News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by bigdubs on Friday November 29, 2019 @09:59PM (#21668242)
The loss of what.cd wasn't difficult because it made piracy hard, it was because the users had created one of the best fully verified lossless cd audio archives on the internet.

Much of this content has popped up (or even been extended) on replacement trackers, but it's only a matter of time before the heroic operators of these trackers get forced to shut down too.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by Iv on Friday November 29, 2019 @10:53PM (#21668407)
I remember the early days of piracy, Napster, Kaza, eDonkey. People were simply sharing all their files. There was pride in having a hard to obtain item, such as TV shows from the 60s, movies not released in DVDs, etc...

P2P could have made archivists jobs so much easier. This is a tech that should have been the next iteration of internet that we killed for no good reason. Not even greed, just a refusal to evolve a profitable but obsolete system.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by javajosh on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:33AM (#21669270)
I used to agree totally, but now I have a more nuanced view. While artificial scarcity offends my hacker sensibility, I also have to admit that this creates a society I like, with talented wealthy celebrities, and a large population of people who make their living in and around the industry. I'm not sure I would like a society where creative acts only happens in home studios and the work is given away for free, and all artists have to have day jobs.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by brownbat on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:34AM (#21670104)
I think that's a fair view.

The only thing that gives me pause is that we transitioned to a system where individual music tracks are nearly free-on-demand* a decade ago and the sky never fell.

There were transition costs, and artists get way more from live performances now, but there's still an industry.

More than anything I'd just like to experiment with shorter copyright terms. I don't think the founders were crazy when they set them at around a generation. I agree that it might be risky to blow everything up, but I think there's a lot of bargaining we could do over term lengths that would be pretty harmless.

* To a first order approximation. Sure, many artists technically can get something when I pull up a track on YouTube. But if I'm not playing a whole playlist, I might not even see any ads.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by katbyte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:30AM (#21670087)
I think if copyright was 20, heck 40 years this wouldn’t be such a problem because that would means everything earlier then 1980 would probably be available online for free. Long copyrights just prop up companies and their investors not people.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by matheusmoreira on Sunday December 01, 2019 @08:21AM (#21675351)
> I also have to admit that this creates a society I like, with talented wealthy celebrities, and a large population of people who make their living in and around the industry.

What should we value more: hacker principles or phony outdated business models that aren't compatible with the realities of the digital age?

Copyright was created back when industrial capacity was required in order to make copies at scale. People had to own stuff like printing presses in order to infringe copyright at a scale that caused any damage. This is no longer the case. Copyright infringement is trivial now. It's as easy as copy paste. To solve this, the copyright industry intends to lock us out of computing. They think unlimited computers are too powerful for mere citizens like us and we should have access to nothing but limited versions that can execute nothing but predefined functions approved by them.

The mere existence of copyright is an existential threat to hackers and their values. If the preservation of free computing and internet requires sacrificing the entertainment industry, then so be it. The alternative is to sacrifice free computing.

Due to the existence of subversive technologies such as encryption, governments have been increasingly adopting the same perspective as the copyright industry.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by Iv on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:06AM (#21669349)
I never said the new model was "give away everything for free" I just said that "Consider every copy needs to be paid even though making a copy is basically free of cost and that this forces us to put a terrible censorship mechanism into place" was not the right approach.

Now that there are crowdfunding campaigns and tons of tools for microtransaction, that is even less excusable than when you had the effort to imagine the apparition of these obvious solutions.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by hakfoo on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:09PM (#21671625)
I feel like we're screwed until we get over the "ownership" model.

It means we spend more effort on metadata (What are we allowed to do with it? Who owns it?) than the actual data.

It has stood directly in the way of new creative types (sampling in music, for example) and locked away content where the metadata is faulty/lost (orphan works problem)

It falls apart badly at scale (if you wanted to get distribution rights for everything on an OSX/Windows installation image, imagine the number of third parties alone, plus the original developers, you'd need to sign off)

and then it only really incentivizes work that's commercially appealing, not necessarily the technical best.

I dream of a day where people who want to create will be able to get a stipend-- it might cover a modest lifestyle, but ensures they can live the dream of being an artist/musician/programmer without having to clutch tight over every scrap of their output to keep their income streams alive. If we did it through a tax-funded endowment rather than market forces, we could probably finance a lot more creativity that way (think how many touring singers we could finance at 50k per year for the price of one Taylor Swift, or how many programmers we could hire to work om their passion projects in database theory for what is currently being spent on Oracle licenses.)

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by dexterdog on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:37AM (#21670127)
Hardly. Top acts make 10s of millions per month today. If people didn't have to spend money on the music itself they would probably spend even more for tickets and merchandise.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by zozbot234 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:43AM (#21669432)
In addition to what the other commenter said about crowdfunding, celebrities now get most of their money from sponsorship deals, not their actual creative activity. Yes, you need to be a real superstar to get these deals, but the world of mainstream, "celebrity" creators is driven by superstar dynamics.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by VMG on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:09AM (#21669480)
Maybe we can figure out how to finance things we like without putting people in prison though.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:59AM (#21669185)
While early-millennium filesharing was useful for finding obscure content, the stuff available wasn’t up to the standards of professional archivists. In the library world, there are strict standards for how information is to be ripped, encoded, and tagged, but the content on filesharing networks seldom lived up to solid archival standards. It wasn’t until Oink and What.cd that we got a rigorous archive of audio material.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by Aeolun on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:05AM (#21668644)
For me it had more to do with the bootleg sharing programs and the inability to download anything without 1500 different versions of malware also making it onto your computer.

For some reason the torrent community doesn’t have quite the same problem.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by vbezhenar on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:30AM (#21669261)
How is P2P killed? I would say P2P matured. There's open source stable torrent software. Just use it, it works.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by bonoboTP on Saturday November 30, 2019 @08:08AM (#21669795)
Torrent is still very centralized. The average user just downloads and seeds torrents made by a few torrent curators on each site. Becoming an uploader on a torrent site is a big privilege/responsibility that few people can take on.

Other older platforms like Napster or DC++ (which actually still exists) let people share their own collection at the click of a button. This gave access to a really really long tail of rarities that perhaps only a handful of people were interested in, while torrent sites are mostly mainstream content.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by dewey on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:51AM (#21670437)
> Becoming an uploader on a torrent site

What do you mean by that? You can upload your torrents to any of the big public torrent sites and if it's a private site just being a member allows you to upload already. Public trackers are also all using DHT which makes this not centralized.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by bonoboTP on Sunday December 01, 2019 @11:51AM (#21676305)
On private sites I know (in Hungary), being an uploader is a privilege one must earn, by being around for some time, earning the trust of the admins, having good uplink, learning all the rules and formats so all torrents are consistent etc. I guess perhaps about 0.1% of members upload stuff to these trackers. The situation may be different elsewhere.

Context: Torrent is hugely popular in Hungary, basically everyone is a member who uses the internet under ~40 years and is even remotely technical, which means more than a million people (with the single most popular site having over 700k members, with account sharing explicitly allowed). Perhaps not so much for the newest teenager generation (I don't know). Until very recently (and still now) streaming services have been limited contentwise and people just cannot afford to buy all the movies, songs, games etc. with the same ease as in Western Europe / North America.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by oneeyedpigeon on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:28AM (#21669519)
I think two things happened which effectively destroyed p2p - for the music-sharing case, for me specifically, at least. Streaming and greater official release of bootlegs, demos, etc. For me, there is so much available through these channels, that I don’t even consider p2p as an option.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by xouse on Friday November 29, 2019 @11:00PM (#21668429)
People have learned from what.cd. Lots of people have the same sense of inevitable doom you do so there's more people who have put thought and effort into being capable of rebuilding quickly if that happens again. Just varroa musica alone has created a giant decentralized metadata archive(and that's not even its main purpose just a neat side effect) that would make the restarting process much easier.

The downside is that the post what community is so much smaller. Spotify et al really put a huge damper on the music tracker community, and that makes it less resilient.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by Lammy on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:28AM (#21668877)
> The downside is that the post what community is so much smaller.

People were saying the same thing in 2007 when OiNK shut down and What was starting up. The community is not smaller; it's more fragmented, and that's a good thing. Centralization is no better in our societal constructs than it is in our technological ones. I'll trade some immediacy and convenience for longevity any day.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by xouse on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:30PM (#21671725)
I disagree, the community is both more fragmented and smaller, what had 144k users on its last day vs the 35k of its spiritual successor today. The few music trackers that have sprung up post what.cd after said spiritual successor are all pretty small. The niche genre trackers all have about the same user numbers since then so they cancel out. Then factor in that waffles has been down for some time now and the difference is pretty big.

I can only estimate because exact numbers are hard to find, but I'd say peak what era music tracker community total users was in the 350k region and we're probably somewhere around 100k now.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by WilTimSon on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:05AM (#21669199)
Does Spotify really cut that deep into the demographic of hardcore music tracker users? I'd presume those people are chasing rare and lost releases in high quality and Spotify and other streaming services aren't exactly touting rarities. Preserving underground music will always be a job for the fans, not streaming services.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by xouse on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:30PM (#21671992)
Yes. Music trackers have always been a ton of effort, but in their prime trackers had the advantage of having basically a monopoly on music discovery. If you wanted to find out about citypop in 2011 what.cd was the place, now youtube will recommended it to you on a Joe Rogan video.

People didn't go to what.cd and jump through all those hoops to find rare music, they went to find good music, and now Spotify and YouTube do a good enough job of that with a lot less effort.

As a funny example of that I discovered Billie Eilish when Ocean Eyes first came out from a private tracker and now she's about as big as anyone. So it isn't just about discovering rare czech folk singers, but any music that you might like.

I think the hardcore demographic you mentioned is spot on and does exist, but they were always a minority and the evaporation of the less hardcore users explains why the scene is so much smaller now.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by joecool1029 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:36AM (#21669279)
> Does Spotify really cut that deep into the demographic of hardcore music tracker users?

It does because private trackers use buffer as currency. The music trackers have had to adapt to use points systems now to encourage downloading activity. But even still, activity is way down from the what.cd days. It's just easier to stream the easily accessible stuff.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by MivLives on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:16PM (#21670956)
Also if you're not an uploader, building ratio to use the site is hard. Going from ten years of what.cd freeleech of buffer to nothing and facing the prospect of building it up again can be daunting.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by dewey on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:32AM (#21670096)
Luckily the internet archive was also working on archiving the content on what.cd even though the results are not public (yet?).

https://archive.org/details/whatcdcrawl

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by ripdog on Saturday November 30, 2019 @11:43AM (#21670723)
Getting the metadata is great, but the content won't come back.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by shortandsweet on Friday November 29, 2019 @11:02PM (#21668432)
What.cd most certainly wasn't the best. They were really stuck up and got what they deserved. I was amazed at the process just to get access to what they didn't even own. Waffles and oink were so much better.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by serf on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:27AM (#21669394)
> I was amazed at the process just to get access to what they didn't even own.

it was that process that helped to curate one of the highest quality audio libraries to have ever been.

it's not all that important for most folks to listen to and compare 20 different releases of Bowie's 'Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars', but to those of us that enjoy music cataloguing as a hobby , the loss of what.cd was pretty terrible.

Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by dewey on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:31AM (#21670089)
By what metric where Waffles and oink better? What.cd was run incredibly professionally, as you can see by the fact that it was active for almost 9 years and nothing happened to any of the people involved.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by MivLives on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:14PM (#21670944)
They're complaining about the invite system. Either you had to know someone or you had to get lucky that they'd be doing irc interviews that day.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by dewey on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:20PM (#21670970)
Then their criticism doesn't make much sense as both Waffles and Oink had an invite system. At least What.cd was more approachable as there was an interview system which made it possible for everyone to join as long as they learned some basics about audio formats / transcoding / site rules and had an hour to spend on an interview.
Re:Disc rot is a challenge for both archivists and collector... by pontifier on Saturday November 30, 2019 @11:49AM (#21670778)
I'm working on something that should be the best place to find any media... unfortunately the VidAngel vs Disney lawsuit has made things a little tougher. Fair use took a big blow there.