Re:Samsung: Anyone's thumbprint can unlock Galaxy S10 phone
by tialaramex on Thursday October 17, 2019 @07:06AM
(#21280766)
U2F doesn't feel like a natural fit for securing a phone because the core "factor" in U2F is "Something you have" and well, you "have" the phone too already. The fingerprints are "Something you are" but as we see _implementation_ may be lacking. So as you realise that leaves requiring a passphrase, "Something you know".
It's awkward, but I think if you care about security that's still really the most practical solid option. Fingerprints were only ever "better than nothing" here and should not have been sold as more than that (Biometrics _can_ be very secure but they need human supervision, e.g. when police take a DNA sample you can't give them somebody else's DNA but nobody is supervising you when you press what may or may not be your actual finger up against the sensor on a stolen phone).
I have a passphrase and a relatively short screen timeout for my phone, it certainly is less convenient than most people's zero authentication strategy, I noticed this when my closest place to buy groceries announced I could use the phone instead of needing a cashier.
For a regular person you just wander around, bagging anything you want and scanning it with the phone, then obviously you pay at the end. But for any time I spent more than 30 seconds or so browsing the phone locked and I needed to re-enter my passphrase to scan an item, cumbersome. There are tweaks I could do to let the scanning app stay active when the screen locks, but ultimately I just won't bother, there are hand scanners for people who don't have a phone or don't want to use it like me. I'll only use the phone if I pop in to get a single item so that unlocking the phone is faster than swiping to get a scanner.
It's awkward, but I think if you care about security that's still really the most practical solid option. Fingerprints were only ever "better than nothing" here and should not have been sold as more than that (Biometrics _can_ be very secure but they need human supervision, e.g. when police take a DNA sample you can't give them somebody else's DNA but nobody is supervising you when you press what may or may not be your actual finger up against the sensor on a stolen phone).
I have a passphrase and a relatively short screen timeout for my phone, it certainly is less convenient than most people's zero authentication strategy, I noticed this when my closest place to buy groceries announced I could use the phone instead of needing a cashier.
For a regular person you just wander around, bagging anything you want and scanning it with the phone, then obviously you pay at the end. But for any time I spent more than 30 seconds or so browsing the phone locked and I needed to re-enter my passphrase to scan an item, cumbersome. There are tweaks I could do to let the scanning app stay active when the screen locks, but ultimately I just won't bother, there are hand scanners for people who don't have a phone or don't want to use it like me. I'll only use the phone if I pop in to get a single item so that unlocking the phone is faster than swiping to get a scanner.