News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @01:38PM (#21261287)
Amazon is a slightly annoying company that I rarely root for, but Oracle is a predatory company whose customer relations strategy seems to actively involve litigating them as a default assumption.

Amazon is considered a paragon of IT, so their expulsion of Oracle is a useful tool at the CIO/CTO level of "nobody ever got fired for IBM" level of reasoning.

Unfortunately, AWS is becoming the new IBM in that reasoning. Great that it took ten years to reach that level of agreement, now hybrid cloud needs to take over the grey haired CIO / CTO level.

Long live Postgresql!

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by gopalv on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:08PM (#21261683)
> Amazon is a slightly annoying company that I rarely root for, but Oracle is a predatory company

Amazon and Oracle couldn't be more different in this point of view.

Amazon's predatory instincts are pointed inwards and downwards, towards employees and vendors, while being mostly great towards the customer.

Everything from their warehouse workers with timers, the crying software engineers and all other things I hear about them are about running an internally facing extraction economy.

The squeeze is being put on those who draw a paycheck (or at least, a profit) from Amazon, while the consumers see instant access servers on EC2, Amazon Go for lunch breaks in a city or One hour shipping of diapers.

In comparison, Oracle seems to be going after those who pay them already.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:35PM (#21263430)
I’m an engineer now at Amazon. I’ve been here 7 years. 5 years ago, our culture was far more toxic. More recently, some orgs are horrible places to work and others are much better. I don’t think we’re much worse than other companies. Our pay for engineers is less than Google and Facebook, as far as I know, but we beat other companies such as MSFT.

Amazon naturally attracts people who want to accomplish big things. It just happens that many of these folks are assholes.

Is Amazon predatory to its employees? Some organizations are - yeah absolutely. Are we worse than other companies I worked prior to Amazon? No. Does that mean it’s okay? No. I’m just saying there’s a public perception of Amazon being at the deepest level of hell and it’s not true.

We absolutely burn people out. We overwork employees. We don’t promote them when we should. We try to find the tiniest bit pick reasons not to promote. We practice stupidity and call it frugality? You’re an engineer making $200K total comp a year? Your computer doesn’t work and is crashing? Oh too bad - we won’t replace it for you. Yeah I mean that kind of fucking stupidity.

We encourage everyone to automate their role so we can replace those folks with college hires.

Amazon is not a place you can have a long career at. You’ll have to jump teams or orgs every couple years and eventually you’ll get tired enough that you learn to manage upwards yourself and stick with a manager that you can manage.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:05PM (#21265000)
Sooooo.... it's not toxic anymore, but you still need to hop teams like crazy or they kick you to the curb?

Your description sounds like my friends who worked there or just left, they were used for 2-4 years and then nitpicked to deny the deferred compensation stock. It's a rolling scam! But so is the rest of the new economy.

I'd hate to know what it was like before.

Interesting that you said "it's being fixed" traces right around the time the various worker stories went viral. And yet you and several other people say "it's not bad!".

I get there's no stats and its all anecdotal and situational, but the very experience of being hired is terrible. Even though I had friends there, I never bothered interviewing. Why waste two days?

At least google has free food. I'd waste an interview with them.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by VRay on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:04PM (#21271886)
It was basically as that guy described when I was there through 2015, but it really wasn't that bad. I saved enough money in the bank to quit and live off it for 6 months, and after that it was less like an oppressive life and more like a game I was playing.

I'll tell you what was REALLY stressful: Trying to find my first engineering job after graduating from college. It took almost 9 months, and I ended up in a really shitty low-paying internship. The whole time bills I couldn't pay kept piling up, and my best friend in the world (my cat) ended up passing away partly because I couldn't afford to pay for any more surgeries after putting thousands of dollars' worth on my card.

If you can land a job at Amazon, though, congratulations: You've made it. You can get a programming job anywhere in the world and make money in the 95th+ percentile. You've got health benefits, a 401k plan, life insurance, etc. If you ever get so burned out that you're crying at your desk, just quit your job, sell your shit, break your lease, and backpack around the world for a year. (Or go get a laughably easy ~$100k/year job out in the Midwest)

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by trustfundbaby on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:43PM (#21263506)
> Amazon naturally attracts people who want to accomplish big things. It just happens that many of these folks are assholes.

You could probably just replace "Amazon" with "Silicon Valley"

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:47PM (#21263550)
I mean - I haven’t worked at any other large tech company so I don’t have any data point to make that claim.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by hef19898 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @04:23AM (#21268218)
While I won't go as far as calling it a scam (as one comment did below), I can to a certain degree confirm what you said. Also, is it bad? Yes. Worse than other places? No, simply more open and direct about it. Personally, I prefer the openess about it. And from a company perspective, it works out pretty well, doesn't it? All that is for the office workers and managers. Warehouse workers are different.

At least for Germany I know that Amazon is paying above average salaries for them (compared to DHL and others). And generally speaking warehouse workers, and all other rank and file logistics workers, are treated like drones. Again, nothing special about Amazon. But that doesn't mean the situation should be accepted.

All that being said, Amazon is a great place to learn and gain a shit load of experience. On all levels, even if there is a hard ceiling for blue collar workers to get promoted to white collar positions these promotions do happen regularly. The blue collar worker still has to suck up to a manager, so. In other places I know these promotions do never happen. The most important thing to have in mind when working for Amazon is, IMHO, to work on a feasible exit strategy from day one. Because long careers are the exception to the rule there. Oh, and be aware that it is a tough place to work at. Of you are om with that, go for it. Otherwise, stay away.

One last comment, one I learned the hard way. If you are not really comfortable with the way Amazon can treat people, even if you do what you can to make a difference there, you will be part of the problem simply by pushing forward and going a good job delivering high quality results. The one cannot be had without the other. Personally, I am not sure how I see Amazon, pretty peculiar place.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by haltingproblem on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:26AM (#21267028)
You (and other Amazon) employees keep saying orgs/organizations while talking about Amazon vs. Google vs. FB vs. .... I was confused and after reading for a bit I realized you mean divisions within Amazon.

That might appear to be a valid distinction, to an outsider it appears less material. Perhaps you can start by describing how the culture varies within Amazon.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:37PM (#21272332)
Amazons internal organizations all have slightly different culture, although there’s a core set of company values (Leadership Principles) that keep us bounded together.

Within Amazon, some places will absolutely grind engineers with nightmare on call rotations, untenable deadlines or deliverable dates, etc. but these things are part of any job depending on your company. What really sets Amazon apart is the brutal honesty - if you’re not performing or meeting someone’s expectation, regardless of how reasonable or unreasonable it is - you will get called out, sometimes in front of colleagues.

Over time, you learn there’s ways of influencing people or motivating them to be at their best. One such way is running a cut throat organization where people end up blaming others to save themselves - sometimes because it is the other person who dropped the ball - other times because that’s how you preserve yourself.

As a business model, this actually works. Running a cut throat organization where people are terrified to go out of line out of fear of losing their jobs - it has worked at Amazon at scale.

But to be clear - not all of Amazon is like this. I’ve been lucky to bounce between really great teams during my 7 years at this company. I’ve had one bad manager who didn’t know how to manage and honestly wasn’t qualified for his role. I’ve met people who legitimately helped me grow and become a better engineer and mentor to others. I’ve gone through two promotions. I’m paid really well.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by deegles on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:25AM (#21271393)
Is the AMZN 401k match still garbage? I remember it was a max of 2% paid out in stock with a 2 year vest.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:29PM (#21272229)
401K match is garbage but salaries are decent. I’d say we’ve gotten far more competitive in pay, and that’s not even counting the crazy stock appreciation over the past several years. In terms of overall benefits, we aren’t competitive - which makes sense considering Amazon isn’t a cash printing machine like FB or Google. We genuinely don’t have the money to spend unless Bezos was to deliberately sell $1 billion each year for Amazon corporate benefits. That itself is a fuzzy proposition - how do you give benefits to these corporate badges while squeezing warehouse workers? If you do something, it should benefit everyone.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @03:11PM (#21274216)
I though salaries were capped at 150k or something. Which is good, don't get me wrong... but a lot of the other FAANGs beat that easily?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @04:12PM (#21274957)
Salaries are capped at $160 but salaries are a part of your total comp. Most of my compensation comes from stock not salary, and my salary is maxed.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by wolco on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:16PM (#21264546)
Most places are not like this. Imagine getting respect and $200k?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by whack on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:08PM (#21263120)
> Amazon's predatory instincts are pointed inwards and downwards, towards employees and vendors... the crying software engineers and all other things I hear about them are about running an internally facing extraction economy... The squeeze is being put on those who draw a paycheck (or at least, a profit) from Amazon

I know 10+ software engineers at Amazon, including people in their early 30s making close to half-a-million in yearly income, and people working 10-6 M-F. Most of them are very happy with their careers, and I don't know a single person who describes their work-life the way you just did.

I'm not disputing that horror stories exist and that some people are being given bad reviews and are being managed out. However, there is a severe disconnect between the median Amazon employee's experience, and public perception.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by freehunter on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:09PM (#21264487)
It's the same way with my company. In the rare situation I see my employer mentioned on HN, I can't even bother reading the comment. It's all so overwhelmingly negative. Not just on the management, but on the employees as well. HN's perception of the company who signs my paychecks is so wildly different from my own perspective as an employee there that I have a hard time believing anyone on HN who talks about a negative work experience at Company X or Company Y.

If the consensus for my company is so wrong, the consensus on every company is highly suspect.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by philwelch on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:24PM (#21266781)
HN isn’t even bad as far as Internet forums go, but the longer you work in the field, the more and more obvious it becomes that Internet forums are generally full of shit.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by technofiend on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:42PM (#21264799)
:fistbump: I never bother to mention my employer because when I used to post job openings on Reddit I'd get vilified for even trying.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by kbenson on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @08:40PM (#21265821)
> However, there is a severe disconnect between the median Amazon employee's experience, and public perception.

Not to get into whether Amazon employees have it good or bad, but using the software engineers to explain the median Amazon employee's experience seems a bit odd. Given that Amazon is widely reported to have well over half a million employees now, and I doubt the software engineers are anywhere near the majority, using them as an example to support the claim that the median employee is not what the public expects doesn't make a lot of sense.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by scarface74 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:34PM (#21266831)
In that case, should we not count how badly Foxconn workers who manufacturer Apple’s phones have it? While technically they aren’t Apple employees, that’s a distinction without a moral difference. Would the same people who are criticizing how Amazon treats “its” employees change, if Amazon contracted out all of its warehouse workers? Somewhere in every tech company’s supply chain there are some blue collar workers that aren’t treated as well as the white collar workers.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by kbenson on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @01:35AM (#21267355)
> In that case, should we not count how badly Foxconn workers who manufacturer Apple’s phones have it?

First, we do. There's been plenty of stories and Apple has gotten a lot of flak about Foxconn. Rightly so.

Second, I really have no idea why you're bringing outsourced companies into this. Amazon is actually employing massive amounts of people. According to a recent NYT article[1], "Amazon had 653,300 employees around the world at the end of June, not including temporary workers and contractors." What's the point of trying to inflate the number when Amazon is already one of the largest employers in the world?

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by wp381640 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @02:51AM (#21267744)
Would you prefer Amazon outsource their warehouse operation staffing or hire them direct and pay them $15 an hour?

Seems people would gripe either way

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by kbenson on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @03:53AM (#21268052)
> Would you prefer Amazon outsource their warehouse operation staffing or hire them direct and pay them $15 an hour?

Nothing I said had anything to do with that... I specifically started my comment with "Not to get into whether Amazon employees have it good or bad" to avoid that conversation, since I don't think I have enough facts to weigh in usefully. My comment was about statistics.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by tw04 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:43PM (#21266860)
Then we can include the same foxconn (or insert odm) employees that build echo devices and Amazon still ends up in the bottom of the barrel relatively speaking.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by scarface74 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:58PM (#21266924)
Yes. Every tech company outsources the dirty work. Facebook even outsources the mentally draining work of monitoring videos for child porn and violence. None of the large tech companies are innocent. We just put more emphasis on struggling factory workers in America than the conditions of people in other countries that “work for” them.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by jjeaff on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:22PM (#21266764)
Ya, when I read that comment, I thought of the warehouse workers. And I don't think many could argue that they have it so great.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by whack on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:57PM (#21272599)
To be precise, I meant to say the median software engineer at Amazon. My parent comment had called out "crying software engineers" and anyone who draws a paycheck from Amazon, and I was responding in that context.

I'll be honest and admit that I'm not sure what working experiences are like for the warehouse/delivery guys. However, neither does the person I'm responding to. Given how completely wrong they are in describing the median tech worker's experience, they have no credibility when it comes to warehouse workers either.

With 500,000+ employees, you can write an entire book of horror stories at Amazon, and you could still be describing only the outliers. You really can't form any judgements without using random-sampling techniques or mass-employee surveys.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by tvontheradio99 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:12PM (#21271996)
I'm coming up on five years, and I can tell you that the negative shit spewed in this thread is nothing I've experienced at Amazon. Is it possible some people have experienced these things, even in the last 1-5 years? Yes, it is possible. Just telling you that my experience has not been like this at all.

As with every company, which manager you have and which organization you are in makes ALL THE DIFFERENCE. Are there people here I wouldn't want to report to? You bet. Is my manager one of them? No. I even switched teams to continue reporting to my manager after they moved to a new role.

I feel compelled to say that I am in no way a shill for Amazon and have never been for any company where I've worked (I've worked in tech companies for a few decades now). When my friends complain to me about how awful Amazon is, I cringe hard and do my best to remain balanced in how I view their feedback. Some of the stories I've read and heard about other people's experiences (especially in fulfillment centers) have been super discouraging and made a lot of us angry. Hey, why don't you quit working there in protest? I've worked in a few other major companies, and I can tell you that all of them have done awful shit that made me want to quit in protest--unfortunately, quitting in protest doesn't pay the mortgage.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by a_imho on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @03:38AM (#21267995)
I know 10+ software engineers at Amazon, including people in their early 30s making close to half-a-million in yearly income

What do these people do?

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by VRay on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:20PM (#21272105)
I can confirm that Amazon is a stressful place so far as tech jobs go, and I saw a lot of the abusive bullshit people are talking about in this thread.

BUT I can also say that it rolled right off my back and had little effect on my friends who are still there after 5+ years

The key is to have enough savings that you don't feel like you're trapped there, IMO. And to have some real world perspective. If you've ever experienced real deal poverty then you'll laugh off anything a toxic management chain can throw at you.

I'd definitely recommend leaving Amazon ASAP in any case though, unless you're some sort of hardcore ladder-climbing business shark. I got super screwed by a lack of bonuses and raises despite being a "top performer", and it sounds like that's the norm rather than the exception.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by dangus on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:05AM (#21269890)
Right? “Well the C-levels think the company is great! No problems here!”
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by zapita on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:33AM (#21267062)
Do you know many Amazon warehouse workers?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by tvontheradio99 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @03:35PM (#21274548)
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by senderista on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:08PM (#21263115)
Great for the customer? Not so much these days. I would happily trade my 2-day shipping for a no-counterfeit/safety guarantee.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by sokoloff on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @05:28PM (#21264026)
I have gotten two counterfeit items from Amazon (that I know of, of course). In both cases, A2Z took care of the problem without fuss on my end. (One with a full refund-don't even send it back; the other with "send it back on us or keep it at half price".)

Would I prefer a genuine article assurance? In general, yes. Would I prefer that over a wide selection of products and range of delivery services? Probably not.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by TwoHeadedBeast on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:48PM (#21264864)
I ordered some lightbulbs with the wrong fitting by mistake. Amazon refunded me and told me to keep them, even though it was entirely my fault.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by wolco on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:16PM (#21264551)
That you know of.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by bartread on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @02:33AM (#21267658)
This is salient: there are some items where I'm confident I could distinguish real from fake, but there are many more where I'm not. And returns/refunds or not, it's a hassle I can live without.

For anything outside of books/music/movies/video games I nowadays mostly use other retailers, and generally those that specialise in that kind of item.

I recently bought some shelves from Amazon that aren't as described and getting a return and refund has turned into a complete shitshow. Totally fed up of Amazon.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by BookmarkSaver on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:31PM (#21261981)
>the crying software engineers

Just like to point out that that NYT hit piece didn't actually interview any software engineers IIRC.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:17PM (#21262518)
Amazon IT employees are carrot-dangles a rolling set of future stock and other money, but as it stands now almost every new hire won't see that money. Amazon will get what they can out of them, and then mark them underperforming and fire them before it pays out any money.

Some of the best people I know that have gone to work there have been subjected to this.

After cycles of this, the only way to survive is to backstab and move up in management.

Amazon/AWS really shows this in it's core web sites and console, which are really backwards and show no signs of improvement or evolution, because all the people that built it have been fired by now or moved on.

Microsoft originally thrived on this, but eventually the culture collapses into backstabbing and the worst breed of middle management Machiavellis, and any productivity is new bolt-on products.

So IMO Bezos built a fundamentally good infrastructure ten years ago that is fuelling Amazon's continued growth, but if anyone fundamentally improves in some way that Amazon would need to fundamentally change the company it will be impossible.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AStellersSeaCow on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:26AM (#21267030)
I'm at Amazon now, my team is fairly shitty - let's say in the bottom third of engineering teams anyone at the company would want to work for - and the average tenure of people on the team is close to 5 years.

It's hard to get fired as a college hire. It happens, but only if you're pretty lazy or a fuckup or a mis-hire to begin with. I've seen vanishingly few cases where someone was managed out at a time that it denied them stock vests, and only once that it was even mentioned (then by an exceptionally petty manager).

To be perfectly clear: working at Amazon sucks for plenty of reasons, some of them covered in this thread. Compensation is not commensurate with the quality of engineer you have to be to work there, the company is disgustingly cheap in general, many teams are drowning in tech debt (the original post's cheerleading aside, half my org is still suffering from the slapdash way the Oracle migration was sped through to meet arbitrary internal deadlines), and the fraction of managers interested in building petty fiefdoms rather than interesting or good tech is increasing at an alarming rate. But anyone who thinks it's a huddled mass of sobbing husks with PTSD is overstating it.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by the_reformation on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:52PM (#21262920)
Absolutely incorrect. I worked there for 3 years, saw one person fired, and everybody who joined with me ended up vesting their shares. Most got promoted too.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by senderista on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:16PM (#21263214)
Shortly after I joined my team, everyone above SDE2 left and were replaced by college hires. There was literally no one around who knew anything about the original project.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by hef19898 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @04:31AM (#21268254)
Could be related to the stock development. My personal theory is that everyone who was hired around 2014 turned out to incredibly expensive, Amazon seemed to be surprised by the stock going about almost tenfold in the next 4 years. That alone made it really hard for that generation of hire to stick around, of the people I know who joined with me at that time I only know of two who were still there (out of a dozen) in early 2018. That ratio is a lot higher for those who joined before or after 2015. Not that I would complain so, including RSUs my last pay turned out to more almost three times what other companies in the same region pay.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:09PM (#21265033)
When was that, roughly?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by earthshot on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:26AM (#21267032)
This comment doesn't hold up to scrutiny if you know how Amazon comp works. A standard SDE package is something like this:

year 1: $X cash + $Y cash bonus (vests daily) + $Z RSUs (vest at end of year), where approximately 95% of the comp is cash.

year 2: $x cash + $Y cash bonus (vests daily) + $Z RSUs (vest at end of year) where approximately 90% of the comp is cash. Likely a few percent more than year 1 in total comp.

years 3 and 4: $x cash + $Y RSUs (vests semi-annually for most) where the RSUs make up a meaningful part of the comp. Likely a few percent more than year 2 in total comp.

Given that comp structure, it is essentially impossible to do what AtlasBarfed has suggested, as people get paid quite quickly.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by senderista on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:12PM (#21263175)
The console sucks because it's done by the individual back-end service teams who have no idea about UX or front-end coding, and don't coordinate with each other or any cross-service owners of the console.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:07PM (#21265019)
AWS makes... how much?

And won't invest in basic stuff like that?

Their CLI is irritating too.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @09:27PM (#21266123)
You might hate the console or CLI tools, but people at Amazon have real data telling them the CX is good enough and their capital would be better spent investing in other features. Source: I work there. :P
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by jjoonathan on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @09:37PM (#21266192)
Yeah, we know you've got us locked in. The steaming piles served up in the console still taste like shit.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @10:59PM (#21266651)
What’s your problem domain? You shouldn’t be locked into AWS. No offense, but sounds like bad design or more generally, you or your engineers don’t know what they’re doing.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by jjoonathan on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @01:40PM (#21273072)
As a percentage of offerings, how much of the AWS portfolio is portable between clouds? 5%? 1%?

Of course we could re-write on a different cloud, just like Amazon can move off Oracle, but it would take time and we would put up with a lot of abuse before it happened, just like Amazon no doubt did with Oracle.

Which is what you were just bragging about: your numbers show that your customers are locked in enough that you can abuse them plenty before they can effectively retaliate.

Congrats.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @04:11PM (#21274940)
You didn’t answer my question and deflected, only responding with personal attacks. Nice.

I still think that your notion of intentional vendor lock in is misinformed at best and poor design and architecting from your side (at worst). I do happen to work at Amazon but my post history will show you how critical I am of the company.

But nothing you’re saying is valid, and I don’t see any parallel here with the migration from Oracle. If you’ve used Oracle DB or have familiarity with its one off special “features”, there’s no parallel between that and using something like RDS or Dynamo. RDS is replaceable. Dynamo is a key value store first and foremost.

There are also enough third party abstractions that let provide you their own configuration and syntax for spinning up resources on AWS, Azure, GCP, etc or mix and match.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @05:24PM (#21275935)
That was a personal attack? Um, no.

DynamoDB is not directly portable, Cassandra is closest, and it's a bear to roll your own. Are you an Amazon employee outright telling people to not use the fundamental datastore of AWS?

S3 also is fairly proprietary, are you, an Amazon employee, outright telling people to not use the fundamental file storage of AWS?

I could go on, obviously.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:38PM (#21277305)
You just wrote that I’m abusing customers and then say it’s not an attack.

S3 is blob storage. Dynamo is a key value store with support for additional indexes. Neither technologies are particularly novel today or provide specific features that would lock you in. You could use comparable technologies on Azure or Google Cloud. Like I said before, you can’t blame Amazon or any cloud provider for poor design/architecting on your end.

Your questions are written as sarcastic personal attacks, which you write instead of posting something of more substance. It seems like you’re just trying to incite a response from me aka trolling. I won’t engage with you anymore. Good luck.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by thefreeman on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @10:36PM (#21266517)
if you are using the console to manage your infrastructure you're doing it wrong
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by zer00eyz on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:13AM (#21266979)
You answered the questions on exactly what is wrong with the console...
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by throwaway981211 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:25PM (#21272173)
How so? Op is correct - you shouldn’t be using the console to actively manage your infrastructure. The consoles primary purpose is to let you quickly spin up resources while you explore. If you have a real business use case, all your infrastructure should be defined in configuration and deployed out to AWS. That way, you always know what you need to spin up and it’s exact, specific configuration, all stored in source control.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by zer00eyz on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:42PM (#21272403)
Because when you do that nothing ever needs tweaked on the fly? Because issues of load and scale aren't often times emergent?

I am not making an argument against what you are saying. I am saying that a common interface between the two would be the sane and rational decision. It should be trivial to use the console and turn that back into your new behavior for committing back to your repository.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @05:28PM (#21275979)
"The consoles primary purpose is to let you quickly spin up resources while you explore."

And it's pretty bad at this.

I'm not saying the interfaces are the worst ever invented, just that they are a step above internal enterprise software, and despite the fact that AWS makes almost 8 BILLION DOLLARS there appears to be less that 1/1000th of that revenue invested in improving it.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by redblacktree on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @10:43PM (#21266558)
It's fine for experimenting, but I agree in general.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by carc on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:17PM (#21263230)
Just wanted to say this is completely inconsistent with almost all people I know who work/have worked at Amazon as developers
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by dabit3 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:08PM (#21263114)
100% not true in my experience, but can't speak for any org other than the one I work in (which has been by far the best job, team, and management I've ever worked with).
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by Tsarbomb on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:06PM (#21262401)
I walked away from taking a job there after I had a "peer lunch" with the team I would be working and found out it was mostly vacant due to firings and departures for "performance reasons".

Any place that can lay off a significant majority of a team has issues.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by kitten_mittens_ on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:36PM (#21262046)
I did leave the company after the article came out because of how it jived with my experience.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by philwelch on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:28PM (#21266797)
The NYT hit piece came out when I worked at AMZN. I was honestly shocked and surprised at how the company was described because it didn’t match my experience nor those of anyone I knew there. It was the first time I’ve personally experienced Gell-Mann amnesia, except I didn’t forget.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by dkersten on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:04AM (#21269453)
> while being mostly great towards the customer.

I know you only said "mostly", but I find their product comingling to be very bad for the consumer and products in general on Amazon.com seem to be a lot worse now. If we're specifically talking about AWS, I'm not anti-AWS and do use them, but lets be honest here: they are very expensive, especially for bandwidth, and their pricing models are definitely not consumer friendly. I find it very hard to determine ahead of time how much my bill will be.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by LordFast on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @09:49PM (#21266253)
Thanks for putting this so succinctly into words that I've struggled to find for the past few years without rambling on and on.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by Wistar on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:00PM (#21261585)
Back in the early days of Oxygen Media I remember the then CTO saying that Oracle's pricing model appeared to him to be based on turning the customer upside down to empty all of the money from their pockets.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by baq on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:04PM (#21261621)
And the final invoice would be for $30k more...
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by Justsignedup on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:44PM (#21262159)
Next up: oracle sues Amazon for not using their product.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by philjohn on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:00PM (#21262342)
I wonder if their latency and performance claims in this blog post fall foul of Oracle's "No publishing benchmark results against our competitors".
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by umvi on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:51PM (#21262910)
What? How could that be legal? You can't say "Comparisons with competitors are not allowed" under a free market... right?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by philjohn on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:03PM (#21263036)
If it's in the contract not a lot you can do ... https://www.brentozar.com/archive/2018/05/the-dewitt-clause-...
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by alexis_fr on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:36PM (#21263439)
Atlassian Jira’s license, section 3.2:

« (h) use the Software for competitive analysis or to build competitive products; (i) publicly disseminate information regarding the performance of the Software; or (j) encourage or assist any third party to do any of the foregoing. »

https://www.atlassian.com/legal/software-license-agreement

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by rhinoceraptor on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @10:01PM (#21266323)
Am I permitted to say that Jira is a bloated, festering slug of a web app?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by tcarn on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @11:43PM (#21266859)
Your doorbell is ringing, I would answer it. It’s the police, with a warrant.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by marcosdumay on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:36PM (#21263437)
Every non-free database management system has this clause.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by james_s_tayler on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @10:13PM (#21266401)
Because Oracle started it back in the day when they got a negative review in a benchmark test.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by BubRoss on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:24PM (#21264627)
Maybe now that their contract has expired it doesn't matter.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:11PM (#21265066)
How much of Oracle runs on AWS? And how many of those customers are evaluating Aurora?

Mwahahaha!

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by cardingggg on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @09:26PM (#21266121)
Well, Aurora _is_ the fastest growing AWS service, sooooo.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by philjohn on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:00PM (#21262337)
Also, kudos to them for not just cutting loose the DBAs who have a lot of institutional knowledge and training them to be consultants on AWS data storage services both internally and externally.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by outworlder on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @01:56PM (#21261520)
> whose customer relations strategy seems to actively involve litigating them as a default assumption

They are not nice to their partners either.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by golergka on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:26PM (#21262616)
Isn't AWS much less prone to customer lock-in? May be I don't have experience with tweaking AWS under heavy high load, but 98% of code I write for backend that I host on Amazon isn't specific to AWS or it's services in any way.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by hiram112 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:03PM (#21263043)
Not exactly. If you stick to EC2 or containers with general Linux for your servers, and RDS Postgres and Mysql for DBs, and similarly for other services, you supposedly would be able to move to another cloud without issue.

We thought we'd be okay.

But when AWS started getting too expensive and we began looking to migrate, we discovered that there was a lot of 'glue' in our stack using bits and pieces of AWS-specific services. A continuous integration was using S3 buckets and Lambda, a few clever devOps guys had found ways to create alarms with SNS and SQS.

So while 90% of it was just a matter of moving to general CentOS containers on another platform and spinning up new Postgres and MySql and Mongo instances, that 10% of AWS specific code still causes issues that had to be remedied.

If I were in charge of a large infrastructure on AWS, the first thing I'd do is absolutely lock down every service that wasn't explicitly whitelisted, and open them as needed. Not wait till half your operation depends on dozens of AWS services that, while make things easy initially, lock you in to their platform.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:16PM (#21265109)
THere needs to be a broad abstraction toolset to enable hybrid cloud.

The ones that should be 100% motivated to develop these tools (the Apache ones are ... meh, and terraform/ansible/config management always gets hard-wired to your cloud) are obviously Google and others that are also-rans.

Google might not be doing it to keep Amazon out of their roadhouse.

There's still meta-tooling for admin and management that are hard to abstract, but come on. K8s is the opportunity to do this, and also serverless to a lesser degree.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by epiphanitus on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @01:55AM (#21267458)
Impractical thought experiment: Leaving the capital expenditures for the data centers aside, what would it take to build an OS clone of AWS?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by xchaotic on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:10AM (#21268769)
That doesn’t make sense a lot of what AWS provides is services such as cloud front at scale. You’d still need to test at scale so infrastructure and experience at scale is part of what makes AWS successful and profitable
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by bdcravens on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:55PM (#21262953)
You can architect an agnostic solution there, but AWS messaging is firmly aimed at lock-in.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by scarface74 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @05:32PM (#21264070)
And when you do “architect an agnostic solution” you now have the worse of both worlds. You’re spending more on hardware than bare metal and you’re spending just as much on management and development time”.

Just because AWS spent years both creating an alternative to Oracle and millions migrating, doesn’t mean that your company is.

No matter how often some bushy tailed developer tells the CTO that they used the “repository pattern and standard sql”, they aren’t going to move away from their six figure+ Oracle installation. The risk of regressions are too high and the benefits are usually not worth it.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by golergka on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:23PM (#21276643)
Can you please explain how exactly am I having worse of both worlds here? Not trying to prove you wrong, genuinely curious: if I have a generic NodeJS app with PotgreSQL hosted in RDS and, say, use AWS-specific services like S3 and Cloudwatch, am I doing something wrong?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by scarface74 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:15PM (#21278626)
No. I’m saying just the opposite.

You see patterns like this from “architects” who want to avoid “lockin”:

- A DBFactory that creates an instance of an OracleRepository that they access through an IGenericRepository interface just in case later on they decide to use a different database and then they don’t take advantage of any Oracle specific features for fear of “lock in”.

- A StorageManagerFactory that you call to create a S3StorageManager that implements an IStorageManager just in case later they decide to move from S3 they can “migrate easily”

You’ll find people who will spin up a bunch of EC2 instances and host their own logging, queueing, messaging servers to avoid using AWS specific services. Now they are spending more for hosting than just going to a colo and spending just as many man hours babysitting infrastructure.

I’m saying that once you choose your foundational infrastructure pieces, no matter what they are, it usually makes sense to go all in instead of creating layers of abstraction.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by bdcravens on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:36PM (#21265314)
I was responding to the parent comment, which said nothing about Oracle or any specific implementation.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by scarface74 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:42PM (#21265363)
I’m more responding to the sentiment of “avoiding lock in”, at a certain scale, you’re always “locked into” to your architectural choices where it doesn’t make sense to spend the time or effort to try to avoid it.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by jrockway on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:41PM (#21262801)
Most people are not using generic services on AWS, preferring the Amazon-proprietary things like CloudFormation to open source things like Kubernetes.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by nostrebored on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:28PM (#21264671)
This is a strange comparison. Cloud provider IaC offerings like Cloud Formation are obviously going to be specific to their service. AWS also has EKS for Kubernetes.

Things listed as lock in with AWS usually have easy migration paths. E.g. DynamoDB integrates with Database migration service and Lambda functions are easy enough to expose by shifting code to dedicated servers.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by jrockway on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:04AM (#21268733)
I don't think it's a strange comparison. Cloud providers offer a combination of services that do lock you in and don't lock you in. If you are using EC2 and SSH in to screw around with Linux, you are going to be fine if you get a better deal from GCP. If all of your deployments are managed by a CloudFormation stack and custom scripts that speak the AWS API, you are never going to be able to move. (This is not unique to AWS, of course! Everyone has their value-adds.)

A lot of the lock-in is historical. Before there was Kubernetes, there was ECS. I am sure a lot of people embraced containerization and not managing individual machines early, and are now stuck on Amazon's proprietary platform.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by rayiner on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @06:04PM (#21264450)
I don’t think most people would view the companies that way. Amazon is taking on mom & pops, warehouse employees, etc. Oracle might be super aggressive, but their targets are generally larger businesses and often huge corporations that are perfectly capable of taking care of themselves.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by chrisdhoover on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:10PM (#21265038)
Peoplesoft was not big enough to withstand Oracle.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by scarface74 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @05:26PM (#21264012)
Unless your company is going to spend years and millions of dollars to create their own OLAP database product for their own internal use knowing that they can then charge customer $4.80 an hour for a usable system, Amazon isn’t a useful model for any other IT organization.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by JacKTrocinskI on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:46PM (#21262191)
How is Oracle predatory? PostgreSQL is great for web developers and small businesses but in terms of support, security, and enterprise features I think Oracle has PostgreSQL beat. I have been an Oracle database developer for the last five years, they have a great database, not sure what all the hate on HN is about.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by NikolaNovak on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:00PM (#21262341)
I believe the "HN hate" is more on the accounting/contract side, rather than strict technology side.

It's the canonical enterprise vendor on the database side (DB2 has far smaller market share, and SQL Server market play is slightly different), so it's the poster child for anything from no two customers paying the same price for same metrics, to opaqueness and perceived unfairness of the contracts, to seemingly predatory fees, to ambiguous and frequently awful licensing on virtual CPUs, to the various shakedowns and so on.

I'm not saying others in the same market are markedly different; but just like IBM is the HN poster child for a "no longer relevant tech dinosaur", Oracle is the HN poster child for "predatory licensing & fees".

(* Note/disclosure, I have the distinct privilege of being happily employed by one to reasonably happily work on the products of the other :-D )

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by Ensorceled on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @02:54PM (#21262268)
It's not about Oracle the db product, it's about Oracle the company. Why did you think everyone was saying the "Oracle database is predatory", that makes no sense.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by JacKTrocinskI on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:11PM (#21262455)
That is fair, when I enter an HN post I automatically think of HN as hosting technical discussions, not business, and that is why I decided to look at the technical side.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by bdcravens on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @04:02PM (#21263035)
Looking at the front page now (and virtually any time), there's quite a few articles that are more of a business or a political bend than technical.

A quick search of "Oracle" from the homepage search (only in the last year, since your account isn't much older than that), shows most articles are non-technical in nature.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastYear&page=0&prefix=tru...

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by czep on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @05:14PM (#21263866)
> Why did you think everyone was saying the "Oracle database is predatory", that makes no sense.

A case could be made that the database itself is predatory, insofar as Oracle encourages use of non-standard functions that make migration to an alternative very difficult.

10 years ago (at Amazon in fact) was the last time I used Oracle and I've never felt any desire to use it again. I wasted far too much of my working life fixing queries that used the silly outer join operator (+) or debugging proprietary functions that already had a perfectly good ANSI alternative.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by scarface74 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @05:33PM (#21264084)
Every database has non standard functions, syntax, and behaviors.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @07:19PM (#21265145)
I'm sorry your comment has been blasted to oblivion. There really is that level of Oracle hate out there. There's no way my top level comment should be 100+ upvotes, it's a pretty vanilla opinion. But man people hate oracle...

In reality, your experience as a dev might not be that bad from within the ecosystem.

But take the hate for what it is: learn portable tooling, be aware of the proprietary bindings, and architect to be more database agnostic.

It may save your job if the budget cuts are between ludicrous oracle licensing and auditing costs, or your salary.

Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by privateSFacct on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:01PM (#21262356)
They constantly sue their own customers - why in the world would you want to do business with someone who will then sue you?
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by rhinoceraptor on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:33PM (#21262707)
We hate Oracle because they're a deeply unethical rent-seeking company.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by xchaotic on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:00AM (#21269038)
As opposed to which Silicon Valley company? Rent seeking is the holy grail of every SaaS company and even the large faangs and Uber and WeWork etc.
Re:Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database by rhinoceraptor on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:18PM (#21277132)
Those other companies at least serve some other nominal, societally engaged goal, besides making money.