News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by deogeo on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:35PM (#21143027)
The inevitable result of letting the manufacturer control what may run on the device.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by rsj_hn on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:13PM (#21143214)
Agreed. However, Android has removed Gab and other free speech apps from it's appstore, too. Although you can circumvent android easier than iOS. This is a tough call -- security versus freedom, and I don't know what the right trade off is. I'd still counsel my parents to use Apple.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by echelon on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:32PM (#21143339)
> security versus freedom

With the app store you're still vulnerable to state actors and zero day vulns. And on Android you're vulnerable to permissions scope creep. The app stores contain malware.

You're never truly safe.

You can't point to the old days of Windows in the 90s and early 2000s as a case for app stores, either. Installers and downloaded executables were great, but Windows had a broken, unsandboxed model that made it easy to break. History would have played out much better if Windows itself weren't so permissible and was more hermetic back then.

If we invested the same billions of research and development dollars that Apple and Google did into their walled garden platforms, an open web with truly cross platform native wasm apps would work just as well or better than anything on the app stores, and it'd be just as "secure". And cross platform. And couldn't be shut down by Apple, Google, or an angry government.

Imagine going to Netflix.com and getting the native app experience. On any mobile device. Windows Phone. Ubuntu Phone. That's how it should have worked.

Walled gardens must die.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:01AM (#21144433)
> Walled gardens must die.

No.

As a user, I am grateful for "walled gardens" like the App Store, Steam, etc.

Because I remember the chaos that was before them, with developers/publishers preying on users all the time, which they still try to do by working around App Store restrictions and so on. I'm grateful for curated marketplaces putting the foot down on them.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by wickedsickeune on Thursday October 03, 2019 @07:58AM (#21145966)
You mention Steam, which is a steaming pile of poo, along with chaos and devs preying on users. Do have any semblance of the amount of shovelware & asset flips published on Steam daily?
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:50AM (#21146895)
Steam has user reviews, forums and a standard process for refunds. What would you do if you had to purchase all games from each developer's own website? Your only recourse would probably be to file a chargeback with your bank.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by kzzzznot on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:22AM (#21144537)
What are you referring to when you say “scummy developers preying on users”? Honestly asking.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:35AM (#21144594)
If you check the news at any frequency it's hard to miss all the reports of this and that software overextending or abusing its privileges to intrude into the user's computer and privacy.

See all the recent news about Chrome, Dropbox, Zoom etc. installing malware on our systems. Steam wiping your disk on Linux when you uninstalled a game. Uber recording your screen.

And those are the big players, caught because they're under constant scrutiny (but still try to act as if they're above the "law").

Life before the "walled gardens" was rife with cases like that, from developers on all scales. There was no single authority for your platform to complain to. It was chaotic and miserable even for techie people.

This is actually what Apple capitalized on during the "I'm a PC, I'm a Mac" days, and it gave them the credibility to carry on to the App Store. Now I see mostly developers complaining about the walled garden, which makes me wary of their true intentions.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by immigrantsheep on Thursday October 03, 2019 @05:40AM (#21145182)
I'm sorry, I don't understand the point you're trying to make here. You say it's better now that we have walled gardens but then you make a list of all the players that are circumnavigating these anyway. This to me sounds like the worse of both worlds. Some people are still doing whatever they want and at the same time we're prevented to install software from different sources. I agree that at some level it prevents everyone to do it, meaning you have to have at least some basic knowledge to do that but that doesn't seem much from a freedom/security standpoint. For the most part and for most users, those walled gardens are nice but I still think users should have the option to install whatever they want. Put on seven disclaimers about it, but let me do it since, well, I paid for that device.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @06:04AM (#21145297)
> a list of all the players that are circumnavigating these anyway.

Do note that almost all of those examples are of apps that are -NOT- delivered via the App Store.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by echelon on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:38AM (#21148234)
> App Store

Now you're picking favorites. So the App Store is okay, but Google Play and Steam aren't?

I don't own Apple devices, so I lack familiarity, but I find it hard to believe that Apple is so good this doesn't happen.

Why do we put our faith in corporations to do right by us?

Apple and Google do not care if users are taken advantage of as long as they don't complain in volume. Both platforms allow play to win games that are designed around extorting "whales". They knowingly allow at-risk individuals to pour thousands of dollars into games, which is an outright travesty.

These companies have too much power and they're abusing it.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @07:55PM (#21153529)
> So the App Store is okay, but Google Play and Steam aren't?

Apps downloaded via the App Store (and I assume Google Play) are sandboxed.

Chrome on the desktop, Steam, etc. are not sandboxed.

Most malicious activity is not possible from within a sandbox. For example Steam wouldn't have been able to delete the user's entire disk if it only had access to its own folder.

> Why do we put our faith in corporations to do right by us?

Why should we put our faith in random individual developers to do right by us?

I'd rather have to trust just one corporation instead of thousands of developers who may pack up and disappear overnight.

> These companies have too much power and they're abusing it.

See comments above. Much of the recent malware is in apps that are not distributed via the App Store.

Developers have always abused their power, and still do. "Walled gardens" check that abuse.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by ajscanlan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:37AM (#21146768)
How would you feel if Apple brought the same philosophy of iOS to macOS (assuming you use mac)?

Can't install anything they don't pre-approve, either from DMG or Brew or whatever, only from the Mac App Store.

I don't know if it's just me and the people i work with, but we think the Mac App Store is fucking useless, to the point we actively go out of our way to download Xcode through other means.

I for one would not be happy with only being able to install apps through the Mac App Store, and I don't see why iOS should be treated any differently.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:46AM (#21146860)
> How would you feel if Apple brought the same philosophy of iOS to macOS (assuming you use mac)?

I wouldn't be OK with that, and I've said so in other comments here (like when they announced the additional security features in macOS during this year's WWDC - which I appreciate, with concerns), but the iPhone/iPad/etc. are different classes of devices, and I'm fine with their restrictions. They make sense there.

I do prefer the Mac App Store to downloading from random websites or manual updates. How is it "fucking useless?"

Matters of convenience aside, see the Transmission BitTorrent client ransomware fiasco for a grave example.

If someone really really wants to circumvent the App Store on iOS, distribute it via TestFlight, or make the source code available and ask users to compile it on their own Macs.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by marmada on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:23AM (#21147293)
I feel like Apple users live in a ivory-tower.

> If someone really really wants to circumvent the App Store on iOS, distribute it via TestFlight, or make the source code available and ask users to compile it on their own Macs.

How many protesters in Hong Kong have a Mac to compile source code and even know how to compile something? TestFlight has a user limit. Can people install an app through TestFlight as easily as they can through the normal app store?

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:09AM (#21147912)
I was talking about a general case (which is still rare), not the situation in Hong Kong.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by ajscanlan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:33AM (#21147436)
> the iPhone/iPad/etc. are different classes of devices

I suppose I just don't understand why, they seem just like computers with a different form factor.

"Fucking useless" might have been a bit too passionate, but it's happened multiple times with me and the people I work with that Xcode installed through the App Store updates itself but gets stuck in the update forcing a full re-download.

First time it happens ok it's just a bug, by the 3rd time I'd just given up on the App Store altogether.

> If someone really really wants to circumvent the App Store on iOS, distribute it via TestFlight, or make the source code available and ask users to compile it on their own Macs.

Those aren't really feasible though, external testing on Testflight requires a review (plus it might need the $99 developer fee to put it on Testflight?). And the source code route is the same issue, either pay $99 or reinstall the app every 7 days.

I suppose I just don't see the downside other than "Some people need to be protected from themselves" which I don't agree with in this case.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Razengan on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:08AM (#21147901)
> Xcode installed through the App Store updates itself but gets stuck in the update forcing a full re-download.

That's a frustration that I share, regarding large downloads/updates on unreliable connections, but that doesn't make the App Store useless. I have received thousands of successful app updates over years and maybe <50 failures.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by echelon on Thursday October 03, 2019 @07:31PM (#21153354)
> iPhone/iPad/etc. are different classes of devices

No, just no.

They're our computers.

This is why I really hoped for the Ubuntu and Firefox phones to happen.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by icelancer on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:56AM (#21144949)
>> As a user, I am grateful for "walled gardens" like the App Store, Steam, etc.

That's nice that you get to experience that. I think the protesters may have a different opinion than you.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by pjmlp on Thursday October 03, 2019 @02:10AM (#21144205)
I guess that is why everyone just uses Chrome nowadays. /s
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by echelon on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:34PM (#21149584)
Google searches used to present Chrome as an app you should download. Google leveraged its market dominance to get people to download their desktop browser.

And on Android it's the default you can't uninstall.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by on_and_off on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:34PM (#21143356)
You don't have to circumvent anything and that's the crux of it.

Android lets you install applications without having to jailbreak your phone or do any other trickery. This should be a prerequisite for any OS (with all the necessary warnings).

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by innagadadavida on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:01AM (#21143541)
There are at least two ways to install apps outside of the App Store: https://www.iotransfer.net/tips/how-to-download-apps-without... In addition you could use TestFlight or HockeyApp to distribute to limited beta testers. HN is a technical forum, proselytizing based on your software freedom beliefs by selectively using facts is very disingenuous. Android works for you, that is great - other people actually have “freedom” to ignore your definition of freedom and do what they want.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by saagarjha on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:58AM (#21144145)
TestFlight requires a review process and HockeyApp uses enterprise certificates, AFAIK. They’re both in the hands of Apple.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by wickedsickeune on Thursday October 03, 2019 @08:01AM (#21145985)
You forgot that the proposed use case for both TestFlight & HockeyApp is against the ToS of both those services and Apple, and will be immediately flagged if you use it for large scale distribution. Also TestFlight afaik only allows 1000 users, which is not that much.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by lern_too_spel on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:21AM (#21143670)
Your solution is to use an enterprise certificate from Anokiiwin Employment Solutions Inc or NANJING SCIYON SOFTWARE TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. Both will certainly get revoked soon. HN is a technical forum, so we understand why your solution doesn't actually work.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by innagadadavida on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:33AM (#21143740)
That’s really funny, trusting my entire data, location, photos all to Google is certainly a big concern for me. I’d rather install that Chinese certificate than give my data to Google. Also, it’s entirely within Googles powers to make Android store closed like the App Store, so can we not speculate on future events? Edit: reworded my comment
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by thekyle on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:51AM (#21143839)
Please don't use these types of irrelevant personal attacks on HN. /u/lern_to_spel has a very good point that your mentioned alternatives will likely be shut down by Apple and are not officially supported.

If you are going to argue, do it against the most generous interpretation of someone else's words.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by jakelazaroff on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:27AM (#21143701)
Let's not whitewash Gab, which was created specifically to be a white supremacist social network under the veneer of free speech. We can argue whether or not Google should have removed it from the Play Store, but let's be honest about what it is.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by el_dev_hell on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:54AM (#21143855)
I signed up for Gab about 1.5 years ago. It pegged itself as a "free speech platform", which I found pretty interesting.

The concept of a wild west free speech utopia sounds great (and I would still like to see that), but it's filled with repetitive white nationalist bullshit. That's the early adopter group.

Because of that early group, it's a horrible experience for anyone else.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by jakelazaroff on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:16AM (#21143951)
It's not just their early adopter group; Gab has actively cultivated a white nationalist userbase. See for example https://twitter.com/ClenchedFisk/status/1027690034718224384

I am skeptical of the "wild west free speech utopia" as a lot of people seem to conceive of it, because some forms of speech have chilling effects on others. For example, if I pass a group of angry people chanting "blood and soil", I'm certainly not going to say or do anything that makes me legible as Jewish.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by SkyBelow on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:11AM (#21147137)
Any early adopter of a technology promising freedom will be the groups who need it the most, which tends to be the groups who are most at odds with current social norms. Just look at who the early adopters are for tor or bitcoin.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by wallace_f on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:25AM (#21143993)
Which is sad. Because if everyone tolerates abuse, whether from governments or corporations, we get creeping authoritarianism.

Also, I think you bith are exaggerating a bit about Gabhere is obviously a lot of alt right though.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by hyperdunc on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:48AM (#21144916)
It's no surprise that people banned from other platforms end up on a platform that accepts them. That doesn't mean Gab was specifically made to promote any specific group or viewpoint.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by jakelazaroff on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:37PM (#21148899)
It's the other way around. Gab was created specifically as a safe haven for white supremacist speech, and so white supremacists flocked to it.

> "Gab welcomes everyone, but sees a unique opportunity to carve a niche in a massively underserved and unrepresented market. We estimate that there are over 50 million conservative, libertarian, nationalist, and populist internet users from around the world who are seeking an alternative to the current social networking ecosystems. These users are also actively seeking out alternative media platforms like Breitbart.com, DrudgeReport.com, Infowars.com, and others," Gab stated in a company filing dated July 11, 2017.

https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/30/tech/gab-anti-semitic-speech-...

This is in addition to white supremacist statements made by the company's official social media accounts: https://twitter.com/ClenchedFisk/status/1027690034718224384

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by hyperdunc on Saturday October 05, 2019 @01:16AM (#21163946)
You seem to be confused about what white supremacy is. It's a small subset of nationalism. There are many other types.

And white supremacy is more authoritarian than libertarian. And it's not conservative in the current political sense and it's populist.

I'm not sure what to make of that Twitter link except that there's a whole bunch of folk so embedded in their own political bubbles that they're incapable of communicating with anyone beyond.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by jakelazaroff on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:37PM (#21182858)
I'm not confused about what white supremacy is. The sites listed are instructive: Breitbart has explicit white supremacist and Nazi ties [1], whereas InfoWars is often a gateway into white supremacy [2]. The Twitter link is a bunch of examples of Gab's official Twitter account making anti-Semitic comments.

[1] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/josephbernstein/heres-h...

[2] https://www.revealnews.org/blog/the-hate-report-infowars-is-...

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by hyperdunc on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:17AM (#21190980)
Buzzfeed and Reveal are every bit as ideology-laden as Breitbart and InfoWars. I happily disregard most of what they all have to say.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by derrick_jensen on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:19PM (#21143254)
100% freedom, all the time

"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Benjamin Franklin

I'm not sure about iOS, but Android still allows installing unsigned APKs (F-Droid and similar platforms work because of this), and what has already been installed stays on the phone until the user removes it.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by cortesoft on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:44AM (#21143795)
100% freedom is an absolutely banal phrase.

What does it even mean? I am pretty sure that you don't mean someone is 100% free to murder someone else. So you clearly believe in some restrictions.

I can already imagine the counter argument: "Well, 100% freedom unless your freedom infringes on someone else's freedom!"

Ok, but what does it mean to infringe on someone else's freedom? Murder is the easy case; what about polluting a river? I think we would all agree dumping enough chemicals to kill all life in a river would be infringing on other's freedoms, so lets prevent that... but where do you draw the line? It will take judgement, consensus, and compromise to find out where that line is.

So suddenly we are back to needing rules around curtailing freedoms that some people aren't going to like.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by derrick_jensen on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:51AM (#21143841)
I agree that 100% freedom was pretty hyperbole. AnCap + the NAP is probably a better comparison (but still lacks some nuance).

In the case of user privacy, I'm against any backdoors or outlawing of encryption (pretty much any government intervention in the messaging space)

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by Shank on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:50PM (#21143472)
You kind of can compile and run anything you want, but by default free developer accounts can only run 3 apps for 7 days until they expire. Tools like Cydia Impactor exist for this purpose.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by song on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:21AM (#21144806)
See, that's a dilemma I grappling with right now. I am trying to decide between an iphone and an android phone. And while android does allow me to install any APKs I want which is great. It also seems to be supremely difficult not to share all of my contacts with google, not to share more information than I want with them and to not have my privacy completely invaded.

So, on one hand, android gives me freedom to install any app I want and to install a firewall like netguard, on the other hand, it destroys my privacy.

I'm really looking for a guide about how to properly secure and prevent data leaking an android phone beyond the basics that I've seen online but without that I'm leaning toward Apple despite finding it abhorrent that I cannot install what I want on my own device (I can obviously side load by using my dev certificate but that's still not something I'm happy with)

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by xurias on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:44AM (#21148306)
The only feasible way to avoid sharing data with Google is using a custom ROM like LineageOS, a Google framework replacement like microG, and XPrivacyLua (module for XPosed). Ideally you'd avoid using any Google services at all, but at least these steps largely prevent Google from freely taking whatever data they want if you do use the Play Store or whatever.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by song on Monday October 07, 2019 @05:38AM (#21178971)
Problem with that is that unlocking the bootloader voids the warranty where I live... I think I'll still try to go down that road if I can't find any other solution...
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by lern_too_spel on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:14AM (#21147178)
> not to share all of my contacts with google

You can do this even using the Google Contacts app. Just go into the account settings and turn off contacts sync. To be extra sure, just use a different contacts app.

> not have my privacy completely invaded.

Android has strictly less privacy invasion than iOS, even on Google phones. You can set an offline maps app to be your default. Getting your GPS location doesn't have to send it to Google, while doing the same thing on iOS always sends it to Apple, no matter which app asked. You can install your own apps usably without telling Google who you are.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by bilbo0s on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:58PM (#21143525)
"I'm not sure about iOS, but Android still allows installing [unsigned APKs likely hacked with spyware integrated courtesy of the Chinese government]"

The kind of "freedom" you're talking about generally has a high cost. At times, that cost is, well, "freedom".

Frustrating actually. There is no platform out there that delivers on the promise of getting you security and freedom. Certainly none that get you privacy. Right now it's all marketing and fanboys, but where the rubber meets the road, there's just no grip.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by derrick_jensen on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:27AM (#21143702)
An untrusted APK is just an APK that isn't signed by Google. They can still be signed by third parties and verified to be correct. It's a shame that more open source platforms haven't taken off, but I'm not too surprised.

I don't understand what you mean by the first sentence. Can you be more specific when you say freedom?

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by dotancohen on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:23AM (#21143984)
The corollary to this quote is that there are people who do not deserve Liberty. Or Safety.
[dead]
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by dang on Thursday October 03, 2019 @02:16AM (#21144231)
Personal attacks will get you banned here, and you've unfortunately done this before as well (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21034818). Please edit such swipes out of the comments you post to HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by kyriakos on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:06AM (#21143577)
Android has multiple stores though and even if none of them carry the app you can still side load it.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:37AM (#21144866)
> security versus freedom, and I don't know what the right trade off is

That is not a trade off at all, if you believe that you have already fallen for the propaganda. Security in and of itself has no value that you could trade off against freedom, only the freedom part of that pair is valuable. Security is a means to the end of freedom: You may need a certain kind and/or amount of security to gain and maintain freedom. But security is also a means to authoritarianism if you do it wrong. Which means: Security is only valuable in so far as it causes a net increase in freedom. If you are actually giving up freedom to make space for more security, that is, you are trading off freedom against security, you have failed.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by radley on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:50PM (#21143468)
> Android has removed Gab and other free speech apps from it's appstore, too

Gab was removed for hate speech, not free speech.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by busymom0 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:59PM (#21143530)
Hate speech is protected under free speech.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_in_the_United_Stat...

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by aaronbrethorst on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:56AM (#21143863)
The First Amendment says:

"Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech"

A company removing an app is not Congress making a law that abridges anyone's freedom of speech. This isn't a First Amendment issue.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by SkyBelow on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:14AM (#21147171)
And Apple is the one who choose to ban the application from the iOS store. The distinction between corporation and government is not clear cut in the modern era.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by fennecfoxen on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:57PM (#21143518)
You say that as if a meaningful, non-political distinction can ever be made between "hate speech" and "free speech".
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by zapita on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:02AM (#21143543)
Do you consider the Universal Declaration of Human Rights to be political?

If so: you are equipped with the necessary building blocks to define hate speech in a non-political way.

If not: your definition of “political” is so broad as to be meaningless.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by voldacar on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:36AM (#21143759)
>Do you consider the Universal Declaration of Human Rights to be political?

Well yes tbh. The fact that a certain group of people in power at a certain point in history made a "universal declaration" about something says very little about whether I or anyone else should care about it or agree with it. In other words it is the epitome of political. I am happy to make up my own mind on the nature of "human rights".

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by rndgermandude on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:50AM (#21144113)
It is clearly political, and not so universal either by the way:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cairo_Declaration_on_Human_Rig...

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by fennecfoxen on Thursday October 03, 2019 @08:53AM (#21146386)
If the Cairo Declaration in and of itself gives us all the building blocks that allow us to define hate-speech in a non-political way, then what was the purpose of the Rabat Plan of Action, with all its rapporteurs and its workshops on four continents? Do you believe that process was not a political process?
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by enraged_camel on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:36AM (#21143761)
>>However, Android has removed Gab and other free speech apps

Gab is not a "free speech app". In fact, the term "free speech app" is itself laughable.

Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by millstone on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:50PM (#21143471)
What prevents a website from offering the same service? Honest question.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by another-one-off on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:35AM (#21143750)
Guessing: Got to have a system that is resistant to single points of failure and where the costs of knocking out a communication node is high relative to the benefits the government gets. A website is quite centralised.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by swiley on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:39AM (#21143776)
At least on the iPhone websites can’t do peer to peer or notifications.
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by fouc on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:42PM (#21143406)
Removing the app from the app store doesn't actually stop the app from running on the device?
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by slimsag on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:51PM (#21143476)
"The poor can put whatever they want in their refrigerators - we don't control that. We just control the food they can buy in stores."
Re:Hong Kong protest safety app banned from iOS store by djmetzle on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:58PM (#21143522)
:point_up: That.