News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by ceejayoz on Monday October 21, 2019 @02:51PM (#21315842)
I don't think that's fair.

The hypothetical with no side effects or safety issues means we have to consider the ethical side of "should we 'cure' autism". We have to answer that before any discussion of "what level of side effects are acceptable".

See, for example, the Deaf community's feelings on things like cochlear implants.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by chr1 on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:21PM (#21316850)
The Deaf community's feelings on things like cochlear implants is the perfect example showing that the whole "ethical side" is pointless philosophical babble. How can anyone even think to justify not allowing other people to improve their lives in the name of preserving "a culture"?

The assumption that there are independent physical constraints and ethical side is wrong, because depending on how actually the reality works, the same action can be either the most ethical or most unethical action.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by ceejayoz on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:38PM (#21317037)
> How can anyone even think to justify not allowing other people to improve their lives in the name of preserving "a culture"?

That was the precise attitude that got us scenarios like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Indian_boarding_schoo... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stolen_Generations.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by chr1 on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:06PM (#21317356)
The important part in the argument above is allowing people to decide for themselves.

The boarding schools were about government "saving" children by not allowing children and their parents to choose.

The people who are unhappy about cochlear implants, want to "save" deaf culture by not allowing some other people to choose for themselves whether they want to be death or not.

So the similarity is the other around.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by SolaceQuantum on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:08PM (#21316697)
Cochlear implants do have side effects health-wise and consequences, though. That's precisely what I was thinking of. They are very expensive, destroys any hearing the person may still have, can cause nerve damage, has questionable 'hearing' clarity...

Asking a deaf person "would you cure your deafness if you could with no side effects" ignores the reality that current abilities to 'cure' deafness do come with significant side effects, and people who consider them need to also consider the pros and cons of undergoing the procedure.

In contrary to 'stripping away info to dive into the ethics' you are trying to do, I believe you'll never approach the ethics without the nuances of the actual circumstances people are actually likely to be dealing with.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by ceejayoz on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:12PM (#21316749)
Some in the Deaf community feel that even without side effects like that, that Deaf children should not receive them. That Deafness is not a disability, just a difference, and that "curing" it would be killing a culture much as raising Native American children in schools that banned their languages and culture did.

"Should we do the procedure at all" comes before "are the side effects of a specific implementation of the procedure worth it".

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by pkaye on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:44PM (#21318838)
Its not the choice of the deaf community. Its the choice of the individual and parents. And there are plenty of people who get deaf later in life that may want the treatment so research should continue.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by chrisco255 on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:18PM (#21317503)
Clearly it should be the choice of the individual (or parents) to receive treatment or not. Why is this even a debate. With any elective treatment, there isn't going to be 100% adoption.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by gugagore on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:14PM (#21319409)
It's not entirely about choice. It's about attitudes of medical professionals. Imagine you have a deaf child, have no experience with Deaf culture, and a professional convinces you to give your child a CI. Yeah, obviously it's the parents' choice. But what are they compelled to choose.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by vertex-four on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:47PM (#21318854)
No, it should not be the choice of the parents - the parents should not be able to force an unethical treatment onto their child.

If this becomes a thing, why would society accept autistic people, rather than telling us to undergo treatment that we don't want to make us more like them?

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by chrisco255 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @01:59AM (#21320737)
Some parents feed their kids growth hormone just so they don't end up being too short. Certainly there's nothing wrong with being short, but we do this for all sorts of things where we know people are at a disadvantage with. We give kids braces, vaccines, etc. How are any of those different? Assuming, it was a healthy and vetted treatment, how would it be different?
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by krageon on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @05:43AM (#21321794)
What makes a treatment unethical? Parents should be able to treat things that they view as disabilities to their best judgement. That is their responsibility as parents. I'm not comfortable with saying that parents need to be limited in such a way.

At the same time, when we see people that do not vaccine their children that also makes me angry. Perhaps it is a fuzzy line and we need to recognise that this is the case without making too many blanket statements.

> If this becomes a thing, why would society accept autistic people

Society has no requirement to accept autistic people. Some people will be willing to work with them just as they always have and some people might not. That's their choice, just like it is the choice of an autistic person (or maybe their parents! I'm not sure) whether or not to seek treatment. If you feel that being excluded sometimes is a fundamental pressure to seek treatment, I have bad news for you: You will never get along with everyone.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by vertex-four on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:27AM (#21322823)
No, it is not the responsibility of parents to force things on their children. Children are not property to be owned and controlled by their parents against the children's will. That we've wound up believing this is honestly embarrassing.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by krageon on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @07:21AM (#21333421)
The reason we make parents responsible for their children until a certain age is because we as a collective have judged them incapable of doing so for themselves. I don't know how long it has been for you, but for me it has not been so long that I do not remember being incapable of making big life decisions.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by big_chungus on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:03PM (#21316647)
I've never understood why some deaf people feel so strongly about it. The fact that deafness is part of their identity doesn't mean they ought to go around telling others they shouldn't try to hear, especially not so vehemently. I'd consider it roughly equivalent to the really obnoxious fire-and-brimstone evangelicals that yell that you're going to hell if you don't convert. Why do people care so much what others do with their lives?
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by knicholes on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:11PM (#21316738)
Because if you're able to hear and they're not able to hear, it means they have a disability. They don't want to consider themselves disabled. I was a transcriptionist for a college when they held a deaf conference, and it was definitely this way. They were angry that they had to mark a disability to receive government assistance, because they felt as though they had no disabilities.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by scarby2 on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:28PM (#21316932)
I've never understood this isn't lacking an ability that 95% of the population have basically part of the very definition of disability.

I lack fine motor control, I'm unable to write legibly with a pen, i have issues with spacial perception and regularly fall over pretty much anything, i struggle with any task that requires co-ordination (if you threw a ball at me i'd have maybe a 30% chance of catching it). I also don't have binocular vision (anything thats supposed to be 3d looks the same as the picture to me). Luckily in the age of technology i this has not impaired me significantly but i couldn't claim to not have any kind of disability...

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by big_chungus on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:26PM (#21317593)
I guess that makes sense, but it strikes me as awfully selfish to try to pressure someone into maintaining a poorer quality of life to fulfill one's own sense of identity. It doesn't say good things about those people, and I would have though they of all people would want the fewest people to suffer what they do.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by knicholes on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:41PM (#21317766)
Because I was so appalled, I asked one of the students to explain it. They said that I was disabled because I can't work in a noisy factory comfortably while they could.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by big_chungus on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:06PM (#21318004)
I applaud that part; seeing the upside is admirable and not everyone can do that. What I still don't get is when they get mad when others try to hear again. It just doesn't make sense. My perspective could certainly be off here, but it sounds like someone being mad his neighbor has a fancier car and yelling at him about it.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by vertex-four on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:58PM (#21318932)
The problem is that you get hearing people go "well, there's a treatment, why should we change what we're doing to accept deaf people?"

When there's a (potentially invasive/experience-altering) treatment which makes people more able to fit into existing society, that society will often pressure people into receiving that treatment. This is, obviously, rather upsetting, and I imagine a lot of deaf people would rather the treatment didn't exist.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by gugagore on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:29PM (#21319498)
Your perspective suggests you think deaf people are jealous of hearing people. I think it's different. Deaf people have created a bunch of other solutions that don't involve cochlear implants, and a lot of that has been ignored by society at large. (For example, how do you raise a deaf child.)

Also the controversy around cochlear implants is mostly about giving CIs to young humans. It's not that much about "hearing again". (In fact I don't think CIs are as effective later in life.)

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by gugagore on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:24PM (#21319469)
And were you able to see one of the other meanings behind "disability", and why deaf people want to avoid that stigma?
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by knicholes on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @09:06AM (#21323145)
I could see their perspective, yes. They also mentioned that they could communicate at a noisy club easily while I couldn't, but that doesn't have much to do with being hearing/deaf but exclusively due to knowing sign language. My conclusion is that they actually are disabled, but no less deserving of respect and love as those who can hear.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by gugagore on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:22PM (#21319457)
I don't trust that you have enough experience with deaf people to make your claim.

The word disability has a lot of meanings and a lot of uses. Only one of them is about getting access to accommodations.

Deaf people absolutely label themselves disabled for the purposes of getting access to accommodations, like you suggest. I think you misunderstood that they're upset about all the other things that are associated with disability. The idea that deafness is "lesser" (e.g. hearing loss) simply does not resonate with most culturally deaf people.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by matt-attack on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:54AM (#21320491)
Well they literally have lesser (or more correctly, “fewer”) functioning senses. Like 4 instead of 5 is clearly lesser.

I really hate when emotions get in the way of objective definitions.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by gugagore on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:43PM (#21327172)
Why is it more important to have an objective definition of deafness than it is to understand deaf people's definitions of deafness? The most important difference between deaf people and hearing people, for deaf people, isn't "5-4=1".

I really hate it when objectiveness gets in the way of compassion and respect for human beings and life generally.

Also, of course deaf people agree they cannot hear and have one fewer functioning sense. In some signed languages, the sign for deafness is an open hand, but with one of the fingers flexed (4 of 5).

And I will argue in fact it's hearing people who get "emotional" about the idea that deaf people don't care about not hearing. By the way, "5-4=1" is not the most important difference for hearing people either. Hearing people will talk about hearing birds songs and stuff.

Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by knicholes on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @06:36PM (#21329154)
I worked with them for nine years, so shrug. I'm not sure how much experience you require for me to have to make my claim.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by narrator on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @03:35AM (#21321157)
Being deaf or autistic is not a religion where apostasy is forbidden.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by scarby2 on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:42PM (#21316394)
I'm not sure the deaf community's views on cochlear implants are entirely relevant here. There is no 'autistic culture' whereas there is very definitely deaf culture. Also we're not necessarily talking about a straightforward disability. If any of us were offered the ability to gan an extra useful sense then we'd probably take it... If we talk about something that profoundly changes our personality then maybe we'd be a little more hesitant.
Re:CRISPR therapy may reverse autism gene mutation effects i... by ceejayoz on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:47PM (#21316455)