> Amazon wouldn't deploy these systems if they didn't move the needle.
This is an appeal to authority that Amazon executives are immune to making mistakes. They could have bad metrics. They could have bad incentives encouraging managers to make poor decisions (basically this describes everything wrong with Google today). They could be incompetent. They could be focused on short-term gains at the expense of long-term gains because it maximizes their personal net wealth and they can just jump ship in a few years.
Again, nobody is saying ML algorithms are worthless. I just don't believe (and have lots of reasons based on personal experience I won't go into) that they are 10% as useful as the industry wants you to believe.
There's a story, and I think it was (re)posted here recently about a series of MBAs all optimizing the cost of the burger bums by removing seeds until there are three seeds neatly laid out at the top.
It might be measurable all the way but at some point it becomes ridiculous. For me that time was some months ago. For the rest of Internet they might manage to reduce the quality once or twice more before it becomes obvious.
This is my way of fighting back. By posting here and on my blog and getting upvoted a lot for pointing out what many can already feel. By letting people who read HN know that yes, that feeling they have that a lot of their ads are wasted because of bad targeting might very well be true.
I'm against most forms of recommendations as well, that doesn't mean that they're not valuable to the businesses deploying them. In most cases the end users of these systems are not the real customers of these platforms, and they're there to serve the advertisers who keep these businesses running.
Anyway, agree to disagree.
Not if it's something I only buy once a year, for example. That's where "learning" part should come in. You don't need any learning to just parrot me back my inputs.
> Amazon wouldn't deploy these systems if they didn't move the needle.
I don't know about Amazon, but I've recently read on HN some articles strongly suggesting almost nobody is properly measuring the impact of ads, let alone the impact of "targeting". In most cases, people more or less just stuff money into ads budgets, because that's what you do, and they get customers - because people still need to buy things, regardless of any targeting - but the casual link between the former and the latter is not really very well established.
You can have a system that generates them a ton of cash while making mistakes in some cases, outliers are inevitable and feedback loops in recommender systems can lead to such issues. Amazon wouldn't deploy these systems if they didn't move the needle.