News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by vasili111 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @10:24AM (#21736308)
Also do not forget that SpaceX is not the only company that wants to launch low orbit satelites. I do not think it is possible to find any other real solution other then to move telescopes to space.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by wongarsu on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:05AM (#21736537)
With James Web having an decently sized mirror on a space telescope that's not as ridiculous as it once was. Still we should search for cheaper solutions first.

https://www.eso.org/public/usa/images/eso1617z/?lang

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mcbutterbunz on Monday December 09, 2019 @12:11AM (#21740532)
JWST still hasnt launched after all these years. Building space based telescopes that will last years without maintenance is hard.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Rebelgecko on Monday December 09, 2019 @04:26PM (#21746782)
For some added context, JWST costs about 10x more than the most expensive terrestrial telescope ever built.
[dead]
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by jesseb on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:41AM (#21736721)
Not every country has the resources or desire to lay nation-wide fiber. Satellite internet could beneift millions of people who don't have access to reliable high-speed connections.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by portillo on Sunday December 08, 2019 @12:06PM (#21736857)
This is, in my opinion, kind of a myth. In the markets where the average revenue per user is high (Europe, USA, Canada, Australia) there is already (or there will be very shortly when Viasat3 is fully launched) high-speed reliable Internet connectivity through GEO satellites. And yes, the latency is huge and there are data-caps (which are pretty low if you want to binge-watch Netflix). But I am not sure that LEO constellations will be able to compete with GEO vHTS in price (not to mention the huge challenge of getting the price of the phase array user terminals cheap enough), so I am skeptical they will be able to capture a significant fraction of the market share.

In the rest of the world, the ARPU is so low that it's hard to have a viable business model for broadband satellite connectivity (for all orbits GEO, MEO, or LEO). Furthermore, 90% of the population is currently covered by 3G/4G networks, so I would argue that for most of the 3.5 billion people currently unconnected, the issue is not infrastructure (but other factors such as affordability, relevance, or readiness). Finally, populations in those countries connect largely using mobile broadband (i.e., in Southeast Asia 75% of the population only use cellphone to access the Internet), so I think that fixed-broadband will have a limited impact in those places. (Maybe they can get a higher share of the cellphone tower backhauling market, but it will depend on the price per Mbps/month they can offer to MNOs).

[dead]
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by chr1 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @12:11PM (#21736888)
First starlink is better than fiber because it will have lower latency.

Second and more important it doesn't destroy astronomy at all, it adds some small temporary inconvenience for some types of observations, but at the same time makes space launches cheaper allowing more space telescopes, which is going to help astronomy greatly.

Your reaction would be totally justified if starlink was really disrupting astronomy, but it is simply not true.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by portillo on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:13PM (#21737995)
It will only have lower latency when they have the inter-satellite links. Until then, they will have the latency of fiber PLUS the RTT from the user terminal - satellite - gateway path.
[dead]
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by chr1 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @12:59PM (#21737136)
> The article is literally about even SpaceX admitting that there is a huge problem.

The article is about spacex admitting that there is some inconvenience, and using maximally cautious wording to not attract angry social media mobs.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:37PM (#21737747)
Satellite internet has existed for decades. Why is spacex the only way to provide high speed internet?
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:20PM (#21738030)
Satellite internet has indeed existed for decades, but via small numbers of geostationary satellites (Iridium only has 76 active satellites; Starlink launches about that many in every launch). That means severely constrained bandwidth, and high latency given the ~50,000 mile round trip the data has to take. It's also expensive to get a satellite out there.

Low Earth orbit constellations have both lower latency (a couple hundred miles for data to travel instead of tens of thousands) and dramatically more (and cheaper) satellites = more bandwidth available.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:29PM (#21738084)
I'm well aware of the scale of starlink, but the speeds delivered by starlink won't be any faster than the existing GEO satellites at the time, not will it be cheaper. The OP talked about high speed internet, which, in most cases, the latency doesn't matter.

Every cost estimate made by people in this industry say it will be much higher than geo to deliver a bit. If you have a source that says otherwise, please post it here.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:17PM (#21738374)
Iridium currently offers a handful of megabits at best, doesn't it? Starlink's loading 20 Gbps on each satellite, and has successfully tested up to 610 megabits on a connection with a military plane. (https://spacenews.com/spacex-plans-to-start-offering-starlin...)

> Every cost estimate made by people in this industry say it will be much higher than geo to deliver a bit.

I'm not clear on whether you're referring to the ground station, the satellite constellation, or the cost of service here.

That said, industry laughed at the idea of reusable rockets, and Blackberry thought Steve Jobs faked the iPhone pre-release. Industry estimates have been known to be badly wrong.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:13PM (#21738753)
The ground system is what will make or break starlink. Every phased array antenna to date is at a price point that would put starlink selling exclusively to enterprise customers. This means consumers won't be able to get it unless you're in the 1% and living very remote.

SpaceX will not realize 20Gbps per satellite in useable bandwidth. It's more like 5Gbps.

http://www.mit.edu/~portillo/files/Comparison-LEO-IAC-2018-s...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:22PM (#21738817)
OneWeb claims to have cracked that, for a price point of $200-300. https://spacenews.com/wyler-claims-breakthrough-in-low-cost-...

Even if it winds up being more expensive, you might see a neighborhood getting an antenna and distributing it to a group of houses.

> SpaceX will not realize 20Gbps per satellite in useable bandwidth. It's more like 5Gbps.

Based on guesses made prior to the first launch of production hardware, and speculative guesses on the number of SpaceX ground stations? Your slides are from 1 October 2018. The first batch of production hardware went up 24 May 2019.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by portillo on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:17PM (#21739148)
I am the author of the slides/paper. The analysis was done with the best data available at the time, but I am interested in knowing what parameters you think are off / have changed substantially since then.

I can say that the mass and volume of the satellites has changed quite a lot, and therefore the number of rocket launches required is pretty off in the paper. But I have not seen much info to invalidate the rest of results.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:40PM (#21739585)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought the mass estimates increased? either way, that should only affect how many that can launch at a given time. I didn't think that number had changed appreciably either.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by portillo on Sunday December 08, 2019 @09:32PM (#21739975)
In their original FCC filing, they were estimating 386 kg per satellite. The ones launched in May were 227 kg each, and those last month 260 kg (they added the Ka-band antennas).

I am not sure how much heavier will the satellites be when they integrate the ISLs (if they do), but I believe that in any case they will be under 330 kg.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:27PM (#21738863)
These are not guesses. These are calculations based on FCC filings with things like EIRP, PFD, etc, all included. SpaceX cannot simply transmit hotter than they filed for just because the filing is old.

If anything, they're worse than those calculations since there's no ISL, and there were reported propulsion system problems.

I personally can't see a neighborhood going in on satellite internet since they still need to transmit between each other, which would mean more equipment.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ericd on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:28PM (#21738447)
Can you point to some of those cost estimates?

Latency absolutely matters for "high speed internet". Once you have reasonable bandwidth, that's the dominant factor in the user experience.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by portillo on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:10PM (#21739097)
NSR has some public estimates here: https://www.nsr.com/leo-survival-of-the-fittestor-the-smarte...

NSR estimates for SpaceX are higher than what SpaceX claims (Gwynne Shotwell just claimed some Morgan Stanley estimates of $1M launch + $1M to be way off [1]), but still, I wouldn't expect them to be able to launch the 4,409 satellites of their intial design for less than $10B. And it's not clear that they will be able to raise such amount of money without a clear path towards profitability.

I agree with the shaklee3, Tim's blog is very legit. As full disclosure, I am the first author of the MIT study he mentioned, and the more I look into LEO mega-constellations, the more skeptical I become.

[1] https://twitter.com/thesheetztweetz/status/11877454453611806...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ericd on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @04:07AM (#21750876)
Thanks! Why do you become more and more skeptical? Is there some fundamental reason they won't be competitive?
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:09PM (#21738725)
No, it's not. Streaming media is by far the largest consumer of bandwidth on the internet today. Latency doesn't matter at all for those.

Please see this blog for approximate cost estimates, or the MIT study comparing leo constellations.

http://tmfassociates.com/blog/category/operators/spacex/

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:15PM (#21738764)
Streaming uses lots of bandwidth, but it's not necessarily the majority of browsing activity. High latency is painful if you're doing things like browsing Reddit.

The blog you're citing claimed Starlink was getting canceled a year ago, so I'm a bit skeptical of its use as an oracle.

http://tmfassociates.com/blog/2018/09/18/420000-km-funding-s...

> Another hint that Starlink is going away was the statement that BFR is expected to consume the majority of engineering resources after the commercial crew development has been completed for NASA next year, despite Starlink supposedly costing more to develop than BFR ($10B+ compared to ~$5B) over the next 5 years.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:23PM (#21738831)
Browsing Reddit is perfectly fine on satellite internet. It's obviously not as fast as cable, but it's not the satellite internet of 10 years ago people judge it on.

TMF is probably the most accurate consultant in this industry if you read the whole blog. He tends to be opinionated, which you won't find on places like spacenews.

Either way, it's not productive arguing. It's like the Tesla versus anti-tesla camp, and that certainly won't be settled anytime soon.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by shaklee3 on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:04AM (#21779249)
I know this is coming in late, but TMF just did an analysis of the economics:

http://tmfassociates.com/blog/2019/12/12/reality-and-hype-in...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by KoftaBob on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:38PM (#21737350)
The current bottleneck to broadband access isn't the fiber backhaul, it's last mile delivery. That part is expensive and labor intensive.

Solutions like LEO satellites and 5G wireless internet allow broadband access to be more quickly expanded to places where it's not feasible or profitable for companies to lay hundreds of miles of cables to each individual home.

If you frame your comment as "My astronomy hobby is more important than internet access to all", it doesn't sound as great.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by sprash on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:08PM (#21737562)
> The current bottleneck to broadband access isn't the fiber backhaul, it's last mile delivery.

The "last mile delivery" problem is easily covered with 4G/LTE already. High licensing cost of spectral bandwidth are more relevant than labor costs at this point. A pure political problem.

> If you frame your comment as "My astronomy hobby is more important than internet access to all", it doesn't sound as great.

If you frame your comment as "A filthy rich[1] billionaire getting even richer is more important than a clear night sky and litter free LEO", it doesn't sound so great.

And by the way "hobby" astronomers make much more contributions than you are obviously aware of. E.g. Earth endangering asteroids will most likely be detected by hobbyists because looking in many directions with weak telescopes will have success with higher likelihood than a single specific scientific survey catching anything accidentally.

1.: https://www.zerohedge.com/energy/cash-strapped-elon-musk-buy...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Tomte on Sunday December 08, 2019 @10:57AM (#21736498)
Sure there is another solution: we ban them, or at least highly regulate them.

The idea that private companies can just do whatever, and there's nothing we can do is just so cliché HN.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by dang on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:21PM (#21737252)
You broke the site guidelines badly with this flamebait and generic tangent, which predictably started a wretched flamewar. Then you perpetuated it.

You do a lot of good for HN with your interesting submissions, but you've also been vandalizing HN with destructive comments for years. We've asked you not to do this many times.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20356880

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18887148

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17952388

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17441941

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17432633

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17113849

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17111984

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14693327

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11705439

Eventually the cost outweighs the benefit. I definitely do not want to ban you, so would you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and fix this? All users here need to have self-control, and experienced contributors more so.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by kbrwn on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:50PM (#21737436)
How is this comment flamebait? First time that I have really thought you missed the boat.

Please don't censor people just because they criticize HN or the community.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by dang on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:53PM (#21737859)
"The idea that private companies can just do whatever" distorted the other comment into something ideologically inflammatory (which the site guidelines explicitly ask not to do), and took the thread on a generic ideological tangent. Those routinely turn into flamewars. Posting something that predictably induces a flamewar is flamebait.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by skinkestek on Monday December 09, 2019 @12:30AM (#21740597)
I was also surprised but then I read up on the rest of The comments from that account in this thread as well and think that it something like that might be justified.

I also read the rest of the comments linked as examples and some of them where obvious to me and some were not.

I'm not a native speaker though and I realize dang has a huge advantage there as well as access to see detailed voting statistics to see what riles people up.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by lacker on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:13AM (#21736577)
I am a big fan of astronomy, but satellites are doing a lot more for humanity than ground-based astronomy.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Tomte on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:19AM (#21736612)
What does an Internet access satellite network do for science? Those scientific uses SpaceX talks about are speculative and clearly secondary (or tertiary behind military use).

By contrast, earth-based telescopes are doing lots and lots of science right now.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:50AM (#21736776)
> What does an Internet access satellite network do for science?

One example: https://www.usap.gov/technology/1935/

> Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station uses communications satellites that serve as relay stations, receiving radio signals from one location and transmitting them to another. The United States Antarctic Program utilizes the satellites for the transfer of South Pole science, operational, and weather data, as well as Internet, telephone, and email services.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by wongarsu on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:14AM (#21736585)
Nobody has jurisdiction over space. We can try to create an international agency and get all space fairing nations to submit to its regulations and rulings, but even if that was politically viable it would take years. Meanwhile Starlink will be deployed mid 2020 if no major delays happen
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Tomte on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:22AM (#21736633)
Great, so any of the hundred-something countries on earth are free to destroy those satellites? ;-)
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by wongarsu on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:45AM (#21736751)
Generally destroying other people's property isn't looked kindly upon, even if done in international waters or in space.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by sprash on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:32AM (#21736675)
I was thinking about what would be the easiest way to destroy those satellites. A highly collimated microwave beam could do the trick. Or may be a really high powered Argon Ion Laser which are rather easy to build. Maybe somebody can come up with a neat DIY solution.
[dead]
[dead]
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:25AM (#21736644)
SpaceX is launching some of those telescopes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transiting_Exoplanet_Survey_Sa...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Tomte on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:29AM (#21736663)
And in order to launch it they are using their constellation how exactly? Ah yes, they don't. They are separate.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:47AM (#21736762)
It was launched on a SpaceX rocket by those "greedy entrepreneurs", at a cost that likely permitted the professional astronomers to save a bunch of money versus launching with a competitor like ULA.
[dead]
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Tomte on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:21AM (#21736623)
Funny, the officially stated purpose is "Internet access". There is some handwaving towards "maybe it could do more".
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by SEJeff on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:42AM (#21736737)
Musk has been excessively clear the goal of Starlink is to allow SpaceX to self-fund a manned mars mission. You're welcome to downvote all you want, but this does not negate the fact Musk has directly said this (in several interviews). Many people tend to agree with him on this possibility:

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/15/musk-on-starlink-internet-sa...

https://www.space.com/spacex-starlink-internet-satellites-ma...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Tomte on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:57AM (#21736815)
So the ends justify the means?

Great, why doesn't Musk trade in Ivory? There's a tidy profit to be had. Maybe he can donate a couple dollars to PETA, and everything's fine.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @12:18PM (#21736924)
https://www.fws.gov/international/travel-and-trade/ivory-ban...

> On July 6, 2016, a near-total ban on commercial trade in African elephant ivory went into effect in the United States.

Hard to make a profit when you're shut down by the government.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by SEJeff on Sunday December 08, 2019 @12:28PM (#21736968)
He’s just trying to build up a strawman to attack. Typical HN troll.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by dang on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:26PM (#21737280)
Please don't perpetuate flamewars on HN, and please especially don't do personal attacks. We ban accounts that do that.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by chr1 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:20AM (#21736617)
Professional astronomers would rather use a swarm of large and better working telescopes in space instead of dealing with clouds, city lights, and the Sun not allowing to work at normal hours.

> Not the greedy entrepreneurs littering the sky with Internet access satellites.

The "littering" will be done not just by "greedy entrepreneurs" but by millions of people who will pay for faster internet, and by astronomers who want better telescopes.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by chr1 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:00PM (#21737909)
I'd be very interested to know if any of the people who strongly disagree with the above comment are professional astronomers, or physicists.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mlyle on Monday December 09, 2019 @11:48PM (#21749679)
Uh, being up above the atmosphere is great and all. But we also like having big apertures and lots of light gathering, which space telescopes don't have. We're not going to have a 39 meter scope with a high quality mirror in orbit anytime soon.

Also, space telescopes are very expensive, so we have a very small number-- we're not going to ever have enough to look at as much of the sky as we'd like to look at. We've got hundreds of thousands of 0.3 meter scopes out there, employed by everything from outright amateurs to citizen-scientists to auxiliary observing and discovery for research astronomers. We can't give all these people time on orbiting telescopes.

[dead]
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by chr1 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:51AM (#21736777)
They do not need to be part of StarLink.

The more satellites are launched the more money SpaceX gets to develop starship, starship reduces the cost of launching satellites and increases the maximum volume of the satellite, with cheaper launches and cheaper mirrors that do not need complex folding launching space telescope becomes cheaper than building a telescope on the earth, which means that new telescopes will be built for space.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Tomte on Sunday December 08, 2019 @12:05PM (#21736852)
The same line of reasoning works for selling weapons to conflict parties.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by chr1 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:06PM (#21737167)
How does it work? By building rockets spacex learns how to build better rockets, by selling weapons it would only learn how to build weapons. If you mean someone could start another company selling weapons and redirect all profits to SpaceX, that could work, but why would anyone do that if there is a better way of selling network connection?