News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Friday October 11, 2019 @08:54PM (#21229749)
Let's assume for a moment that we did find something resembling simple organic life on Mars and confirmed that earth isn't the only life bearing planet. What functionally changes for our existential understanding of the universe? I'd argue little to nothing. We'd learn a bit more about organic life, but no fundamental philosophical or existential questions would be resolved. Life has been confirmed to be able to thrive in many more extreme places here on earth than anywhere observed on Mars. There wouldn't be any firm resolution on the question of whether humans are the only intelligent species in the universe.

I think that would be a different answer if we found inorganic life, as that would blow up the concept of organic life as singular in "life" bearing capability. I doubt we would recognize inorganic life as "life" in that case however, as humanity has a poor working definition of "life."

Absent a recognizably intelligent form of life found off planet, I doubt much would change (practically or existentially) for us here on earth.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by evil-olive on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:45PM (#21230012)
> no fundamental philosophical or existential questions would be resolved

If you don't consider "does life exist on other planets?" to be a fundamental, existential question, can you share an example of what you do think is such a fundamental question?

Finding life on Mars wouldn't necessarily resolve any fundamental questions, but it would open up a whole new realm of questions. Is it similar to life on Earth? How similar? Is there evidence for or against some form of panspermia? (at its most extreme, life arriving on Earth from outside the solar system, but this could also be life arising on Earth and being transported to Mars via impact ejecta, or vice versa)

Also, lots of worthwhile science is done even though it doesn't have an immediate and obvious impact on everyday life. I can't think of any particular way in which the discovery of gravitational waves has changed my life, for example - but I recognize that the work that's gone into it has advanced human knowledge, and probably will indirectly benefit my life (or my descendants' lives) in ways I can't predict.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:12PM (#21230150)
Sure:

Is the concept of objective meaning valid in any possible universe?

Is it possible for the universe to be a fully observed deterministic system?

Is there a universal objective function motivating what we consider reality?

Is it possible to determine with certainty the origins of what we can conceptualize as reality?

Is it possible to forecast with mathematical certainty events in future time steps.

Basically just off the top of my head my questions boil down to: Can laplaces demon actually exist, is there a resolution to the munchausen trilemma and is godels incompleteness theorem disprovable.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by not_kurt_godel on Saturday October 12, 2019 @03:06AM (#21231172)
> is godels incompleteness theorem disprovable

Do you actually understand its proof? On what basis would it be disproven? It's really difficult for me to even conceive of what disproving it would even "mean" - you seem to think that it's somehow tied to whether the universe is deterministic, but it's not. A "disproof" would essentially break the very logical tools used to construct itself (since it is the nature of these that Godel's theorem concerns); it's like trying to drive further north than the north pole - there simply isn't a conceptual direction to go unless you completely redefine the meaning of "north".

Edit: Also, Laplace's demon has likely been formally proven to be impossible: https://phys.org/news/2018-05-proof-reveals-fundamental-limi... Perhaps your apparent belief in Laplace's Demon combined with the comparison of this proof to Godel's Theorem is your motivation to suggest that it can be disproven?

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Saturday October 12, 2019 @11:21AM (#21233818)
I agree with you that any progress in these areas would include breaking pretty much everything we "know." That's kind of the point though, current epistemology and computability questions basically stop with these irreducable theories. So we live with this irreducable uncertainty currently.

I'm not proposing solutions or saying that there are errors with these proofs. Rather, when I finally understood them years ago it induced an existential crisis that I don't see any pathways to resolve.

My hypothesis is that humans aren't capable of conceptualizing experiments or building tools that could approach the three most intractable problems in epistemilogy. Maybe we don't have the math to do it, or it's fundamentally intractable and it will never be resolved, I dunno. But those are much more interesting questions than "is there an amoeba on europa?"

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by not_kurt_godel on Saturday October 12, 2019 @03:09PM (#21235473)
I think you'd probably be interested in Gerard 't Hooft's latest work: https://arxiv.org/abs/1405.1548 It's rather, shall we say, controversial (that is: widely rejected by his peers), but it's an attempt to construct a framework through which the laws of the universe can be interpreted as deterministic which leverages the sorts of epistemological concepts you seem to be interested in.

(That being said: I personally find "is there an amoeba on Europa?" to be supremely interesting, but to each their own.)

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Saturday October 12, 2019 @03:44PM (#21235701)
Thanks for this, I'll definitely take a look. My concern always, as you point out, is falling into crackpottery territory. Hopefully being acutely aware of that serves as an inoculation to some degree.

I should also state, I certainly find the concept of life on other planets extremely fascinating. However as I said above its insufficient to give clarity to some of the more fundamentally existential questions around our existence.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by not_kurt_godel on Saturday October 12, 2019 @03:53PM (#21235752)
I should also mention - there is quite a bit of discussion on 't Hooft's work on StackOverflow, including heavy participation by 't Hooft himself. I don't have any pointers handy, but they should be fairly easy to discover with a minimal amount of searching.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by erichocean on Saturday October 12, 2019 @02:29PM (#21235164)
I don’t accept non-constructive proofs that require “constructions” as being valid. (Diagonalization is another invalid technique in my book.)

So there’s at least one of us.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by JasonFruit on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:44PM (#21230281)
Wow, you're really smart! I'm glad you're here to discuss things with us.

That being said, for most people who aren't operating on your level, the fundamental existential questions haven't changed much in a few hundred years. "Are we alone in the universe?" is probably among the newest for us.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:55PM (#21230326)
I'm assuming you're being sarcastic. If so it's unfortunate that just answering honestly warrants such hostility.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by kdmccormick on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:53PM (#21230536)
To say what I think JasonFruit is trying to say, but with less condescension:

Your questions are valid and really interesting, but that doesn't make the questions of "Do other planets have life?" and "Where did life on Earth originate?" invalid or uninteresting. Personally I'm interested in all of them.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by The_rationalist on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:19AM (#21231929)
Do other planets have life? Is a ridiculous question to ask, it is epistemologically one of the weakest hypothesis possible given the scale of the universe and the non singularity of what make earth the earth.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by JackFr on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:06AM (#21230600)
Well sure, I take your point. We live, we die. Science tells us how it all happens, but can never tell us why it happens at all.

And yet despite the certainty of death, we, individually and as a group, seem to have an unquenchable desire to know more. To know is to grow, and this collection of processes we call life has never been seen off the planet so yeah, it'd be quite some growth.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by joshmarlow on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:20PM (#21229881)
If the life evolved independently of life on earth (ie, no panspermia or anything like that), then it would have philosophical/existential implications because of the Great Filter Hypothesis - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter.

Edit for a TL;DR - The basic idea is that, if we don't see evidence of intelligent life in the universe, it must be because star traveling species must be rare. If we find life evolving twice in one solar system, then the early parts of life evolving must be relatively easy - which suggests the later parts of life becoming technologically advanced are the hard parts. In other words, life on Mars may mean that there may be more problems ahead of us than behind us.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:49PM (#21230028)
If it were organic, we would not know if that life evolved independently from life on earth though. So, again finding non-intelligent organic life elsewhere doesn't answer the question of where did we come from.

Simply verifying distance between two similar things isn't a sufficient variable to answer questions about distinctiveness of origin.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by CardenB on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:07PM (#21230126)
Not necessarily. It just suggests the bottleneck for life lies at whatever point is after mars. Nothing would suggest that complex life gets progressively more difficult to evolve.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by ALittleLight on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:09AM (#21230613)
Right now there are a few places for the great filter. To my knowledge:

1. Life

2. Multicellular life

3. Intelligent life

4. Interstellar colonization tech

If you make it through all levels you should be colonizing the galaxy and detectable by us therefore.

Finding life with a separate origin than ours removes one of the possible spots for the great filter and makes it significantly more likely that the great filter is ahead of us rather than behind.

This is a question that will help with the survival of humanity.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by cabalamat on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:18PM (#21229872)
> What functionally changes for our existential understanding of the universe? I'd argue little to nothing.

It depends on how different it is chemically form earth life. If it is similar enough that it shares a common origin, it's no big deal. If it isn't, then that's a massive deal because it means life originated twice in one solar system, therefore is probably widespread.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:50PM (#21230035)
Whats the common origin of organic life again?
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by monadgonad on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:04PM (#21230368)
That it originated on one planet and was sent to the other by ejecta, as mentioned in the article.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Saturday October 12, 2019 @11:54AM (#21234091)
That's a hypothesis... It's still totally speculative
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by NeedMoreTea on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:09PM (#21229830)
Presuming SpaceX pull off their plans, there will be trips to and from Mars. We'd better be pretty sure what microbes we're being exposed to or bringing back to Earth before we do.

Or we might get a repeat of when the Spanish brought disease to the Inca and Maya.

The mere knowledge of life is viable off-Earth is huge. If we find it on our nearest neighbour, the chances of encountering it elsewhere rise markedly. Hopefully it would trigger a search elsewhere in the solar system, like Europa.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by lovemenot on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:12PM (#21230151)
>> Or we might get a repeat of when the Spanish brought disease to the Inca and Maya.

Unlikely. There's been no animal hosts on Mars, in which such a micro-organism might have evolved to threaten humans on Earth.

Not to say we shouldn't be careful for other reasons though. The bigger risk is the sudden extinction of entirely different branches of life, by more highly-evolved Earth-originating species.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by TaylorAlexander on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:11PM (#21230395)
I think the other person is saying that Earth bacteria could potentially wipe out Martian bacteria if the conditions are right. And that would be tragic.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by NeedMoreTea on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:44AM (#21230937)
That was exactly my thought. We discover extraterrestrial life, and inadvertently wipe it out, or just swamp them with an invasive species, without getting a chance to study them before we mucked up their ecosystem. As you say it would be tragic, but also very typically human.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by defterGoose on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:08PM (#21229826)
I'd argue that the jump from 0 to 1 of "knowledge of life on other planets" would be huge. Currently, we have an almost pseudo-religious understanding of what place life holds in the universe, but that's based on the fact that when we've looked up at the cosmos for all of history, it seemed impossibly devoid of anything familiar. The discovery of life on another planet (even if that life somehow originated on Earth), turns the proposition of finding intelligent life elsewhere from at best a 50/50 question of belief into a near certainty. And that is huge.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by wallace_f on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:17PM (#21229868)
>we've looked up at the cosmos for all of history, it seemed impossibly devoid of anything

This is popularly misunderstood. We obviously don't see Type 3 civilizations, but if another of our own civilization was in our galaxy, we would have had an very small to extremely small chance of seeing it.

I'd wager life is everywhere, and just as is the case on earth, it pays, in terms of survival, to blend in with your surroundings.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by rgross1 on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:02PM (#21230101)
Disagree- folks outside of the sci-fi bubble won't appreciate microbes on other planets. 0 to 1 happens when we find multicellular organisms with cognitive capabilities IMO
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 12, 2019 @03:11AM (#21231193)
"Folks outside of the sci-fi bubble" rarely appdeciate much about non-monetary impacts of space. But discovering life - even alien life - would really shake up many big religions, which tend to assume we're special, unique creations. I'm sure religions would eventually evolve to accomodate the discovery in their belief systems, but it would get noticed by regular Joes and Janes.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by ksaj on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:53AM (#21230770)
Those come later, in the form of evolution. If we find the precursors alone, novel forms of single cell life still at that early stage, we can learn a whole lot about how multi-cellular life came about.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by gsich on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:55PM (#21230547)
Doesn't really matter.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by dleslie on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:06PM (#21229818)
> What functionally changes for our existential understanding of the universe?

The anthropic principal becomes less compelling; to say nothing of the religious implications.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by jacquesm on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:12PM (#21229843)
Religion will have absolutely no problem to adapt to new information and incorporate it as though it had always been there. This has happened time and again in the past to the point where the religions of old would have been in direct contradiction with even the most basic scientific knowledge if they didn't adapt. The funny thing is that the so-called holy books are full of stuff that no sane human would believe in. That doesn't stop a lot of people from doing just that when those books are creatively re-interpreted by intermediaries.

Religion will last for a very long time into the future, forget about major lasting change on that front other than some rearguard action to ensure survival.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by dleslie on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:04PM (#21230114)
I did not intend to state the implications are the end of religion; simply that many faithful will alter their faith, in no small manner.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by jacquesm on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:12PM (#21230152)
I highly doubt that. If the genetics, the silicon revolution, access to space imagery, quality education, the internet and science in general did not alter faith in a drastic way I don't think 'life on Mars' is going to do anything either unless it comes in the form of little green creatures.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by Jweb_Guru on Saturday October 12, 2019 @04:35AM (#21231525)
Yup. It's like how many religious people differentiate between "evolution" and "microevolution," with the latter (basically) encompassing whatever evolution happens to have been experimentally witnessed, no matter how drastic. Generally anything involving bacteria gets lumped into this latter category.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by dleslie on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:26PM (#21230211)
Curious that you don't recognize a significant shift in religious thought in the last century.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by jacquesm on Saturday October 12, 2019 @05:51AM (#21231816)
What shift would that be?

Until the 1970's or so it was getting better, since then it's gotten worse if anything.

On the Christian side we have whole continents that are following some cliff notes' version of Christianity, mostly centered around money and some opportunistic politics. On the Islamic side a small group of fanatics has managed to divide the world in a way that seemed unthinkable 25 years ago and so on.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by mindcrime on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:09PM (#21230387)
Nah... religious people don't depend on reason, logic, evidence, etc. They can (and will) always absorb any new discovery and incorporate it into their belief systems in such a way that it doesn't invalidate anything they already believe.

Some people think Christians would have a hard time with extra-Terran life because the Bible doesn't mention any life other than the life here, and therefore any such life would arguably be free from the weight of Original Sin, yada yada yada. But I'm pretty sure if life on another planet was discovered (even intelligent life) they would just reinterpret the Biblical references that seem to refer to "Earth" as referring to "The Universe" and make "The Garden of Eden" a metaphor, and the flaming sword would become a supernova, blah, etc., yada, blah, blah, blah. At the end of the day, approximately 0.0% of Christians would say "Hmm... the Bible is obviously incomplete and or inaccurate, so maybe the whole thing is a load of bollocks" or whatever. And I expect it would be about the same for every other faith.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by pfdietz on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:10PM (#21229834)
No, because the origin of life on Mars would probably be the same event as on Earth, with life having been transferred by impact ejecta. It would not allow us to conclude that origin of life was common.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by dleslie on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:05PM (#21230117)
Perhaps, or perhaps it's different enough that it most likely developed independently.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by pfdietz on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:17PM (#21230172)
In which case, why haven't we seen it already on Earth? Life will have been transferred back and forth between Earth and Mars for billions of years.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by trianglem on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:04PM (#21230110)
I read your whole post and all I can come up with is that if we found life of any sort on another planet it would completely change my internal narrative and I guarantee I'm not the only one. This would in a subtle or unsubtle way gradually influence literally most of the decisions we make on earth.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by kd5bjo on Saturday October 12, 2019 @02:28AM (#21231054)
> Life of any sort

Aside from the narrow one involving the oxidization of carbon, I have a hard time coming up with a definition of life that doesn’t consider storms, planets, or star systems “alive”. In particular, they are all time-limited phenomena that are organized but somewhat unpredictable at macro scale and chaotic at micro scale.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by philwelch on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:01AM (#21231853)
Most of them aren’t self-replicating.
Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by mindcrime on Friday October 11, 2019 @10:59PM (#21230349)
I think it's a shame that you're being downvoted for nothing more than expressing a reasonable, albeit apparently unpopular, opinion.

For plenty of us, AndrewKemendo is right... learning that there is life on Mars would not answer any particularly fundamental questions. Maybe because a lot of people simply take it as a given that life exists on other planets (whether or not Mars is one of them isn't really a big issue) because they don't have the hubris to believe that there's anything so special about Earth as to believe that life could only emerge here.

Frankly, you can count me in that crowd. I'd be more surprised if it was somehow proven that there isn't life anywhere else.

To me, "fundamental questions" would be more like:

1. Is free will possible? If so, how?

2. How did the universe begin? If there was a "Big Bang" as popularly described, where did all the matter come from that expanded out of the initial singularity? If time did not exist before the universe began, how did the transition from state "no universe" to state "universe" happen, since - presumably - nothing can "happen" without time.

3. What is time?

4. Is space discrete or continuous?

5. Is time discrete or continuous?

6. Are there multiple dimensions of time, analogous to the multiple dimensions of space we know about?

7. Is our "4-D" world actually embedded in a higher-dimensional reality of some sort that we can't access/understand/see/etc.?

8. Is our world a simulation (ala The Matrix)?

9. How, exactly, do fields (electromagnetic field / higgs field / etc) permeate all of space and permit the existence of particles like photons or the higgs boson?

10. Is there actually a way to unify gravity and quantum mechanics?

11. What is dark matter? Where did it come from?

12. How will the universe end? Big crunch? Big freeze? Big bounce? The simulation ends and we all just disappear? Other?

13. Why is there any matter at all in the universe? The fact that there is implies a certain fundamental asymmetry to the universe, since if matter and anti-matter were created in equal amounts at the beginning, they should have annihilated each other leaving no matter behind.

14. Why are right-handed people more common than left-handed people?

15. Why does the universe itself appear to have a "handedness" property[1]?

[1]: https://arxiv.org/pdf/0812.3437.pdf

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by AndrewKemendo on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:55PM (#21230543)
In fact these are the lines of questioning I'm most interested in and nearly none are resolved by the existence of other intellingent life, that is unless they are more intelligent.

I feel like this should be more pervasively held belief to a bunch of people with a higher than average propensity of consuming scifi. Star Trek did a pretty thorough job of showing that the same fundamental questions persist even if we assume there exist more intelligent species out there.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by anon234345566 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @11:18PM (#21238128)
But what would be the geopolitical effects of having found the ruins of an old datacenter, under the dust of a couple of millions of years, old hardware, looking like maybe 500 years more advanced than the state of the art on Earth.

You would know there's tech out there, the first able to reach to it will have the edge over the rest for centuries ahead.

The effects will be massive, no one dolar, yuan, yen, gold bar would be left unspent in the quest to get there and learn before the others.

Re:I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s by modzu on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:03PM (#21229803)
what? so would we have a common ancestor with this organic life (like all life on earth shares)? id think that has philosophical and existential implications