News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ProAm on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:46AM (#21463650)
Is anyone really surprised? Years before the IPO we knew they were not profitable in the least. We knew VC cash was subsidizing rides. We knew that their future was purely dependent on a self-driving car fleet where they could ditch drivers (and their pay) completely. This on top of a horrible culture with pretty lousy ethics and morality.

This is how this was supposed to play out and everyone here (on HN) knew that. The only people suckered were public investors during the IPO roadshow.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by dehrmann on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:24AM (#21464073)
This reads like the usual Uber criticism and doesn't touch on the lockup. The market knew the lockup was ending, so it should have been priced in. Dropping when the lockup ends should mean that markets underestimated how many insiders wanted to cash out, and employee sentiment is worse than market sentiment.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by dragontamer on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:31AM (#21464143)
> Dropping when the lockup ends should mean that markets underestimated how many insiders wanted to cash out, and employee sentiment is worse than market sentiment.

Uber's volume is 700% compared to last week. With volume-swings like that, there really isn't much you can do.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by cik on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:41PM (#21464887)
Of course there is. You can short, it's pretty profitable.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by dragontamer on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:51PM (#21464983)
You can only short if you can find someone willing to lend you shares. Shorts can "run out of shares to borrow" in practice. Similarly, you can buy put-options (or sell call options) on the shares, but only if you can find a counterparty to accept the "other side" (that is, a short-put or a long-call) of your bet.

Run out of counterparties, and it becomes impossible to trade. Reality becomes evident at times like this when volume is way, way, way higher than anybody expects.

--------

I admit that I don't know what happened today with Uber, but we can't just assume "invisible hand / market is always perfectly efficient". Reality simply doesn't work like that.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by Domenic_S on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:12PM (#21465214)
I'm not sure what value your comment is adding - look at uber's option chain, there's plenty of volume everywhere: https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/uber/option-ch...
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by scurvy on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:31AM (#21464145)
While yours is an economics textbook answer, any trader will tell you, "it doesn't matter until it matters."
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by whatok on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:12PM (#21464568)
Yes. A lot of discussion here seems to be very academic vs how things play out.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by rongenre on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:34PM (#21465495)
Trader proverb: "Markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent"
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:32PM (#21464790)
No one likes unquantifiable market factors like confidence, which is hard to suss out and can rapidly deteriorate without yet showing up in technicals.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by x0x0 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:52AM (#21464342)
I dunno, but I wouldn't read too much about employee sentiment into this.

Say you have $150k in savings and $x million in Uber stock. Any competent financial advisor is going to get you to diversify out of Uber. You'll miss upside, but prevent that $x million from potentially going to zero based on the actions of just one company.

Also... goodbye sf housing market :(

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ska on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:38PM (#21464853)
> Also... goodbye sf housing market :(

That ship sailed a while ago, no?

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by x0x0 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:52PM (#21466421)
Another 1k millionaires looking to buy a house is horrific.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ska on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @03:00PM (#21466512)
Is that going to materially change the ability of a non millionare to purchase a house in the bay area? Honest question.

If in effect they are all going to compete with each other an other (mostly IT) millionaires for housing and pay slightly more, it doesn't seem like a real shift.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by philjohn on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:06PM (#21465857)
This. I sell any stocks as soon as I can after vesting (trading window permitting) and then diversify into other holdings. I still have RSU's that have not vested that I get to enjoy any upside on.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by dehrmann on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:48PM (#21470479)
> Any competent financial advisor is going to get you to diversify out of Uber

Agreed, but they seem to have no problem suggesting putting 50% of your net worth in a home.

Having been though a company going public, while that advice is correct, the endowment effect is a real thing, and it's shocking how long people hold on.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by cj on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:42AM (#21464243)
Agreed, I came to post the same thing.

The lockup period is a known event (nothing to be suprised about). The market already adjusted the stock price to reflect the anticipated insider cash out after the lock up.

Any rise or fall in the price at the specific time the lockup ends is because the reality is different than what the market anticpated.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by dragontamer on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:56AM (#21464383)
Volume is extremely important.

The 90-day average volume for Uber is ~10-million shares per day. Lets pretend you knew that Uber was going to drop today (last week). How many shares do you sell short?

That 10-million average is ALL market trades, buying, selling, etc. etc. If 10-million shares were short-sold, it'd take a full day to cover all of those shares (based on average volume). There's only so much trading activity that happens at any given moment in time.

Well, what happened today? Uber is now up to... (check's Yahoo finance...) 95-million volume, and counting.

Huh. Well, I guess you could have sold more shares short last week. But given the 10-million share 90-day average volume, there was basically no way to predict 95-million shares traded before noon come Wednesday.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ska on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:39PM (#21464869)
Surely with a lock up date it was pretty predictable that volume would be some large multiple of it's usual.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by dragontamer on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:54PM (#21465024)
Sure. But what multiple do you expect?

If you expected 2x or 3x the volume, you were proven wrong in the 1st hour. Between 9am EST to 10am EST, over 40-million UBER shares traded, representing ~400% of the average daily volume in just 1-hour.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ska on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:43PM (#21467741)
But getting it exactly right isn't the point, is it? You were asking how many should you short, if you think the market hasn't priced the lock out in ,the answer doesn't have to be optimal, it's just more than the usual volume.

What am I missing? For sure you couldn't know it would be 95 mil, but is 20 really that speculative?

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by Ididntdothis on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:19AM (#21464011)
”self-driving car fleet ”

Uber has zero competence in fleet management. Everything they do is to avoid investing in a fleet.i would argue that rental car companies or car dealers are positioned much better.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by bloomer on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:28AM (#21464119)
Weird that this is being downvoted because Uber has shown no interest in acquiring and managing assets (self-driving cars or even their own cars) which is a completely different business than being a marketer for independent taxis. If self-driving cars become a business it seems like rental car companies would be ideally positioned to take advantage of them.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by papito on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:16PM (#21464608)
Once a VC-funded tech company starts maintaining inventory, actually assets, then things get real pretty quick. The only reason these companies become unicorns is because they don't have the overhead of owning stuff. Then you are just any other company.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by marcosdumay on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:24PM (#21465363)
It's very reasonable for a small company to avoid owning assets and focus on markets where the flexibility of not owning them is an advantage. They don't have money anyway, nor enough people to manage those assets.

It is completely crazy to expect large companies that are burning money to grow not to go after the largest markets just because it needs investment... Yet, that's what you described, and AFAIK you are completely correct.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by Ididntdothis on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:30AM (#21464136)
Uber is the ultimate middleman company. It would only work if people bought their own self driving cars and rented them out to Uber to make some extra money.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by Avshalom on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:50AM (#21464316)
At which point of course owners would shop for top dollar and riders would shop for rock bottom and they'd still be stuck lighting money on fire to subsidize rides.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ghaff on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:50AM (#21464311)
And it's difficult to see how those ad hoc rentals can compete with a fleet management company that has economies of scale and optimizes for short-term rental. Car depreciation is more mileage-based than time-based so it's reasonable to assume that the rates people would get would tend to reach a point where they were pretty close to the cost--with perhaps an exception for times when there's extraordinary demand.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by RantyDave on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:37PM (#21464838)
Yes and no. I can certainly agree on a theoretical basis, but the black cabs that have crawled around London since the 50's are privately owned and built to last.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by hodder on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:00AM (#21463804)
Sure, but the same could be said of Tesla. Horrible employer, constant exec churn, unbelievable cash burn, what appears to be structural losses.... But Tesla still has a 56B mcap today. Uber is 46B. These VC/equity issue cash furnaces can go on longer than most can fathom if a subset of investors believe in the long term vision.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by mdasen on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:38AM (#21464204)
I think part of the issue is market timing. If we went back to June, Tesla is sitting at a $33B market cap after a huge slide. Uber started sliding in August. If we were just looking at market cap, Uber's had been decently stable for 3 months post-IPO and is now sliding. Tesla's would have been at its low point in June. You could have said then, "same could be said... but Uber is sitting at a $71B market cap while Tesla has slid down to $33B".

I do think Tesla is overvalued, but presents less risk than Uber. Ultimately, Tesla is looking to be a car company. $56B is a bit expensive for a car company, but there are examples. GM is $54B, Ford is $35B, Fiat Chrysler is $25B, Volkswagen is $100B, Toyota is $230B, Honda is $50B, Nissan is $27B, and Mazda is $6B. I think Tesla is overpriced because I think it's highly unlikely that they're the next Toyota. In 10 years, I think they might be the next Mazda or GM or Nissan or Honda - representing no gain to a significant loss over the next decade. Even if they become the next Volkswagen in 10 years, that would represent a less than 10% annualized return for something that's unlikely to happen. Even if one thinks Tesla is making a great product, the likelihood of becoming the next VW is very slim. Heck, Mazda makes some great cars and sells nearly 2 million, but they're only a $6B company.

But fundamentally, building cars and selling them for the amount of money people buy cars at is a reasonable proposition. Tesla's quarterly reports show that they can make them profitably and that the solar business is weighing on their financials. I can see Tesla being a profitable, sustainable company. They've proven out the economics of their batteries, drive-trains, manufacturing, etc. enough for me to believe there isn't an impediment to them continuing to exist indefinitely. I don't think they're going to justify their high valuation, but I can certainly see them becoming a Mazda, Nissan, or Honda - well respected, profitable, etc.

I mean, Tesla had $143M in GAAP net income in Q3.

However, I think there are big questions on whether Uber can stick around indefinitely. As states turn against the gig economy, does that wreck their business model? As self-driving seems many more years away, do they have the runway to keep going? Even with self-driving, are they the ones that will capture that market or will a company without the losses from a driver-oriented business take over that space? Will customers give a company like Uber margin or will they constantly be searching for the cheapest option?

I think the auto industry in general will face challenges over the next couple decades (another reason I'm less bullish on Tesla), but Tesla (at least its auto business) is fundamentally traditional. You give them tens of thousands of dollars, they give you a car. It might be an electric one with interesting new toys, but it's a traditional transaction and one that seems to provide good margin as the ramp-up costs start to wind down (launching an auto company takes a lot of time and money). Tesla is trying to convince people that they want to buy a Tesla rather than a Nissan. Uber is trying to convince people that they want to buy a lot more taxi rides and the only way to do that is by making them cheaper. Can they make that happen? Even if they make that happen, is there a barrier to someone else coming in and competing?

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by SergeAx on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:05PM (#21465126)
> next Mazda or GM or Nissan or Honda

Please stop comparing Tesla with car companies. Tesla is a tech company, like Apple iPhone branch (which outlived, say, Nokia and Ericsson and Siemens). Most valuable part of Tesla is their IP and datasets. And don't forget their supercharger network.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by grvdrm on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:58PM (#21465059)
Excellent
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by john_moscow on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:16AM (#21463976)
Tesla is toxic because the founder has a vision, sets tight constraints and pushes hard on people to meet them (hello Amazon). Uber is toxic because there are too many people sitting on a pile of investor money, hence politics and infighting. As an employee, you may want to avoid both, but as an investor, you need to see the difference.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by deweller on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:08AM (#21463889)
Tesla has arguably a more clear path to a profitable future. Uber's path to profitability is arguably much more speculative and dependent on risky technology advances.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by drannex on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:14AM (#21463942)
Agreed. Not only did Tesla have a clear path, but they had a product that could sell at much higher margins, better quality control, not-so dubious legal ways of selling them, paid their employees decent wages (Uber... does not), and they won't have technology that can be copied and repeated by a second year student at uni.

Uber and Tesla are not anywhere close to directly comparable.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by toong on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:45AM (#21464264)
Additionally, Tesla is pushing hard on battery tech etc, ...

As far as I understand, Uber does some autonomous vehicles R&D, but the required tech advances will probably not be developed by them ?

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by aplummer on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:15AM (#21463959)
I think very clearly, I’m not a Tesla fan but the solar roof and car are both unique and the core fan base is very strong.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by erikpukinskis on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:26AM (#21464095)
Do you really see structural losses when you look at the graph of Tesla’s P/L?

I don’t understand how you could interpret the charts that way. That seems like a talking point people parrot who have never looked at the numbers.

I mean, this is Tesla and Uber on the same timescale:

https://imgur.com/gallery/NOsh4b1

Certainly one of those companies has structural losses.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by hodder on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:39PM (#21464861)
Yes I see structural losses. Look at the cash flow.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by erikpukinskis on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:53PM (#21465006)
Appreciate the honesty!
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by dd36 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:13AM (#21463933)
Tesla is building a product. Automated dispatch is not protectable.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by MaupitiBlue on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:56AM (#21464392)
Like Hertz and Avis and Budget aren’t already established brands in the fleet financing, servicing, and dispatch business.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by aSplash0fDerp on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:30AM (#21464139)
BINGO!

After all of the pennies are counted, the cost to pave the way for the future where other companies take market share after the dust settles is astounding.

Had they rolled their 1st mover advantage into building and smoothering markets (think scooters) with IP locked autonomous taxis, a trillion dollar valuation would have been acceptable.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by marcosdumay on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:27PM (#21465409)
Don't Tesla earn some profit on each sale, while Uber loses money?

Both are losing money overall, but this detail makes a lot of difference.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by zby on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:45PM (#21466348)
Elon has overpromised many times in the past - and probably it won't happen in 2020 but I still believe that Tesla is leading the driverless competition. They have the data.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by 0zymandias on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:21AM (#21464040)
Uber is a huge mess because the narrative is not credible. Dara is trying to tell a story about fast grow + profitability.

The reality is that they have three types of businesses. 1. Businesses that are slowing down dramatically, e.g. Ride Share. As they raise price it may have negative growth. 2. Businesses that are growing by unsustainable subsidy, e.g. Eats, Freight. 3. New business that are purely speculative. Uber Money, Autonomous, Flying Taxis.

They have no businesses that fit the fast growth + profitability. Dara is trying to balance the three categories above to pretend that it is happening.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by tzs on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:52AM (#21464331)
> We knew that their future was purely dependent on a self-driving car fleet where they could ditch drivers (and their pay) completely.

I've never really understood this.

Their drivers do more than just drive, don't they? They also supply the cars, and deal with maintenance of those cars. If Uber switches to a self-driving fleet and ditches human drivers, who will own the cars?

If Uber owns or leases the cars, Uber will have to be dealing with maintenance. I suppose they could go to a model where people who have bought self-driving cars can let Uber use them when the owner does not need them, but then Uber has just replaced paying a zillion drivers with paying a zillion self-driving car owners.

So, assuming they go with the model where Uber is the one handling maintenance so they don't have to have a zillion pseudo-employees I don't see what would stop other companies from doing this better.

If Waymo wanted to go for that market, for instance, they have better self-driving technology, and could probably get integrated with the Google Maps app that is already on everyone's phone so they wouldn't have to convince people to download anything. Sure, Waymo doesn't currently have, as far as I know, anything set up for managing and maintaining a large fleet of cars...but neither does Uber.

Or what about the car makers? Many of them are working on self-driving, too. I could see some of them deploying self-driving taxi fleets, with maintenance handled through their dealers. This could become a new sales channel for them--new car to their taxi fleet for a couple years, then sold off as a used car which the buyer can be assured was well maintained and still has a good warranty.

Imagine your self-driving Audi/BMW/Mercedes/etc taxi dropping you off at home at the end of the day, and then presenting you with a report showing how much you used the service over the last year, how much it cost you, and how it would have been cheaper for you to have your own private self-driving car, and offering to sell you that very car. If you accept, the car drives back to the dealer, gets cleaned, inspected, tuned up, and drives back to your place to be waiting for you to take ownership the next morning.

In summary, owning and operating a fleet of self-driving taxis is sufficiently different from what Uber does now that I'm not sure that Uber has any particular advantage over anyone else who might want to do so, and might even be at a disadvantage, so I'm skeptical that this is their future.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by Konnstann on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:17PM (#21464620)
The maintenance cost of 1000 cars owned by one company are most likely going to be less than those of 1000 cars owned by 1000 owners, just through negotiation and bulk maintenance pricing.

Uber is banking on people not switching to whatever other self-driving service comes out, due to being a household name. I don't think very many people outside of SV know what Waymo even is, everyone has taken an Uber though.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ghaff on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:26PM (#21465405)
>everyone has taken an Uber though

I think you'd be surprised at Uber's profile outside of some relative bubbles. Pew Research last year said the number of Americans who have never taken an Uber has gone down but it's still something like 36%.

I live 40 miles outside of a major city and near a couple of smaller cities and Uber barely works for me during daytime hours. I couldn't begin to use it for an early morning airport run.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by braindeath on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:44PM (#21464917)
Everyone has heard of Lyft though, and in larger markets Juno. If Uber management is truly banking on brand loyalty of all things, especially based on their behavior, they are idiots. Nobody trusts Uber.

If Waymo arrives with a more cost effective solution, that’s it.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by hluska on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:14AM (#21463945)
This will sound very naive (because it is), but I thought that the free market would see through the bullshit and value them appropriately. That is happening, just far more slowly than I imagined.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by zanny on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:19AM (#21464008)
The valuation was largely over the general hype for self-driving vehicles. Those who thought they were imminent must have just been ignorant to how slow regulation moves and how risk averse corporations are to the potential fallout of being "first to market" with a self driving car that ends up with someone dead regardless of fault.

As the hype dies down so does Ubers market cap.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ghaff on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:44AM (#21464249)
You also had a bunch of execs/founders in SV particularly trying to outcompete each other in their claims about how soon autonomous vehicles were going to arrive. This combined with tech that got to the point where it at least demoed well and a lot of people who really wanted to believe they'd never have to drive a car fell for it hook, line, and sinker.

There will certainly be regulatory and liability issues to work through but if the tech were really ready for prime time I actually don't believe those those are showstoppers.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by asdf333 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:51AM (#21464327)
at least its happening. you could argue that uber's insane valuations before were due to deluded vcs (non-free-market)

now that its a publicly traded company and its financials are transparent to investors, the free market is doing what it is supposed to do.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by smabie on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:03PM (#21465115)
I mean, if no one was surprised the stock price wouldn't have moved a lot when the lockup ended. Clearly most everyone was surprised (including you), otherwise you and everyone else would have shorted Uber or bought some puts before the lockup ended therefore neutralizing any price movement.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by scarface74 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:47PM (#21464950)
No everyone on HN didn’t know that. Posters on HN are routinely making excuses for money losing tech companies and consider a “success” another rounding of funding at an increased valuation and being able to pawn off bad businesses to the public markets.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by paulcole on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:40AM (#21464225)
> We knew that their future was purely dependent on a self-driving car fleet

This is by far Uber's best trick. Convincing people that there is an end game they can win.

I see no way that self-driving saves them. Either they'll have to buy/lease/maintain a massive fleet of cars or they'll have to rent self-driving cars from the owners. Either way, in the near future, how much cheaper can it be than paying humans peanuts?

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by tempsy on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:59AM (#21463796)
It's still a 45B company...still the largest and most successful company to come out of SF this decade.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by throwaway_law on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:08AM (#21463897)
>still the largest and most successful company to come out of SF this decade.

That's a lot less reflective of UBER and more reflective of the type of startups SV is trying to take public. Look at any other SV Unicorn that IPO'd...take Twitter that IPO'd in 2013, it turned a profit one year since going public.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by tempsy on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:11AM (#21463918)
I'm using market cap as a proxy for success not profit...

Twitter isn't really a shining example of success either - their share price has been sideways for 6 years.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by devicetray0 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:51AM (#21464323)
> I'm using market cap as a proxy for success not profit...

Market cap is not and has never been a good proxy for success.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by tempsy on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:57AM (#21464405)
I think you're referring to private valuations
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by JohnFen on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:13AM (#21463935)
If Uber counts as a successful company by SV standards, that's a pretty strong condemnation of SV standards.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by barry-cotter on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:40AM (#21464218)
If it’s worth one third of its current market cap it’s worth $15B. For a company that’s ten years old that’s incredible.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ewb on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:38PM (#21464852)
Turning $10 billion into $45 billion over 10 years isn't really that incredible.

That's less growth than Comcast has had over the same period. Which most would not consider a dynamic incredible stock.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by JohnFen on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:00PM (#21464438)
I think measuring whether or not a company is successful solely by that yardstick is very dubious.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by tempsy on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:20AM (#21464023)
It's not a SV company - it's an SF company.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by celticninja on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:24AM (#21464063)
If we assume the meant SF instead of SV, does that negate his point somehow?
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by JohnFen on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:25AM (#21464090)
Yes, I meant SF.

I do find it amusing that I was called out on this, though, since in the past I've been called out for not including SF as part of SV.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by swampthinker on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:02AM (#21463827)
It's the most successful cashout for investors and early employees, but let's not act like Uber isn't still running on borrowed time.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ProAm on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:02AM (#21463831)
It's not successful though. WeWork is still valued at 47B technically speaking today. They are a company that only loses money, has a horrid culture and does some morally reprehensible things.

Their true value is their logistics software. If they would lease/sell that to other industries they would be rich beyond belief.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by tempsy on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:07AM (#21463878)
Private valuations are not the same as public ones, especially one post-earnings and post-lockup.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ProAm on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:57PM (#21466485)
Every private company tries to turn those private valuations into public ones at IPO.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by vkou on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:05AM (#21463854)
What morally reprehensible things are done by WeWork?
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by lm28469 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:23AM (#21464051)
Their business is sketchy and their CEO is double sketchy. Type "wework" or "adam neumann" in google and you'll find plenty of sources
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by ProAm on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:10AM (#21463912)
I was referring to Uber
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by naravara on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:16AM (#21463974)
>We knew that their future was purely dependent on a self-driving car fleet where they could ditch drivers (and their pay) completely.

Nah. Right now their business model relies on having their labor bring their own capital. I've always seriously doubted that cutting the labor out of the equation and replacing it with capital that Uber now has to furnish and maintain was going to save all THAT much money.

The numbers are all over the place, but from what I've been told once you factor in mileage costs, gas, and maintenance + cleaning of the vehicles most rideshare drivers are only earning somewhere from $1.50 to $3.00 an hour. If Uber then has to internalize all those costs plus add all the software maintenance/development costs of their self-driving AI how much is that saving them really? Is it going to be enough to defray the billion and a half dollars they're bleeding every year?

No, their long-term game was always going to be to undermine public transit and personal vehicle ownership through an artificially cheap business model and then once their monopoly (or oligopoly with Lyft) is firmly entrenched to boondoggle municipal governments into subsidizing rides for them instead of spending money on building out transit.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by trhway on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:46PM (#21464937)
>Right now their business model relies on having their labor bring their own capital.

That is really post-Marx. It is a new economy structure enabled by technological progress, and which couldn't have existed and hasn't been predicted until it was enabled by technology and was created by Uber and the likes. In marxism, ie. in classic capitalism the capital owner extracts added value which is created by the labor applied to the capital. In the post-marxism economy the birth of which we're witnessing today Uber, by the owning of the information network, manages to extracts the added value which labor creates by applying itself to the labor's own capital. Marxism economical theory naturally postulates socialism after capitalism with the socialism being the maximum entropy of capital ownership distribution, and that is what we've observed in the last 100 years. These days with the rise of technology that got the post-Marx economy enabled the future driven by that economy isn't socialism, its the new fundamental state of society - the network.

Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by naravara on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:53AM (#21473132)
This is economically illiterate gibberish.
Re:Uber Sinks to New Record Low as IPO Share Lockup Expires by trhway on Saturday November 16, 2019 @10:54PM (#21556468)
let me guess - 1. you have so far lived only in one economical system, probably capitalism, and in particular you have never lived in the socialism 2. you don't have degree in Math 3. you haven't read Das Kapital

So, you basically don't know most of the things what i was talking about. No wonder it sounds gibberish to you.