This was about as far from being threatened with prison I've ever been... And believe me I've come pretty close to being arrested (during exercise of my 1st & 4th amendment rights on multiple occasions).
The effort to reduce the complexity of the 1040 into 6 new schedules was a great way to factor out those with complicated situations such that the majority of tax payers are oblivious to those nuances. The crux of the matter is that legislators passed into law all these onerous mass of rules to turn various levers to entice and discourage certain things and bite those with progressive tax rates. It is precisely the existence of these rules as to why the government doesn't know what tax valley you land in that huge parameter space. It will not presume to know your specific circumstances but assume that you being aware of your own money and circumstances are in the best position to know these things. At the least one thing I learned is that with tax laws if you have no idea what a thing is it probably in not applicable to you.
Needless to say all of this would be much more simple if we just pay a flat tax on all income for all people. Nothing simpler than that.
I wonder if I could FOIA myself my tax return from the IRS for the coming year haha.
Flat tax is totally unrelated and a conversation worth having. It's regressive, disproportionately impacts those least well off (the poor) and doesn't make sense when you index the taxes paid to the marginal utility of money. For someone who makes 10K/yr, 10% is 1K and may be the difference between rent and homelessness. For someone who makes 1M/yr 10% is 100K leaving them 900K to futz with. 1K to a poor person ls worth way way more than 100K to a rich person. That's why we don't do it. That's why almost nobody does it.
Flat tax is "simple" in the way it's always easier to re-write something from scratch: what you're left with tends to be a bastardization followed by a long and expensive lesson in how it got that way in the first place.
(For an example of what it might look like, the Canada Revenue Agency offers this already: https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/e-services/...)
But not instantly. And not all of it in time for April 15th. Sometimes those details don't make it to the IRS for years.
We don't yet live in a world of instantaneous information transfer about every American citizen to the government.
Some people also see that as a good thing.
And yet it has to get there by tax time so I’m having trouble believing it takes some tax forms literally years to make it to DC. Especially when you go to jail if they don’t.
> We don't yet live in a world of instantaneous information transfer about every American citizen to the government.
Buuuut it all has to get there by April 15th (actually February right) so I’m having trouble following this line of reasoning.
> Some people also see that as a good thing.
Why would information arriving quarterly (bi-weekly even) instead of annually be a bad thing when that information is legally bound to arrive at its destination anyways?
The only thing you're arguing is that the government shouldn't run their program a few months before you submit the documents, then send it to you for review, instead of afterwards and sending it to a tax judge. That's madness.
It sounds like you've never needed to file a revised tax form for a previous year. I have, and millions of other people do it each year.
Especially when you go to jail if they don’t.
The IRS doesn't show up on your doorstep on April 16th if you don't file. There's a process. A long, involved process. Even if you pay nothing, it takes months before they start forcibly taking money from you. If you file for an extension or two, it's even longer than that.
Why would information arriving quarterly (bi-weekly even) instead of annually be a bad thing when that information is legally bound to arrive at its destination anyways?
Because the vast majority of America's accountants are one or two person shops with neither the time nor the technology to make this happen. In spite of the rhetoric you see on the internet, the government (via the politicians) doesn't like to make things hard on small businesses unless it really has to.
The only thing you're arguing is that the government shouldn't run their program a few months before you submit the documents, then send it to you for review, instead of afterwards and sending it to a tax judge.
I argue nothing. I merely state facts.
Wouldn’t it be great if it was automatic and right the first time and you didn’t have to file amendments as a consequence because the source material made its way to the IRS AND they told you how much to pay? Or the frequency was dramatically reduced via automation?
> Because the vast majority of America's accountants are one or two person shops with neither the time nor the technology to make this happen.
(a) companies, employers, brokerages, etc all do this filing.
(b) we wouldn’t need nearly as many tax accountants, they’re just a drain on the economy. They’re employed to do the same thing as TurboTax: fill a hole intentionally left open in the IRS as a make work project. Like lamplighters, some jobs get obsoleted by technological and legal advancements.
Regular accountants sure. I’m talking about starting with individuals not business edge cases though.
(c) accountants already file quarterly, for me anyways...
Except that life doesn't work that way. Not everything in life is linear. Things have to be changed. Going back and making revisions is what humans do.
Tax filing and payment periods can be amended to accomodate that, even the fiscal year. It is not like these periods are unchangeable articles of basic law.
FYI we get all those figures ready by the start of March here in Turkey (Turkish yearly income tax deadline is March 20th). US can clearly figure a way out with three times as more people than Turkey.
The resources and infrastructure to increase tax compliance and make it easier for everyone exists it's just that it has been grossly misallocated.
We have to remember too that the government itself is dealing in approximations and assumptions of its own. People make mistakes including those in government and corporations.
So the ideal solution would be that the IRS sends you a letter in January that basically says "You made $XX,XXX this year, you are in YYY tax bracket, and thus you owe $ZZ,ZZZ money".
So if they sent that in January, then Americans could have until April 15th to either send a check for the amount owed or to send back an approval for the refund.
For most people, the amount the IRS sends us will be accurate. But if you do want to submit additional deductions then there could be a deduction form you fill out that takes the IRS' total and submits deductions against it.
Again, most Americans would not need to do anything. Self-employed individuals or individuals with many investments or donations might need submit additional information. But this would be the minority. Most people honestly could just agree with the IRS' determined amount due.
They also keep a running tab on your tax account, if you underpay or overpay you have an interest-yielding balance that you can either correct or let sit until next year if the amount is so little it doesn't matter. And it's symmetric with respect to a surplus or deficit, unlike the IRS "if we owe you, then thanks for the zero-interest loan you gave us, but if you owe us then there will be interest and possibly penalties" scheme.
For these specific two examples, the IRS need only introduce monthly reporting requirements for all tax-affecting investments, at which point they once again have sufficient data to do your taxes for you. They already have your SSN, so there’s no excuse not to have integrated reporting.
What tax-affecting data does the IRS need to be collecting that they are not, in order to prepare viable estimates taxes for 90% of citizens?
(Or, if you’re being sarcastic, please indicate so more clearly.)
A flat tax is completely orthoganal to the complexity of the tax system(which is almost entirely what counts as income, and what type of income does it count as).
If tomorrow we merged all tax brackets into one, no one's taxes would get any simpler, just the poor would pay far more in taxes and the rich far less.
Eg, maybe the most optimal retirement plan changes depending on whether you are in the 2nd-to-lowest or highest tax bracket. That means advice for one person might be suboptimal for someone else solely because they are in a different tax bracket.
Factoring in indirect taxes like payroll, in Australia about half my marginal income is directed to government purposes (Australian tax system). Rationally I should be spending 2-3 days/year of thinking time reading up on changes in tax law and scheming on trying to optimise my tax burden if I believe I can find a way of reducing that by 1% somewhere. Having 5 different tax brackets is just asking for me to try and find some complicated scheme where I filter income to unemployed relatives (eg, the ol' put income earning assests in the wife's name). I don't want to be incentivised to be thinking about that sort of thing, I'd rather just know there are no options.
The more combinations there are, the more weird schemes people come up with. Having everyone pay a flat 30% and with some sort of minimum income scheme would reduce the number of alternatives there I have to think about and make it easier to be confident that my taxes are properly optimised.
That's the flip side to a flat tax, we save a ton on the opportunity costs paid for with time and the development of expertise in all this minutiae. We have entire industries and corporations devoted to taxation. At what point does the benefits gained by our tax complexity get outweighed by the regulatory costs and burdens associated with compliance to that complexity?
A quick check
> Tax preparation is BIG business – there were 300k people employed at 109k firms in 2012 - generating $9 billion in revenue in 2012. The industry grew over 2% from 2010-2015, and is expected to speed up the pace of growth. Revenues of $11 billion are forecast for 2018. https://www.franchisehelp.com/industry-reports/tax-preparati...
What else could we get with that sort of brain/man power?
That would be a highly regressive tax system that dramatically transfers even more wealth to the already wealthy. But sure, it's definitely simpler. That doesn't make it better.
If I go from spending $200/month on groceries and then I get an enormous 300% raise at work, I'm not going to start spending $800/month on groceries, maybe $300. The rest goes into the discretionary part of my budget. So, to someone making $40,000/year, paying 20% of that in rent, 10% for food, 20% for healthcare, and 15% for other stuff, adding a 15% tax is a decent chunk of the rest of their budget. But, for someone making $400,000/year, paying 15% for rent, 2% for food, 10% for healthcare, and 15% for everything else, then 15% of their income towards taxes is comparatively much less of their total budget!
This is true, even though everyone is paying a proportional amount of their income. Another way of thinking about this is as follows: if there is a homeless woman on the side of the street who makes $30 one day begging for change, should she be taxed at 15% and have to give the government $4.50 because it's "fair", or, should she be receiving more value in benefits than the average citizen because there is a floor on how much you can spend on food and survive?
Thus, even a flat tax can in practice be regressive, because essential spending does not scale with income.
An addendum: While it is not relevant to this argument, I also agree with the other commenters that whether a tax system is flat or has marginal brackets is not the main source of complexity, and is relatively super simple. The main complexity comes from determining which sources count as income. Presumably, birthday presents don't, but whoops, now there's an exception. And this is suddenly how tax laws get super complicated.
Premises
X = income
c > 0 (income difference)
p = tax rate
e = some expense
==> X+c > X (income inequality)
==> (1-p)(X+c) > (1-p)X (income after taxes)
==> 1/[(1-p)(X+c)] < 1/[(1-p)X]
==> e/[(1-p)(X+c)] < e/[(1-p)X] (expense relative to disposable income)
Like with many things people mean different things by the same terms. I'm thinking more along the lines of the second investopedia article which makes the point of This type of tax has no correlation with an individual's earnings or income level.> That's about as equal and fair as you can get
Equal in terms of % of income paid: yes, fair: no way. Your statement makes the assumption that the opportunities to gain higher income are equally and fairly distributed, which they are manifestly not.
Looking at the wikipedia article they claim that flat tax lies between a regressive and progressive tax.
> The opposite of a regressive tax is a progressive tax, in which the average tax rate increases as the amount subject to taxation rises. In between is a flat or proportional tax, where the tax rate is fixed as the amount subject to taxation increases. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regressive_tax
Where in my statement does the assumption of equal income mobility pop up?
Another hit mentions a proportional tax as a middle ground between regressive and progressive gradients. The central point is how things are treated relative to income. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042415/what-are-dif...
> [A flat tax is] about as equal and fair as you can get
I disagree about the fair part, but we likely have different ideas about what fair means in this context. For me, equal opportunity to income mobility is part of what fair means.
Once we start trying to equalize along these other dimensions of marginal utility or equality of some other thing we're no longer focused on funding government but enacting some equality/justice endeavor. Those I imagine probably also suffer from holding no simple formula to calculate their equalities against. Let such endeavors be handled by some other government agency dedicated to those causes, why drag the tax system into the mix and complicate things is what baffles me.
Creating equal opportunity and administration of justice are functions of government. You seem to agree:
> Let such endeavors be handled by some other government agency dedicated to those causes,
How would you fund such government agencies except via tax revenue?
> why drag the tax system into the mix and complicate things is what baffles me.
The IRS doesn't administer, i.e. Social Security and Medicare. It is just responsible for collecting the tax needed to fund them. Otherwise each government agency would need it's own revenue collection arm, which makes little sense from an efficiency perspective.
A flat tax set at the very low levels its proponents advocate would effectively defund government programs like Medicare and Social Security, which is often the goal behind such proposals.
Note by the way that social Security tax is today an example of a regressive tax which caps out at around $132,000 of income.
Yes. And as part of that you have to decide how much each person is to contribute.
> We should have a simple tax formula strictly dedicated to funding the government where everyone has skin in the game
Yes.
> ..and contributes equally along some metric.
Yes, according to their means. The metric is contribution proportional to your ability to contribute and that folds in implicitly the idea that your "means" are non-linear with respect to marginal utility. Noblesse oblige. [1]
> The flat tax seems a dead simple reasonable metric and is unquestionably equal when focused on contributions.
No, it is not. Because 10% of 10K/yr income of someone working at burger king is an undue hardship whereas 10% of 1M/yr income of someone running a big company is no burden at all. 1K to someone making 10K may be the difference between sleeping in a bed and sleeping in the street, but 100K to someone making 1M, frankly, they wouldn't even notice it.
> Once we start trying to equalize along these other dimensions of marginal utility or equality of some other thing we're no longer focused on funding government but enacting some equality/justice endeavor.
No, we know how much we need to fund the government based on cost of policies enacted. That's not the job of the IRS, that's the job of the budget committee in congress. What the IRS is doing is figuring out how to apportion that burden among the population.
> Those I imagine probably also suffer from holding no simple formula to calculate their equalities against. Let such endeavors be handled by some other government agency dedicated to those causes, why drag the tax system into the mix and complicate things is what baffles me.
Again, the goal is to figure out how to apportion the burden, and that's done by indexing to marginal utility, bringing us back to where we began.
To be clear this isn't coming from someone looking to take from others, I'm in the top marginal income tax bracket, and I think it should be much higher than it is. IMO it should go back up to 70% as it was for much of the 1900s. [2]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noblesse_oblige
[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/us-policy/2019/02/27/top-tax-...
https://www.businessinsider.com/the-republican-tax-reform-po...
Just doubling the standard deduction is fine. Capping SLPT was a kick in the nards to liberals on the coasts. It's not just "upper middle class" folks who got hosed, its actually people on the bubble, for whom their SF property tax (1.188%) already eats their entire deduction, and now they're double-taxed on their state taxes. 100K may be upper middle class in Iowa but it won't even get you a studio apartment in SF. That's who gets hosed.
And anyone with way too much money got more money. The net of it was dumb.
If those taxes can be deducted, the nation is subsidizing the more wasteful states. We create a situation where the winning move is to jack up state and local taxes. This diverts more money to the state. The cost of wasteful spending gets spread across the nation, while the benefits stay with those who are wasteful. This encourages a race to see who can be most wasteful, with the federal government being forced to have higher tax rates to make up for funds lost to tax deductions.
Your argument just makes it more efficient for the federal government to be wasteful than state governments which do way way less. It’s useless. The federal government has no business keeping states “lean” that’s up to the voters of said states. There’s nothing in the constitution that makes it the federal governments responsibility unless I missed an amendment.
Further these high tax states also pay for literally all the other states. California is massive net givers of transfer payments and the flyover states being given a break from this are net takers of transfer payments. It’s just biting the hand that feeds. Of course it’s not politically expeditious to say that. [1]
This was done for votes, nothing else.
[1] https://www.politifact.com/california/article/2017/feb/14/do...
There is no double taxation. You owe tax first to the federal government. The state could let you deduct federal taxes from your state taxes, or not. The federal government has no duty to give you a discount for your choice to live in a place that would divert lots of your income to local purposes.
As a thought experiment, consider the ultimate extreme. The local government takes 100% in taxes, then provides you with everything (house, food, clothes, etc.) as government services. Your region thus pays ZERO federal income tax despite having wealth to enjoy (you are fed, etc.) and receiving federal funds for various things.
What you have is a partial version of that extreme. Your state isn't being 100% unfair to the other states. It is just modestly unfair. The federal government shouldn't enable that kind of unfairness.
BTW, politifact is not credible due to strong partisan bias. I also don't think that "transfer payments" are a proper accounting for differences.
California takes that tax revenue and reinvests it into the populace which is what generates the income the federal government relies on in the first place. Think of state tax revenue as COGS. The federal government has always been second behind the states and been severely limited in scope and responsibilities. You know what if a state had 100% tax, they could decide between themselves and the federal government how that would be used to service national obligations without involving me.
Further it is patently double taxation if I have to pay taxes to two entities based on the same unadjusted income. Fair or unfair (in your opinion or mine) it is what it is: double taxation.
Double taxation and beyond is the norm. You have sales tax, paid to a vendor that pays their own income tax, for goods that were imported with tariffs.
Unless you voted against the California politicians, you should enjoy paying your taxes. Those politicians are why we can't cut expensive government programs at both the state and federal level, and why we must tax heavily to compensate.
Nobody's evading anything. The federal, state and local governments together are your government. That's why you've always been able to deduct the local from your state and federal, and state from your federal. In fact I can't think of a country where that's not true, can you?
> Double taxation and beyond is the norm. You have sales tax, paid to a vendor that pays their own income tax, for goods that were imported with tariffs.
Not with income taxes. Historically not within the United States, and again, as you continue to refuse to address, not for taxes paid to foreign governments. The US has a huge network of no-double-taxation tax treaties with foreign governments because it's not fair to tax people on their taxes.
The IRS has a no-double-taxation treaty with Azerbaijan and yet it can't manage to sustain one with California? [1]
> Unless you voted against the California politicians, you should enjoy paying your taxes. Those politicians are why we can't cut expensive government programs at both the state and federal level, and why we must tax heavily to compensate.
California's top tier is 13.3%, the US federal is 37% + FICA. You can't tell me with a straight face that California's measly tax rate is the reason the US federal government has to charge 40% of both my income and my taxes.
I have no problem paying my fair share. I'm also a non-citizen so I can't vote.
[1] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/international-businesses/unit...
If I'm in Texas, my state income tax is $0. My federal tax rate will be higher without having state taxes to deduct. Part of this money goes to you, in California.
If you're in California, you get a reduced federal rate if you can deduct California taxes. The money from California taxes stays in California to benefit you. I do not benefit from your California taxes.
California would be getting money from you without paying federal taxes on it. The money then goes to you, via services provided by California. You're getting that money back in the form of superior services like better schools, homeless services, and roads. You're getting to spend that money in your state, free of federal taxes.
The deduction is thus a massive subsidy to states with high local taxes. It places a greater burden on states that are less wasteful, since nobody there gets to deduct state taxes. Such a deduction thus encourages wasteful local government.
As viewed from outside California, money owed to the federal government is staying in California to be spent for the benefit of people in California. That simply isn't fair.
If you are unhappy with the resulting high tax rate, you can leave the state or you can try to get the state to eliminate taxes.
> The situation with other countries is irrelevant to the matter of California income evading federal taxes.
No it’s very relevant. You’re trying to have it both ways. Either the state represents an arm of the government in which case taxing taxes makes no sense or it’s more akin to a country on its own where you could make the argument double taxation makes sense. But you argue it’s part of the government to the extent it should be contributing to your state but autonomous enough that it should be double taxed.
> As viewed from outside California, money owed to the federal government is staying in California to be spent for the benefit of people in California. That simply isn't fair.
If you want those services you can move to California. However that money isn’t wasted it’s used to support the people and economy of California which in turn would by itself be the 6th biggest economy in the world. That money is being invested in California and other states benefit from the tax revenue it generates.
> If you are unhappy with the resulting high tax rate, you can leave the state or you can try to get the state to eliminate taxes.
No haha I’m good, then I wouldn’t live in California where the state invests in its people (to an extent).
You can perform all the mental gymnastics you want to justify this but I think you’d feel differently if a democratic administration wanted to tax the tax revenue paid by oil companies or lord help us carbon. This was done plain and simple to own the libs on the coast. Anything else is backing out a justification and fighting for double taxation isn’t a good look.
California (the land and the people and the government and every other way you could view it) must pay. Internal use and abuse of funding shouldn't have anything to do with what is owed.
When you say that the change was "done plain and simple to own the libs on the coast", you presume that the previous situation was fair. It was not. Those "libs on the coast" were evading taxes, plain and simple.
That "6th biggest economy in the world" was doing so well partly because it avoided taxes. That was unjust enrichment at the expense of middle America.
> Gov: you owe us money. It's called taxes
> Ctzn: oh ok, how much do I owe you?
> Gov: you have to figure it out
> Ctzn: oh well, then I owe you 0
> Gov: no, no, we know how much you owe, you have to figure it out, and by the way if you get it wrong you go to jail