In 2001 Volvo released a concept car called the SCC (safety car concept) that had see through a pillars!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volvo_SCC
image: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ee/Goteborg...
A couple of weeks ago I was driving along a steep valley with constant winding hairpin turns for over an hour, and I'd never been more aware of the fact that the pillars prevented me from seeing any oncoming traffic whatsoever when curving (extremely) left, even if I craned my neck as far as I could to the right. The pillar just blocks it all out.
It was really disturbing to drive knowing you just can't see if there's oncoming traffic or not, and if they're in their lane or drifting into yours. You just have to hope and pray everybody's staying in their (narrow) lane.
Absolutely sucks from a safety and awareness perspective. I consider myself a really responsible and careful driver, and I hated being put in such a literally blind situation.
Apparently instead of just making the pillars thicker to satisfy rollover ratings like many manufacturers, they used some engineering and higher strength materials to reinforce it. (https://www.subaru.ca/WebPage.aspx?WebSiteID=282&WebPageID=2...)
My wife (unfortunately) has a Jeep Renegade. Every time I get in it I'm surprised she doesn't get in more accidents. Never mind the A/B pillars, the C pillar is like a solid foot and a half wide: https://st.motortrend.com/uploads/sites/10/2016/05/2016-jeep...
If you try and back out of somewhere at an angle you're backing out 100% blind.
There is a lot of concern over a lot of these auto-assist features reducing the engagement of a driver. It is a trade-off of course. An automated system with good sensors can react faster than a human driver to prevent some types of wrecks, but they do have limits. Over reliance can lead to the situation where that Tesla drove full speed into an exit ramp barrier.
Until ever street has guide rails and ever vehicle can attach to a track, truly safe autonomous vehicles are a very difficult problem and a long way off. A standard street track system would probably be cheaper honestly (and it's a solved problem).
Generally SUVs are the worst mix of properties you want from cars - center of gravity is too high (bad handling), rolling in case of accident is much easier to achieve, too heavy so pretty bad acceleration, more expensive maintenance (ie tyres, more oil, heavier taxation in many places etc.), more consumption because of the weight and crappy aerodynamics etc.
/end of SUV rant
The Model 3 ended up being a breath of fresh air for me in terms of visibility overall, it has dramatically better visibility compared to the Leaf, Accord, and Corolla I had been accustomed to driving.
I should note the Leaf has absolutely atrocious visibility and stands out as the worst I've encountered in a car.
I've not driven a Leaf or current Accord or Corolla. I find the rear 3/4 visibility out of the 3 to be TERRIBLE (rear deck is too high), same for rearward visibility in the mirror (can't even see the headlights of the car behind you). However, the forward visibility is AWESOME. I love the low dash.
In the Leaf I have the seat all the way back and bottomed out as low as it goes. At that position I can see forward just fine though at some traffic lights I do have to lean forward and lookup. However at that position my shoulder is still forward of the B pillar so when look left I have an obstructed over the shoulder view. Looking right isn't much better as the rear passenger window tapers upward so I can only see up and out, not down.
If the A pillars were narrow and not triangular, the side mirrors smaller and lower, and the rear windows didn't taper up but were just horizontal then it wouldn't bother me so much. As it stands, I just find myself bobbing and weaving a lot like I'm trying to find something I dropped under the kitchen table trying to look around a dozen chair legs.
Contrast that with the Model 3 where I also have the seat mostly back and bottomed out. The low hood and high ceiling give great elevation view and the narrower A pillars and smaller lower side mirrors offer much less obstruction. That combined with the glass roof gives a very open air feel to the car.
In the Model 3 my shoulder sits behind the B pillar so when I look left the pillar is in the middle of my FOV so my left eye can look out the rear driver side window. This is how it was in the last 3 Accords I owned and my partner's Corolla. When I look right out the passenger side the low window line that's mostly horizontal affords excellent visibility out the rear passenger window over my shoulder.
In the Leaf I'm occasionally surprised by cars, something I've not experienced with any other car or even truck that I've driven.
Keep in mind some of your behavioral changes are associated with you becoming a more experienced driver and learning just what sort of evil can lurk in curious places. As much as my car's blind spot irks me, there's no way it's as bad the 1979 Crown Vic I learned in.
Though I guess it could always be better, for me I'd personally prefer if they shifted the the hard panel further forward, trading some sunroof for rear window.. and of course there's the drivetrain which I'm sure is not your first pick.
For now, given the current limits of structural engineering, the only hardtop cars without B pillars are coupes.
[0]: http://cdntdreditorials.azureedge.net/cache/7/b/c/3/e/3/7bc3...
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Blind-Spot-Mirrors/b?node=491998903...
As someone who learned to ride a motorbike before driving a car, I got used to needing to know where everything is around you at all times (because you pay the price, regardless of whose fault it is). I think this has helped with my driving generally, but also means I do 'lifesaver' looks before every lane change, which I sometimes get asked about.
I only wish that it also worked for the left-side mirror as well. My understanding is that Hondas new all electric cars will feature cameras instead of mirrors entirely.
https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a27007185/honda-lanewatch-...
Thicker pillars means better structural integrity during crashes, particularly the roof during rollovers.
There are obvious market reasons for it to be this way, but it seems like a failure of regulations that it is. And given this reality, it's not surprising that pedestrian fatalities are way up per TFA.
You can also use different, stronger materials. But those are generally more expensive.
Subaru solves it with better engineering and using higher strength steels (and reinforcing the B-pillar with a boron reinforcement bar).
Making the pillars thick is just cost saving.
Only given a crash. Better visibility improves your own safety by reducing the likelihood of a crash.
Ideally, we would analyze the whole solution and only increase the pillar sizes to the point at which more increases caused net-greater morbidity and mortality rates, both for the driver and passengers, and for others outside the car.
Depth perception might come into play when you are timing your own move in front of a car that is already overtaking you. I would caution against that; you already have a double light path to deal with in the mirror and you are also looking in front of you. Just stick to your lane and wait until it is obvious that you can make a move; for instance when the lane is completely clear or when there is ample space, not a space that may or may not be narrow enough to slot your car in.
With a normal mirror watch a car pass you and watch it disappear for a bit before it is visible in your window. The blind spot mirrors show you a car is there all the way until it is past you.
Those are phenomenal... I honestly don't miss the blind spot detection / warning system at all, you can see so much.
That’s what I mean by 0 blind spot.
It's VERY easy to lose a pedestrian in the A-pillar (windshield pillar) of modern cars, particularly due to how large these units have gotten to accommodate side curtain airbags.
Note that the fixtures on the body don't have to 100% optically obscure things for them to be 'invisible' to the driver.
https://www.portsmouthctc.org.uk/a-fighter-pilots-guide-to-s...
>It gets even worse. Not only can we not see though solid objects; research has shown that we tend not to look near to the edges of a framed scene. In plain language, we tend not to look at the edges of a windscreen. So, not only do the door pillars of a car represent a physical blind spot, but our eyes tend not to fixate near to it, leading to an even bigger jump, or saccade, past a door pillar. This is called windscreen zoning.