News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by mullingitover on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:35PM (#21631242)
Minimum wage isn't just flat for a decade, it's not being adjusted for inflation. This means minimum wage workers have been getting a pay cut over time.

The debate isn't just whether we should raise minimum wage, it's whether we should be cutting it. By allowing it to remain stagnant we're making the default decision to cut.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by hinkley on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:24PM (#21631746)
I'm old enough to remember this conversation happening three times, and wise enough to know that this conversation happens every ten years or so probably since the first wage was paid in currency instead of goods.

A certain pay rate creates supply. Conditions make it hard to switch jobs. And every year you ever so slowly reduce the effective pay to those employees and they slowly give up little luxuries to make ends meet. And when demand outstrips supply, you raise the minimum wage, pulling in a new group of people.

If you're paranoid or cynical, you might call this class warfare instead of unintended consequences.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by bb88 on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:44PM (#21632595)
I'm cynical. I think it's frankly worse than that. When we talk about economic and market forces, we don't talk about "greed" as a major economic force. We know it's the creation of capitalism, but economists seem to do everything in their power to ignore it. Standard economic models breaks down when people are powerful enough to create their own supply/demand curves.

We've had the term "working poor" for a while. I suspect that we'll have "working homeless" in the decades to come.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by klipklop on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:38PM (#21633092)
The working homeless already exist Los Angeles/California. There are more than a few employed people, with kids, living in their cars.

https://www.kqed.org/news/11690325/thousands-of-californians... https://www.latimes.com/opinion/editorials/la-ed-economicall...

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by bb88 on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:38PM (#21634916)
But that's LA/California right? Thousands is not millions, and California is not the US.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sudosysgen on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:49PM (#21635247)
Working poor != working homeless
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:37PM (#21633080)
> I suspect that we'll have "working homeless" in the decades to come.

"A 2010 longitudinal study of homeless men conducted in Birmingham, Alabama, found that most earned an average of ninety dollars per week while working an average of thirty hours per week[192]"

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_S...

"Employees at Amazon's base in Dunfermline, Fife, were apparently so worried they’d lose their jobs if they were late they decided to sleep rough in the woods nearby."

https://metro.co.uk/2016/12/10/desperate-amazon-workers-forc...

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday November 25, 2019 @06:55PM (#21634256)
And it's highly disturbing to me that people will defend these situations on this site. An alarming amount of HN commenters seem to believe that the cost of labor is a function of the money created by the labor. In other words, a job will only pay $X/hr because it creates $Y/hr in revenue where Y > X + some margin. They pretend that if Y goes up, then it brings X up and if X is low, then it means Y MUST be low as well. It has nothing to do with the greed of shareholders.

This line of thinking is what leads to managers firing the entire IT team because they don't generate revenue, and then panicking when the email server crashes.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sokoloff on Monday November 25, 2019 @10:14PM (#21635371)
The more logical claim reads more like "employers will logically try not to employ unprofitable labor", meaning that the wage paid to a worker will generally be no higher than the variable profit enabled by that worker.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by bb88 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @07:03PM (#21644011)
I think the truism really is this:

In a micro sense: each company will try to reduce labor costs as much as possible, since costs are the enemy of profit.

But when we look at the macro situation then: employees are much of the demand curve. Less income means less demand.

This is the reason for much of the talk about UBI and job automation.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Sohcahtoa82 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:34AM (#21636773)
Certainly, but that's nothing more than a truism.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sokoloff on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @02:30PM (#21641745)
Yet proponents of raising the minimum wage seem to disregard this truism when it comes to the case of workers who for whatever reason can only create variable profit at a rate between the old and new minimum wage.

These workers can easily be moved from “profitable to employ” to “unprofitable to employ” by the increase in minimum wage, either entirely or by cutting those hours which would become unprofitable.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Scapeghost on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:40PM (#21634926)
While not exactly homeless, employed people not being able to afford their own house is the norm instead of the exception in the majority of the world.

In the "East" and Middle East, many employed young adults live with their parents instead of moving out, even after getting married. In the UAE for example, many expats live in crammed conditions with as many as 6 people in a single room! and sharing a single bathroom.

Employment == Your Own House is largely a first world expectation.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by bb88 on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:56PM (#21635005)
UAE is not a poor country. They choose to provide for native citizens, not for expatriates. That's on them.

"The wealth gap between rich and poor in the UAE is one of the worst in the world, largely due to the amount of welfare and protection afforded to native Emiratis and the amount of neglect towards migrant workers."

https://borgenproject.org/top-10-facts-about-poverty-in-the-...

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Scapeghost on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:29PM (#21635162)
You are correct and that is true.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sudosysgen on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:53PM (#21635269)
I come from Morocco. There, until recent times, most left the family house to go buy their first home, after their first real job. "Renter" was an insult because you had to be really poor to have to rent. Now that speculation and foreign investment is flooding the housing markets and land prices have literally went up 3000x in some cities, it's changing. It's not a first world dream, it's a problem that's rising everywhere around the world.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Scapeghost on Monday November 25, 2019 @11:56PM (#21635734)
Thanks for the different perspective. I guess Moroccans are/were relatively more prosperous than other Middle-Eastern nations.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by andybak on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:20PM (#21632941)
> I suspect that we'll have "working homeless" in the decades to come.

In the UK several BBC documentaries have covered exactly this phenomenon. I don't doubt it is already more common in the US then you suspect.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by abvdasker on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:06PM (#21634325)
I don't understand why you're being downvoted (a comment which itself is likely to solicit downvotes). No serious discussion about the advantages or disadvantages of capitalism can be had without considering the role and utility of greed.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sokoloff on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:45PM (#21635226)
I strongly suspect that greed is much older than capitalism.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sudosysgen on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:48PM (#21635243)
Capitalism is literally allowing greed to run wild and almost completely unchecked. It's the driving force behind greed being such a force in 2019.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sachdevap on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:04PM (#21632808)
Let me rephrase that last sentence for what you are meaning it as "If you call this class warfare instead of unintended consequences, in my opinion, you are being paranoid or cynical."

Neither "paranoid" nor "cynical" are absolute terms to base your argument on.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by hinkley on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:53PM (#21633717)
I picked my phrasing carefully.

As the old saying goes, "Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't out to get you."

Actively plotting this outcome? That's a movie plot, sure. But negligence - even willful negligence - and microaggression? We know this happens all the time.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by helpPeople on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:18PM (#21631680)
Not sure your area, but unskilled labor goes for 15$/hr in metro Detroit.

You cannot get people to show up for less than that.

Source, wife owns a business and that's going rate to answer phones.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by michaelmrose on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:23PM (#21632381)
Because people can't live much of a life on less. This is especially true of health care which in places is free at some level of poverty and ruinously expensive at other levels. At some points working harder actually earns you greater poverty.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by gowld on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:24PM (#21632386)
Could you expand on the relation of that fact to the topic of minimum wage? Is $15/hr above or below Detroit minimum wage?
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by adventured on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:17PM (#21632909)
Walmart is commonly paying $12-$13/hr to first year employees around the US, Target is at a minimum $13/hr ($15/hr in 2020), Amazon is at $15/hr. Those are, broadly speaking, the new floor in American wages.

In cities, companies almost always have to pay more, so Walmart's wages on average are even higher in Detroit than in the middle of nowhere. They hoover up a lot of labor near or above $15/hr in places like Detroit.

Basically his wife's business is competing with massive labor absorbing machines that will pay at or above $15/hr. They also offer benefits. Small businesses (mom & pop types) that pay low wages and have tight margins often struggle to offer even basic competitive benefits, it's a very large additional cost in a business. So if she wants to take employees away from Walmart in Detroit, she might have to offer $18/hr instead.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by roflchoppa2 on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:20PM (#21631703)
is it difficult for your wifes business to make money, and pay your employees at $15 (or more)? Serious question.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by helpPeople on Monday November 25, 2019 @10:52PM (#21635530)
Maybe in a few years it will be easier. After 2 years she's only made 6k profit.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by xinsight on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:53PM (#21632069)
If it is difficult, then it's not a very good business.

Serious question: Why would you want to run a business that can only survive by paying people poverty wages?

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ryan_j_naughton on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:40PM (#21632552)
This is a very naive view of economics. Ideally everyone's income should be derived from the value they generate. So ideally wages continue to rise because productivity continues to rise.

But there are many cases where it make more sense to pay 4 low skilled workers to do a job instead of paying the costs of automation plus the cost of the higher skilled worker to use the automated solution. It's why so many jobs in India are still entirely manual labor -- it is simply more cost effective than a more technical, automated solution.

My wife works in international developmental economics, and providing jobs to the wide swaths of unskilled labor of the world to incrementally lift them out of poverty is an essential part of economic development. Sure, it would be nice if those people could just leapfrog in their education and consequently their levels of development, but that just isn't realistic.

Your comment indicates you are only looking at a very small subsector of the labor market and economy. Not everyone can be software engineers and highly skilled labor in the present.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by TheOperator on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:15PM (#21632893)
Generally I'm keen to believe the externalities of automation are not being passed onto its users. I.E. creating efficiency by taking away people's source of income & turning them into a tax burden.

With the minimum wage I suspect a similar effect. The effects increasing wages have on employers red ink doesn't wholly comprehend the positive effect more money in people's pockets has on black ink & overall productivity. A well invested grand in the hands of the poor is DRAMATICALLY more impactful than in a well invested grand in the hands of the rich due to diminishing returns. A company making a new product can deliver more value for society making some wonderful new invention the poor and middle class can spend their income on rather than some out of reach luxury good.

This logic by the way underpins the very unpopular around these parts notion of affirmative action.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:05PM (#21634320)
> Ideally everyone's income should be derived from the value they generate.

Define "value". Or more specifically, how do you measure "value" for jobs that don't directly generate revenue?

How much value does the janitorial staff create?

How much value does your IT team create?

What's the dollar value of your cybersecurity team?

What about HR?

None of these teams directly create revenue for the company, but certainly they created value. Meanwhile, Amazon has workers that pack boxes. They are directly contributing to revenue by doing the actual work that is core to the business. If cybersecurity, HR, the janitors, or IT were to disappear for a week, theoretically packages would still get sent to customers and Amazon still makes money.

And yet they're having to fight for fair wages? They're the most valuable labor in the company!

The idea that income should be derived from value is incredibly naive. As I mentioned in another comment, that mentality is what leads to managers laying off the entire IT team because they're seen as a money sink.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by gpanders on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:57PM (#21640762)
> The idea that income should be derived from value is incredibly naive.

On what other basis do you propose it be derived?

Non-revenue generating roles provide value by allowing the revenue-generating roles to generate revenue. This is the basic concept of specialization. You could likely even take a stab at quantifying this: time spent freeing up revenue-generating roles to generate revenue combined with some kind of supply-and-demand factor.

For example, if I'm a one-man widget shop, hiring a janitor to sweep the floors for me means I can spend that time generating more widgets instead of sweeping floors. The value provided by that janitor is proportional to the additional revenue I generated from those extra widgets, scaled by the large supply of janitors in the labor market.

The idea that income should be derived from value is only naive if you take a fixed view of "value == revenue". No doubt some middle managers have this view, but that's a sign of ignorance and incompetence, not a flaw in the underlying theory itself.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ChrisLomont on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:58PM (#21635293)
>How much value does the janitorial staff create?

When the company hires them, the company has decided that the company obtains enough value for the transaction. So does the janitorial staff.

>And yet they're having to fight for fair wages? They're the most valuable labor in the company!

Not if someone else is willing to do the job for the same pay - this is market clearing. They're paid what it takes to fill the position, and they show up for that wage. Both sides benefit, otherwise the side without getting benefit would not show up.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Sohcahtoa82 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:14AM (#21636665)
So then we are in agreement that wages are not a function of value created by the worker. They pay only what it takes to get the position filled, which is a completely unrelated number to value.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ChrisLomont on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:59PM (#21640788)
>So then we are in agreement that wages are not a function of value created by the worker.

Wages are a function of value created. As a trivial example, wages are capped by total cost to employ, which is driven by wages and legal requirements. There is no way around this on a large scale without a business losing money, i.e., dying.

>which is a completely unrelated number to value

No, this is untrue. Marx had the same thought, but didn't understand that employers also compete for workers, which is why the poorest workers are vastly richer than Marx could have understood.

A simple way you can check it empirically is to take a dataset of companies, compute mean revenue per employee, and correlate to mean wage by company. You'll certainly find that these numbers are completely related.

You can do the same thing using work sectors using BLS data on pay by job type, then revenue generated in those jobs. Again, you'll find a strong correlation between revenue generated per employee and per employee wages.

These empirical tests you can do yourself should convince you wages are tied to value added.

If you then do proper factor analysis to account for other costs varying between companies, such as cost for materials or equipment, the correlation between wages and value becomes stronger.

Edit: here's a dataset to get you started [1]. 1000 companies with # of employees and median wage. Find revenue per company and you're all set to do an initial analysis.

[1] https://www.wsj.com/graphics/how-does-your-pay-stack-up/

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by AlexandrB on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:44PM (#21633623)
> Ideally everyone's income should be derived from the value they generate.

This utterly breaks down at the upper end of income, so why is everyone gnashing their teeth about keeping it intact at the bottom end?

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by gridlockd on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:41PM (#21634928)
> This is a very naive view of economics. Ideally everyone's income should be derived from the value they generate. So ideally wages continue to rise because productivity continues to rise.

This is an ideal with no basis in reality. Wages are, to a first approximation, set by supply and demand, not "value generated". If I hire somebody, I pay the going rate for that type of employee, but only if I estimate that I can still make a profit. I take all the profit, I don't pay more than necessary just because there's more profit, unless I expect to generate even more profit as a result. If I estimate I don't make a profit, I don't hire at all.

Of course I want the most productive workers, so in theory I would be incentivized to reward more productive workers. In practice, actually measuring productivity is extremely difficult in most cases. Also, paying workers differently sows discord. Further, let's say I run an assembly line, I actually have no use for workers that are more productive than the average.

There's a narrow band between minimum wage being completely ineffectual (i.e. real wages are already higher than minimum wage) and pricing people out of the market (i.e. business becomes unprofitable). Only within that band, workers get higher wages, paid for by business profits. There can't be any one "correct" number here for all regions or all professions. Without a safety net to take over those priced out of the market, raising minimum wage is therefore completely irresponsible.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by pbhjpbhj on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:09PM (#21633353)
Serious answer: to achieve a particular lifestyle that's not available to you any other way.

We ran a pottery studio for 15 years whilst we raised our kids; very low wages, below minimum wage but paid our workers minimum wage (despite not needing to, because of age [in UK]).

The market we wanted to serve, a relatively poor UK city, couldn't take higher costs. So to provide that service - which brought us and many others much joy - we could only do it by accepting poverty wages. More money would have been good, but money isn't everything.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by pstuart on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:43PM (#21634938)
Thank you.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by throwaway5752 on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:01PM (#21632151)
Every business tries to pay people as little as possible. They are essentially obligated to do so by corporate structure, but just from competing in a free market this is usually the outcome outside of regulation (minimum wage) or collective bargaining. Right now there is a high demand for top end tech talent, but that too will pass, and we'll all see how our employers view us in a lower returns world. Stock options and grant comp is just a question of best outcomes and alignment.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by tyri_kai_psomi on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:21PM (#21632356)
I don't mean this offensively, but I had to roll my eyes at this one. This is the exact type of question I would expect from a tech startup focused board.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by cosmodisk on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:49PM (#21633179)
It's not a bad question per se. I've met so many people who complain how bad it is for their business because of low margins and etc. For instance, I'd never even consider starting a retail business,as unless you have economies of scale or sell water in the middle of a desert, you'd have to count every penny. However, having said that,I'm more than happy that people start all sorts of businesses,as otherwise we'd all end up selling CDOs to each other...
[dead]
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Romanulus on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:16PM (#21632304)
Amen. Imagine having to pay people to answer phones _more_ money.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:03PM (#21631536)
We inflation-adjust social security benefits annually, we could also do the same for minimum wage.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by noja on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:21PM (#21631712)
Would that defeat the point of inflation?
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by learc83 on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:33PM (#21631854)
No because 1. It only impacts a small percentage of workers. 2. It's a wealth transfer--money isn't created to pay it.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by wffurr on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:36PM (#21631902)
No, prices could still go down in real terms by remaining constant. The same for above minimum wage rates.

But by continually raising the floor, we make sure it doesn't get too far below the median or mean. That should be in everyone's best interest, both in terms of keeping the economy going by consumer spending and in terms of fairness and not having a desperately poor underclass.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by smileysteve on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:28PM (#21631790)
If anything, that would enforce it more.

Where the point of inflation is to force people to spend or invest their money today over keeping it as a store of value.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by pbhjpbhj on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:56PM (#21633239)
The point of inflation is to reduce the wages paid to poor people?
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by donatj on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:37PM (#21632527)
I would think if anything it would accelerate inflation, as it raises the price floor on what stores can ask for basic items.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by clairity on Monday November 25, 2019 @06:14PM (#21633916)
inflation is used to drive economic activity by keeping people from sitting on money (because it devalues over time). so do you think putting more money in the hands of minimum-wage workers will cause them to hoard money? what do you think is the point of inflation?
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by downerending on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:28PM (#21632999)
Some would say that the debate is whether raising minimum wage even has a net beneficial effect for those at the bottom of society.

The fact that we still have no clarity after looking at this closely for decades suggests that it's probably close to a wash, randomly benefiting some of the poor at the expense of others.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ajross on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:00PM (#21633279)
Sorry, can you cite some of the "Some" who would say that? I'm not aware of any serious research showing that minimum wage laws actually hurt "some of the poor" (I mean, like all regulation, they aren't perfectly targetted), but would be curious to see it.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by downerending on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:06PM (#21633334)
I meant some of us here in the peanut gallery.

(As to whether there are losers as well as winners when the minimum wage is implemented, this seems obvious, and I doubt anyone on any side would seriously try to dispute it. The question is the relative effect.)

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by larnmar on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:09PM (#21633352)
In the US, for instance, you have a massive (and very deliberately created) population of illegal aliens who can’t legally work anyway, so are unaffected by minimum wage laws. Raising minimum wage has the effect of making legal employees even less competitive with illegal ones, and since the authorities have no interest in enforcing their own laws, legal employment at the unskilled end is a sucker’s game.

This, I suspect, accounts for much of the backsliding in the last few decades among black and poor white populations in the US.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:05PM (#21635045)
I think you'll find those who support minimum wage laws also support the enforcement of those laws. I'm not sure if you're advocating for deportation, restrictions on immigrant labor, or something else entirely, but given that you're using terms like "illegal aliens," I'm going to assume you're not a fan.

We've already got mechanisms to crack down on black-market labor. Tax-dodging, not paying workers minimum wage, and subjecting employees to unsafe work conditions should be punished as such. In addition to punishing employers who exploit immigrant workers by paying them illegal wages, we should have much larger programs to allow unskilled undocumented immigrants to legally participate in the above-ground economy so the legal citizens aren't undercut. It's the same reason why we don't allow employers to pay teenagers below-minimum wage. Sure, teenagers don't have to support themselves (let alone a family) and might be happy to work for less, but if employers are allowed to pay kids five bucks an hour, they'd only hire kids and the minimum wage would completely fail.

In short - the only way to reduce black and gray markets is to punish the exploiters and decriminalize the exploited. Punish the pimps instead of the prostitutes, the drug-lords instead of the addicts, and the business-owners who skirt sensible labor regulations instead of the immigrant workers.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by downerending on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @02:56PM (#21642029)
I'm not the parent, but as a second-generation immigrant, I broadly agree with all of this. I'm fine with whatever laws we all decide, and I think they should then be vigorously enforced.

Our current wink-wink scheme, supported by both major parties, is bad for a lot of people, and in many way most harmful to illegal aliens (who are abused and/or are virtually enslaved).

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ajross on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @03:59PM (#21642631)
You think literally millions of people are sneaking across the southwest desert and risking having their children seized and put in cages[1] to be "abused and/or virtually enslaved"?. No, that's not how it works. Immigrant jobs tend to be poorly regulated (no taxes witheld, benefits delivered nor social services funded, etc...). But they're jobs and they pay what jobs pay, generally around minimum wage, because that's where the market chases.

I'll leave the both-sides-do-it argument. It's wrong, but there's no way to argue that on this site without getting myself banned.

[1] A policy very much not "supported by both major parties"...

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by downerending on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:20PM (#21684441)
I think that most illegal immigrants don't fully understand the downsides, yes. But whether or not that's true, I think it's unethical for us to tacitly encourage them to put themselves and their children in a position where they can be practically enslaved, or even raped or murdered, with little recourse to law.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by dragonwriter on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:30PM (#21684538)
> You think literally millions of people are sneaking across the southwest desert

No, even without the later qualifications; unique illegal border crossers aren't that high, and aren't all “sneaking across the southern desert”. It's not 2000 anymore.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ajross on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:13PM (#21633384)
Right, but what's the evidence for that? I get the argument you're making (and the nativist agenda behind it), but... it's literally disputed by the linked article. I mean, at some point one has to give up and just admit that maybe the analysis was wrong, right? Political facts still have to be facts in the real world, eventually, and thus subject to reason, right?
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sjg007 on Monday November 25, 2019 @06:42PM (#21634159)
A lot of farm labor (aka fruit pickers) and food processors.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by TrackerFF on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:26PM (#21634859)
> Minimum wage isn't just flat for a decade, it's not being adjusted for inflation. This means minimum wage workers have been getting a pay cut over time.

All while necessities like rent / housing has increased faster than inflation.

No wonder lots of minimum wage people have multiple jobs. Pay stays the same, but rent goes up $50/month every year - without any changes.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sobhaobnONJ on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:22PM (#21631732)
I don't understand why this isn't a red herring. Minimum wage may be remaining stagnant but total employee compensation has been rising steadily, it's just that most of that compensation is in the form of spending on employee benefits like insurance. If people quit expecting employers to provide them with anything except for cold hard cash then you'd likely see wages increasing with time.

To expand a bit more on this, large companies in America can negotiate rates with the insurance companies they interact with (assuming they don't own one in house). This creates a scenario where a dollar into the insurance budget yields more than a dollar worth of value and so it makes much more sense to invest heavily in the insurance than in outright wages because a dollar paid to an employee only ever yields a dollar with of value to the employee.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by hinkley on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:29PM (#21631803)
It's rare for a company to offer health insurance to employees who are pegged to minimum wage.

If salaries are going down due to inflation, then you may have a point but it's a perverse one; medical costs are going up way faster than anything else.

Both are reasons to support socialized medical coverage, but they don't really enter into this particular line of discussion.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by gowld on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:31PM (#21632470)
If medical costs increase more than the amount of general inflation's effect on both medical costs and the rest of wages, than covering those increasing costs while holding the rest of wages constant is a wage increase.

If you don't like that, it's a social issue and a policy question, but it's not evidence what wage (how much employer is paying for employee benefits) is stagnant or droppiing.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by yardie on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:41PM (#21633117)
If the workers aren't getting it in their paycheck it is not a wage increase. It is simply another tax, neither the employer nor the employee benefit from it so who exactly is this benefit for?
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by AlexandrB on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:48PM (#21633661)
Worse, it’s a regressive tax.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by CydeWeys on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:40PM (#21634538)
Yup. You can't eat your medical insurance, nor can you live in it.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sobhaobnONJ on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:01PM (#21632147)
Truthfully I agree but I'd argue this seems more like a reason to decouple healthcare from employment entirely. Such as with socialized medical coverage like you suggest.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ambicapter on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:08PM (#21632226)
Large US Companies are incentivized to keep healthcare something they solely provide because it ties their employee's health coverage to their employment status, putting pressure on them to keep their job or face paying their hospital bills in full.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by hinkley on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:19PM (#21632334)
Which in almost any other conversation would be called extortion.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by asdff on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:25PM (#21632973)
It really shows you whose interests a politician is working to advance when they state how much Americans love their private extortion plans.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by cosmodisk on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:55PM (#21633230)
And yet people go and vote for them with hopes that some random real estate billionaire will bring prosperity to their homes. The entire thing would collapse after first election if people would vote with brains instead of feelings.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by boomboomsubban on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:33PM (#21631863)
>This creates a scenario where a dollar into the insurance budget yields more than a dollar worth of value

Using this same logic, a better use of that dollar would be spending it on taxes as the even larger government can negotiate even better rates with healthcare providers, providing even more value to the employee.

Instead, the company fights to keep that dollar so they can spend it as they see fit, and the employee wants that dollar so they can use it as they want to.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by kangnkodos on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:49PM (#21632650)
"government can negotiate even better rates"

Yes. Up to a point. It's true that in general, the government currently pays less than private insurers.

What's not clear is what happens if/when the government is the only one paying hospitals to keep their doors open. At the reduced rate, hospitals will have hard choices to make. Only about 20% of hospitals are for-profit. For the other 80%, less money coming in the door will result in changes of some kind. I can't imagine how hospitals can do that, and make things better for patients at the same time. Something's got to give.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by boomboomsubban on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:29PM (#21633495)
>What's not clear is what happens if/when the government is the only one paying hospitals to keep their doors open.

What isn't clear about this? The government pays the hospitals to keep their doors open.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by AlexandrB on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:03PM (#21635038)
The same thing will happen as in almost every other developed country: average well-being will go up but some people will have to wait longer for treatment. It’s not like this is some novel, utopian idea. Public heath care is the norm in most western countries with plenty of variations and lessons-learned to choose from.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sobhaobnONJ on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:43PM (#21631969)
That's not entirely true. Taxes on production and services are ultimately taxes on consumption, this is part of why many economists have advocated for a mix of raising income taxes on specific income brackets and having a more generous EITC.

You could of course do as you propose, but that same logic could also be used to argue that we simply shouldn't let healthcare providers negotiate with employers and instead restrict them to dealing directly with State entities (since otherwise the bargaining power becomes slanted against individuals).

Edit: I didn't clarify well, the reason I mentioned the point about production taxes is because many minimum wage employees work in places like Walmart that sell commonly needed items and thus some of the benefit is lost because you've increased costs for the people you're helping. In theory this isn't a problem for luxury goods but that's more complicated so I haven't talked about those much.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by boomboomsubban on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:27PM (#21632426)
> and thus some of the benefit is lost because you've increased costs for the people you're helping

This is nonsensical. If paying that one dollar in taxes necessitated raising the prices, then the company spending it on insurance would also necessitate raising prices.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by bart_spoon on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:27PM (#21631777)
Increased spending on employee insurance is due to increasing healthcare costs. Even if companies are spending more on their employees healthcare, employees are still paying more on healthcare than ever before. So, that still means less money available for everything that isn't healthcare, and is functionally equivalent to a pay cut.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sobhaobnONJ on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:50PM (#21632044)
An increase in spending is an increase in spending, it is still a part of the total compensation an employee has received. My point was purely that lensing the issue through minimum wage by itself seems like a distraction in terms of understanding employee wealth, I'm not arguing that employees should stop wanting more because they're getting enough.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ikeboy on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:25PM (#21632398)
Which is great. Wages are sticky, making it difficult to reduce nominal wages. Inflation helps prevent layoffs by allowing for some real reduction in wages in a weak economy without having to reduce nominal wages.

Getting rid of this mechanism would be bad.

Perhaps minimum wage should be indexed to median wage or something, but it should absolutely not be indexed to inflation.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by donatj on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:35PM (#21632500)
> This means minimum wage workers have been getting a pay cut over time.

This here is the strawman of the argument. Very few employed continuously for ten years continue to make minimum wage / don't move on to better jobs.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by heylook on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:50PM (#21632671)
No, you are making the straw man argument. The argument is not that the exact same people have been holding the exact same jobs with exactly the same pay the whole time. There's a reason you found it so simple to lampoon. That reason is you chose to view the argument as naively as possible.

The argument is that any minimum wage earner is worse off than a minimum wage earner the year prior, and the year prior, and the year prior, etc. By holding the minimum wage fixed, we are making the default decision that a minimum wage earner tomorrow should have less effective purchasing power than a minimum wage earner today.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by cheriot on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:51PM (#21632680)
There's always a segment of society trying to make ends meet on minimum wage. It doesn't matter how long one person is doing it.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:21PM (#21634403)
You're not thinking your argument through.

A quick Google search says that a dollar in the year 2000 is worth half as much as a 1980 dollar. Yet, during that time, federal minimum wage went from $3.10 to $5.15, an increase of only about 66%. That means my parents had an easier time surviving off of minimum wage than I did.

How is that fair at all?