Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by filoleg on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:37PM
(#21131617)
Out of curiosity, why not just lump most of it under "socioeconomic disadvantages" category (mostly based on the family's financial situation)? E.g., poor asian kids shouldn't be grouped with the less poor asian kids and shouldn't have been at a disadvantage compared to a rich african american kid for admission purposes. This proposed approach sounds so obvious, I feel like there has gotta be some caveat in it that I am missing. Is it easily gameable or something?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by sjg007 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:29PM
(#21132967)
Yes it is gamed.. a lot of rich kids "emancipate" from their parents to qualify for financial aid for example and probably preferred admissions.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by mlevental on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:08AM
(#21135503)
I love this thing that happens where someone jumps in to make an incisive point based on something they learned just recently and even on this same forum. the article about emancipation was posted here just like 2 weeks ago. so that's how certain you should be about that fact. and yet here you are proclaiming it as if you yourself have done the research and know exactly how prevalent emancipation is.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by sjg007 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:40AM
(#21136957)
Maybe you missed it but there’s a well researched and detailed Vice news article on it.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by Ancalagon on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @08:04PM
(#21132211)
I think this is the ultimate solution. Of course people will still try to game this system by e.g. sending their kids to high school in poorer districts.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by ravar on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @08:23PM
(#21132322)
Arguably if people try to game the system in that way it would be socially good. Don't we want the privileged people going to the same schools as poorer people?
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by sushid on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:36PM
(#21133013)
Because it’s zero sum? The rich kid pretending to be poor is taking away a seat from an actual poor kid.
Re:Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions...
by kelnos on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @10:34PM
(#21132997)
Isn't that easy to detect, though? The FAFSA (among other things?) requires disclosing family income (and assets?). The university gets to see all this stuff (well, the FAFSA applicant lists schools that get to see it). If they see "family makes $300k/yr and has $2M in assets" and "kid goes to a poor high school not in his/her normal district", they can say "hah, nice try", and toss their application in the bin.