News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aeternum on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:56PM (#21276936)
Wasteful compared to what though? How much energy, human capital, and resources are consumed by the banking industry?

If (and big if) bitcoin is able to replace a significant fraction of the banking industry it will be extremely efficient in comparison. Per-transaction measures isn't the right metric since the Bitcoin blockchain can still be successful as a reconciliation backbone without being used for small everyday purchases.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by roywiggins on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:00PM (#21276971)
> Per-transaction measures isn't the right metric since the Bitcoin blockchain can still be successful as a reconciliation backbone without being used for small everyday purchases.

This idea has been around the corner for a while now. How likely is it really, how long will it take, and what will adoption look like? Until it happens and is popular, it seems fair to discuss how much a Bitcoin transaction actually costs...

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aeternum on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:05PM (#21277017)
It's up and running now: https://bitcoinvisuals.com/lightning
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:50PM (#21277418)
Too bad lightning network requires bitcoin at the on and off ramps to function. Those transactions alone would kill bitcoins pathetic transaction rate if the ecosystem ever took off.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by bitcurious on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:10PM (#21277071)
Here's an apples and oranges comparison.

According to the article, bitcoin consumes about the same amount of electrical energy as Austria, a nation of 8,857,960.

According to Bureau of Labor Statistics, ~8.6 million people are employed in "Financial activities" in the US.

BLS: https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/employment-by-major-industry-...

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by skywhopper on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:11PM (#21277082)
I mean, the article lays out the energy costs of competing transaction processors. But if Bitcoin is just a clearinghouse for large-scale reconciliation, then... who is the audience exactly? Large banks that have to operate using real money under actual governmental regulation have no use for Bitcoin's naive guarantees, which pretend that the court system and human ambiguity don't exist.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by dragontamer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:58PM (#21276948)
> Wasteful compared to what though? How much energy, human capital, and resources are consumed by the banking industry?

The article actually answers this to some degree. See the following graphic: https://i.imgur.com/8TdKevG.png

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aeternum on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:03PM (#21276998)
As others have commented, per-transaction is a very misleading metric. Hashing difficulty is based on the number of other miners and time between blocks, not based on the number of transactions.

With something like lightning network, a single Bitcoin transaction can facilitate millions of 'lightning' transactions.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by dragontamer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:16PM (#21277120)
> As others have commented, per-transaction is a very misleading metric.

Can you name a better metric that we can measure?

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by baddox on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:23PM (#21277172)
Well, what do you actually care about? Why choose, for instance, cost per transaction instead of, say, cost per USD (or equivalent) transferred?
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by dragontamer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:27PM (#21277209)
I like cost of electricity. While Chinese plants are subsidizing the BTC network right now, we can estimate the cost of "unsubsidized" BTC in the future based off of electricity costs today.

--------

With regard to the Lightning Network, it seems that it requires a bit of supervision to be secure. https://themoneymongers.com/lightning-network-watchtowers/

That supervision probably will have a cost of some kind.

> You can hire watchtowers nodes for a fee and design the revocation transaction in such a way that the watchtowers will also receive their service fee when you get funds of the other party as a penalty.

So we're adding many, many more middlemen to the picture. Not only do we have to pay for the final transaction (which requires a large amount of electricity to be "mined" into the blockchain), we have to hire watchtowers to ensure that our Lightning Network transactions remain correct even if our counterparty tries to screw with our transaction history. (Remember: the full transaction history in the Lightning network is off-chain).

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aeternum on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:52PM (#21277432)
It should be possible to build watchtowers into the protocol itself. A lightning node could elect some number of random nodes as watchtowers at bootup, similar to how many clients now elect random channels.

Being a watchtower is extremely low cost, it only requires a small amount of memory. Every full lightning node is watching the blockchain anyway so it is easy to watch for some extra transaction ids with a certain prefix. Transaction IDs are sufficiently long that only part of the txn ID (half) needs to be shared with the watchtower. The tower can only decrypt and send the revocation txn once the malicious txn is broadcast, and the watchtower reward can be built in to the revocation txn.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by dragontamer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:00PM (#21277506)
> watchtower reward can be built in to the revocation txn.

How much will watchtower rewards cost?

The economics aren't fully studied. But I'd expect a good watchtower would be proportional to the amount of the transaction. That is, if you wanted to protect a 100 BTC transaction, you'd want to spend more on the watchtower reward than if you wanted to protect a 1 BTC transaction.

Hypothetically, if you spend too little, the watchtower + your opponent can collude to effectively steal some of your money. (Ex: the Watchtower could be paid by your opponent to NOT send the revocation message).

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aeternum on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:26PM (#21277701)
The reward can still be low because you can choose many watchtowers. If you have a high value channel, you could choose for example hundreds of watchtowers. Only the first one to broadcast the revocation would get the reward.

The reward only has to be high enough for it to be worthwhile for other nodes to spend a small amount of memory storing your txn.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by dragontamer on Thursday October 17, 2019 @11:51AM (#21283324)
What's the point of being a watchtower if only one watchtower gets the reward?

In the case of 100x watchtowers watching one transaction, each watchtower only has a 1% chance of actually getting the reward.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aeternum on Thursday October 17, 2019 @01:56PM (#21284640)
It's true, I believe the low probability of getting the reward is the greatest flaw with the watchtower reward scheme. Not just if you have many watchtowers, but the likelihood of a peer attempting a channel breach in the first place esp. when watchtowers are in place would be extremely low since that peer is almost certainly assured to lose money.

There are some services currently providing watchtower for a flat fee instead, and the going rate is low (1 satoshi / txn watched) =~ $ 0.00008

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by WillPostForFood on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:03PM (#21276994)
How much energy to mine an ounce of gold?
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by jcranmer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:27PM (#21278397)
Since gold bullion isn't legal currency anywhere, I'm not sure it's the most relevant comparison.

From the US Mint's financial statement [1]:

2017 cost $13.5 million dollars in "Communications, utilities, and misc charges", which presumably is the bucket that electricity bills falls under. There's no breakdown of overhead between currency coinage production and bullion/numismatic production, but the manufacturing obligation suggests that currency is roughly ⅕ of their total costs, which suggests that we might ascribe about $3 million in utility cost to produce coinage. The coins themselves were worth about $870 million, which suggests about 250 kJ (or 0.07 kWh) per $1 of coinage if we assume the Mint pays $0.05/kWh. I'm not including the energy cost of metal production itself, because I don't want to spend the time to track down that information.

[1] https://www.treasury.gov/about/budget-performance/CJ19/23.%2...

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by Erlich_Bachman on Thursday October 17, 2019 @09:04AM (#21281554)
> Since gold bullion isn't legal currency anywhere

Neither is Bitcoin, so it should be a perfectly valid comparison?

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by ctdonath on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:35PM (#21277762)
This is a good relevant question. Both are easily verified, impossible to duplicate, convenient value density, and (!) production correlates to increase of total world economic value.

As such, the question is interesting: how much energy required to produce one new ounce of gold? vs one bitcoin?

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by easymodex on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:29PM (#21277226)
Why is this getting downvoted, I'm curious as well.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by dragontamer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:31PM (#21277248)
I don't think any modern currency is really using Gold these days. The cost of creating dollars is basically the cost of the Fed signing a few papers. A lot of modern currency is fully virtual.

So I don't think "mining gold" is an appropriate analogy.

EDIT: Case in point: how much did it cost for Visa + Bank to increase a credit-card from $500 credit limit to $2000 credit limit? $1500 of credit appeared out of thin air.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by cwkoss on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:59PM (#21277493)
I think your Edit example actually points to the root of the issue with these comparisons.

The first credit limit increase "from scratch" costs hundreds of billions of dollars in creating a system of legal compliance, accounting, communication, internal and external risk management, executive compensation, regulatory oversight, credit ratings, cybersecurity, salaries of millions of workers, building public trust in the credit system, writing and passing legislation, even Fed responsibility of building and maintaining a fiat currency.

The second credit limit increase once this system exists is essentially free.

To what extent do these costs need to be accounted for in creating an accurately comparable 'per transaction' metric? By replacing much of the logic with 'just math', Bitcoin has the potential for a much higher theoretical efficiency than the current banking system. Whether market penetration will ever reach the current banking systems levels - and function without replicating these same structures - is certainly highly debatable and for many of the above items implausible.

Bitcoin transactions in isolation are also essentially free - it's the maintenance of the system which keeps it secure and trustworthy that is expensive.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by jayd16 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:56PM (#21277468)
This is a different metric akin to mining a bitcoin. Making a transaction with gold can be carbon neutral, it would seem to me.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by KirinDave on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:40PM (#21277799)
Bitcoin physically cannot scale to replace any substantial portion of the financial industry. That is a primary design feature of proof of work systems.

It's this wasteful at this level of scaling. That only gets worse.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by shsjxjbsbs on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:58PM (#21276945)
There’s no indication I’m aware of that Bitcoin is removing any labor or equipment from the banking system. So far all I’ve seen is traditional banking layering crypto on top.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by leppr on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:43PM (#21278480)
There's nothing fundamental about this state of affairs. We're simply early in the adoption curve: the network of services around fiat is larger than the one around cryptocurrency, so to use cryptocurrency effectively you have to connect with fiat.

The infrastructure required for functional cryptocurrency usage in society is far smaller than for traditional money, so with enough adoption to supersede fiat, there would be efficiency gains.

Remember, we used to need the phone network to connect to the internet. 30 years later, the trend is reversed and it's telephone that we layer on top of the internet.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by iopq on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:31PM (#21277247)
it's cheaper to transfer Bitcoin and immediately convert to fiat than to do a wire transfer from overseas. Then you're using the home banking system like ACH in the US and SEPA in Europe

Wires cost me $50+ because of intermediary banks, even if I don't pay anything at my own bank, someone is getting a big cut.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by shsjxjbsbs on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:37PM (#21277296)
Don’t companies like TransferWise already do international payments electronically without the need for a blockchain? I definitely support lowering the amount of human labor required for payments, but I don’t see the need for many coal plants worth of computers randomly hashing a bunch of junk over and over again when a normal efficient server can do it.

Every bitcoin exchange I’ve used required me to physically write something on paper and show it to a human, so it seems like the human labor in the banking system is a regulatory issue, not a technical one.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by iopq on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:51PM (#21277426)
Maybe to sign up, but to actually make trades it's just taking orders off the book.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by shsjxjbsbs on Friday October 18, 2019 @03:40PM (#21294474)
Sure, but why do I need a blockchain for that? Can’t the service trusted by the government to enforce KYC regulation also run a normal commodity server to process transactions, without burning the earth?
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by stordoff on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:38PM (#21278722)
> Every bitcoin exchange I’ve used required me to physically write something on paper and show it to a human

I'm curious - what did you have to write? Is it just part of proof of identity, or something more?

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by leppr on Thursday October 17, 2019 @01:08AM (#21279078)
Usually the date and name of the exchange, to comply with "Know Your Customer" regulations and fight duplicate accounts.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:52PM (#21277442)
It is only cheaper today because the price of those traditional transfers are set artificially high. Make no mistake if banks had real competition for inter-bank transfers you’d see the price drop to near zero.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by leppr on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:42PM (#21278199)
It's not just the banking industry that trustless cryptocurrencies can do without, but also the whole infrastructure necessary to maintain the value and trust in fiat money.

This encompasses a very large part of the responsibilities of the political system, army, secret service, ...

Those cost centers can't be ignored if the goal is an honest comparison between the energy efficiency of bitcoin vs. fiat.