And yet it has to get there by tax time so I’m having trouble believing it takes some tax forms literally years to make it to DC. Especially when you go to jail if they don’t.
> We don't yet live in a world of instantaneous information transfer about every American citizen to the government.
Buuuut it all has to get there by April 15th (actually February right) so I’m having trouble following this line of reasoning.
> Some people also see that as a good thing.
Why would information arriving quarterly (bi-weekly even) instead of annually be a bad thing when that information is legally bound to arrive at its destination anyways?
The only thing you're arguing is that the government shouldn't run their program a few months before you submit the documents, then send it to you for review, instead of afterwards and sending it to a tax judge. That's madness.
It sounds like you've never needed to file a revised tax form for a previous year. I have, and millions of other people do it each year.
Especially when you go to jail if they don’t.
The IRS doesn't show up on your doorstep on April 16th if you don't file. There's a process. A long, involved process. Even if you pay nothing, it takes months before they start forcibly taking money from you. If you file for an extension or two, it's even longer than that.
Why would information arriving quarterly (bi-weekly even) instead of annually be a bad thing when that information is legally bound to arrive at its destination anyways?
Because the vast majority of America's accountants are one or two person shops with neither the time nor the technology to make this happen. In spite of the rhetoric you see on the internet, the government (via the politicians) doesn't like to make things hard on small businesses unless it really has to.
The only thing you're arguing is that the government shouldn't run their program a few months before you submit the documents, then send it to you for review, instead of afterwards and sending it to a tax judge.
I argue nothing. I merely state facts.
Wouldn’t it be great if it was automatic and right the first time and you didn’t have to file amendments as a consequence because the source material made its way to the IRS AND they told you how much to pay? Or the frequency was dramatically reduced via automation?
> Because the vast majority of America's accountants are one or two person shops with neither the time nor the technology to make this happen.
(a) companies, employers, brokerages, etc all do this filing.
(b) we wouldn’t need nearly as many tax accountants, they’re just a drain on the economy. They’re employed to do the same thing as TurboTax: fill a hole intentionally left open in the IRS as a make work project. Like lamplighters, some jobs get obsoleted by technological and legal advancements.
Regular accountants sure. I’m talking about starting with individuals not business edge cases though.
(c) accountants already file quarterly, for me anyways...
Except that life doesn't work that way. Not everything in life is linear. Things have to be changed. Going back and making revisions is what humans do.
Tax filing and payment periods can be amended to accomodate that, even the fiscal year. It is not like these periods are unchangeable articles of basic law.
FYI we get all those figures ready by the start of March here in Turkey (Turkish yearly income tax deadline is March 20th). US can clearly figure a way out with three times as more people than Turkey.
The resources and infrastructure to increase tax compliance and make it easier for everyone exists it's just that it has been grossly misallocated.
We have to remember too that the government itself is dealing in approximations and assumptions of its own. People make mistakes including those in government and corporations.
But not instantly. And not all of it in time for April 15th. Sometimes those details don't make it to the IRS for years.
We don't yet live in a world of instantaneous information transfer about every American citizen to the government.
Some people also see that as a good thing.