It sounds like your concern is that all three fields of Physics, Engineering, and Chemistry could claim this output, which would be odd, because if every field did this, their combined 'value added' would be many times the total GDP, since their contributions overlap, like you mentioned. That doesn't matter, because we're not concerned about measuring the GDP with this method (if we were, we would have to divide credit like you mentioned) just the objective contribution of a single field.
Same issue with how studying life expectancy and mortality allows you to quantify the risk of death, injury and disease, thus enabling life insurance and health insurance.
The problem with the claim "this is all physics" is that, yes, Newton wrote down the original formulas for mechanics, but those had to be translated into all the engineering practices to be useful. Most of the economic value comes from engingeers who have mastered nth-order derivations of the original equations.
Unlike what most people think, engineering is only partly based on physical/mathematical models. In fact, much of engineering is based on heuristics and empirical knowledge/know-how, and some of this knowledge isn't quantitative and it's not in the province of most physicists.
The difference between physics and engineering is actually quite vast.
I think the economic activity referred to in the article is around large-scale physics activities by organizations like CERN.
This exercise is completely pointless. At best, it serves to show people's biases.
This exercise provides valuable data, for example would you rather government research dollars go toward academic research into Chemical Engineering, Physics, or Aerospace? Data from this sort of study can inform that sort of decision.
Right, but I'm not arguing the Oil & Gas industry depends on debt funding. I'm arguing it depends on funding, period. And that funding is obtained through capital markets, generally, which includes equity raises as well. Even in private markets, someone will be performing valuation on the potential project and calculating expected returns, which will drive the decision on whether to extract the oil – and whether it's done today or in the future.
You need funding even to do basic research, so organizing all of that is a key aspect of the process, just as managing these businesses is.
> This exercise provides valuable data
Does it? That seems like an assumption. It attempts to provide valuable data, but some of us are arguing it doesn't. It could be garbage in, garbage out. Bad data is worse than no data.
> would you rather government research dollars go toward academic research into Chemical Engineering, Physics, or Aerospace?
I think this is a pretty limited framework for making such big decisions. I'd prefer deep research into each of these industries with qualitative discussion on which are the most promising ones for the next 25-50 years, an analysis of what other governments are doing, what is best covered by the private sector, what is the best form of government investment, and the expected return on any of these investments. Anything else is just too shortsighted.
How about financing investments, accounting, sales, supply-chain logistics and managing the business?
Don’t know why you need supply chain logistics for a subsistence farm, because that’s the best you’ll get without physics.
Don't know why you need physics for a steam engine with no motion, because that's the best you'll get without money. That's if it ever goes beyond the blueprint.
Seriously though, I don't think the point behind counting value created by every dependant into dependencies is necessarily a bad one. Surely there must be some mathematical concept that would allow to "balance" the value in a dependency network of industries.
You jest but all those people are listed before the post-credits scene of any blockbuster movie
Saying you are a physics company as soon as you use advanced materials does not seem that far-fetched from where I stand.
And the criterion of "these companies competitive advantage depend partly on recent physics research" is a pretty good one that may indeed include drilling companies and geological exploration.
There's no value in calling a company a "physics company" because that means nothing outside of this very specific conversation we're having
These 72 sectors have a revenue of 4.40 million euros. This means that for example, if you ban all physics education tomorrow, all this revenue will drastically fall because they critically depend on physicists. Note that this is about ensuring that physicists of today are trained to continue working in this industry. And not what some physicists might have done in the past.
[1] https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.eps.org/resource/resmgr/policy/eps...
1. Technology transfer to an existing business 2. CERN employee starts a business to commercialise it 3. Nothing useful is done at all
Obviously people that originally worked on this research will have a head start when it comes to commercialising it. Most research never leads to anything commercial (at least not withing a reasonable time-frame)
As an example, they consider "Extraction of crude petroleum" as a physics-based industry. Naively I would consider that industry at least 33% physics, 33% chemistry, and 33% engineering. Aren't they largely overestimating their conclusion by neglecting chemistry and egineering?
Disclaimer: I am a former physicist. I really think that science funding is vital to Europe, that this kind of studies should help supporting the field... I would just like to better understand how the EPS and CEBR got to such a clickbait title. I have the impression that this kind of article could actually undermine the credibility of all the contributions that Physics research is actually bringing to society at large.