News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by ilamont on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:21AM (#21311392)
A data analytics firm that specializes in the Amazon Marketplace recently analyzed the site’s 100 best-selling food products for CNBC and found that at least 40% of sellers had more than five customer complaints about expired goods.

In other words, Amazon knows about the sellers who ship expired goods yet lets them continue to operate. It has the data and it still fails to take one of the easiest steps to address the problem, removing bad actors from the marketplace (which would also make many other sellers clean up their acts).

I've had a similar issue with buying books advertised as "new" and they are clearly used ... including one book that had a "USED" sticker on it. I complained about the seller, and nothing happened. As of the last time I checked this seller was still in business on Amazon, with 22% negative ratings in the last 30 days.

The message to third-party sellers is clear:

Win the buy box however you can. We won’t police your listings. We won’t punish you if you lie about the condition of the goods. Even if many of Amazon’s customers are complaining about you, you can still stay in business on Amazon.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by dpark on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:00AM (#21313034)
> In other words, Amazon knows about the sellers who ship expired goods yet lets them continue to operate. It has the data and it still fails to take one of the easiest steps to address the problem, removing bad actors from the marketplace

I have anecdata contrary to this. We used to buy gluten free bread from Amazon because of my son’s gluten allergy. It was a pain to buy locally so we would buy 4 loaves at a time from Amazon. We started getting expired loaves from some seller. It happened multiple times, to about 50% of the orders. This bread has a long shelf life so these loaves were months old.

We got reimbursed multiple times through the automated return system but it continued. Finally my wife called to complain. They apologized, gave us some credit, and said they look into it. The next time we got expired bread again. She called again and they promised they’d remove the seller. Indeed they did something this time. The bread was unavailable for about a month and when it came back we never had another expired loaf delivered.

I think Amazon does listen. What they don’t seem to do is listen to people who complain in reviews. Reach out to Amazon directly if you want to complain about a real issue with a seller.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by lotsofpulp on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:06AM (#21313113)
Sounds to me like amazon takes a 15% or 20% cut of the transaction, and the customer gets to do all the work of vetting sellers?

I’d rather pay more and support a reputable manufacturer or vendor directly.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by not_a_cop75 on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:09AM (#21313153)
Amazon is the equivocal of the retail end. Any sufficient and provable complaint to Amazon will result in a refund.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by lotsofpulp on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:13AM (#21313200)
I don’t want a refund, I want to support companies that use the right processes to save me time, but companies that choose to commingle to save the company a penny and cost me time are not worth supporting.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by not_a_cop75 on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:42PM (#21314332)
What retail shop honestly saves you time? Does waiting in line at Walmart save you time? Yes, you have the option of checking the expiration in line, but is anyone really shopping at Walmart for the time savings?
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by lotsofpulp on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:56PM (#21314502)
Costco, for one. Based on their track record, I don't think twice about purchasing something from there or something branded Kirkland Signature. I know what I buy is decent quality at a decent price.

Target/Home Depot/Lowes also helps, I know what I buy from them doesn't come from a random reseller, and I don't have to filter through reseller garbage on their website either. They also have pickup in store options, as well as showing me where the items are in the store if I need to go find them. Also, I don't recall waiting in line more than a couple minutes.

I just happen to use those stores as an example, I'm sure many others offer the same benefits. Point is, I don't want to worry about counterfeit, commingled, and all that nonsense. I also know sometimes Amazon hides the option to only show items shipped and sold by Amazon.com, and based on their attempts to deceive me, I assume they intentionally break search to make it not as easy to find things.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by jschwartzi on Monday October 21, 2019 @02:50PM (#21315829)
It saves me time in the sense that I can trust that Walmart knows who is selling them products to stock. Amazon has no idea where their products come from or even if they're counterfeit. And they certainly couldn't be bothered to find out. They also don't really care if the stuff you buy from them actually arrives. I stopped buying anything from Amazon after the 3rd or 4th shipping screw up in as many orders.

The last shipment was just left somewhere in the building that I sublet in. Luckily the guy who runs that office was nice enough to complete the delivery. And before that they had apparently just lost an entire shipment of 24 orders. They were all marked as delivered, but nobody had any way to change that in the system so they wanted me to call customer service.

They were great about 10 years ago when I first signed up for Prime. I don't trust them anymore and will advise all of my friends not to trust Amazon for anything.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by heavyset_go on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:48PM (#21317165)
If Walmart sells something tainted with lead, heads will roll. Walmart bears liability for the things they sell on their shelves.

If Amazon sells something tainted with lead, we get a bunch of corporate apologia about co-mingling and nothing changes.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by serial_dev on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:10AM (#21313174)
Your anecdote is a good example that they don't listen. How many times did you complain before they took action? It looks like you had to complain multiple times which most people will not do (they complain once and try to not order from that seller).
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by dpark on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:13AM (#21313202)
I believe my wife complained to a human twice.

Most people probably complain zero times. Posting negative reviews of a product is a poor way to give feedback about a bad seller.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by bryanrasmussen on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:48AM (#21313614)
After you stopped having problems with the bread did you ever try to log in with another account and buy it with another credit card and send it to another address - I just wonder if the seller retooled and put in an array of accounts that must not be screwed over because they complain too hard. I guess I'm overly paranoid.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by dpark on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:20PM (#21314068)
I absolutely did not do that. Who would?

It’s possible that what you’re describing happened, but I’m not investing the time and energy to try to “trap them” like this. I also don’t think it’s terribly likely. I believe it was also FBA so they don’t have control over what item gets sent to which customer.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by bryanrasmussen on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:47PM (#21319602)
I might, but that it the overly paranoid part I was talking about. But then since I don't trust or like Amazon and I'm in Europe I wouldn't have been in the position to do it.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by Jean-Philipe on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:18AM (#21312513)
Funny thing, my auntie once got banned for life from Amazon. She used to sell used books on Amazon (as "used", obviously) until she got one single complaint from a client. Even though the complaint was without basis, she offered him full refund while letting him keep the book. Still, she got banned by Amazon. They even banned the account of her husband, with no explanation and no possibility for recourse. She cannot ever sell anything ever again on Amazon, and she doesn't even know why.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by ilamont on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:48AM (#21312872)
I hear stories like that, and then I see my own experience with serial cheaters allowed to keep selling and racking up negative ratings. I am wondering if Amazon gave up enforcement, or just changed its practices/loosened the rules.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by dpark on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:10AM (#21313169)
I hear stories like that and question innocence of the protestor. I know sometimes people get screwed over for no reason but I’m also aware of numerous cases where someone loudly protests the unfairness of being blocked for a single unintentional infraction and upon further review it turns out they had a history of abuse, sometimes with a secondary account that they assumed BigCo was too stupid to link to their “real” account.

Sometimes it’s a bit of a failure on both sides (e.g. BigCo also fails to notify about the abuse on the other account). Sometimes it’s just bullshit on the part of the complainer (e.g. Endless public protestations of innocence from someone who was actually sharing child pornography). I’m too jaded to trust the intentions of corporations, but I’m also too jaded to blindly trust the claims of those who assert they’ve been screwed over, especially when my gut says the story doesn’t make sense.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by papln on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:37AM (#21313494)
There's a cottage industry of this in HN, where someone posts a blog complainings about BigCo destroying their small business, getting hundreds of upvotes and comments, and then it turns out, every time, that oops their software developement was outsourced to a developer who is a known serial spammer or scammer, and it's "not fair" because mom&pop can't know that they hired a criminal so BigCo shouldn't blame them.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by throwaway2048 on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:59PM (#21317928)
Every time? I don't think so.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by FireBeyond on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:45PM (#21317125)
Right. I got very sick once, and was 2 days late shipping an item (a camera lens). That one complaint was enough to get me banned forever. I had offered in my response to say I was willing to be "required to use FBA" for all sales from the future forward, and they weren't interested. There was no complaint about the product, just that it arrived 2 days late (and I -had- messaged the buyer before that to advise).
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by papln on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:34AM (#21313459)
How do you know that story is true? Amazon is full of sellers with many complaints published on the site.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by ben509 on Monday October 21, 2019 @02:19PM (#21315464)
His auntie wouldn't exaggerate or leave out details... would she?
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by rwmurrayVT on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:28AM (#21312629)
Book selling is an insane market on Amazon. I ran a used bookstore on Amazon with 380 positive reviews and 1 negative review over the last 12 months. The sellers are cut-throat. They're all trying to sell something they got from a thrift store for $0.50 on Amazon to make $3. Amazon intentionally allows "acceptable" books to take the buy box over "very good" just based on price and seller feedback. If you end up selling the acceptable book then you get bad feedback for having a terrible quality book. The whole thing is a damn mess. Many sellers will list as "new" either intentionally or unintentionally. I'd be lying if I didn't say I sold several books I found in pristine condition or even shrink-wrapped as "new". The difference between $15 and $9 for an FBA book sale is the difference between $1.75 and $8. Book selling on Amazon is insane.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by zaroth on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:09PM (#21313901)
As a buyer sometimes the deals are absurdly good. For example got my daughter a hardcover Harry Potter Cursed Child for $3 Like New, and that included next day delivery. Shows up as described, and I just saved $15.

I’m slightly ashamed to admit I was actually at BN at the time where they were selling it for $30. But I did spend $100 during that trip, on books that were comparably priced to Amazon.

I assume Cursed Child is an outlier because I’d guess a huge number of people are buying it expecting it to be something it’s not, and then likely returning or offloading the book in disappointment.

Obviously no one made money on the transaction so I assume it was a buggy algorithm, but I’m not complaining!

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by rwmurrayVT on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:40PM (#21317070)
Repricers often go awry. If you bought it FBA then they could have repricing software set to match lowest FBA price, but the available repricing API only returns 20 lowest. If there aren't any FBA then you'll get the MF. The whole system is a mess.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by mcgoo on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:10AM (#21312419)
If you create a listing that competes with someone else’s high volume product you will get fake reviews claiming the product is expired. Multiple times this has happened on a brand new listing with no sales, before the product even arrives at Amazon. Expired is one of the go-to false complaints.

In my experience Amazon reliably push expired product back to the seller, at least using the dates that were declared by the seller. This does not stop a seller from claiming what they like, I suppose.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by amitport on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:40AM (#21312111)
"more than five customer complaints"

Five out of _?

We should care about the proportion, and should consider some time decay (maybe the issues were a decade ago).

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by michaelt on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:02AM (#21312329)
I work for a company that (among other things) sells food.

The acceptable number of customers to send expired food is zero percent.

It's not a complex or unusual requirement to make sure your goods are in-date - any properly designed warehouse management system will take care of this. This is absolutely table stakes if you're going to deliver food.

Unopened baby formula has a shelf life of 6 months+ when properly stored, so they've got a gigantic margin of error here. It'd be pretty poor customer service to ship baby formula that only had 2 months of its 6 month shelf life remaining. There's really no excuse for shipping expired baby formula.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by crazygringo on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:21AM (#21312548)
Actually, genuine question: how do you do that technologically?

With multiple supplier deliveries that result in combined stock with multiple expiration dates, how do you ensure expired food isn't delivered?

Because I assume a warehouse doesn't keep a separate shelf spot for each separate delivery of a unique expiration date?

And also, the expiration dates are printed on products in places that can be hard to find and hard to read. (Every time I buy bacon or greens I spent sixty seconds trying to find where the hell the date is on the plastic.)

It's also generally not cost-effective on low-margin food items to print out and scan a unique label for each item that would allow the expiration date to be machine-readable.

So I've always just assumed new deliveries try to be put in a warehouse bin behind/under existing items, and workers try to check visually for expired items, but that neither of those will ever be perfect.

So what's the properly designed warehouse management system that solves for this?

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by michaelt on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:57AM (#21312977)
> Because I assume a warehouse doesn't keep a separate shelf spot for each separate delivery of a unique expiration date?

Actually, that's pretty much what we do.

If the goods arrive from the supplier as a whole pallet of a single product, every item on the pallet will have the same expiry date, and you track each pallet separately.

If the goods arrive on a pallet with a variety of products on it, you split it up by product then do exactly the same thing.

The warehouse management system knows where each pallet is, and what its expiry date is. If a pallet has expired, workers picking items are sent to to non-expired pallets instead, and someone working on 'purge' is sent to remove the expired goods for donation/recycling/discarding as appropriate.

You need a system like this if you want any chance of selling things like bread, because gaining or losing one or two days of product life makes the difference between a customer who'll shop again and one who won't.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by turtlebits on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:05PM (#21317349)
Unless you check each item, you don't actually know if the expiration date is correct. I don't see much difference in what you are doing vs Amazon, except that Amazon is getting their product from a various sources (which may be less trustworthy than your supplier).
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by michaelt on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:05PM (#21318553)
Ah, perhaps I should have specified; as well as being industry convention, our suppliers are obligated by contract to ensure all the items on a pallet have the same expiry date; and they are generally the original manufacturer who packaged the goods and attached the expiry date in the first place.

They can, of course, print any expiry date on it they like. But they're also pretty motivated not to poison their customers, which is widely seen as bad business practice :)

In our case we do carry out random spot checks on inbound goods, but that's mainly checking for things like bruising on fresh fruit and vegetables.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by Scaevolus on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:29PM (#21317624)
Since everyone in the chain cares about expiration dates, food manufacturers aren't in the habit of commingling products with different ages. Why wouldn't they ship a pallet that's all made at the same time?
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by yifanl on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:46AM (#21312846)
So, if there isn't a solution to do something at scale, then the answer is to simply not do said something at scale.

The defence that "this isn't technologically possible" isn't at all a defence. The _most_ charitable interpretation would be that this is Amazon stress-testing how well they can handle co-mingling of various product lines... but that's still not great if they don't pull the experiment immediately after realizing they can't.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by papln on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:39AM (#21313514)
What's wrong with babyfood that must be consumed within 2 months. (And note that it doesn't turn toxic after it's expiration date, shelf-life for canned goods is far longer than stamped date.)
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by michaelt on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:21PM (#21314079)
> What's wrong with babyfood that must be consumed within 2 months.

Maybe the customer saw a good deal, or had a visit from a rich relative who wanted to do something nice to help them out, and knowing the product lasts 6+ months, ordered a 3 month supply.

If the stuff that turns up has a shorter life than they expect, they're going to be disappointed which is bad for your reputation, and they may get a refund causing you to make a loss on the order.

The same applies to a loaf of bread or a pack of batteries or almost anything else with an expiry date.

Of course if you were explicitly listing the product as discounted due to short shelf life, and your website was clear enough users couldn't overlook that by accident, it's fine - but AFAIK Amazon doesn't have different listings for different shelf lives of the same product.

> And note that it doesn't turn toxic after it's expiration date

Sure, but there's a market rate for expired goods, and it's way lower than the market rate for non-expired goods. If you're selling expired goods to customers who thought they were getting non-expired goods, you're ripping them off and it's fair for them to want a refund.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by amitport on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:22AM (#21312554)
I didn't mean to say that it's OK. Just that I would like to have a good quantitative grasp of the actual situation.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by ilamont on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:51AM (#21312903)
You are correct. I am assuming most marketplace sellers are low-volume sellers, therefore 5 negative seller reviews/ratings is enough to justify a red flag. If it's a high-volume seller with many hundreds or thousands of reviews in a 1-month period, then it's not as big of a concern.

For the example I cited earlier of a 22% negative rating in the previous 30 days, that represented dozens of negative reviews.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by Keverw on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:39AM (#21313513)
> In other words, Amazon knows about the sellers who ship expired goods yet lets them continue to operate. It has the data and it still fails to take one of the easiest steps to address the problem

Yeah, I wonder if companies are so big complaints are just noise to them that isn't even really looked at. I feel like I'm just a number that doesn't matter to any of these companies. Then also feel like a lot of the reps at companies are powerless, given limited training, tools and relies a lot on scripts.

Some of these companies are huge, and some things are free like say Gmail. So I feel with all these internet companies, support is a challenge it seems for both the company and the customer sadly. Even the local cable company has a help link but it's just a knowledge base, they hide their phone number on another page now. I do like the approach of letting people try to solve issues on their own, but being able to talk to someone would be nice.

About 2 years ago, I found a app on the iPhone App Store that would popup the in-app purchase by itself randomly, so when you go to exit the app using the home button Touch ID would then buy it for you using your fingerprint. I did get a refund though, less than $4 purchase but pretty scary that's possible. On newer iPhones with FaceID and the side button maybe it's less likely to happen since you pull down to go home instead of pushing a physical button.

I figured the app would of been removed, but just checked it and seen a review from this year with the same problem...

Then some big companies, everything is different departments walled off from each other, which unsure if they really communicate with each other. Just seems like support is pretty poor in general in tech, but other industries too like calling up your health insurance company due to a billing mistake. The other thing that super annoys me too, is when you get transfered from agent to agent it's like you have to start over again with companies. Not sure why they can't transfer a note and your account info already pulled up to the next agent. Have to repeat yourself over and over, was helping a relative set up a new phone and the transfer didn't seemed to go through, and got transferred like 6 times same and same. Gave up, and decided to just buy a new phone, transfer worked and then return the other phone. You just get the runaround, and feel powerless.

Someone I follow who does the full time RV life was having trouble with his insurance company after changing his domicile to South Dakota, and after playing the phone game he just got sick of them and switched companies. Both companies had full time policies, but seemed like someone didn't know what they were doing. So due to poor customer support, they lost a loyal customer they had since he was a teenager driving, making payments on time, good record, etc. I guess some things are easier to switch though, just deciding to shop somewhere else or pay your money to another company and get a new proof of insurance card. While say switching phone or computer operating systems might be more difficult, especially if you like or rely on apps not available on the other platform.

So something I think about, and would worry me about having my own startup, as I feel like support is key from the training, processes to the people. As the people they interact with is representing the company. Wouldn't surprise me if you get big enough, there's consultants too but it's a fear of getting this area wrong. Ideally things should work in the first place though. Plus I think doing things in house, who knows your products might be better than outsourcing. One call could be for company A, next call could be company B, etc so they are just jumping around and might not even be familiar with products.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by not_a_cop75 on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:57AM (#21312971)
This is why you should generally:

1) Review all negative ratings prior to a purchase

2) Refuse to buy anything that's less then 4/5 stars.

Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by dpark on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:02AM (#21313050)
This doesn’t help if a single bad actor is co-mingling with multiple good sellers.
Re:Amazon is shipping expired food, customers say by ryan-c on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:31PM (#21316251)
They commingle reviews for multiple "related" products too.