News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by umvi on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:11PM (#21130026)
It's like we have these two irreconcilable ideas:

- Diversity is good

- Discrimination is bad

When 50% of the world's population is from China/India, how do you both promote diversity and not discriminate?

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by gameswithgo on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:31PM (#21130264)
To me the obvious thing is to aim to eliminate racial/national/gender bias as much as possible by blinding admission/hiring processes to those things. Then on top of that offer spots for people who have had to deal with exceptional difficulty. Whether that be physical handicap, racial prejudice, economic, etc. There are companies/grants that take an approach like this. Its going to be subjective but perfect is the enemy of good. Then let the percentages land where they may. Having quotas or racial/gender preferences is crazy.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by filoleg on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:37PM (#21131617)
Out of curiosity, why not just lump most of it under "socioeconomic disadvantages" category (mostly based on the family's financial situation)? E.g., poor asian kids shouldn't be grouped with the less poor asian kids and shouldn't have been at a disadvantage compared to a rich african american kid for admission purposes. This proposed approach sounds so obvious, I feel like there has gotta be some caveat in it that I am missing. Is it easily gameable or something?
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by sjg007 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:29PM (#21132967)
Yes it is gamed.. a lot of rich kids "emancipate" from their parents to qualify for financial aid for example and probably preferred admissions.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by mlevental on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:08AM (#21135503)
I love this thing that happens where someone jumps in to make an incisive point based on something they learned just recently and even on this same forum. the article about emancipation was posted here just like 2 weeks ago. so that's how certain you should be about that fact. and yet here you are proclaiming it as if you yourself have done the research and know exactly how prevalent emancipation is.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by sjg007 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:40AM (#21136957)
Maybe you missed it but there’s a well researched and detailed Vice news article on it.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by Ancalagon on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @08:04PM (#21132211)
I think this is the ultimate solution. Of course people will still try to game this system by e.g. sending their kids to high school in poorer districts.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by ravar on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @08:23PM (#21132322)
Arguably if people try to game the system in that way it would be socially good. Don't we want the privileged people going to the same schools as poorer people?
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by sushid on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:36PM (#21133013)
Because it’s zero sum? The rich kid pretending to be poor is taking away a seat from an actual poor kid.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by kelnos on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:34PM (#21132997)
Isn't that easy to detect, though? The FAFSA (among other things?) requires disclosing family income (and assets?). The university gets to see all this stuff (well, the FAFSA applicant lists schools that get to see it). If they see "family makes $300k/yr and has $2M in assets" and "kid goes to a poor high school not in his/her normal district", they can say "hah, nice try", and toss their application in the bin.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by repolfx on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @06:01AM (#21134796)
How do you blind an admissions process to race, and then offer spots for people who have suffered racial prejudice? That sounds like a contradiction.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by mar77i on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:17PM (#21130776)
What I'm seeing happen is that unis (and other affected institutions) are trying to get rid of diversity of opinion in favor of diversity of skin color/ethnicity, and... I find that reasoning nothing but racist.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by bduerst on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @07:00PM (#21131799)
Isn't that a false dichotomy though? You can have both, and I'm not entirely convinced that universities are disqualifying candidates based on opinions in their applications.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by mar77i on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @05:08AM (#21134569)
As far as universities do these things publicly, this is inadvertently going to tip the scales in who is going to apply. And I'm nowhere seeing an university that is actively filtering for opinion-conciousness in this sense, that might actually not be that bad of an idea.

Then again, if they test for both things, how are they supposed to not prioritize one over another?

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by slg on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:45PM (#21130415)
I think the debate from progressives is the definition of the term discriminate. We all agree choosing an unqualified person over a person who is qualified based on their race is discrimination. However is it discrimination to choose the diverse candidate when presented with two candidates that are equally qualified in every other regard? Because that is often the situation. There is no shortage of people who are qualified to get into Harvard or capable of succeeding there.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by dwoozle on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:59PM (#21130573)
Why set a minimum bar at “qualified”? If you try out for an NBA team they won’t say “you are really fucking good at basketball, you’re not as good as these guys but you’re diverse so you’re hired.” You get scarce positions by outcompeting people, not by clearing a bar and then getting selected for your race.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by defen on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:10PM (#21130700)
Basketball is zero-sum, undergrad college admissions mostly aren't. As long as Harvard lets in enough students who are "good enough" to not fail out or besmirch their reputation, it can continue indefinitely as a prestige-generating institution. Put another way - the "Michael Jordan" of undergraduate academics doesn't really exist (in other words, there is no individual undergraduate you could admit who would instantly make your college superior to every other one)
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by rohit2412 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:26PM (#21130874)
So, Bill gates, Zuckerberg, Sergey Brin, Larry Page etc etc did not bring their amla mater's any extra fame?

Is your bar just "do not besmirch the good name of this institution"? Then I guess nobody should care for or covet International olympiad winners.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by defen on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:32PM (#21130933)
Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg dropped out of Harvard. Neither Brin nor Page went to Harvard and are both more famous for their connection to Stanford as graduate students IMO
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by rohit2412 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:42PM (#21131024)
They did bring fame though right?
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by Retric on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @04:13AM (#21134307)
I think their dropping out may have hurt Harvard’s reputation as much as helped it. It’s often viewed as a place smart people and the elite go, but not always where they receive a great education.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by defen on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:10PM (#21131299)
Sure, but this is about undergraduate admissions, not graduate.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by sjg007 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:31PM (#21132983)
I mean I don't think the graduate level is that different.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by dwoozle on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:18PM (#21130796)
Of course there are — they are the “Michael Jordans” of the world... not only Michael Jordan himself, but all of the top accomplished people in the world... presidents, Nobel Prize winners, CEOs, famous authors... Harvard is prestigious because they admit people who later do those things. The content of the curriculum is largely the same as other colleges.

Harvard is looking for people who have the highest probability of becoming prestige generators, the same way that NBA teams are looking for people with the highest probability of being points generators. Sure, the assessment methods for Harvard are much more coarse, but that doesn’t mean they don’t exist.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by defen on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:25PM (#21130867)
You can't really assess someone's capability of becoming a president/CEO/famous author based on their achievements before age 18. It's also really hard to determine whether people achieved those things because they went to Harvard. For example, getting access to the Harvard network massively increases your chances of getting a business funded, being successful in politics, etc. Finally - Harvard's prestige in the sciences is mostly due to graduate students/professors, not undergraduates.

> The content of the curriculum is largely the same as other colleges.

Maybe in some departments, but Harvard's math curriculum is not the same as most other colleges in the US, for example.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by nybble41 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @07:12PM (#21131892)
> You can't really assess someone's capability of becoming a president/CEO/famous author based on their achievements before age 18. It's also really hard to determine whether people achieved those things because they went to Harvard.

These statements are almost completely incompatible. If there is no way to tell who is likely to be successful beforehand, and yet those who attend Harvard are more successful as a group than those who do not, then it is fair to say that attending Harvard led to their success. Personally I'd say it's some of each: the admissions process does in fact manage to select for applications who are more likely to be successful, as a group, and there are also some unique benefits available to Harvard students and alumni (as you yourself pointed out) which tend to boost their chances even further.

> For example, getting access to the Harvard network massively increases your chances of getting a business funded, being successful in politics, etc.

That would be one of the means by which people achieve things because they went to Harvard. It's not just about the academics. Of course, not everyone would be capable of taking full advantage of that network even if it were made available to them.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by defen on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:07PM (#21132866)
What I'm trying to say is that Harvard has a selection process in place, for which thousands of people per year count as "qualified", and I don't think there's a strong reason to believe that the admitted students are in any way "better" than the qualified-but-not-admitted students. However, getting that Harvard stamp of approval (which really comes down to luck, if you're qualified) opens a ton of doors, in terms of network, "brand", etc.

One big difference between Harvard and OPs NBA example is that Harvard gains prestige from its alums, for things they do years or decades after their affiliation with the institution.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by dwoozle on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @04:13AM (#21134311)
> I don't think there's a strong reason to believe that the admitted students are in any way "better" than the qualified-but-not-admitted students

On what basis do you think that? What data or reasoning suggests that the people Harvard almost admits would produce equal (fame, donations, other currency) to the university as those who are actually admitted?

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by defen on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @12:09PM (#21138003)
No concrete evidence, just my opinion based on personal experience. I attended Princeton as a lower middle class white, non-athlete, non-legacy admit. Most of the undergrads aren't particularly intellectually impressive - you'll find way smarter and more intellectually curious people in Silicon Valley. The Ivies have a baseline level of intelligence you need to hit, which isn't extraordinarily high, but after that they're selecting based on conscientiousness, willingness to work hard, athletic ability, parental resources, and luck. See https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2001/04/the-org...
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by brlewis on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:17PM (#21130767)
Professional sports have well-defined skills and roles to compete for. Diversity of backgrounds/perspectives/ideas is not as valuable in athletes as it is in an academic community.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by tooltalk on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:06PM (#21130650)
> ... when presented with two candidates that are equally qualified in every other regard? ... Because that is often the situation

Is that the case? I always thought that the case is brought on because the diversity candidate is NOT often "equally qualified,"

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by slg on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:08PM (#21131272)
That depends on what "equally qualified" means?

If it means "someone who is equally likely to be successful at Harvard" the answer is likely yes. Like I said there is no shortage of people who fit that definition.

If it means "someone who has quantifiably the exact same quality of resume" the answer is potentially no.

Although if you subscribe to the second definition, you should probably have a bigger complaint against athletes and children of alumni, staff, or donors. Almost half of all white students at Harvard are in one of those groups[1] and yet there are always more complaints about "diversity" than there is about these students.

[1] - https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/study-harvard-finds-43-...

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by rohit2412 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:43PM (#21131033)
If you read the argument, he/she is setting a lower bar and calling everyone qualified. They do not even acknowledge that their policies discriminate.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by TulliusCicero on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:18PM (#21130783)
This only makes sense if you're looking at it as a binary thing: qualified vs not-qualified.

But the reality is that it's more of a spectrum, and in general universities usually want to take the most qualified people they can, just like companies want to get the most qualified job applicants.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by gatvol on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:34PM (#21131590)
> However is it discrimination to choose the diverse candidate when presented with two candidates that are equally qualified in every other regard?

Absolutely discrimination. Unless the definition of discrimination has changed significantly that is.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by bluecalm on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:38PM (#21130982)
Of course it's discrimination. Just look at the definition of the word. The only debate is if slight discrimination is acceptable if it achieves higher goals.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by alexis_fr on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:55PM (#21130519)
Yes it is discrimination, because it gives people of that race systematically fewer chances of having a life.

The difference is when it is systematic. It is currently systematic in most universities and schools.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by aviraldg on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:11PM (#21130702)
By realising that India is not homogenous at all, and is inherently diverse?
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by humanrebar on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:16PM (#21131365)
Sure, but so are Americans: white, black, Hispanic, etc.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @09:36AM (#21136240)
Pick two random Indians and there's about a one in three chance that they won't even be able to talk to each other due to not sharing any common languages.

The US has nothing remotely close to India's level of diversity.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by Konnstann on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @04:15PM (#21140323)
Considering the US selects for English-speaking immigrants, and the fact that English is taught as a second language in a lot of the world, I don't think that's a valid way to measure "diversity".
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:47AM (#21146871)
How would you prefer to measure it then? Any reasonable measure of diversity you come up with, India will score highly on.

Skin color? India has the whole spectrum from dark brown to people who could pass for southern European.

Religion? India has a huge variety.

Economic? Everything from some of the poorest people in the world to multi-billionaires.

What percentage of the population's ancestors has been enslaved by other parts of the population's ancestors? Still very high.

Please explain how you are measuring diversity if you want to make the outrageous claim that India is not diverse.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by Konnstann on Friday October 04, 2019 @04:50PM (#21161761)
I wasn't making the claim that India isn't diverse, just what was in my comment. The claim was that people being "unable to communicate" makes the country more diverse than the US. Take any western European country and you'll find exactly the same huge diversity in skin color, religion, economy, and all of those factors.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by Barrin92 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @07:51PM (#21132140)
I think there is at least one way forward that at least reduces the intensity of these conflicts. Increase the admission numbers of people at Harvard.

Stop treating it like an exclusive club that hands out occupational licenses for an elite class of the well connected few and give as many people as you can a quality education. With the money that these universities receive that should be possible. If increase in the amount of students would have even remotely kept pace with funding we wouldn't have the need to treat this like a zero-sum race game.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by AdrianB1 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:16PM (#21130088)
50% of the world and admission at Harvard in USA are different groups, so the comparison is flawed. If you would use USA population structure, that is a relevant argument.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by umeshunni on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:34PM (#21130295)
This might come as a shock to you, but people from outside the US also attend/apply to US universities.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by AdrianB1 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @05:02PM (#21130599)
About 10% at Harvard. Not negating my argument.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by prolepunk on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:39PM (#21130345)
Its not about absolute numbers, it's about admitting people from historically underrepresented or oppressed groups.

I think the name 'Race Conscious' is not a great description where it actually means race and oppression.

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by prolepunk on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:52PM (#21130491)
Everyone who's downvoting me. Please explain why simply stating this is so controversial?

Hasan Minhaj did a pretty informative episode on the lawsuit against Harvard affirmative action -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zm5QVcTI2I8

Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by rolltiide on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:16PM (#21130081)
Then you start focusing in the diversity within those extremely large countries and groups of people. So further partition once the US becomes saturated with a more accurate representation of who lives on this planet.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by theonlyklas on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:45PM (#21130405)
Why does the US need to be first?
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions... by rolltiide on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:24PM (#21131480)
Because this is a thread about Harvard, a US college, being scrutinized under US laws in the US court system.