News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by Multicomp on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:10AM (#21280431)
I've never used fingerprint scanners for paranoid reasons as this, so this gives me both some undeserved smugness and renewed paranoia.

Are long pins and passwords still the most secure way to control access to your phone? Is there U2F for phones as a 2nd factor?

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by DCKing on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:37AM (#21280606)
Long pins and passwords make you a lot more susceptible to casual attackers, as they can be gotten from shoulder surfing and casual video, like e.g. surveillance footage.

Fingerprint replicas (or your actual fingers) are obtainable by targeted attackers of some sophistication. But if you're targeted by attackers willing to go that length for you, you have other problems. IMO, fingerprints provide the best practical security.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by benj111 on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:47AM (#21280652)
Ultimately its a device you're carrying around with you, if someone wants access they're probably going to get it, all you're aiming to stop is chance opportunists.

Pin, fingerprint reader (that works) is enough.

Btw, I don't think 'casual attackers' really fits with access to, and willingness to go through cctv.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by dillonmckay on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:49AM (#21280657)
Only one of those can unlock your phone while you are unconscious, or with a body part that has been removed.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by zimpenfish on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:02AM (#21280739)
If someone is going to go to the lengths of cutting off your finger to get into your phone, I would suggest you're screwed anyway because they seem like the kind of people who'd chop off your/your wife/your children's fingers to get you to unlock it if you had a passphrase anyway.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by whack on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:21AM (#21280848)
Consider someone robbing you in a dark alley. They just want your phone and to disable any security alarms/tracking that may exist in the phone. They certainly have no motivation to cut off your finger, but now you've given them one

Consider also a roommate or someone you've recently started seeing. They can very easily unlock your phone by using your finger while you're asleep. They could shoulder-surf as well, but you can be vigilant against that. It's almost impossible to be vigilant against someone grabbing your finger while sleeping

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by tzs on Thursday October 17, 2019 @04:22PM (#21285996)
> It's almost impossible to be vigilant against someone grabbing your finger while sleeping

I believe most phones have a way to easily disable fingerprint or face unlock until the next time the pass code is entered.

For example, on recent iPhones, just hold both the power button and one of volume buttons down for a couple seconds, which brings up the screen for power off, medical ID, and emergency SOS. Hit cancel on that screen, and biometrics are disabled until you next enter the pass code.

It should be reasonably possible to be vigilant enough to do that before going to sleep.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by sjwright on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:00AM (#21281070)
There's no value to a robber of unlocking an iPhone with a fingerprint. Unless the phone is dissociated with an iCloud account (which requires entering the user's Apple ID and password) it's useless for anything other than for spare parts.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by lotsofpulp on Thursday October 17, 2019 @09:04AM (#21281558)
There is if you’ve allowed touchID for bank accounts and have ability to transfer money. Also, it could happen if you’re a heavy sleeper or passed out drunk.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by zelos on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:41AM (#21280950)
Over here (UK) at least, I think a lot of phone thefts are done by people on mopeds who grab phones out of peoples hands while they're using them, so the phone is already unlocked.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by rypskar on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:23AM (#21281231)
>> or with a body part that has been removed

If I remember the order correctly: One of the first attacks on finger print readers was to blow on them, making them read the remains on the previous fingerprint used. That was fixed by adding a temperature sensor to the reader, so to attack it you had to use a plastic bag with water at around human temperature. The easy fix was to also check for a pulse while reading the fingerprint, this also make it impossible to use a removed body part.

I have not kept up with the progress in the last years, so not sure how good creating a fake fingerprint that you put on top of your own prints work, like they do in movies. Finding and reproducing a print is not that hard.

As others have written, fingerprint are usernames. It is not secret and you can not change it

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by smcl on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:51AM (#21280674)
Those would be the "attackers willing to go that length" the person was referring to. If these are the adversaries you want to defend against, your solution is even simpler - don't store such secrets on your phone. Also maybe hire a bodyguard.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by scarface74 on Thursday October 17, 2019 @10:03AM (#21282133)
If those are your adversaries, they are going to use rubber hose decryption.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by melcor on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:54AM (#21280683)
If someone have lifted your pin/password, they can very much unlock your phone while you are unconscious.

IMO a combination of bio-metric and pin/password/phrase would be a good solution.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by kmlx on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:53AM (#21280682)
"or with a body part that has been removed"

wow. in what line of business do you work if you don't mind me asking?

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by dillonmckay on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:24AM (#21280867)
Technology.

;)

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by wongarsu on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:42AM (#21280955)
Just stealing your drinking glass to get a good print to replicate seems to be almost as reliable as detaching body parts, with much less mess.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by mikestew on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:52AM (#21280678)
Is that more of a day-to-day problem for you than shoulder surfing? I ask because I used to have a drinking problem, too.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by zelos on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:25AM (#21280872)
The kind of criminal prepared to knock you unconcious or remove a thumb is pretty rare.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by HeWhoLurksLate on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:10AM (#21281139)
I'd say finger removal is a few steps less likely than knocking someone unconscious, esp. if you can knock them unconscious and then clone their fingerprint.

Mind you, there are some quite dumb criminals, so "likely probability" besides "how likely am I to get robbed?" likely goes out the window.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by lotsofpulp on Thursday October 17, 2019 @09:10AM (#21281622)
There’s quite a few people that knock themselves out with drugs like alcohol.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by wjoe on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:01AM (#21280733)
Fingerprints were never supposed to replace passwords, they're more analogous to usernames.

I like fingerprint scanner as a quick way to unlock my phone, it's at least more secure than the 4 digit passcodes or patterns I used before that, and more convenient than that or face recognition. But I wouldn't want to use fingerprint to replace entering a password for making payments or accessing any secure data.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by dsr_ on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:53AM (#21281034)
Vehemently agreeing with you. Fingerprints are identification, not authentication or authorization.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by sokoloff on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:39AM (#21281370)
Genuine question: in what way are fingerprints not authentication? (to a ~1:500K uncertainty)
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by consp on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:46AM (#21281426)
A few issues:

First of all because they cannot be revoked. Unless you count cutting tools and torches. Just as well as they can be easily used without the user's consent (e.g. sleeping) without them being aware of it. Note: this does not require stealing anything as in the passphrase case.

Additional problems are the high false positive rate.

They just identify the user, not an action of authentication/authorization; i.e. a mental action like remembering a password and actively approving something.

See it this way: Your bank card identifies you, you pin number authorizes the payment. These are distinct differences. If you ignore authorization you get nfc payments which are very convenient but far less secure and easier to manipulate. Note: your pin can be revoked, your fingerprint can't.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by tialaramex on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:06AM (#21280766)
U2F doesn't feel like a natural fit for securing a phone because the core "factor" in U2F is "Something you have" and well, you "have" the phone too already. The fingerprints are "Something you are" but as we see _implementation_ may be lacking. So as you realise that leaves requiring a passphrase, "Something you know".

It's awkward, but I think if you care about security that's still really the most practical solid option. Fingerprints were only ever "better than nothing" here and should not have been sold as more than that (Biometrics _can_ be very secure but they need human supervision, e.g. when police take a DNA sample you can't give them somebody else's DNA but nobody is supervising you when you press what may or may not be your actual finger up against the sensor on a stolen phone).

I have a passphrase and a relatively short screen timeout for my phone, it certainly is less convenient than most people's zero authentication strategy, I noticed this when my closest place to buy groceries announced I could use the phone instead of needing a cashier.

For a regular person you just wander around, bagging anything you want and scanning it with the phone, then obviously you pay at the end. But for any time I spent more than 30 seconds or so browsing the phone locked and I needed to re-enter my passphrase to scan an item, cumbersome. There are tweaks I could do to let the scanning app stay active when the screen locks, but ultimately I just won't bother, there are hand scanners for people who don't have a phone or don't want to use it like me. I'll only use the phone if I pop in to get a single item so that unlocking the phone is faster than swiping to get a scanner.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by Ayesh on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:30AM (#21280892)
I switched to my first Fingerprint phone a year ago, and I can't imagine going back to passcode unlocking for convenience reasons.

Which is the most secure? It depends on the threat model. With an NFC sensor, I suppose it should be possible to unlock a phone from a physical key, but is it really convenient?

The only downside of a fingerprint is that there is no key rotating. If your fingerprint pattern is compromised, you are screwed. This doesn't have to be a security vuln in the device itself. A determined attacker can take your fingerprints off the screen surface or back fit eh phone.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by fulafel on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:25AM (#21280873)
It hardly counts as paranoia, the gummy bears trick is so old hat and it's obvious you have no effective assurance of keeping the prints safe.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by OJFord on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:12AM (#21280449)
You can use NFC or USB Yubikeys etc.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by andimm on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:21AM (#21280500)
I know Yubkeys can be used as a second factor for apps but can you use them to unlock a phone aswell?
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by eumoria on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:39AM (#21280614)
Yubikeys can do FIDO along with storing a static complex password. I know android phones can lock with a password so it seems possible but it would be extremely clunky to have to plug in your key every time you unlock your phone.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by carstenhag on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:52AM (#21280675)
Also sorta silly, because you are going to have to carry it with your phone anyway.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by wongarsu on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:48AM (#21280996)
In the scenario "I forgot my phone and now it's gone" the Yubikey offers perfect security, because I'm unlikely to loose both my phone and my keyring with my YubiKey (that assessment might not hold for a woman with a handbag). In any targeted attack it's useless.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by tialaramex on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:26AM (#21281256)
But if you need the FIDO key to use the phone you actually are likely to lose both at once, surely?
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by OJFord on Thursday October 17, 2019 @04:20PM (#21285981)
Only as likely as you are to lose your phone at the same time as your keys today, which as GP says depends on your habits / how you carry them.

It's not perfect, (and my Yubikey doesn't support it so I don't do it) but what is?

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by tialaramex on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:26PM (#21286909)
> Only as likely as you are to lose your phone at the same time as your keys today

This makes no sense and I struggle to even comprehend how somebody could come to this conclusion.

Before: I take my phone out, I unlock it, I look at something on the phone, then I get distracted, I leave it on a bar, a desk, somebody's refrigerator, wherever.

Now: I take my phone out. I need the FIDO key to unlock it, so I get that out too, I unlock the phone, I look at something on the phone, and then I get distracted and this time leave both the FIDO key and the phone in the same exact place, because of course I do I was using them both when I was distracted.

Can at least one of the people who seems so sure that somehow this wouldn't alter how often they lose the two items they now need together explain their thinking? Do you just... lose things randomly like maybe you have a gaping hole in your pocket and things fall out but you've never bothered to repair it? How are you losing things so that it somehow doesn't matter whether they're used together?

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by OJFord on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:29PM (#21286936)
> Now: I take my phone out. I need the FIDO key to unlock it, so I get that out too, I unlock the phone, I look at something on the phone, and then I get distracted and this time leave both the FIDO key and the phone in the same exact place, because of course I do I was using them both when I was distracted.

If I had an NFC one what I imagine doing is just pulling my phone out of one pocket and tapping it against the other, where my keys are.

I suppose if I was going to plug it in I could do that today (albeit with a USB-C adapter) but I don't because, the security point you mention aside, it's a usability nightmare (even if I didn't need an adapter).

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by jcadam on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:54AM (#21280685)
I don't use fingerprint readers because they don't freaking work for me.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by fullstop on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:54AM (#21281038)
Do you have fingers?
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by jcadam on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:08PM (#21286795)
yes
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by isodude on Thursday October 17, 2019 @06:58AM (#21280715)
The best is to have a secret phone like secure folder or private space. Thus you are protected even if someone makes you unlock the phone.
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by HeWhoLurksLate on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:15AM (#21281172)
Like a full second phone? Easily noticeable via Wireshark.

Like a folder? Probably noticeable with a utility like WinDirStat.

Like a separate user? Can the other one install apps? If so, you're likely done for if someone gets access to the one account. Also there's this [1] to consider, as well.

I hate shooting privacy ideas down. Unfortunately, that's all I have to contribute this time.

[1] https://xkcd.com/1200/

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by isodude on Friday October 18, 2019 @03:36AM (#21289379)
Well depends I guess.

After using it I like the idea with Huawei Private Space. You need to unlock the phone with a different biometric/password to get notifications even. So separate storage / user / app store.

Samsung Knox is a bit more seamless, you can choose how much you share (like copy & paste).

In case you are made to do it both can fool goverment to accept that you phone is clean with the correct setup.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by Lucadg on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:00AM (#21280724)
Could you elaborate?
Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by isodude on Friday October 18, 2019 @03:31AM (#21289354)
Huawei Private Space Use another password to unlock the private space. Samsung Knox (secure folder) App hidden as a normal app (can be renamed as something completely normal)

Both have separated contacts / app store etc and are separated with support from the hardware.

Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone by ivix on Thursday October 17, 2019 @10:30AM (#21282441)
Samsung Knox for example. Defence in depth.