Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by jessriedel on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @01:47AM
(#2142415)
I was hoping Slashdot was going to reduce the huge amount of padding around each comment, but no luck. For instance, on my screen right now I can fit 13 comments on HN or reddit but no more than 5 on slashdot. This makes it much harder to navigate comment threads, connect replies with comments, etc.
I'm I the only one who thinks this is easily the worst part of Slashdot? It's reminiscent of a bad forum where each 3-word quip comes with an avatar, a custom border, and a 5-line signature.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by atgm on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @11:14PM
(#2142102)
I liked slashdot more when it was plain, quick-loading HTML. I liked most sites more when they were plain, quick-loading HTML. Ain't It Cool News is the only other one coming to mind at the moment, though.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by baddox on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @11:43PM
(#2142172)
Reddit has been pushing it these days, and its performance has been awful for a while now (due mostly to growing pains, I reckon), but their aesthetic is still pretty plain. And of course this site definitely qualifies!
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by atgm on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @11:46PM
(#2142176)
It's not so much the design aesthetic as performance for me. Sometimes browsers just seem to choke or take more time on complicated AJAX for something as simple as making a comment.
Hacker News is great in that respect -- it's all simple and very responsive.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by julian37 on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @05:00AM
(#2142787)
Huh, why would that be? Drawing a round corner is in fact more complex than drawing a square one, but surely for a few dozen rounded corners the number of additional CPU cycles spent pales in comparison to things like anti-aliased font rendering, calculating CSS box model layouts, decompressing gzipped contents and the myriad of other tasks that a browser has to perform during loading and rendering of a web site nowadays.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by robgough on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @08:35AM
(#2143198)
Most modern browsers (all but IE I believe) will let you round corners with CSS. An extra line or so of CSS is hardly much of a transfer overhead.
I believe current thinking (on non-enterprise sites anyway) is to let the IE people have their square corners, and those on new browsers get all the curvy goodness.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by dreyfiz on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @02:34AM
(#2142512)
I don't doubt that she said this, but I can't find the quote by Googling, and I would love to see it for myself, in context. Can you provide a link? Thanks!
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by peng on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @07:20AM
(#2143031)
The old Slashdot design bothered me so much I proposed a minimalist layout last year: http://nylira.com/p/slashdot
Thoughts on this one:
Slashdot's homepage is much cleaner than before, but the thick green bars denoting each story is visually oppressive. I understand that it's a branding element, but it hampers readability.
The fixed navigation annoys me, but that's a personal preference: I don't think the menus are important enough to be constantly on-screen.
I see they still haven't added a max-width to text columns either. It's difficult reading comments on a 1440px+ screen.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by btrask on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @11:56PM
(#2142197)
It's unfortunate that they've jumped on the fixed positioning bandwagon. Non-scrolling headers/footers break the way Page Up and Page Down work, because the visible size is no longer the size of the scrollable area.
Luckily there's a user style in the Slashdot comments that changes the fixed elements to absolute positioning. It isn't a perfect solution, though (e.g. for when you use an alternate browser).
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by kd0amg on Thursday January 27, 2011 @02:09AM
(#2146943)
Non-scrolling headers/footers break the way Page Up and Page Down work, because the visible size is no longer the size of the scrollable area.
It also seems to break their "Parent" links -- it ends up with the top bar partially covering the comment's header. I've yet to encounter a web site where floating title bar is a good idea.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by GrooveStomp on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @12:47AM
(#2142323)
It probably looks better, as I remember Slashdot being really ugly, but the new design is still ugly. The Slashdot header font in particular is an eyesore, but very little on the site actually looks modern or pleasing.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by bermanoid on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @03:24AM
(#2142603)
Ugh, all this time, a whole new revamp, and it still suffers from the problem where hitting "Get more comments" moves everything around, and you've got to look through everything to figure out what the hell actually just loaded...
Why would anyone ever think that hitting more should load more comments above the comment you just finished freaking reading? And yes, I realize they're loading low ranked deeply nested comments that are underneath ones that are already visible, but yeesh - just clip the damn comment tree after a certain number of comments are displayed, FFS, no need to try and be clever about it...
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by wladimir on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @05:01AM
(#2142789)
I might be alone in this, but I actually preferred the old-fashioned pagination approach to to 'get more articles' buttons.
Actually, I might not be alone in this as HN does the same thing :)
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by zeemonkee on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @03:41AM
(#2142628)
I don't really care so much for design as content. Slashdot looks tired, whatever design you slap on top of
it. For example they've updated the Bill Gates Borg icon. It looks very dated now, though.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by asnyder on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @12:38AM
(#2142287)
If I remember correctly, setting the wmode param slows down flash performance significantly. I also remember it having significant trouble in opera. However, it's possible that these issues are now fixed in the newer browsers, but I'm pretty sure that older browsers still experience them.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by randall on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @12:49AM
(#2142330)
Def some quirks back in the day (I think FF on Linux still doesn't even listen to the wmode param, iirc) but I think modern browsers deal with wmode better now.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by Duff on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @12:03AM
(#2142220)
This is probably the first good redesign that /. has done this century!
I actually stopped visiting Slashdot because the previous rounds of "improvement" to the comment system was always a pain in the butt if you had to switch tabs while typing. It will be good to be back.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by wazoox on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @02:41AM
(#2142532)
I hope it will work better than the previous one. It was unbearably slow on my puny work PC and hardly usable on my other machines, and frankly, I don't think that I should upgrade to quad core because of ONE website.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by tjansen on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @11:14AM
(#2143697)
I am glad they kept much of the original design, especially the rounded edges and the green. Yes, it's not pretty, but for me it's like listening to an oldie station. Slashdot was there in the 90s when you felt like participating in a revolution for using Linux (or, if you wanted to be even more avantgarde, one of the BSDs). It helped people get through the time of the Columbine massacre, was the best place to discuss the Halloween documents, offered endless First-Post/Nathalie-Portman trolling opportunities, and with Jon Katz you always had something to talk (or complain) about.
The problem is that the culture did not really evolve. There's nothing that Slashdot stands for anymore. I wonder whether it would be a good idea for Slashdot, now that the readers as well as the authors are older, to cover topics for geeks in their 30s or 40s: homes, families, kids... I believe that there would be a range of interesting topics, and I don't know any news site that covers them.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by yaix on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @09:47AM
(#2143405)
Now it looks like a framed site from good ol' 1997 again. Fixed header, fixed menu cluttering up your 800x600 pixel smartphone screen, and a small scrollable area (of which most is white space) with the actual content. Wow, that went seriously wrong.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by tzs on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @03:18AM
(#2142593)
It looks uglier than the old version, in my opinion. On the other hand, it looks like paste now works correctly when entering comments. (It used to often fail on Webkit-based browsers if there was any text already in the box), so that's a huge improvement.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by easyfrag on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @08:57AM
(#2143267)
My problem with /. was that the stories were not voted in on by the community but rather by a select few curators who added editorial content in the headlines.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by recoiledsnake on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @09:51AM
(#2143420)
That could easily be called a feature, looking at how Reddit's focus changed. Hacker News is able to keep it's narrow focus, but it's the exception rather than the rule.
You're right about the editorial content in the headlines and summary though but I like that the stories have a small blurb explaining the story unlike Reddit or Hacker News.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by cubicle67 on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @12:29AM
(#2142274)
I'm lucky in that I have a somewhat more open relationship with HN; HN allows me to view other sites, and in return I let HN have more users than just me
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by johnohara on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @09:02AM
(#2143275)
I scan the RSS feed, ignore the dupes from HN, reject the political stuff, and glance over the remaining tech headlines.
Of the three that might appeal to me, I read the abstracts, and occasionally follow the links to the original articles. I ignore the comments because I never log in anymore. The only ad I might see is in the upper right.
The new design seems to confirm that I'm not alone.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by cabalamat on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @08:21AM
(#2143163)
> It is likely Slashdot will still be here when HN is gone.
My gut feeling says no. I used to read Slashdot as much as I now read HN or Reddit. I hardly ever go there any more, and when I do it just doesn't seem interesting.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by fleitz on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @01:49AM
(#2142422)
Does the redesign involve removing most of their userbase? There's some kind of aversion to people charging money on that site that just doesn't jive with me. I assume that HN will at some point reach the critical mass that killed slashdot for me. Hopefully that day will be far far in the future.
Re:Slashdot Launches Re-Design
by kaiwetzel on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @07:53AM
(#2143104)
I noticed the same (i7-920, FF 3.6) - after removing the fixed position bar (using firebug) the site at least seems significantly less sluggish. Weird how a seemingly simple thing can hurt performance so much (or maybe it's just a psychological effect ?)
On a large screen I find it visually more pleasing than the last version but I stoppped using the site completely after they introduced that silly ajax-abuse and the new one wouldn't make me come back if for that reason alone.
I'm I the only one who thinks this is easily the worst part of Slashdot? It's reminiscent of a bad forum where each 3-word quip comes with an avatar, a custom border, and a 5-line signature.
Not pretty, but readable and very usable.
The padding and useless decoration that you (rightfully) complain about was introduced with the first ajax-redesign a few years ago.
Surely you mean a 200 pixel signature containing an animated image? :-)
Hacker News is great in that respect -- it's all simple and very responsive.
It isn't the processor time that is taking longer its the transfer time.
I believe current thinking (on non-enterprise sites anyway) is to let the IE people have their square corners, and those on new browsers get all the curvy goodness.
Thoughts on this one:
Slashdot's homepage is much cleaner than before, but the thick green bars denoting each story is visually oppressive. I understand that it's a branding element, but it hampers readability.
The fixed navigation annoys me, but that's a personal preference: I don't think the menus are important enough to be constantly on-screen.
I see they still haven't added a max-width to text columns either. It's difficult reading comments on a 1440px+ screen.
Did you design a comment page too?
Luckily there's a user style in the Slashdot comments that changes the fixed elements to absolute positioning. It isn't a perfect solution, though (e.g. for when you use an alternate browser).
It also seems to break their "Parent" links -- it ends up with the top bar partially covering the comment's header. I've yet to encounter a web site where floating title bar is a good idea.
Why would anyone ever think that hitting more should load more comments above the comment you just finished freaking reading? And yes, I realize they're loading low ranked deeply nested comments that are underneath ones that are already visible, but yeesh - just clip the damn comment tree after a certain number of comments are displayed, FFS, no need to try and be clever about it...
(flash in most (all?) browsers appears on top of even html regardless of specific css rules)
http://www.communitymx.com/content/article.cfm?cid=e5141
I actually stopped visiting Slashdot because the previous rounds of "improvement" to the comment system was always a pain in the butt if you had to switch tabs while typing. It will be good to be back.
The problem is that the culture did not really evolve. There's nothing that Slashdot stands for anymore. I wonder whether it would be a good idea for Slashdot, now that the readers as well as the authors are older, to cover topics for geeks in their 30s or 40s: homes, families, kids... I believe that there would be a range of interesting topics, and I don't know any news site that covers them.
And they're still using the Bill Gates Borg icon?
You're right about the editorial content in the headlines and summary though but I like that the stories have a small blurb explaining the story unlike Reddit or Hacker News.
Of the three that might appeal to me, I read the abstracts, and occasionally follow the links to the original articles. I ignore the comments because I never log in anymore. The only ad I might see is in the upper right.
The new design seems to confirm that I'm not alone.
It is likely Slashdot will still be here when HN is gone.
There's a lesson in that.
My gut feeling says no. I used to read Slashdot as much as I now read HN or Reddit. I hardly ever go there any more, and when I do it just doesn't seem interesting.
For me, Slashdot lacks the buzz it used to have.
They're sinking in the last year or so while HN is rising somewhat.
On a large screen I find it visually more pleasing than the last version but I stoppped using the site completely after they introduced that silly ajax-abuse and the new one wouldn't make me come back if for that reason alone.