News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by gorgoiler on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:26AM (#21619996)
If you consider this to be exploiting the consumer then this is a good example for the textbooks of how, in a free market, there has to be some regulation to prevent exploitation of those at the edges of society.

It’s exactly the same argument for laws against the most vulnerable types of sex work, or selling body organs donated by the living. Without those laws, those who are most desperate will be able to act in desperation, to someone else’s benefit, with society doing nothing to stand in the way.

It’s probably time ad-tech was re calibrated on this spectrum before we race to the exploitative-bottom there as well, and build a shopping mall that we don’t want on the open common land that we do.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:37AM (#21620324)
Regulating freely consented exchanges _you_ don't like out of existence will not actually make them disappear, just push them underground, out of society's eye and where the REAL exploitation takes place.

That's why adults actually working in those domains militate for legalization and that's why totalitarian societies require so much surveillance just to avoid collapse.

Because people WILL do the deals they need to do to survive or get ahead. Your laws will just provide the reason to catch and incarcerate them afterwards.

See the marijuana legalization mess.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by geofft on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:40AM (#21620674)
Sure, but that's not an argument for "actually exploitation is good." That's an argument for figuring out a solution to exploitation seeming like a rational choice in the first place.

In some cases, the problem is just that the free market sets up a race to the bottom and regulations can provide an artificial bottom. This is the standard argument for the minimum wage, for instance: even if businesses can afford to pay more and still be profitable, they won't voluntarily do so in a market where there's more supply of labor than demand for it.

In some cases, like livestreaming your hotel stay or selling your organs or sacrificing your lungs to mine coal, there's a qualitative difference, and saying "This job no longer exists" doesn't solve problems. If that's the case, society should figure out if it can afford in any way to provide for people's basic needs so that they can start having meaningful other options.

It seems entirely possible to me that a society with a strong social safety net (welfare, UBI, whatever) needs less regulation of its free market than one that puts the burden on its market to treat the most desperate in society with fairness.

(BTW, a minor point about sex work: I believe "legalization" refers to making it a regulated industry with the remaining possibility of criminal penalties for breaking regulations, and many sex workers prefer "decriminalization," i.e. just removing criminal penalties.)

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:56AM (#21620760)
Minimum wage hurts most the very people it pretends to help: the least productive of us, who become unemployable legally.

Business who can't raise their labor costs will either:

  - raise prices while passing costs to consumers
  - go out of business thus reducing consumer choice
  - turn onto robots or offshoring (if possible)
None of those is good for neither workers nor consumers. I'd rather we raise worker wages the Silicon Valley way: through merciless competition between companies for talent, while encouraging said talent to start their own competing businesses.

You know what minimum wage is great for? Electing politicians.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by contravariant on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:10AM (#21620843)
Businesses that cannot turn a profit without paying their employees enough to cover basic expenses (leaving aside whether this is higher or lower than the current minimum wage) do not deserve to exist. Having those jobs automated away or passing the cost of living of the employees on to the customers are both reasonable alternatives.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by katzgrau on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:29AM (#21621400)
> do not deserve to exist

It's an easy position take take when you're a well paid developer and money problems aren't a concern.

I used to feel the same way, until I started my own business. I couldn't attract venture capital and I had to bootstrap the company. There was no way in hell I was using my house for a loan.

Early on I relied on people who wanted to stay relevant, but needed flexibility, and were happy to take a lower hourly wage. For example, a stay at home parent whose SO earned the majority of the household income.

My business contributes sincere value to a niche industry that otherwise doesn't get any attention or investment. It's been said by several in my industry that without my company, several hundred community news organizations would likely fail.

Today, I can afford to pay a living wage. But now I understand that growing a real revenue generating business (without artificially inflating a company via investment) is difficult, and often requires low cost labor in order to get to the place where you can afford higher cost labor. Try it and you may not be as idealistic.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 24, 2019 @01:00PM (#21622077)
That's a good point, and a nice bottom-up view. The other side, the "do not deserve to exist" position however seems also true. It's a top-down view, coming from empirical observation: under competitive pressure, businesses will end up abusing everything and everyone that they can get away with abusing. Your bottom-up view relies on your own moral character - you were able to find people willing to work for below-market rates while making it a win-win and non-abusive situation. Top-down view correctly notes that ethics don't scale under economic pressure - and I have a whole collection of second-hand anecdotes demonstrating that - things people I personally know experienced.

My point being, I see both views as correct in principle. The hard challenge lies in reconciling them - letting good people craft better deals, while preventing malicious individuals from abusing their fellow human beings.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by em-bee on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:10AM (#21627373)
i totally have the same problem. i can't afford the wages that employees ask for. but that doesn't give me an excuse to hire people who are willing to work for less. yes, off-shoring is an option, and financially that would work, and is certainly a better option than underpaying locals who need more to pay their rent.

i do not believe that underpaying locals is a better option than off-shoring. even if the unemployment is high enough that people are willing to work for scraps, then i still believe that it is better for changes that allow me to actually pay local employees instead of taking the money out of employees pockets by paying them less.

the question should not be: how can we lower employment income so that you can hire more people. but how can we lower other costs so that small businesses can afford to pay people what they need for life.

so yes, i am trying for some years now, and i remain as idealistic as ever.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by thenewnewguy on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:41AM (#21621491)
Does that mean you _would_ agree with this position if the qualifier "that has existed for more than X months" or "makes more than $X/year" was added?
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by tenebrisalietum on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:51AM (#21621569)
Couple of counterpoints:

- Let's say I'm a 16 year old adolescent who's doing well in school and wants to take a part-time/weekend job to gain experience in the job market. My basic expenses are covered (I live with my parents). Should a business get to pay me less just because of this fact?

- I'm a wife of a rich man and have never had to work, but decided to try it because I'm bored. I know nothing but the finer things of life and my basic expenses are 10x what the middle class is. If a business has to cover basic expenses why are we not going to cover this claim of full expenses, what determines in a corruption-free manner whether a claim for a basic expense is valid, and what is an acceptable burden to a business owner to determine this?

- Let's say I'm a jobless struggling adult, sharing a cramped living space with 4 others including 1 or 2 who are drug addicts. A job would really help me get out of this situation, but company X is only willing to pay minimum wage. It's better than what I have now which is nothing. How is having this job automated away a reasonable alternative for me - because you don't want this employer to give me a job in the first place because it doesn't cover my expenses.

- Let's say I'm a customer of your business, and you decide to pass on the full cost of living of all employees to me. Your product jumps from $10 to $50. I'm not shopping there, your business closes, and your employees are now jobless. How does this help anybody?

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by thenewnewguy on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:11PM (#21621730)
Are the first 2 points even made seriously? Obviously they aren't advocating for businesses to compensate people for exactly their specific 'basic expenses', they clearly intend to mean basic expenses for low to middle class in general, not based on the person.

Also, it always seems weird that whenever a minimum wage discussion comes up people jump in with these obviously contrived what if scenarios. How about we care about the real people that can barely/cannot afford food/housing/etc because businesses don't pay enough, rather than these situations with made up people.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by dantheman on Sunday November 24, 2019 @02:24PM (#21622648)
The number of teenagers having jobs has plummeted over time as minimum wage has increased. Teenagers don't often have the skills / work ethic / experience needed to provide more value than they cost and so the job is eliminated. We are removing the bottom rung of the ladder. This is not a contrived example.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by tenebrisalietum on Sunday November 24, 2019 @03:33PM (#21623154)
> How about we care about the real people that can barely/cannot afford food/housing/etc because businesses don't pay enough

Obviously depending on people to care out of the goodness of their hearts isn't working, if someone really cared about these people they wouldn't be in their situation. You can ask me or anyone else to care, you can even pressure them into appearing to care, but you can't really make them care, so this is a bad way to solve a problem.

If a good system that doesn't depend on emotions, media performances, or pathos can be put into place, it's probably going to be more reliable in the long run, and can mutually benefit both those in bad situations and those who would like to be able to walk in a city without getting asked for money constantly.

Hence it's very valid and good to ask what exactly entails things like "basic expenses" and use hypothetical situations.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by jebeng on Sunday November 24, 2019 @06:25PM (#21624242)
> if someone really cared about these people they wouldn't be in their situation.

Do you really think that?

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:54PM (#21622030)
1 and 2 are counterexamples to something nobody really argues for, even in case of UBI. 3 is a more general problem, and a social safety net is one example solution here.

WRT 4, regulatory intervention ideas like minimum wage only work and derive all their power from being universally. Even if, as in your example, my product jumps from $10 to $50 (which would be something unprecedented), all my competitors (within the country) face the same issue too! Their prices will have to jump by roughly $40 as well. The overall demand for the product category may go down, but my position relative to competitors remains unchanged.

This may not work well for goods that can be easily offshored, like manufacturing plastic widgets. But (with the caveat that I'm not an economist, and didn't study this in too much detail) it seems perfectly matched for physical-space services sector - something, which by very definition can't offshore, and also resists automation pretty well.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sabujp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:13PM (#21621740)
> Your product jumps from $10 to $50

Please show where this has happened.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by hartator on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:20AM (#21620884)
What about an artist selling his art for less than the hourly minimum wage it cost him to make it? Should he get arrested?
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by jsjohnst on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:03AM (#21621187)
> passing the cost of living of the employees on to the customers

I see this trope a lot, but the point I think it misses is the customers of these businesses are often enough the ones making minimum wage. So raising the business’s prices to pay the higher wages just ends up in a self defeating loop for all involved.

If the solution to poverty was “just give the poor people money”, it would’ve been done already I believe. Sadly, societal problems are generally not easy to solve.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:17AM (#21620869)
By your logic startups (and pretty much any new business) should not exist, since they turn no profit for years.

And this is why Socialist economies are so crappy and need minimal wage laws: they kill their startups before they even exist and have no competition on the talent market.

And then they wonder why they can't produce an Apple, Microsoft, Amazon or Google...

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by humanrebar on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:33AM (#21620962)
See also: low paying internships and apprenticeships where the experience and networking is part of the compensation.

The problem with minimum wage laws is that they presume there are no other forms of compensation than wages.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by thenewnewguy on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:48AM (#21621550)
The problem with this argument is that is presumes that other forms of compensation can be used to purchase food, healthcare, housing, etc.

Also, unpaid internships are legal in the US (at least federally) if they are primarily for the benefit/training of the worker and that information is made available upfront.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by humanrebar on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:33PM (#21625235)
No, it presumes that the people taking these jobs have access to those things through other means. Like parental support, spousal support, scholarships, student loans, fellowships, government programs, side gigs, etc.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by bachmeier on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:12AM (#21620849)
Just FYI, the argument for a minimum wage is that the market for workers is not a competitive market, allowing firms to pay low wages and putting the difference between the competitive wage and market wage into profit.

Kind of funny that you'd refer to Silicon Valley as an example. Aside from having no practical implications (you can't snap your fingers and make markets act the way you want) they had one of the most famous cases of employers colluding to drive down wages.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:21AM (#21620893)
And even then they managed to get wages to a few times larger than in the rest of the country.

I rest my case...

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by salawat on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:16AM (#21621296)
Your case isn't rested at all given most businesses in the United States aren't in a position to do business globally without heavily escalated logistical or infrastructural cost expansion due to physical goods or services (body in seat) as their product. Whereas Silicon Valley companies often only have to ensure that their information processing infrastructure expand to meet the capability to track/handle transactional load in order to have global consumer bases to pull from, thus allowing that several times higher wage financially. The digital expansion scales far easier than the physical.

Those wages therefore aren't some quirk of the unregulated free market. That was physics. More income sources = more income extraction = higher geographic pool to fuel competitive salary while earning a profit. Yet you still have to answer for wage suppressive collusion. Despite having everything going right for them, they still colluded.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by jyounker on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:16PM (#21621765)
Those of us subject to the wage competition in silicon valley make wages many times higher than the minimum wage. We're talking an order of magnitude more money. Competition in silicon valley does shit all for the people on the lower end of the wage scale in the bay area.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by Faark on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:16AM (#21620863)
You conveniently forgot the "use existing profits that would have gone to owner to instead cover costs", something that seems to actually happen in combination with the others instead of the usually doomsday prediction before introduction / increase of minimum wages.

I understand slower progress would mean less conflict. But I'm also fine with robots, since accelerated progress means I'll experience more of it in the time I have left.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:24AM (#21620912)
OK, I'll add it here:

- decrease owner's profits to the point she will rather close the business and get a low-stress job as middle manager in some multinational corporation

As it happens, I am looking forward to robots too but I doubt they will help the least-productive members of our society too much...

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by geofft on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:37PM (#21621915)
I should have been clearer: I'm not taking a position on whether that argument for minimum wage is accurate. I don't know enough.

If it's not, then minimum wage also falls in the second category - of problems that should be solved by saying "Society will provide for the least profitable workers among us," not "You shouldn't be legally unemployable, but being legally underemployable is your own problem."

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by pacala on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:43AM (#21621501)
Minimum wage laws are part of the larger system, not an isolated black/white switch. What if people out of employment also get some financial support to retrain / kick out their addictions / cure a sickness. A minimum wage law would push a number of people out of employment, but the additional support systems would increase their chances to come back at a higher wage level. We do this all the time at a personal level, by deferring employment and using the time [and hefty sums of money] to go to school.

The end result may well be diverting resources from the most productive centers of society to the most needing sections thereof. Worse, it will be afflicted by corruption, only a fraction of the diverted money will end up on the most needing people plate.

What level of wasteful spending we are comfortable with?

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by jyounker on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:02PM (#21621649)
> Minimum wage hurts most the very people it pretends to help: the least productive of us, who become unemployable legally.

How do you explain that the countries with the highest minimum wages also seem to have plentiful jobs and high performing economies? It seems that with your logic the should have large unemployed underclasses, but that doesn't seem to be the case.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by outlace on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:17PM (#21621776)
Probably because already rich countries can afford to have high minimum wages in the first place. But many European countries with high minimum wages either by government fiat or because of strong unions have unemployment rates 2 or 3 times higher than the U.S. (e.g. Spain, Italy, Portugal, Sweden, France).
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:21PM (#21624511)
A fourth possibility: wage distribution flattens.

Few policies split economists as equally as the minimum wage, and I'm not necessarily advocating for it, but it's a little bit telling that you don't even consider that business might successfully adjust their compensation structures.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by gorgoiler on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:20AM (#21620573)
I think it’s ok to separate what one approves of or doesn’t approve of, from a separate axis of looking at what causes objective harm and misery to people.

Some of the hardest policy topics involve accepting things one finds distasteful because there is a moral ground for people being allowed to do what they want, and vice versa.

Your point on cannabis is certainly an excellent example of how to get policy wrong and create a huge net harm to society, especially in the US where late night TV hosts can joke about getting high, while 8 million others were arrested and harassed for possession over the last decade.

In my experience, from what I’ve learned from my friends who work with rough sleepers, all sex work is exploitative of those in desperation to some extent. It’s a spectrum that has at one end people trying to make ends meet, and at the other, slavery and trafficking.

I know of attempts to unionize and protect some kinds of sex work, but I don’t know if that represents the majority or a vocal and comparatively unexploited minority. It’s never the most exploited that you see in a debate arguing for complete legalization.

It’s easy to see both sides of an argument. It’s difficult and important to focus on where harm is being done, and to do something about that. For something with as rocky a history as prohibition has, I’m in favor of the arguments for it when it comes to sex work, and to my original point — to try to drag this back on topic! — it’s an example of required action to step in where the free market fails to protect the most vulnerable from harm.

Edit: and it’s stories like this $1 voyeur hotel that really add positively to thought on the subject. A really good non-tech HN submission, imho.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by mirajshah on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:42AM (#21620682)
Your friends are probably not the best source on the matter. Go on YouTube and listen to interviews with actual sex workers in places where it is institutionalized (e.g. Amsterdam, New Zealand). There are plenty of Vice documentaries e.g. https://youtu.be/Q8_UGthO3CM
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by gorgoiler on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:50AM (#21620714)
I’d reiterate that my sources are trained professionals who already work with the most vulnerable people who society has already failed — those who sleep rough and who have turned to or are thinking of turning to sex work. I accept your point though, that “sex worker” is a wide bracket that encompasses a range of personal situations though. Thanks for the link.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by Jamwinner on Sunday November 24, 2019 @01:43PM (#21622358)
Exqctly, get it first hand. Most of the professionals are so detached by nessesity, that their views are skewed, no matter how noble their intentions.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by timoth3y on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:49PM (#21625547)
> Regulating freely consented exchanges _you_ don't like

I believe the argument they are trying to make is not about whether they like the transaction, but what constitutes "freely consented".

If someone's alternative is, for example, going hungry or sleeping on the streets or having their children go hungry, can we really say they are giving their consent freely?

Should we be concerned about other forms of coercion in addition to direct physical violence?

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by debrice on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:15PM (#21621760)
I think your argument would make more sense if the actor in the room was paid a fair wage
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by Jamwinner on Sunday November 24, 2019 @01:49PM (#21622398)
Define 'fair' in a way 65% would agree with. To me, 'fair' is what I negotiate. In my view, when value and price are decoupled, things tend not to go well. Keeping the things we value expensive, is exactly as it should be. This view does not perclude a social 'safety net', it just takes the position that wage laws should not be forced into imperfect duty as one.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by gorgoiler on Sunday November 24, 2019 @06:43PM (#21624329)
Somewhat tongue in cheek, but if we’re going to consider the hotel residents as actors, and the room as remuneration equivalent to the fair market value of the room, then US residents should expect to be paying income tax on their stay. Oof: this is sadly all too plausible a scenario.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by lightedman on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:25PM (#21621840)
"Regulating freely consented exchanges _you_ don't like out of existence will not actually make them disappear,"

If only online discussion forums could figure this one out...

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by paggle on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:10PM (#21621720)
Yes, but the theory is that the requirement to be underground decreases transaction volume. So in a country where organ selling is banned, there will be far fewer cases of organ selling, although those that do happen will be far more horrifying than anything that would happen in a legal framework.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by balfirevic on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:05AM (#21620480)
> It’s exactly the same argument for laws against the most vulnerable types of sex work, or selling body organs donated by the living.

So, invalid?

Selling organs is such a curious example because people present it thinking it's a completely clear-cut case. But it's nowhere close:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_trade#Ethical_debate_for...

https://www.npr.org/2008/05/21/90632108/should-we-legalize-t...

Please note that you don't have to be persuaded that organ trade can be good, just understand that it's very far from obviously and always being bad.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by gorgoiler on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:41AM (#21620677)
Thank you for the counter-point. I can see how it’s easy to come from the view that it is always bad. It certainly puts Hotel Voyeur into perspective, as an issue for society to spend its finite energy on tackling.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sneak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:37AM (#21620042)
It’s not exploitation if adults, without coercion, agree to it of their own free will. It’s no one’s place to tell them what they aren’t allowed to do with their bodies or their lives (provided it’s not harming anyone else), simply because you wouldn’t make the same choice or don’t agree with it.

This is what self-ownership is about. To try to control others in this way is deeply immoral.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by caseymarquis on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:07AM (#21620496)
Adhering to axiomatic principles like self-ownership to the degree that you can justify scenarios like 'an addict legally selling their kidney' is a mistake. It's the equivalent of trying to stick to Newton's laws to explain the universe: they work great right up until there's a contradiction.

I'm all for decriminalization of drugs and sex work, but another first principle is that society should protect the vulnerable. Sometimes, regulation will be the best tool for that. Other times, a deregulated market will be the best tool. Unfortunately, the world is complex. While our principles can guide us, each situation needs to be considered individually and the right set of tools needs to be selected after careful consideration.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sneak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:04AM (#21621197)
> Adhering to axiomatic principles like self-ownership to the degree that you can justify scenarios like 'an addict legally selling their kidney' is a mistake. It's the equivalent of trying to stick to Newton's laws to explain the universe: they work great right up until there's a contradiction.

That is precisely when it's most needed! There is no entity on Earth that can make any better claim to authority over a person's kidney than the owner of that kidney. The fact that you call them an "addict" as a way to delegitimize their decisions is an appeal to emotion; but ultimately every person is the sole determining authority on their own kidneys, without exception. This is not something that the opinions of others have any bearing on. In fact, "in cases of addiction" is a good canary in this coal mine: it's frequently trotted out by people who think that circumstances—any circumstances—are legitimate reasons to override another person's self-determination about their own physical person or choices about which that harm no other party, in an appeal to "common sense". It's not!

There isn’t a contradiction in an addict deciding to destroy themselves in continuing an addiction, and this decision is no more or less legitimately made than an addict deciding to cease their addiction. In all cases it is theirs alone to make.

Many of my friends have made each choice. It is always theirs to make, and neither is correct and neither is incorrect—unless it is forced upon them against their will!

It’s not a matter of “vulnerable”, or “decriminalization”, or “regulation”, or of markets. It is the basic philosophical premise that you don’t get to make these decisions for others unless you are willing to declare yourself their master and dominate them, using some handwaving excuse (e.g. "addiction") as justification for substituting your wishes for theirs—over their own body or choices.

The fact that you may have widespread opinion supporting “people shouldn’t get addicted to drugs and destroy themselves” is irrelevant. No person can legitimately claim this power over another in any circumstance, especially and most importantly the extreme ones. Self-destruction of any kind, but, to use an example, euthanasia, is not only legitimate in the case of terminal illness, or when loved ones agree and empathize with it. It is every person's own right to determine what happens physically to their own body, at all times and in all circumstances.

You’re using a lot of words and emotional context to dodge this plain and simple (and perhaps inconvenient) fact; the truth is, unfortunately, that such arguments have no moral basis, and are fundamentally immoral in that they violate consent.

Our bodies are our own to destroy and mutilate in any way we see fit. To use force to impose your will over top of their own and prohibit someone from exercising that basic right of self-determination is the blackest of crimes against an adult human being; it is logically equivalent to raping them, in my view of the violation of consent that it opts to impose upon them.

Please abandon this way of thinking, that you (or anyone else, or "society", or "government") are entitled to choices over the body of another person—for any reason, including and especially the ones you find disgusting, destructive, distasteful, or repugnant.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by helen___keller on Monday November 25, 2019 @11:10AM (#21629418)
This is a feels-good paragraph, but it does not apply to the real world we live in.

Full and unlimited self-determination implies that all contracts made in any situation by an individual are valid. But not every contract is well-analyzed and well-considered and made in perfect information.

If you are arguing that all contracts made by individuals are valid, even when in imperfect information, when not right of mind, etc, then I disagree with you. It may be a fundamental philosophical difference, but all your feels good "oh dont violate my right to self determination" seems weak if that person can't even properly comprehend the transaction they are making.

If you are not arguing this then your entire argument falls apart: once we care about being right of mind, we can speak of restricting addicts or drunks from certain transactions. Once we care about imperfect information, we can restrict or remove usurious loans. Indeed, these basic ideas of what is a "valid" transaction give credence to to the language of "vulnerable people" and laws that aim to protect them from predatory transactions.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by CryptoPunk on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:07AM (#21620825)
No court would consider the exchange you describe as consensual. The addict wouldn't be judged as having the capacity to provide consent.

These issues should be decided by courts, after deliberating on the facts of individual cases, and not narratives that spread throughout the public due to the virality of simplistic generalizations that appeal to emotions.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by madiathomas on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:46AM (#21620078)
People need to be protected from themselves sometimes. Just because someone is an adult, doesn’t mean they will always make correct decisions. Plus, you are never sure if they are doing it without being coerced and silenced at the same time by some powerful mafia.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sneak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:55AM (#21620126)
> Just because someone is an adult, doesn’t mean they will always make correct decisions.

It is impossible for you to substitute your definition of correct for another person’s own when it comes to their body and their life without denying them agency and declaring yourself their superior, and in the process violating their rights to self-determination.

If they are harming no one but themselves, you have no moral basis to deny them their freedom to do so, unless you deem yourself competent to be their parent or guardian simply on the basis of that single decision of theirs, which is not reasonable by any stretch of the imagination.

> People need to be protected from themselves sometimes.

The only protection that most people want is protection from people who think this way about their lives, myself included.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by madiathomas on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:03AM (#21620164)
That’s why society as a whole makes that decision about what they consider correct and what they consider incorrect through laws and ethical standards. Unless you are in a dictatorship, laws and ethical standards are representative of the majority.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sneak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:19AM (#21620237)
“Society as a whole” cannot decide anything, as “society” is an abstraction, and a leaky one at that.

If an individual can’t decide for another, no assemblage of individuals can legitimately claim that authority either.

I certainly don’t want to live in a place where it takes hundreds of years for the majority to finally decide that, for example, racial minorities really do deserve equal protection under the law (or a hundred years to reach the point where it is not legal to enslave them).

Surely you see the problem.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by bcrosby95 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:09AM (#21620507)
Ultimately the law of the land is might makes right. In a democracy that tends to lie with masses of people (sometimes counter balanced by protective laws), in other instances it tends to rest in the hands of the few.

Ultimately power has to rest somewhere. If it's nowhere then someone will come and take it.

The modern alternative isn't some panacea. It's the corporation and the indifference of rights so long as it doesn't negatively impact the bottom line.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by Cakez0r on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:58AM (#21620776)
The majority can end up oppressing a minority. Better to just err on the side of "live and let live", no?
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:13AM (#21620208)
> People need to be protected from themselves sometimes.

Said every dictator, ever. Also:

  "It's for your own good"
  "Without me, others would take advantage of you"
  "I am protecting you"
  "I know better than you what you need"
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by madiathomas on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:25AM (#21620260)
But even countries which aren’t under dictatorship have laws to protect people against themselves. Even those who are on top of the list of most democratic countries.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:47AM (#21620376)
And while some of those laws are OK, they should ALL be scraped for the principle that:

"Nobody knows better than me what is better for myself and mine."

It's not always true (see vaccination or smoking) but the alternative is much worse and in much more cases.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by madiathomas on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:25AM (#21620600)
> "Nobody knows better than me what is better for myself and mine."

Smokers and anti-vaccination also use the same argument. Even though their actions are also dangerous to other people(kids). I am sure they felt oppressed when public smoking was banned. Smokers will tell you that smoking isn’t different to dangerous sports or unsafe sex. Yet, dangerous sports/unsafe sex isn’t banned.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by rowanG077 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:25PM (#21621834)
This is completely different. Smokers and anti-vaxxers are harming the public in a significant way. I wouldn't care for smokers if they could only do it in a hermetically sealed room where no smoke escapes from. Neither would I care for anti-vaxxers who are completely segregated from society so they don't hurt herd immunity.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sneak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:05AM (#21621206)
The argument against banning smoking in public is that it forces others to inhale the smoke against their will simply by sharing space, not that the person doing the smoking has no right to put it into themselves. In a sense, it is an anti-pollution law.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by zzo38computer on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:40AM (#21625963)
I agree with that. But I also think there is other reason for anti-pollution laws, which is in addition to saving people, also saving the Earth, too, which is also important (independently of if the people are saved; some people want to do so for the people but I think that is only a part of it).

And if someone does have a hermetically sealed room no smoke will escape from, I suppose that is OK, so shouldn't be illegal except forcing someone to do against their will.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by kennyadam on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:47AM (#21621539)
You libertarians.

Please address their point about antivaxxers.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by iudqnolq on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:33AM (#21625937)
A libertarian might argue that that falls under restricting an individual's right to harm others. They might believe that individuals don't have the right to increase the risk to people who can't vaccinate for heath reasons, and they might believe that parents don't have the right to harm their children by depriving them of their health.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by moron4hire on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:34AM (#21620305)
Maybe we shouldn't protect people from themselves, but we should definitely protect people from the consequences it others disastrous mistakes. I don't need my idiot neighbors playing with fireworks.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickpp on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:42AM (#21620350)
Agreed. But the OP was talking about a freely consented exchange with no repercussions on others.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by moron4hire on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:21AM (#21620892)
Ah, yes, the mathematical "spherical cow".
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by madiathomas on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:28AM (#21620615)
That’s why I said sometimes. It isn’t all the time that you need to protect people but kids needs to be protected. People who are mentally ill must be protected from themselves. In some cases, even forcefully put them in mental hospitals. There is always a grey area.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by zzo38computer on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:48AM (#21625990)
Laws should not protect people from themself (education should do that instead). It can protect people and animals and trees from some bad stuff some people are doing (e.g. fireworks, as message 21620305 mentions), while trying to not be so restrictive. I think even mentally ill people should not be protected from themself (unless the condition is temporary).
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by gorgoiler on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:43AM (#21620683)
In an attempt be polite and constructive: reaching for dictatorships as a counter example feels extreme.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by learnstats2 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:20AM (#21620241)
Every sentence you have said could equally refer to tech industry workers - and perhaps there would be more logic behind it.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by MrBuddyCasino on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:07AM (#21620182)
> It’s not exploitation if adults, without coercion, agree to it of their own free will.

This is the only moral stance to take. It is amazing how people, with totally incomplete information and no matching life experience, decide they can decide for others. Popular example: payday loans are bad. Well sometimes they are the last line of defense between having a working car and being able to go to work vs loosing everything. Just ask them, people may have better reasons than you can imagine.

Its the same kind of folks who think that Facebook should be outlawed/heavily regulated because it caused all the ills in the world ("Trump"). No it didn't, stop thinking of other people as gullible idiots and yourself as the one with all the smart ideas.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by learnstats2 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:22AM (#21620247)
Payday loans are bad - a proper "democracy" would provide fair protections for people who are at risk of losing everything.

Payday loans exist because people in vulnerable situations are not protected as they should be.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sokoloff on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:55AM (#21620418)
Abortions are “bad”. Chemotherapy is “bad”. Payday loans are “bad”.

In many cases, the “bad” is less bad than the alternative; I’m opposed to restrictions on freedom of informed choice in general.

I would love for the rate of all three of those things to be reduced to zero by effective interventions upstream. Until they are though, I want all of those things to be available options.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by learnstats2 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:14PM (#21624718)
I'm saying that payday loans are bad because there is a better alternative today, yes. We could replace payday loans overnight if the government provided decent welfare.

So, that's what we should do. It seems like you agree, so hopefully you are contributing to the political/democratic will to do this.

That clearly doesn't apply to the other two cases. I also disagree that "interventions" are necessarily preferable.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by chr1 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:32AM (#21620630)
Payday loans are a bit different, because someone signs a bad contract by mistake, and then government has to use force to ensure the contract is maintained.

Banning payday loans seems like a noble thing to many people, but that simply ignores the real question, which is: what to do if someone signs a stupid contract and then wants to annulate it.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by nickthemagicman on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:43AM (#21620066)
Wow you seriously think that someone selling their kidney to feed their kids is done with their own free will?
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by louisswiss on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:20AM (#21620242)
Yes.

As a society, we should put measures in place to make sure no-one ever has to make this decision (easily accessible food banks, state support etc).

And we should make sure anyone making that decision is aware of the alternatives (and implications) and not suffering from a medical condition which is impairing their ability to make decisions.

But the fundamental choice should be down to the adult in question.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by tjoff on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:44AM (#21620359)
Now should we first ensure all of those measures exist? Or just pretend they do and not do anything?
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by louisswiss on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:12AM (#21620524)
My original comment (above) made it pretty clear that I believe we should be doing everything we can to ensure people don't have to make these kinds of choices.

But the way to do this is by adding new, better options, not by restricting existing, 'bad' options.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by tjoff on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:38AM (#21620662)
Sure, but that is an utopia that I hardly believe we will ever reach. No question hundreds of years in the future.

Lets allow people to get exploited because it might not be a problem in the distant future? Or, work from both ends. By restricting bad options at the same time as we add, best we can, the good options.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by louisswiss on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:51AM (#21620726)
The whole point of the scenario was that there are no good options.

We shouldn't allow people to get into a situation where they have to choose between losing a kidney and their children starving.

But - if someone is in that situation - it makes absolutely no sense not to let them decide which option they find least worst.

By doing that, you're only making things worse.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sodii on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:55PM (#21622038)
Your argument makes sense when you view such transactions as a decision problem with a single actor and no temporal element.

But such transaction happens within a lifelong game with at least two players. Changing the rule of the game can influence their game tree and their behavior, far before they get into a situation where the change applies.

For the kidney trade, banning it might discourage potential organ-buyers from 'check-mating' people into selling their kidneys. It also might nudge parents to work harder since they have one less things to sell off.

I acutually have no opinion over banning organ trade. I'm just saying that it could make some sense.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by leetcrew on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:06AM (#21620490)
"free will" is sort of a red herring in this situation. the choice should probably be considered to be made under duress, because the person's children are starving. but you don't really help the person by preventing the sale; the family is still starving. if you really don't want people selling kidneys, you need to give them enough food to eat.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by mjburgess on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:00AM (#21620154)
Person A1 has value X, Person A2 has value X

Person A1 and A2 are compelled by circumstance to compete. The nature of this competition forces A1/A2 to prioritize their values according to the cost to retain them (eg., suppose X = privacy in living quarters, and retaining X costs $100/day)

The impact of X being unaffordable is equal on A1/A2, ie., equally traumatic. But A1 is more able to compete than A2 (ie., retain their values) due, eg., to having more money.

Are we saying that A2 is free when she "decides" that $100/day is too expensive? And therefore has to abandon X (eg., dignity)?

Should we instead, rather, regard these circumstances suspiciously. Circumstances in which people are compelled to throw-away their values and race-to-the-bottom.

If A1/A2 never enters these circumstances they both retain X, if they do, only one does. Do we wish for dignity, privacy, (...) to be so circumstantial?

We can regulate to prevent this (and routinely do, very successfully) -- if society bares additional costs for its members retaining X (eg., via taxation to provide welfare/housing), then so be it.

Circumstances routinely bring people into competition where success requires abandoning values such that all participants would have preferred never to have been in that competition -- but when in it, abandon them.

The libertarian view of the mind is deeply naive -- it takes behaviour as always based on desire. We are more complex: we endure the trauma of not being free to act on our preferences when circumstances overwhelmingly incentivise behaviour contrary to those. Freedom is not mere action, it is acting according to our desires.

Addiction is a paradigm case, but extreme competition for resources is of the same kind: we sincerely wish not to do what we are compelled to do by external incentives that destroy our sense of self, will, freedom.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by sneak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:02AM (#21620160)
> Circumstances in which people are compelled to throw-away their values and race-to-the-bottom.

I don’t think anyone is being compelled to do anything here.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by mjburgess on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:15AM (#21620218)
That's because you have a peculiar (and I think) false view of psychology.

Any person can be made into a slave through "abusive freedom": overwhelming financial incentives (eg., blow up this building and ill give your very poor family $1mil); overwhelming social incentives (eg., take drugs or you wont be our friend); overwhelming constraints; ...

A person is a deeply malleable thing and circumstances change people, they traumatise and abuse them. A person can be arbitrarily reduced to an arbitrarily murderous/desperate/slavish state.

The libertarian notion of freedom mystifies this and prevents us from recognising it.

We need to distinguish between those cases where people change through learning, growth, development (ie., value their X differently due to learning more); and those cases were people are caused to abandon freedom-preserving, dignity-preserving, life-preserving values.

We oughtnt regard all behaviour as "expression of true desire", and all changes to what we desire as being of the same kind. When the very poor are provided with an overwhelming incentive to abandon their dignity (ie., here, essnetially free housing) we should regard the effects of these incentives as harming those people.

And that harm isn't theoretical: it is abusive to live without privacy; it is traumatising. That people do it does not mean they desire to, it does not mean they want to. This is a vicious misunderstanding of human psychology.

People are trapped in circumstances of abuse "freely" and routinely. So much for that notion of freedom.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by harryh on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:29AM (#21620278)
If society feels that people below a certain level of income don't have enough freedom, the correct solution to this problem is to give them more money.

Further constraining their freedom by forbidding them from making their own decisions about what is most important to them will only make their lives worse. They know more about what tradoffs (even difficult ones!) are worth doing in their own lives than you do.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by mjburgess on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:40AM (#21620341)
No one is talking about forbidding people from deciding something. Regulation prevents the circumstances of that decision arising.

> They know more about what tradoffs

This just seems like an ideological presumption. Empirically it is obviously, routinely, false. There are very many cases where people make self-injurious decisions that post-decision they wish they would not have made; and were obvious to everyone they shouldn't have made it.

The relevant political question is: in what cases should "society" regulate to prevent those cases arising?

If we say "every case" then we end up in a tyranny, and a very terrible one, because "society" is unlikely to get every case right. If we say "no cases" then we permit widespread abuse and manipulation.

A modern casino is a skinner-box designed by psychologists to maximize your merely impulsive behaviour (ie., non-free behaviour). Should we regulate to prevent people from ever entering? I'd say so.

A human being is not 'master of their own house'; they are not 'acting under their own will' much of the time. We are pigeons whose animal nature is easy to exploit: society should act to preserve our willful capacity to act under reason and preference.

Not action under impulse, desperation, etc.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by harryh on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:46AM (#21620371)
I love casinos. I went to Vegas all the time when I lived on the west coast. Sadly, not so much since I moved east and had a kid, but what are you gonna do?

I'm a grown man with my own money who has always been responsible with it. Spending a few hours playing cards isn't merely impulsive behavior, it's something I find entertaining. I know more about my own money and my own desires then you do.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by mjburgess on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:57AM (#21620434)
Yes, because you have a greater capacity to retain your values despite overwhelming incentives not to do so.

Gambling in this way destroys people and their families, much like drug addiction. You might say those people are "vulnerable" in some special inherent way, but really, they just happen to be in different circumstances than you.

My view is that your enjoyment here has a cost: it preserves environments we know cause human animals to change for the worse. I don't see that as, empirically, a controversial point.

Casinos take a healthy rat in, and frequently, an unhealthy rat leaves.

Behind all this "decision making" is the reality of human psychology, and of abuse, trauma, and health. And it is no hidden thing that gambling, opioid over-prescription, prostitution... as environments take in healthy desperate animals and exist deeply unhealthy ones.

This transition preserves "freedom" in the libertarian sense -- and it is my view therefore that this sense is pathological and misunderstands people.

What you are saying is that pre-post casino you retain your freedom (in the intuitive, healthy sense). Alas very many people do not.

When environments cause people to give up on values that keep them healthy, those environments are sick and make people sick. Humans are not blank slate masters of everything: we're animals. And what we need isnt arbitrary and different and unique and special.

There are some values so essential that when we see people giving them up, we ought regard the perpetrators of that changes as abusive manipulators; or at least, naively engaging in abuse.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by acollins1331 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:40AM (#21620054)
Sorry to inform you but the world isnt as simple as your dictionary definition of exploitation.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by colechristensen on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:03AM (#21620163)
Money and debt have a weird way of distancing people from morals often entirely.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by timwaagh on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:57AM (#21620438)
If anything he's helping poor people to be able to afford traveling. I do not understand the comparison.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by LudwigNagasena on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:53AM (#21620415)
We should tell Kardashians and all other reality shows stars that they are being exploited!
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by antihero on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:03AM (#21636624)
Weird, I had a totally different take and thought it was more of an exciting, fun concept with aspects of exhibitionism etc.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by jdjdid7282 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:29AM (#21620279)
I realize this is nitpicking since you were just reaching for examples to list, but a plethora of research and even the WHO has suggested that criminalizing sex work primarily just makes things even more dangerous for sex workers. This is part of what makes the efforts by law enforcement to rebrand their battle against prostitution as a battle against "human trafficking" especially insidious. Regardless of how a trafficked human got where they are, making sex work illegal only makes it harder for those workers to practice their work safely. A perfect example of this is whatever that American law was that made Backpage take down what was effectively their adult services section, there was a fairly substantial outcry at the time from members of the 'industry' because this had been a tool that allowed at least some minimal way to vet clients.
Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by technoplato on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:59AM (#21620783)
What if you turn this around though and rather than the hotel owner take 100% of the profit (assuredly from ads as the article mentions), create a fungible digital token that tenants “earn” when staying at the hotel and stake interest against speculation in the token, therefore sharing the profit with those that are part of generating it - the actors so to speak.

Of course this doesn’t apply to sex trade but I’m just curious on picking your brain here.

Would love a bit of engagement into the idea rather than just downvotes. Specifically into the idea of how to create mechanisms by which the free market could produce ethical outcomes at least moreso than current practices.

Re:Japanese hotel room costs $1 a night, but you have to liv... by CryptoPunk on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:55AM (#21620756)
How about let courts decide if it's not genuine consent, after carefully deliberating on the facts of the case, and not social activists having knee-jerk emotional reactions based on a very low resolution view of the situation - often based only on a headline.

>>Without those laws, those who are most desperate will be able to act in desperation, to someone else’s benefit, with society doing nothing to stand in the way.

A law prohibiting it doesn't solve the problem of them being desperate. It only takes away an option that they perceived as the best one available to them, all so that you can be sure no one is profiting from an exchange that exposes the inequality that exists in the world.