Apple is also one of the most notorious tax avoiders in world history. They've taken extreme efforts to avoid paying taxes in every jurisdiction in which they do business, to the extent that a number of their tax structurings have been deemed illegal.
On the one hand, it's good that Apple is finally putting its money where its marketing is. On the other hand, if they hadn't spent 40 years avoiding taxes, they wouldn't have driven the development of an entire cottage industry of multinationals avoiding taxes.
As far as I'm aware, Apple (as do most large corporations) follows various tax laws in the various jurisdictions they operate in. If you feel those laws are unfair then you should lobby your government to change the laws. IMO, blaming companies for the laws they follow is not a good way to fix the problem you see.
If we increase teacher pay will the bad teachers become good teachers?
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/4/4/17164718/te...
https://www.brookings.edu/blog/brown-center-chalkboard/2018/...
> To begin, how do we know who works a second job? The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) conducts a year-round survey, called the American Time Use Survey, in which it asks individuals how they have spent their time both on the day of the survey and in the very recent past. In addition to asking about a person’s main occupation, the BLS asks if they worked another job in the last seven days. Our sample is made up of individuals with a college education who report being employed full-time from 2003 through 2016, giving us just over 36,000 observations.
> Overall, teachers (defined as elementary and secondary teachers, excluding special ed) are about 30 percent more likely than non-teachers to work a second job based on survey responses. That comes down to about 11 percent of non-teachers and 14 percent of teachers.
Now possibly this difference is due to having summers off and time to take on a job and that job doesn't affect their main seasonal work of teaching. However, we don't know as these studies didn't look into that. Wait, or do they?!?
> What time of year would you expect to find that teachers are most likely to hold second jobs? Like me, you may have guessed summer, but it turns out that’s not what the data says. First, teachers are more likely than non-teachers to have a second job all year, except in the October and November run-up to the holiday season. For teachers, the big months for second jobs are January and February. I would have thought that teachers are more likely to pick up outside work when school is not in session. But you can see from the chart that that’s not what’s going on.
If you pay people whatever, then they're gonna start competing against each others for the same finite resources (housing), driving up prices to artificially high levels. You see this is cities with tech, oil & gas, finance, or other high-paying industries.
This is quite a stretch. Apple's effective tax rate is somewhere near 24-26%, which is far above many of its peers.
However when the tax conversation comes up, every level and every jurisdiction has self-serving ideas about how much of that tax should be payable to them. e.g. "Apple made $X worldwide, therefore they owe Cupertino/California/United States N% of $X", etc.
They're doing this because it's what US tax law allows. People can whine about Apple being a "tax avoider" but that's just a fig leaf to cover the truth, which is that you can't call Apple a "tax evader" because it's untrue.
Want Apple to repatriate all that income? Great. Change the tax law, which means, get rich Republicans to change it.
Til then? Stop blaming the companies for working within the system that we, the voters, have set up.
I guess they could do both, but what should the standard be?
Taxes and their distribution are controlled by elected representatives who are ultimately beholden to democratic voters.
Companies and philanthropists are beholden to nothing but their personal whims.
This sounds like a great way of only diverting resources to those who already have it, and also of creating company towns that have historically been bad for workers.
Can we at least have Swedes decide “what constitutes incompetence and corruption?” Like democracy, except only Swedes in Sweden get to vote in US local elections. Once a year, a committee of Swedes will have to come over here and ride BART/the NYC Subway/Metro and report back before voting.
Do you think the government officials would create better iPhones?
Government suffers from bureaucratic overhead and tyranny of the masses. But most of the other things it suffers from — control by special interests, regulatory capture, buying elections and politicians, are caused by billionaires and rich corporations. At least going through taxes and government has some amount of public influence instead of just abdicating the whole thing and submitting to becoming an complete oligogarchy.
Billionaires and rich corporations caused WMATA and MTA to completely neglect maintenance for decades and let their systems literally catch on fire (despite being just as well funded as European systems?) Billionaires and rich corporations cause our education system to underperform (while being among the most well funded?) Billionaires and corporations cause our intractable housing issues?
I just don’t buy this. European countries have billionaires and big corporations, regulatory systems that can be captured, etc. In fact they’re often the ones more overtly pushing pro-corporate policies. (Trump’s corporate tax cuts, for example, came long after similar cuts in Sweden, France, Ireland, and the U.K. Trump is fighting to cut the capital gains tax, for example, while many OECD countries don’t even have one.) Yet their trains somehow run on time, their schools are good, their crime rates are low, and their cities are generally nice and orderly.
They don't want affordable housing. If they do start wanting it then relief funding won't be necessary.
These large salaries are affecting inflation in the areas the employees live, driving up the demand for large homes that the typical non-techie could never hope to afford.
It's indirect, and it's not fair to lay everything at the feet of the companies, but there are consequences to them growing so quickly.
That said, this is a systemic issue that needs to be solved at a higher level, not at the level of individual companies or people.
Without modifying the system, we're going to see this gap between the skilled-in-IT and the not-skilled-in-IT get wider and wider until anyone not doing IT might as well sign their lives away to unending dept and poverty.
Labor is finally being compensated (somewhat) fairly is what you mean, I think.
Tech employees offer unprecedented leveraged effort -> work put in affects so many people, and has huge effects. In terms of return to capital, right now employees, especially for startups, are getting shafted beyond belief.
Thanks for attending my TED talk on "why I will never work for another startup again".
Developers might be compensated fairly, or at least somewhat fairly, but that value isn't pulled from nowhere.
Too often people who critique the economy are focused on the individual view. Economies are large systems, and any good developer knows that a system with weak spots quickly turns into a sinking ship.
This doesn't mean they necessarily have an obligation to do anything about it and again, it also doesn't mean it's a bad thing. It's an inevitable side effect of their success. They did business, made a ton of money, spread it around, and one of the myriad indirect consequences is social inequality which contributes to the housing problem. Again, it's not a bad thing per se, but it's a real thing. The fact that it wasn't a bad thing doesn't mean there is no moral responsibility attached.
It's nice to see a company trying to deal with the consequences of their actions without being forced to.
Because it isn’t really a consequence of their actions, what Apple is doing here is not really the kind of action that we want to see. It’s not like a company coming and cleaning up an oil spill that they made — it’s like a company coming in and cleaning up the government’s oil spill, and it represents an extension of corporate involvement in public life that dealing with the consequences of their actions wouldn’t. They are dealing with the government’s consequences.
Literally any country in the world would accept Apple's headquarters and not demand a cent in donations for anything.
I wish American companies would put more pressure on the government to solve public problems, this would include threatening to leave to other jurisdictions if necessary.
I'm happy for it, but would be happier still to see Apple paying taxes to fund similar programs rather than privatizing something that I agree should be done through the government.
Causing a mass of people to arrive at a location that previously did not have that.
Over time, of course.
People who, due to the nature of their job and their employer, earn way more money than the average working person.
And when 10 people like this go for the 1 available house on the market, guess what happens? The price of the house goes up. Up to a point where only 1 of the bidder is willing to pay that price. Or rent.
Notice that I said "willing to pay" as opposed to "what that person can afford".
Supply and Demand is nice in theory, but really, pricing is more a game of "ask the maximum amount you can get away with".
And of course, owners of property in the same region can't let their property sit at a value much lower than the property around them. If the property around them can go for a certain amount, then so can they.
And this process repeats unendingly. Making it impossible for people with non-tech jobs to get affordable housing. And if not for the big tech company, it never would have happened.
So yeah, it is 100% correct to put the blame on tech companies. If not for them, this would not have occured in the first place.
And in most other locations with land and/or lax building policies, this isn't a problem. This is a feature. But in California (and NYC to some extent too, back to the HQ2 example), developers can't soak up the demand. There's no land left, and upzoning isn't an option.
So yes, it IS California's fault. The money is there -- the article being the most absurd example of it, but the land use policies aren't. Free up the land, let people build up, and you'll have 5x the housing in a matter of years.
California can't even build an In-N-Out, let alone multi-story dense housing.
https://reason.com/2019/11/01/california-nimbys-sue-to-stop-...
This is true of almost every company. I would say that tech companies have a higher % of remote employees than most; our frustration is only that it can be higher.
The city has had a literal generation to respond to housing pressure. How much housing has been built in Beijing, or even in New York, over that same time period?
Why do you think that what you are describing is not precisely "supply and demand"?
> Causing a mass of people to arrive at a location that previously did not have that.
Do you think this is more true of tech than other industries?
That's exactly what the theory of supply and demand is premised on.
Most relevant point, well said. Is there any academic term for this?
While your statement is true, it makes no sense in the context of this topic.
https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/clients/summary...
Apple on Monday announced a $2.5 billion plan to help address the housing crisis in California, becoming the latest tech giant in the state to address a problem that it helped cause.
Apple makes computers! They don’t write tax laws or run housing associations. Policymakers and older Californians have managed to shift blame to a younger generation of working people.