of fighting back. By posting here and on my blog and getting upvoted a lot for pointing out what many can already feel. By letting people who read HN know that yes, that feeling they have that a lot of their ads are wasted because of bad targeting might very well be true.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @04:13PM (#21930683)
That's definitely true, maximizing shareholder value is all about extracting as much value as possible from your customers, until it no longer works.

I'm against most forms of recommendations as well, that doesn't mean that they're not valuable to the businesses deploying them. In most cases the end users of these systems are not the real customers of these platforms, and they're there to serve the advertisers who keep these businesses running.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by OnlineGladiator on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:25PM (#21930362)
I know what you're saying. I don't think you understand what I'm saying, which is those systems can be wrong or they might not be optimizing for the bottom line. Why didn't their systems catch that bug that was discounting expensive equipment for more than 90% that I linked in my previous post? People make mistakes. And for a frame of reference, Google's corporate policies definitely don't optimize for the bottom line, and it took a minimum of 5 years for it to affect them negatively (I'd guess closer to 10+).

Anyway, agree to disagree.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by smsm42 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @11:11PM (#21932964)
> Recommending something you bought before is probably a much better bet

Not if it's something I only buy once a year, for example. That's where "learning" part should come in. You don't need any learning to just parrot me back my inputs.

> Amazon wouldn't deploy these systems if they didn't move the needle.

I don't know about Amazon, but I've recently read on HN some articles strongly suggesting almost nobody is properly measuring the impact of ads, let alone the impact of "targeting". In most cases, people more or less just stuff money into ads budgets, because that's what you do, and they get customers - because people still need to buy things, regardless of any targeting - but the casual link between the former and the latter is not really very well established.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by smsm42 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @11:06PM (#21932946)
> in maximizing their revenue instead of your utility.

I am not sure how these are contradictory. My interest is buying things I want. Their interest is selling me things I'd buy. How showing dating site ads to a married person promotes any of those? Where the revenue would come from? Or do you mean it's ad agency revenue, not advertiser revenue? In that case we clearly have a case of agent problem.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by harryh on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @07:52PM (#21932017)
We keep getting ads for the thing we bought yesterday

This does not demonstrate that the machine learning algorithms are doing a bad job. Quite the opposite really. See:

https://twitter.com/patio11/status/875629380105416705

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by saghm on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @08:13PM (#21932122)
2% of households returning their refrigerators and buying a new one seems pretty high, although I don't have any data to back this up. How many people reading this have made multiple (separate) refrigerator purchases in a week?
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by smsm42 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @11:14PM (#21932985)
With arbitrary assumptions about statistics, you can "statistically prove" pretty much anything. Until the 2% figure is substantiated, it's all baloney.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by harryh on Thursday January 02, 2020 @07:58AM (#21934979)
There's also the fact that advertisers spend many millions of dollars buying these ads, so they have a pretty large financial incentive to do it well.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by smsm42 on Thursday January 02, 2020 @08:07PM (#21941932)
You are assuming there's a way to do it well and not well, but what if nobody actually knows how it is - doing it well? What if marketing is just given a budget of X million dollars to spend on advertising, but nobody there actually knows whether doing X or Y works, but they know everybody does X, so if they do X, there's no chance they'd be fired for that?
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by chubot on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:05PM (#21929817)
Machine learning finally came of age in the 2010s and is now table stakes for every tech company, large and small.

I would say it's table stakes for large companies in certain areas, but not small (see my other reply).

Machine learning seems to be good at squeezing percentage points out of monopoly with a business that already works. That's very different than "table stakes for small companies". Small companies need optimize their product with fundamental changes.

For example, in the early days of AirBNB there was a more inconsistent user experience, which you heard about in the media. I think they addressed those problems with policies, incentives, and some elbow grease (kicking bad users off the platform, etc.). Not machine learning. Machine learning doesn't help you expand into Europe or Asia, etc.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by ken on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:10PM (#21930252)
ML is certainly valuable for speech recognition, translation, and fraud detection, but those are somewhat niche applications. It's a long way from "every tech company, large and small".

As for ad placement, social media, and search ranking: is that actually effective? The one constant with ads and social media and web search, IME, is that it just never gets any better. From the Lycos/AltaVista days to Google there was a huge jump in search result quality, and then it plateaued.

The ads I see online are still laughably bad. They're more professionally produced than 10 or 20 years ago, but they're still never for any category of product that I'd ever buy. Targeted and tracked advertising seems like a big scam.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by WalterBright on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:37AM (#21933255)
I cannot recall ever buying anything from any ad targeted at me through a website I visit. Am I a unique snowflake in that the AI always guesses wrong for just me, or is AI based advertising simply a total failure?

I have bought many things from ads related to the media I am reading. For example, I read muscle car magazines, and buy parts/tools from the ads in those magazines. Back in the era of print mags, my company would do well placing ads for compilers next to relevant programming articles.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:29PM (#21930390)
> ML is certainly valuable for speech recognition, translation, and fraud detection, but those are somewhat niche applications. It's a long way from "every tech company, large and small".

Those were just some of the most visible examples. OCR, image recognition, NLP and speech recognition alone are enough to revolutionize most data entry jobs and we'll see a ton of startups using them to do just that for every industry.

There are countless other examples of machine learning applications, including drug discovery, radiology, production line quality assurance, etc.

> The ads I see online are still laughably bad.

Have ads ever been good? You see the ads that you're seeing because someone is paying a lot of money to put them there.

Bloomberg spent 120 million on ads last month, ad platforms had to find eyeballs for them.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by hakfoo on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @09:27PM (#21932482)
IMO, you can get a pretty good ad experience by sticking to content-targeted ads.

If I'm looking at, for example, "how to programmatically control my model railway with a Raspberry Pi", there's a large number of easy to target, relevant products you can advertise against that. You don't need a gigabyte of creepy backstory on me to figure out "hey, show me ads for the products mentioned in the article, and there's a good chance I'll buy them because it's convenient."

Yeah, Mike Bloomberg might be willing to pay $1 to show his ugly mug next to that page, but the ad from a modeler's supply shop, who would only have paid 95 cents, would have felt much more appropriate to the consumer. I know some ad networks try to measure quality via clickthrough rate, but I'm not sure it was weighted in a way to nerf this issue.

Another problem is that a pure-content model doesn't extend to all types of site. There's no suitable product to advertise against "six die in New Year's party gone horribly wrong." and nobody wanted to run low-yield CPM branding ads, so they had to backfill wth retargeting and profile-based ads instead.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by louisv on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @08:57PM (#21932349)
Because the fault here doesn't lie with ML, but with errors of judgment made by humans when setting up the targeting demographics for their ads.

There's still a lot of anti-data sentiment in the paid ad industry, where media buyers will guide themselves by what they think their customer looks like, and not what data tells them it is.

And until this is a fixed behavior, you'll keep on seeing untargeted ads.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by ekianjo on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @09:19PM (#21932441)
> In the next decade it will start taking over computer graphics, medicine, manufacturing, surveillance, hardware / software and every other aspect of our lives.

The counter-example to your point is that deep learning maniacs were predicting self driving to be a done deal by 2020 and we now realize we are so far away from that goal. Machine learning will only work well for one-pony tricks problems that can be clearly isolated. Nothing like "every other aspect of our lives".

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by ksec on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:58AM (#21933319)
I think people are downvoting you because of the word you are wrong, might be I disagree would be a better phase.

I do think in general Machine learning is only just started with respect to All industry, not just tech. There is so much shown what could be done, the next 10 years will be very interesting.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by cm2012 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:06PM (#21929822)
This guy is downvoted but he's right. A huge amount of Facebook's and Google's value growth comes from machine learning driving their various algorithms.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by agumonkey on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @07:21PM (#21931838)
Any link on ml use in medicine ?
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by smsm42 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @10:55PM (#21932901)
> Machine Learning is driving all of the ad placement on major ad platforms

And the results are, as far as I can see, horrible. I mean yes, if I make a mistake to search for shoes on Google, half of the internet will be showing me shoe ads for the next 6 months (how many feet do you think I have? Do you think I buy shoes in dozens?) - but presenting it as the triumph of ML is IMHO an overreach.

> personalization on all top social/media apps

From what I see, the same apps struggle to not get sued because of the said personalization regularly pushes sex content on kids, triggers on snowflakes and election interference on potential voters. Or at least that's what I hear every time next round of censorship is introduced into the social media. Somehow I am still not seeing a cause for celebration here.

> search ranking for google

Same as above, plus one shouldn't use Google search anyway. Use DuckDuckGo.

> translation, speech recognition

OK, here it got pretty good results, though sometimes it is as good as a very drunk chimp who got into a dictionary store, but in many other times it's decent. You get this one.

> finance, fraud detection

As a consumer, haven't noticed it. 100% of fraud on my cards have been detected by me reviewing my credit card statements. 100% of fraud alerts by banks have been false positives. I do not begrudge that specifically, I'd better have false positives than more fraud, but not seeing much ML-driven progress there tbh.

> In the next decade it will start taking over computer graphics, medicine, manufacturing, surveillance, hardware / software and every other aspect of our lives.

Not sure what "computer graphics" means, medicine probably not, surveillance maybe, but that's exactly the opposite of what I'd want, software definitely not even close, for the rest I'm not even sure what you're talking about.

> here's a ton of recent research showing that you can use machine learning to beat human crafted heuristics in hardware, scheduling, compiler design and query planning.

I'll believe it when I see ML-driven code generator doing something useful without tight supervision by humans. I can believe ML doing specific heuristics better (heck, doing exactly that has been part of my job recently) but there's a huge difference between "figure out exactly how much sugar makes the specific cookie recipe taste the best" and "invent whole cookie recipe from scratch and bake the cookie". I am sure ML would be useful for the former, for the latter... I'll believe it when I see it.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by Entalpi on Thursday January 02, 2020 @02:40AM (#21933639)
Machine learning is interesting in computer graphics for denoising path traced images för example. There also some uses in game developmemt where graphicsl artefacts might be detected during automated test runs instead of having an army of QA people.

Pretty sure ML have shown promising results in cancer classification in images (such as xray, etc). Not sure how this will pan out but the limited scope seems ideal .

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by redisman on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:33AM (#21933249)
> fraud detection

Having worked in this industry for a while I just want to point out that the vast majority of fraud detection is done for the merchant, not the customer.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by smsm42 on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:41AM (#21933265)
OK, that makes sense. Hopefully there's some progress there.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by CapmCrackaWaka on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:10PM (#21929851)
I think machine learning masquerading as AI is definitely over-hyped. The real revolution is open source predictive modeling and statistical techniques becoming commonplace. Creating statistical models is much more useful and applicable to 99% of the businesses that have a need for analytics, but it seems to be overshadowed by the AI hype.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:48PM (#21930094)
AI and machine learning have no business being mentioned in the same sentence. The AI hype is pushed by marketers and journalists because it gets clicks and invites the futurist crowd to chime in. We're decades away from anything that will resemble an AI system and any talk of it now is a waste of time.

Machine Learning has made amazing strides in the past decade and will change all aspects of our lives. There will be a ton of startups in the next decade using speech recognition, image recognition, natural language processing and etc to automate all of our repetitive tasks. If hardware keeps up we'll probably see a boom in robotics in the next 5-15 years that will allow us to automate most manufacturing and food production.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by aianus on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:57PM (#21931344)
> We're decades away from anything that will resemble an AI system

I use my Google Home Mini every day and it's just like the computer in Star Trek. If you could show it to someone from the early 90s they would certainly say it resembles an AI system.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by barbecue_sauce on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @07:52PM (#21932015)
Google Home is basically the text parser of an early Sierra adventure game with voice recognition in front of it and the internet in back of it.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by ekianjo on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @09:22PM (#21932459)
It's not, it's a toolchain that has voice recognition, a NLP parser, and a big model to give you answers back that fails for anything remotely like a complex sentence. It's decent, but nothing like an intelligent being that can answer all types of questions like in most SF stories.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by why_only_15 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @10:48PM (#21932882)
This is just pushing the meaning of "artificial intelligence" farther up the chain because we understand it better. If you told someone in 1950 computers would be able to win 100 times out of 100 against the best humans in the world, they would call that artificial intelligence. Now we just say it's a MCTS system based on heavily tuned heuristics.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by rodw on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @11:47PM (#21933102)
I have travelled here from the early 90s and I gotta say it seems more like a parlor trick (voice recognition plus a much larger, more sophisticated, networked Eliza) than true AI. But that's the AI problem in a nutshell: Once we've figured out how to do something it no longer seems like an AI problem.

The computer in Star Trek is just a smart speaker. Lt. Cmdr. Data is AI.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by CapmCrackaWaka on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @04:52PM (#21930975)
Sure there will be a (ton??) of startups using these things, but my point is that it will not be nearly as prevalent as general statistics and predictive modeling. Which one do you think will be more common: 1) companies using speech recognition, NLP, Image recognition, etc. 2) companies using R/Python to help guide their business decisions through predictive models / simpler statistics?

I believe the demand for companies to actually use the fancier parts of machine learning are going to be much fewer than people think. Number 2, on the other hand, is much more generalizable, and is having a much larger effect on the 'average' business than NLP and image recognition.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:25PM (#21931166)
Operations research and business analytics will obviously continue to be important but we'll also start seeing machine learning replacing a lot of labor and augmenting a large portion of our daily tasks. It will change how we interact with computers.

I used to work at an image recognition API startup and went through an AI incubator with my own company so I got to see the huge range of applications of this technology. At the incubator we had a company automating customer support (acquired by google), another one automating appointment booking and scheduling, sales call analytics using speech recognition, automatic reading comprehension quizzes for K-12, deep learning for radiology, patient tracking/monitoring at retirement homes and hospitals, imitation learning based robotics, deep learning based hedge fund, amazon go like vending machines, fashion analytics, social media analytics/engagement for brands.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by falcor84 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:46PM (#21930508)
This is just semantics. What you're referring to as AI is often given the name AGI (Artificial General Intelligence), while many (most?) would agree that AI includes nowadays common technologies such as maps pathfinding and grammar checking.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @04:04PM (#21930629)
I've been doing machine learning for almost 10 years now and can tell you from experience that when a layman hears AI they think AGI, a magic pixie dust that can solve any problem that they throw it at.

AI is a branch of computer science, but outside of A* search it's practically all machine learning.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by ekianjo on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @09:21PM (#21932455)
> esemble an AI system and any talk of it now is a waste of time.

I think the usual terms we use nowadays is narrow AI and general AI to differentiate both types.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by chubot on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @01:57PM (#21929771)
Yup, I came here to question that as well.

What are some examples of companies that hinged on machine learning?

DATA is crucial, but that's very different than "sophistiated machine learning models". For example, do Uber and Lyft need machine learning?

As far as I can tell, they need data about drivers, users, ride completion, maps, and a lot of people doing simple statistics on that data and improving the product. Machine learning might give them a few percentage points in some specific subsystem, but it isn't going to make or break the product as a whole. It's not "table stakes".

Pick another industry and do the same thought experiment. What are some other breakout companies? Did snapchat succeed (in its day) because of machine learning? What about AirBNB? I think they are optimizing the product with "data science", not machine learning. Certainly not deep learning.

Machine learning finally came of age in the 2010s and is now table stakes for every tech company, large and small. Accumulating a data asset around your product and service and using sophisticated machine learning models to personalize and improve your product is not a nice to have.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by AndrewKemendo on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:26PM (#21929934)
You would be astonished at some of the non-public (not that they are secret) machine learning things that Uber does that you wouldn't even be aware of.

My favorite is that they do pothole detection, prediction and routing around based on what they classified based on driver accelerometer data. They've also reduced traffic incidents with insights from the same dataset that drove product changes.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by chubot on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:39PM (#21930020)
That's interesting, and in line with what I perceived as Uber's extreme focus on operations.

To me, the accelerometer DATA is the new and important thing -- it's the thing that taxi companies don't have.

Whether the machine learning model is "sophisticated" doesn't seem critical on the face of it.

I guess it depends whether there are a lot of non-pothole events that look like pothole events to "naive" signal processing. Do you need deep learning for this problem? I don't know but I would be skeptical without a citation.

But I am interested in more info and examples. If someone can give a bunch of examples I would adjust my view.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by AndrewKemendo on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @04:32PM (#21930819)
This is just nitpicking phrases at this point, a popular past time for us nerds, so I get it but it misses the point. "Sophisticated" is enough of a suitcase term that it's effectively worthless.

More importantly it's worth understanding that ML allows us to do things we couldn't do before, because it's cheaper and scales better than previous optimization methods, when you have the data.

So yes, the data infrastructure is the critical part, however the ML pipelines and Data Science work is what gives the massive multiplier at a cost/scale you can't get with traditional optimization methods.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:54PM (#21930136)
Amazon uses machine learning to forecast demand and ship products to warehouses before you order something. It's part of what makes their 1 day deliveries work. https://www.npr.org/2018/11/21/660168325/optimized-prime-how...

Data is obviously crucial, but it's useless if it's just sitting on hard drive. Machine learning allows them to squeeze out as much juice from it as possible, and a few % point lift makes a huge difference at scale, especially in high volume businesses with low margins per transaction.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by m_ke on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:36PM (#21929998)
Machine Learning is a technology the same way blockchain is. Customers buy products and solutions, not your tech stack so it doesn't make sense for any company to sell themselves as a machine learning company, unless you're selling APIs.

Alexa / Siri / Google Assistant would not be possible without machine learning. Same goes for Snapchat's filters and any other form of AR. Google's Pixel phones wouldn't have such a great camera without computational photography / machine learning.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:45PM (#21930069)
Those of us doing it mostly roll our eyes at how VCs and (especially) marketers describe it, so I agree with you, but the "is it ML or stats?" conversation has been going nowhere for as long as this round of AI hype has been here.

That said, uber and lyft certainly benefit from much more interesting ML and stats than just "simple statistics." For example, setting prices and incentives to properly balance the driver side against the rider side of the marketplace.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by chubot on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:06PM (#21930233)
Yeah I agree the argument is mostly about terminology. Anyway you slice it you have a bunch of data and you have a team that's improving the product with the data. That is for sure "table stakes".

And yes I probably should have said "data science" or "statistics" rather than "simple statistics", definitely for Uber and Lyft (less so for smaller companies).

I worked on a data science team 10 years ago when it was called "statistics". I even remember a 2009 NYTimes article that talked about data science without using the word "data science", because it hadn't come into use yet.

If people want to redefine "machine learning" to mean "data science", OK fine. I guess that's what's happening now. The term "data science" already annoyed some people, but I guess now it's "machine learning" and "deep learning".

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by morganherlocker on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:36PM (#21931215)
> For example, do Uber and Lyft need machine learning?

Anyone doing large scale ETA prediction and routing these days is using ML models at various phases in the pipeline, from GPS noise filtering to road network data generation. You might get past the early stages of a rideshare or delivery service with more traditional naive models, but there are still significant efficiency gains to be made in even the most cutting edge systems today. For maps and navigation, this is especially true when you go global and need models that adapt to subtle cultural and behavioral changes across markets.

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by CalChris on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:05PM (#21930220)
Strongly dis-disagree. Google's AlphaZero and AlphaGo look awfully fearsome. Generalizing from that to other expert endeavors seems inevitable rather than some sort of mania. Moreover, saying that chess and go aren't benchmark hard problems strikes me as a technical No True Scotsman because they were always seen as that before Alpha obliterated them.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by hakfoo on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @10:00PM (#21932644)
Chess and Go are constrained problem spaces. The space may be huge, but it's still finite. The win condition is unambiguous. The rules can fit on a postcard. There are only a finite number of possible board configurations.

Real-world win conditions tend to be more complex. For non-general AI tasks, this is much less of a problem. "Identify hot dog vs. not-hot-dog accurately 99% of the time" is measurable and verifiable. But a simple goal for a complex general-AI task is likely to build a Paperclip Optimizer. I suspect we don't even have the right language to build a good win condition for a lot of real world problems-- we may end up ignoring "insignificant" factors only to discover they're huge over tine or at scale.

Games also tend to provide near-perfect or perfect information. At a minimum, there's constrained state transitions. I can't pull out my Oyster card in the middle of a poker game, add it to my hand, and declare it's actually a four of clubs. Real problems can have surprise off-the-wall, or outright externally triggered transitions, that completely throw the model off.

"AI, build me a market-beating stock portfolio to cash out 2040-01-01" is a lot harder than "AI, checkmate this king."

Re:What Happened in the 2010s by CalChris on Thursday January 02, 2020 @08:28AM (#21935152)
I was replying to a comment about ML, not AI.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by eanzenberg on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @08:08PM (#21932099)
What an interesting thing to say when practically all user interactions in apps and devices are now driven by data science and machine learning. In fact you’d have to work real hard to use a device or service that hasn’t been tuned or driven by ml.
Re:What Happened in the 2010s by Psyladine on Thursday January 02, 2020 @04:42PM (#21940193)
The giveaway is in the text; "Machine Learning" is being propped up to support cloud architecture by the big 3.