I guess it improves their user session time metrics but as a user the experience sucks and I feel Ellen Pao and earlier CEO's eras would not have sold out the user experience the same way (though maybe that's just because they lacked the dev resources to do so)
You see this sort of shit in a lot of places where employees can't be bothered to dogfood their own platform.
I use the old.reddit chrome extension but I imagine most computer users do not.
Internet community communication should be free to see by the public regardless of the host. The commenter are providing content to other users but it is the host that owns it. Its just not right.
Unless I get a reply from a reddit dev who can guarantee that it works on my phone, I’m just gonna stick with “it doesn’t work.”
5. Resignedly click on “Use mobile app” because reddit.com is basically unusable on a small-screen iPhone.
6. App Store opens at the Reddit app page. I already have the Reddit app installed and, often, open. But reddit.com never sends me there. It always sends me to the App Store to download an app I already have.
I unblocked old Reddit from my ad blocker and would have paid a reasonable monthly subscription to eliminate ads entirely (hated Reddit gold solution though...). Their new site is full of trackers so they're back on the naughty block list.
The site isn't hard to make, but it is hard to get the users. If I could pay ~$5/month or something to get old Reddit without ads and with a completely open source stack, I'd do it in a heartbeat.
I hate the AMP page which is a poorer read experience, and to expand comments its now multiple clicks just to get back to reading the entire thread.
1. Google search turns up a reddit result.
2. Click link to AMP page.
3. Scroll to read comments and click another link to open real reddit to view all comments.
4. Get to real reddit domain and watch a long loading screen.
5. Click away 2 notifications saying you should use mobile app.
6. To read a child comment, click again to read below. Page reloads above the parent comment causing you to search the page again to see child comment.
Absolutely ridiculous but still I do this because most Google results are SEO garbage. Google disabled conversation only search. Reddit is unfortunately still the best way to get a real person's view on a topic that most likely not an ad.
Just like with digg, we need a new reddit.