News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by cat_plus_plus on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:00PM (#21055756)
That's what makes me so furious at the morons who deplatformed RMS over some silly devil's advocate defense of Minsky on an internal mailing list. The guy has an important idea that he put most of his life into developing. In the process, he made programming much more inclusive than anyone could dream about in the days of proprietary operating system with compilers that sold for thousands of dollars. So even if having to deal with a difficult old man makes you feel a little less inclusive, it's not too crazy to give him some breaks. The kids who ran him out of town only know how to destroy, not how to create anything comparable to what he did.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ariabuckles on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:08PM (#21055792)
It wasn't just this incident. RMS alienated so many women from open source and free software over the last 30 years, and we've lost all of those potential contributions. He's been getting breaks for 30 years.

That he has also done some very good things isn't a good argument for continuing to tolerate his harmful behaviour after he's been asked to fix it for literally decades, and hasn't.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:14PM (#21056143)
Do you believe he has alienated more women from FOSS than he has inspired people to contribute to it? Considering the frankly extremely low percentage of female contributors, it seems that he would have had to personally (considering that all of the creepy behaviours listed seem to be limited to his meatspace circles) alienate multiple women for every one woman who did wind up working on in free software, which seems unrealistic simply on the basis that most people in FOSS never met Stallman. (On the same basis, I would actually be inclined to believe that he has probably inspired more women specifically than he has alienated, too.)

Note also that all of the anecdotes of actual bad behaviour that seem to come up are from about two decades ago, and we seem to be supposed to conclude that the pattern never stopped on the basis of that and a pathologically misquoted and misrepresented email he sent on the Epstein/Minsky case. Considering that the real email is at most slightly tone-deaf, the most likely model of reality to me seems to be that he has fixed that behaviour well over a decade ago, but a number of activists had resolved to never let it go until they found some way to completely destroy any status and reputation he has.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ariabuckles on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:38PM (#21056271)
That's an interesting way of framing it—I expect that no, he hasn't directly dissuaded more people than he's encouraged.

But I expect that the second- and third-degree network effects have. MIT has had a huge influence on open source software. Keeping the number of women who contribute to FOSS lower has a snowball effect of discouraging other women from contributing—there are fewer leaders to look up to, and day-to-day misogyny in FOSS spaces goes unchecked more often.

As another commenter pointed out, I also don't think net impact is the bar. But besides that, it's very hard to measure, so I prefer to focus on having positive impacts and limiting/fixing negative impacts. I think the things he said on the CSAIL mailing list continue to contribute to a negative environment for women at MIT.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:43PM (#21056292)
> But I expect that the second- and third-degree network effects have. MIT has had a huge influence on open source software. Keeping the number of women who contribute to FOSS lower has a snowball effect of discouraging other women from contributing—there are fewer leaders to look up to, and day-to-day misogyny in FOSS spaces goes unchecked more often.

Surely second- and third-degree network effects occur on the encouragement side of the equation, too. Why would we expect any putative discouragement of women by Stallman to travel further in the social graph than his encouragement of both men and women?

> I think the things he said on the CSAIL mailing list continue to contribute to a negative environment for women at MIT.

Which things specifically, and in what way?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ariabuckles on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:12AM (#21056458)
I think the negative effects spread further because they skew the field more. I think women are more likely to avoid FOSS because there are few women, even without knowing who RMS is, than men are likely to go into FOSS because of RMS or someone who was inspired by RMS. That's an assumption on my part, but I think making tech more equitable for all people is a worthy goal in itself, even if that doesn't increase the total number of contributors.

> Which things specifically, and in what way?

Saying that we shouldn't call sexual assault "sexual assault", and implying that there's any way a rich, famous, 73-year-old man can "have sex with" (rape) a 17-year-old girl, whom he has extraordinary power over, and who, in in this case was his friend's trafficking victim.

The idea that Minsky's "honour" is in any way more important than harm in what happened to Giuffre perpetuates rape culture. It perpetuates the idea that women are worth less than men, and that it's okay for famous men in CS to rape girls. That emboldens other rapists and makes CS very unwelcoming for rape victims.

Minsky should have known. Implying there's any way what he did was okay creates an unwelcoming environment for women, especially young women and girls at MIT.

(Background and links from https://medium.com/@selamie/remove-richard-stallman-fec6ec21... )

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:28AM (#21056558)
> implying that there's any way a rich, famous, 73-year-old man can "have sex with" (rape) a 17-year-old girl, whom he has extraordinary power over, and who, in in this case was his friend's trafficking victim.

...what are the scare quotes for? Is "have sex with" not a definitional superset of "rape"? As far as I can tell, Stallman does not assert that Giuffre was not raped, only that Minsky would probably not have known. (As far as he knew, she could equally have been one year older and legally, voluntarily engaged in prostitution...?) You could argue that (and I think that if Minsky did indeed have sex with her, you would have a very good case) that Minsky was extremely naive and/or irresponsible to not suspect anything amiss in the setting, but sexual (or any other) assault, in the view of many people, requires intent to harm someone against their will.

Here, it seems that the intent, and hence the primary guilt for the assault, most likely was squarely with Epstein and his associates: if a gun salesman takes you to his shooting range and tells you to fire a weapon at a target that he actually secretly tied a person to the back of, and you shoot that person dead, you are not on the hook for murder even if you should really have known that something is off and recall hearing muffled screams from somewhere at one point in hindsight.

> The idea that Minsky's "honour" is in any way more important than harm in what happened to Giuffre

Where did Stallman claim that?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by tzs on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @01:52AM (#21056936)
> Minsky should have known. Implying there's any way what he did was okay creates an unwelcoming environment for women, especially young women and girls at MIT

How would Minsky have known? It was 2001 or early 2002, before Epstein's trafficking came to light. From Minsky's point of view, a girl who worked at Epstein's retreat as a masseuse and was above the age of consent [1] offered to have sex with him. (Which, according to Gregory Benford, who was there, Minsky declined).

[1] 16. It wasn't until later that the US Virgin Islands raised it to the current 18.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by shagie on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:00AM (#21059039)
https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/9/20798900/marvin-minsky-jef...

> In 2012, the Jeffrey Epstein Foundation issued a press release touting another conference organized by Minsky on the island in December 2011.

The press release is at https://www.pr.com/press-release/383199

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by dspillett on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:27AM (#21058385)
> Do you believe he has alienated more women from FOSS than he has inspired people to contribute to it?

Almost certainly not, but at this stage it is not unlikely that he'll put off more than he'll encourage going forward. So by the same "net effect" argument you make for accepting his behaviour up to a point in the recent past, he should go. Live by the sword, get asked to resign because of the sword.

> Considering the frankly extremely low percentage of female contributors

That low number of female contributors is at least in part due to the impression people have of working in these areas. Allowing him to continue to alienate people works against efforts to rectify that impression (and where it is true rather than just an impression, work to fix the behaviours that are causing the problem).

> all of the anecdotes of actual bad behaviour that seem to come up are from about two decades ago

Perhaps most, but not all. I've definitely seen some more recent claims, and they were mentioned before this particular episode. They weren't as egregious as the earlier behaviour so he was at least controlling/curbing/changing the creepy behaviour for which I suppose there should be some credit, and there is definitely some curious timing wrt MIT and the Epstein contributions so there is presumably a bit of "throw him under the bus as a distraction" going on, meaning this is a case with significant grey areas, but I think painting him as an entirely innocent victim is a step too far.

Let's be fair handed: if we wouldn't accept it from a politician or other celebrity, we shouldn't accept it from someone whose other ideas we agree with either.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:23PM (#21056183)
You are okay forgiving people as long as their "net impact" is positive? Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:37PM (#21056266)
In general, yes. Murder is a very peculiar case that is hardly suitable to be the benchmark for building our intuitions about trading off harm in general: human lives are not fungible, murder is not reversible, the victims do not generally get a meaningful way of influencing how the murder impacts them etc., all properties that do not apply in the case of being put off a pursuit like FOSS. (Even then, we're sometimes okay accepting murder to save more lives: e.g. the Allies' actions in WWII are considered a heroic even with nearly a century of historical distance) Arguably, the progressive argument for {affirmative action, inverted burden of proof in Title IX, ...} also amounts to "accept some harm if the net impact is positive"; few people claim that these policies will not result in some people being rejected from positions they deserve or punished for crimes they did not commit.

Some countries are more explicit about this and actually constitutionally single out matters of life and death as being prohibited from being traded off against each other (e.g. Germany), i.e. the state is not allowed to play in trolley problems. The corollary is that the state, and most everyone, finds it okay to trade off other harms: you can for instance choose to build an airport that will drive down the value of some people's homes and expose them to considerable noise in order to give convenience and good business to a large number of people. I think discouraging some women from participating in FOSS is much closer in quality of harm to "your home is now worth half as much and you have to put up with the noise of planes flying overhead everyday" than "you die a painful and untimely death".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:42AM (#21056632)
Also notice how it is almost always okay for "women" to be discouraged and counted as collateral damage. The fact that you do that tells me a lot.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:42AM (#21058883)
> Also notice how it is almost always okay for "women" to be discouraged and counted as collateral damage.

Quote one person in this thread who said that it wouldn't be ok if it affected men instead. Or just one person implying that.

You're assuming a lot here. If anything, I think it's likely less people would care if a bunch of men were alienated, since there's already so many of them in the field in the first palce.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:41AM (#21058463)
> "women" to be discouraged and counted as collateral damage

this never happened though.

According not to me, but to Thomas Lord (if you don't know who he is, go and check)

> One remarkable thing about the FSF at that time, when we worked out of dinky spare offices on the campus of MIT, was the degree of participation by women. In the tiny society that was then the FSF, women were more prominent than I had seen in Silicon Valley, or acadamia prior.

https://archive.is/7qepC

And it says a lot about the amount of fabrication going around.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:50PM (#21056329)
Wow I've seen everything on HN to protect RMS. The Allies action was to counter gratuitous aggression and persecution of large swathes of people. Are you telling me RMS has had the same experiences in his life to warrant his egregious behavior ?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:57PM (#21056375)
I don't think my leap from murder to war was greater than your leap from some gauche remarks during a talk in the '90s and a handful of emails lawyering about word choice that might have put some people off working in the speaker's discipline to murder. Other than that, what exactly is your point? At no point did I imply that rms's life history should be compared to the Allied intervention in Europe; I merely brought it up as as an example that proves there is no such thing as a universally accepted rule against trading off murders and people saved.

("Wow, I've seen everything on HN to attack RMS. (...)")

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:41AM (#21056623)
If any other person did this, especially someone from FAANG etc. you'll be out with your pitchforks. The double standard is so real.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:52AM (#21058980)
Let's accuse strangers of double standards based on our assumption of how they'd act. That seems like a constructive way to have a discussion!
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:13AM (#21061052)
I do want FAANG to threaten me that they will kill themselves if I don't go on a date with them.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by pjmlp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:37AM (#21057163)
That is what armies happen to do all the time.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flatb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:01AM (#21060232)
Can you explain, in general, how armies and war are ethically relevant to Richard Stallman threatening coworkers to kill himself if they don't go on dates with him, or asking them to lay down topless on a mattress in his office?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by pjmlp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:06AM (#21060305)
I was answering to "Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?".

Armies don't have much issue with that ethical question.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by donatj on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:04AM (#21056418)
Yes? lol. Why does everything always come to the Trolley Problem?

I think anyone who was ever in favor of any war would agree that sometimes a death is justified when it saves many more?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by JamisonM on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:20AM (#21056505)
It is not the Trolley Problem, you seem to misunderstand the issue. There is no binary choice here, it is not comparable.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:44AM (#21056645)
There is one: (1) let Stallman keep his position and inspire/encourage one set of people, while discouraging/putting off another; (2) remove Stallman from his position, foregoing both the inspiration/encouragement and the discouragement/putting off.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by donatj on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:53AM (#21056681)
> Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?

That is a yes or no question. That is literally a binary choice. Yes or no - is murder OK if that murder saves more than one person.

That is literally the Trolley Problem.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by bitofhope on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:53AM (#21057872)
That wasn't really the question, though. There was nothing there about saving lives _by_ murdering someone. It's more like "is it ok do do bad things if you've built up good karma beforehand by doing more good stuff".
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:59AM (#21059031)
Nope. That's a strawman right there.

The question is, is it acceptable to tolerate someones bad deeds because the benefits of doing so is greater than the harm.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by JamisonM on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @03:56PM (#21074639)
It is not the Trolley Problem because the literal question is "Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before?" and that is not the Trolley Problem, that is the "letting someone off the hook for present and future misdeeds based on past good acts."

It just isn't the same thing.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by knolax on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:31PM (#21056239)
That's not a good analogy because murder are both one time actions. Punishing a murderer who saved before doesn't prevent more people from being saved. A more apt example would be granting clemency to a highly talented surgeon specialized in an operation nobody else can do.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:39AM (#21058453)
> Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?

Murder is a crime.

Where is the crime here?

It is ok to let go a "fuck you" if that persons did good before.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flatb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:57AM (#21060187)
> Where is the crime here? The analogy is between a good thing not cancelling out a bad thing. The police are not involved. There isn't a crime. He has been pressured for making people very uncomfortable in pursuit of his sexual interests, which is a perfectly good reason to reprieve someone.

He has been accused, by several independent parties, of, among other things:

-Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office.

-Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

-Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:12PM (#21061695)
> He has been accused, by several independent parties, of, among other things:

Who, exactly?

> -Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office. > -Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

Sooooo, your entire analysis is based on legends circulating since the 90s about a weird man who was even told to be scared by plants?

For reference, Thomas Lord, creator of GNU arch (think about Git before Git), who worked for FSF for a long time said

    One remarkable thing about the FSF at that time, when we worked out of dinky spare offices on the campus of MIT, was the degree of participation by women. In the tiny society that was then the FSF, women were more prominent than I had seen in Silicon Valley, or acadamia prior. 


    p.s.: In the closet-sized "office" Bushnell, McGrath, and I shared for a time we did have some spider plants as part of a running silly joke. They did not actually scare RMS away **OF COURSE** and he usually had helpful criticism and advice of our efforts, from my point of view. 
> -Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Can you tell an inside joke when you see one?

p.s. all of us have being young and done some innocent stupid shit, the kinds young people do, like having stupid signs on the door. It doesn't make any of us a criminal.

[dead]
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:07AM (#21068770)
> your narrative of sexism in the software industry being a mostly made-up issue

Is this what this is all about? Stallman has approximately 0 sway in the "software industry".

I'm sure it is a real problem, but Stallman is neither the cause nor the solution to it. I would look into how paying high salaries for unethical work would attract abusive people, and one shouldn't want to work in those industries in the first place.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by TulliusCicero on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:25AM (#21058728)
> Do you believe he has alienated more women from FOSS than he has inspired people to contribute to it?

If I save a hundred lives as a doctor and then murder one person, does the calculus go in my favor?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ralfd on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:05AM (#21059668)
> If I save a hundred lives as a doctor and then murder one person, does the calculus go in my favor?

It can be. A sharpshooter killing a terrorist and saving 100 lives would be lauded as a hero.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flatb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:43AM (#21060039)
Do you mean to say that your analogy is relevant to the claims against RMS being partly or completely dismissed as a "necessary evil" comparable to shooting a person who's on a killing spree, when weighted against his contributions?

I'm just asking. I got that feeling reading your comment. I get that feeling reading a lot of comments here. I could be wrong.

As a reminder, he has been accused, by several independent parties, of, among other things:

-Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office.

-Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

-Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by TulliusCicero on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:51AM (#21061457)
Don't be obtuse, I said murder, not kill. Of course there are some justified instances of killing.

Again, if you save a bunch of lives, but then murder someone in cold blood, does the fact that you saved way more than you murdered mean that society ought to look past the murder? After all, your net contribution is very positive!

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by shagie on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:41AM (#21060009)
Except now he’s being investigated for kicking a handcuffed prisoner over a cliff.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:49AM (#21060790)
Mortality from smallpox vaccine was small, but not zero.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by TulliusCicero on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:48AM (#21061426)
Yes, but that's an inadvertent side effect of an otherwise-beneficial treatment. 'Murder' implies explicit intent.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by zaphirplane on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:36PM (#21055951)
That just can’t be true, a lot , I’ll go as far as say absolute majority of paid and hobby OSS developers have no interaction with RMS

Even projects under the gnu.org umbrella probably don’t interact that much with RMS, let alone have discouraging interaction.

I have no dog in this fight but have a bias for factual discussions

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by megous on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:55PM (#21056060)
Pretty much. I think I've seen one of his speeches this year for the first time, yet his ideas hugely changed my life forever, since I understood them. My exposure was just reading some texts onf fsf website in 2003, and jumping into learning GNU/Linux back then.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by knocte on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:24PM (#21056194)
I agree with you about all the past bad behaviour, but the e-mail about Minsky was a bad choice to be the "last straw". It was an email calling for accusation-inflation prevention, which the media portrayed as completely the opposite (and this way of manipulation information from the media should be criminal, in my opinion).
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by hdfbdtbcdg on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:07AM (#21057325)
If we made deliberate or negligent defamation a criminal offence it might restore some sanity to society.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:06AM (#21059107)
That's similar to how "free speech"* works in Germany, and you have people like crowder saying in public that "Germany has no free speech".

I agree in principle, but I think there's lots of good arguments against it as well.

More importantly than the question of whether it's legal, I'm amazed that people can still see themselves as "the good ones" after all the things they do to their fellow humans.

* In German, we use the word "Meinungsfreiheit", which literally translates to "Freedom of Opinion", not "Free Speech", so yes, technically speaking, we don't have free speech; only the right to express our opinions.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by hdfbdtbcdg on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @01:21PM (#21062463)
Sounds non-insane. Opinions should indeedbe free. Facts should be free. Lies that harm should not be OK.

A nice side effect of criminalizing defamation would be that the enforcment would be up to the state. When it is a civil affair only rich people can defend themselves.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by sprafa on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:27PM (#21055906)
Didn’t know about this. Where can I read more about his behaviour around women?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ariabuckles on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:18PM (#21056155)
https://geekfeminism.wikia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman and https://medium.com/@selamie/remove-richard-stallman-appendix... are good starting points; I also saw threads about it from women MIT alumns on twitter.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by norcalli on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:37PM (#21056267)
It would be horrifying to have meticulously documented notes on every thing you ever said that may or may not be true, and may or may not have been a joke. If his career had been a comedian and not a FOSS advocate, then would he still be crucified for saying the same things or would he simply be an awful comedian?

I would be dollars to doughnuts that the author of that site and the editors of that "wiki" have made or thought worse things at some point, but because they have not reached a certain level of celebrity, there's no dossier on them. It's truly ridiculous to me the amount of effort spent on trying to claw others down.

I accept that inequality exists and perhaps RMS has some awful opinions, but if that's the case then just ignore him.

If there are people who are choosing to make it incumbent upon themselves to take down these "problematic" individuals, then it must be because they think that all of the systems that have allowed a person to continue to exist despite those opinions must be unreliable in adequately judging them. If that's the case, then wouldn't it be more practical to fix the endemic problem rather than destroy a single person? I'm guessing that the latter is just easier to do and more profitable as well. You gain "credibility" by attacking someone else, so it's difficult to believe that they are doing it for altruistic means.

All in all, I'm pretty sick of this nonsense. A world where everyone is constantly being watched by eachother and reported on is already too authoritarian for me to want to continue living in, not to mention the already authoritarian governments doing the same.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ariabuckles on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:51PM (#21056345)
Honestly, I think we let a lot of mean-spiritedness pass as "comedy", and I think sexist comedy causes a lot of real-world problems.

> I would be dollars to doughnuts that the author of that site and the editors of that "wiki" have made or thought worse things at some point, but because they have not reached a certain level of celebrity, there's no dossier on them. It's truly ridiculous to me the amount of effort spent on trying to claw others down.

"With great power, comes great responsibility." When operating in contexts where you have a lot of power, one has to be more careful with their words and actions. If he had voiced that opinion to a friend of his, no one would have complained. But voicing his opinion minimizing rape on a university mailing list has direct negative effects for a lot of people.

Also, some people do listen, apologize, and put in the work to learn.

> I accept that inequality exists and perhaps RMS has some awful opinions, but if that's the case then just ignore him.

The problem is that other people don't just ignore him. By ignoring his harmful behaviour, we let his negative impact spread further as others repeat his misogynistic ideas.

> A world where everyone is constantly being watched by eachother and reported on is already too authoritarian for me to want to continue living in

I'm sorry and hope you find a way to continue living in this world. And I agree strongly about authoritarian governments.

I don't really think calling out a post on a large mailing list counts as "everyone is constantly being watched by each other" though.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:04AM (#21058602)
> on a university mailing list has direct negative effects for a lot of people.

That very mailing list was about to arbitrarily accuse a dead innocent man of a crime to help provide cover for actual criminals still walking the halls at MIT.

This charade around Stallman is an injustice against Epstein's victims, the decent people at MIT, and Minsky.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by concordDance on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:28AM (#21057431)
> his misogynistic ideas.

I can find nothing that meets this criteria in the above links. Do you have an unusual definition of "misogynistic", were you being rhetorical or do you have another source?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:44AM (#21057522)
Those are terrible starting points.

For the actual background on the current chain of events at MIT:

https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/index.html

For earlier allegations, take the original sources including quotes and references:

https://stallman.org/archives/2006-mar-jun.html

(note: there are many more archives. This also gives you an idea of the effort it must have taken to find those few "damning" posts, and to skew those out of context)

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by donatj on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:17AM (#21056487)
> In 1993, he asked for birth announcements to be banned from emacs mailing list, unless they are announcements for seahorses, because then it would be the male that gives birth and therefore interesting.

I feel like that is pretty sensationalized. The argument being made there is that regular birth is a common thing, and should be left off the list unless it is something out of the ordinary.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:45AM (#21058483)
Selam G. builds weapons for US Department of Defense...

That's not really feminist, isn't it?

> • Co-Principle Investigator for a U.S. Department of Defense SBIR Phase II research contract, prototyping autonomous ground vehicle (AGV) with collection system.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/selam-gano-089895ba

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by cat_plus_plus on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:31PM (#21063698)
What kind of women and does anyone else find it sexist to assume that men will always be the offenders and women the offendees? Programming involves deconstructing complex problems into basic steps while ignoring full real world nuances in order to derive a reasonable abstraction. Like... deconstructing allegations against Minsky into basic aspect (instructed to have sex vs actually had sex, aware of lack of consent or not, aware of age or not, 16 can consent in jurisdiction X year Y or not). Successful programmers trend not super socially aware and often on autism spectrum. So maybe women genuinely interesting in programming would be like Ada Lovelace, a compulsive gambler with messy love life who dreamed of building a computer to beat poker? How long would she last in 2019 MIT?

And if you get alienated from a career path because of one bad professor, go and find something else that you want so badly that you are willing to tough it out. Otherwise you will always blame your professional success limits on people not supporting you enough, or cracking an off-color joke or two or microaggressions. Do you honestly expect to never have to deal with a problem boss/coworkers/customer in a super-competitive private sector job? Don't tell me nurses and schoolteachers never have to deal with someone like RMS or worse. And sure, some degree of bad behavior should have proportional consequences, but do we hear about how women get alienated from these professions en masse?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:37AM (#21058444)
> RMS alienated so many women

[citation needed]

[dead]
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DoreenMichele on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:36PM (#21055957)
Some people are sympathetic for reasons that have nothing whatsoever to do with some cult of celebrity, like being generally fed up with shitty, hypocritical puritanical BS out in the world generally.

That would include me, which is why I'm speaking up: Your comment smears me, though I'm sure you didn't think you were talking about me.

Otherwise, I wouldn't have said anything. I think rehashing this instead of actually discussing the ideas he wrote about is just more disrespectful BS and I hate seeing it.

[dead]
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DoreenMichele on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:42PM (#21055996)
So hang on, you're happy to say that you are leaping to his defence because you're sick of some abstract concept against which you rally rather than the facts of the case himself?

There is nothing whatsoever abstract about the things I'm tired of.

This is neither the time nor place to rehash my criticisms. It wouldn't do any good anyway.

My previous comment was For the record. I don't intend to hash it out with you further in this thread.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:30AM (#21061233)
He's defended based on rational merit and sense of justice.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:23PM (#21056186)
Completely agree.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by luckydata on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:22AM (#21056520)
Agreed, the message is worth spreading and fighting for, the man can go, he's too toxic.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by hinkley on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:35PM (#21056253)
Until the latest stink I wasn't even aware that RMS still had a platform. I haven't heard from him in probably 15 years.

That may be a good thing. FSF isn't about Richard Stallman.

And some of the "kids" that ran him out of town know to keep plants at their desks because it turns out he's kind of a creep around young women, and also afraid of plants. None of that information has anything to do with mailing lists. There is always some reason that gets people to deal with a problem and that reason is often objectively kinda shitty. People overlook it because the problem is finally being addressed.

One of the things that's going on in the current political climate is that it's no longer enough to be a great developer but a horrible human being. Development in the 90's was punctuated by some truly titanic man-children that everyone had to 'put up with' because they were just so good at the rest of their job.

Gates seems to have grown up (I'm curious what Ballmer has been up to). Jobs, god bless him, died of his own stubbornness. They keep Ellison out of the spotlight, as they seem to have done with Stallman. Until he retires that leaves Torvalds (who I hope outlasts Ellison).

I am sure there were points in my life where I could be painted with that brush, and I can say with a bit of authority that we don't need that kind of behavior. And if behavior is tolerated at the top then it's effectively tolerated everywhere.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:52AM (#21057564)
> and also afraid of plants

from someone who actually worked with him:

"p.s.: In the closet-sized "office" Bushnell, McGrath, and I shared for a time we did have some spider plants as part of a running silly joke. They did not actually scare RMS away OF COURSE"

https://archive.is/7qepC

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by concordDance on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:31AM (#21057446)
> There is always some reason that gets people to deal with a problem and that reason is often objectively kinda shitty

The problem is that that reason is the one people think is the reason the problem got dealt with.

It has a nasty chilling effect.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by malvosenior on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:06PM (#21055779)
I don’t think that’s fair to those who had a problem with RMS. Him arguing about peodophilia on a mailing list does nothing at all to help his ideas spread. It takes quite a lot away in fact. What was the purpose of his argument? To defend his friend Minsky? Again, that does nothing to promote free software, it only adds unneeded and negative baggage. That’s bad leadership and bad for RMS’ message.

Yes he had great ideas. They were so great that they exist beyond the man who created them and now benefit from him not being involved.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by jnwatson on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:14PM (#21055833)
So just because he happens to be the president of an organization means he can’t defend his colleague on an unrelated private message board?

The chilling effect of such a policy essentially means that all advocacy groups must be led by slick marketing politicians, always on-point and on-brand, even if off camera.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by malvosenior on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:38PM (#21055968)
If he’s defending his colleague having sex with a 17 year old who had been trafficked for sex since she was 15, then yes I don’t think any president of an organization should do that.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by wander_homer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:08AM (#21057011)
His entire argument was that it was possible that he had no idea that she was a trafficking victim when she approached him, it could have been a regular prostitute from his point of view. However Stallman didn't downplay the harm that's been done to the girl and he didn't rule out the possibility that his friend indeed knew about all of that.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:54AM (#21057577)
> If he’s defending

That's a big "if"

Stallman was reviled not for things he didn't do, but for thoughts he didn't think.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flatb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:08AM (#21060330)
Stallman was reviled because he has been accused, by several independent parties, of, among other things:

-Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office.

-Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

-Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:01AM (#21060916)
> Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office.

Even the initial accusation doesn't try to push the story that far:

"He literally used to have a mattress on the floor of his office. [..] (the mattress was also known to have shirtless people lounging on it…)"

Person has sleeping accommodation in place where he lives (odd thought it may be). Sometimes people use it as chair. No mentions of requests or toplessness.

> -Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

Unsubstantiated: saying something like "I can't imagine life without you" can be interpreted just like that depending on a variety of circumstances. That was also decades ago.

> Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Really now? Incidentally also the only one of your accusations of which there is evidence instead of hearsay or urban legends. Furthermore, "a sign" not "signs".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by _rpaf on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:45PM (#21063819)
How excellent of you to redact the most damning part of your quote of the initial accusation, that literally says:

> He kept the door to his office open, to proudly showcase that mattress and all the implications that went with it. Many female students avoided the corridor with his office for that reason

Now go ahead and tell me it's a coincidence you kept that part out, and it was probably not a big deal, and they were all exaggerating in some inexplicable coordinated effort to be disturbed.

So your arguments basically consist on half-quotes, "it happened long ago, so it isn't true", "unsubstantiated; since there's no recordings of it, he probably just said something nice and was misinterpreted yet again" and "maybe that happened, but since I, a man, who'd never be targeted by his sexual advances, think it's ok, it's ok", completely disregarding the fact that all these accusations have been corroborated by witnesses, ranging from people interviewed on several media and dozens of reports and online comments from people who claim to have worked with him over the years, let alone the several unrelated victims of his "urban legends", and most of all, the fact that people repeatedly let him know about his attitude and he didn't give a damn.

In short, yet another big, somehow coordinated witch hunt by overly sensitive SJWs.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by noobermin on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:51AM (#21068373)
I've been in grad school offices that had cots or bean bags in them. Is the contention in here he explicitly said that "people fuck me in my office" or something as coarse as that? Tbh, the only purpose those beds served was for people to rest on them during late nights working. Now, the issue of course why they need to spend so many late nights at the university working, but that's besides the point.

Btw, you seem to be citing something. Could you share it here?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flatb on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:33PM (#21075743)
Sure. There are plenty of first-hand accounts of his behavior, a quick Google search will lead you to many.

Here's a link to one I've most recently run into from someone who worked at MIT. Yes, it's a Reddit comment, but if you check out his profile you'll see the user's been on the site for 11 years, has close to 140k karma, and has many posts in the past that refer to his professional career.

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/d59r46/richard...

>A lot of people are acting like this is just about the Epstein comments. The MIT community was up in arms not just over that but at the mountain of shit Stallman has gotten away with over the last few decades, including crap like telling female researchers he'd kill himself unless they dated him, keeping a mattress in his office and inviting people to lay topless on it, defending pedophilia and child rape. He's been making women at MIT uncomfortable for years

>I wish there were more to tell but it's exactly what it sounds like. He had a mattress in the corner of his office and he'd leave the door open and if you were a woman who happened to walk by or heaven forbid need to talk to him for academic reasons he would find an excuse to invite you to use it

You'll also find other similar stories on that thread.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:08PM (#21064653)
Of course that's not a coincidence, hence the ellipses of omission. I left out the bits that weren't factual. Even then your "Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office" comes out of nowhere.

"He kept the door open to proudly showcase" could have easily been "He kept to door shut to hide his actions", that is: both cases would be equally damning from the writer's perspective, and hinges only on their "implications that went with it" which are their invention alone.

Facts remaining, he had a mattress in his office. He left his door open. Sometimes people were sitting on the bed.

> "it happened long ago, so it isn't true"

No. It happened a long time ago. People, over time, remember the emotional impact of something on them, but no longer the precise wording. She remembers the gist of someone talking about suicide, because that's what she thought he meant. Without the exact wording and cirumstances, it can be very difficult to figure out what transpired. So it's not "it isn't true" or "she must be lying", but the account is unsubstantiated, likely irretrievably so, because "it happened a long time ago."

> completely disregarding the fact

I don't disregard them, I check them one by one, and so far I found them lacking.

Why are you angry at me for reading what other people said before believing them at face value?

> that all these accusations have been corroborated by witnesses, ranging from people interviewed on several media and dozens of reports and online comments from people who claim to have worked with him over the years, let alone the several unrelated victims of his "urban legends", and most of all, the fact that people repeatedly let him know about his attitude and he didn't give a damn.

Please provide links outside of twitter. So far most accusations lead back to the initial article on medium by Salem G.

> In short, yet another big, somehow coordinated witch hunt by overly sensitive SJWs.

I don't know, and frankly, I don't care. I read the allegations, try to find the various sources, and try to put them into a logical context. I guess I'm simply a Knight for Justice (also: old weirdos)

[dead]
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:34PM (#21073050)
>You are part of the same system that vilifies assault / harassment victims

"I'm out of arguments, so you're just a ..."

Please don't do that.

>by saying accusations are "too old" / "he / she isn't remembering correctly".

It's been nearly a week now. That's a long time for people to come forward with police reports, official complaints, etc. So far there is "Knight for Justice (also: hot ladies)", and, "I hear people have spider plants in their offices to keep him away."

>You have the gall to call anyone who does care SJWs,

I do? Feel free to quote my stuff back at me. I know you won't, because you can't, so you resort to making stuff up about things you hope I would have said.

Please don't make stuff up, it's all there for you to read.

>I guess I didn't expect anything more from you.

I'm sorry if I disappointed you. But I can only start caring the moment someone presents me with something substantial to care about.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:58PM (#21073332)
Church of GNU / Emacs video..."a virgin girl who hasn't used Emacs before". If that isn't alienating then I don't know what is.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:29PM (#21073680)
You are aware that the St. IGNUcius bit is a spoof on dogmatic religion, right?

Maybe that offends you as a religious person, but it's hardly fair to hold that against Stallman whose audiences are usually mainly fellow atheists, or religious people who can tolerate being the subject of a bit of light satire.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @03:33PM (#21074423)
Conveniently ignored "a girl who is a virgin". How frustrating must that be for a girl in the audience.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:55PM (#21076001)
Wondering about your effort to maintain an argument in good faith, I read up a little:

"mav3rick: What about the KoolAid that HN drinks against anything Facebook, Google ?"

"mav3rick: He seems like an out and out terrorist."

I think these are indicative you will say whatever it takes to discredit rms, because he takes a stand against everything you believe in.

You are being dishonest in your motivations. I think I'll conveniently ignore you all together.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by dang on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:24AM (#21078145)
You both have been breaking the site guidelines. Please stop, and please avoid this sort of spat on HN in the future, regardless of how right you are or feel, or how wrong the other person is.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @07:04PM (#21076552)
Nice, attack the person and not the point I made. Did you address the "virgin girl" that RMS uses in his stupid speech.

Even your comments are all pro RMS yet I'm engaging you.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by dang on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:25AM (#21078152)
You both have been breaking the site guidelines. Please stop, and please avoid this sort of spat on HN in the future, regardless of how right you are or feel, or how wrong the other person is.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:26PM (#21074973)
Oh so now it's the audience's fault to not be "tolerant" of RMS' bullshit.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:19PM (#21075621)
Again, please read what I wrote. I'm starting to doubt you are providing an argument in good faith here as you are constantly generalising.

If some religious members of an audience, who are very serious about their faith, go to see a known outspoken atheist, maybe that wasn't the best idea. As far as I know the St. IGNUcius skit is fairly well received in general.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @07:10PM (#21076593)
I don't care about religion. I care about alienating women. The 'virgin girl' bit is clearly gratuitous and peddles gender stereotypes about men in CS.
[dead]
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:43PM (#21073844)
> You get to decide how much time is enough to exonerate someone of all accusations i.e. 1 week

Not at all. Again, something I didn't say or imply. Please make an effort to read what I write, not what you think I wrote (e.g. "That's a long time", empatically not: "That's enough time"). If something substantial comes up at a later time, I will make sure to critically read it.

> You say that other accusations are "too old"

I said that one specific accusation is probably too old to retrieve the exact words and circumstances, and as such can be considered unsubstantiated.

> this is precisely why victims are afraid to come forward in every such case.

What case(s) are you referring to? To put it differently: what, exactly, do you think Stallman is "getting away" with here? And why do you think he's getting away with it?

> No one takes them seriously and in fact vilifies them more than the alleged perpetrator.

That is of course very regrettable, but again, how does Stallman fit in here? You can't just take a person you obviously dislike, ascribe various characteristics and motivations to them, and then rile against that.

> Have fun being a "Knight of RMS", defend him on his most egregious qualities.

I'm not having "fun", and I don't see why you would assume that. I find the whole situation very regrettable.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by denton-scratch on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:56AM (#21061521)
In point of fact, nobody has accused Minsky of having sex with the girl. Well, not anybody who could know. Someone who was there has stated specifically that Minsky turned her down. AFAIK nobody (who could know) has contradicted that.

RMS was simply saying that bullshit was being perpetrated in that CSAIL mailing list, about his dead friend and colleague. If Minsky had been alive, no doubt he'd now be suing.

RMS has been traduced by Selam Jie Gano, Vice and TechCrunch, and goodness knows how many others (the bullshit and distortions seem to be everywhere). I regret that FSF have accepted his resignation; I am now resigning my membership of the FSFE.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by SolaceQuantum on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:24PM (#21055885)
"an unrelated private message board?"

Was this an unrelated private message board? I was under the impression it was on a mailing list at MIT.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ryeights on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:42PM (#21055994)
The list is semi-private, CSAIL-affiliated students and faculty only
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by SolaceQuantum on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:00AM (#21058578)
So not a private message board?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:53PM (#21056354)
Having a leadership position comes with its own checks and balances. RMS isn't special to go over that.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by zaphirplane on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:49PM (#21056031)
you are wording the sentences to create a vague wrong impression Of what transpired

Be specific about what he said that you find abhorrent

This topic is uncomfortable and a lot of people stay out of it or strongly self censor. he didn’t.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by malvosenior on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:05PM (#21056114)
> This topic is uncomfortable and a lot of people stay out of it or strongly self censor. he didn’t.

This is my point. As the president of an organization it’s not your job to make people uncomfortable about things that have nothing to do with that organization’s goals. Debating what is and is not statutory rape is not a discussion that should take place in any professional or technical environment.

This instance is actually even worse than just debating something in the inappropriate context. Epstein is a huge scandal. He raped dozens if not hundreds of girls. He loaned them out to other powerful people. It is within this context that RMS’ statements are most damning. He’s wading in some very murky ethical waters and it should be no surprise he caught a backlash.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:27AM (#21057422)
> As the president of an organization it’s not your job to make people uncomfortable about things that have nothing to do with that organization’s goals.

Did anyone claim it was his job?

> Debating what is and is not statutory rape is not a discussion that should take place in any professional or technical environment.

Why?

> This instance is actually even worse than just debating something in the inappropriate context. Epstein is a huge scandal. He raped dozens if not hundreds of girls. He loaned them out to other powerful people. It is within this context that RMS’ statements are most damning.

Why is that? Does the fact that someone commits a crime make it inappropriate to defend people associated with them against incorrect accusations? How do you square that with the rule of law?

> He’s wading in some very murky ethical waters and it should be no surprise he caught a backlash.

He also should not be surprised that he gets a lot of opposition for promoting free software ... so, supposedly, he should not promote free software either?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by zaphirplane on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:45AM (#21057842)
Rms is an extreme proponent of freedom, the GNU software aspect is part of his larger beliefs. While not a follower most of what I hear is him talking from a freedom angle. Censorship limits his freedom

I can’t comment on the rest of your point because again you talk about the horror of the crime and it’s not clear what of what he said or did you find abhorrent

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by malvosenior on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:24AM (#21059855)
I said exactly what I find abhorrent. He should not have addressed this topic at all.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by knolax on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:28PM (#21056218)
I saw a tweet on Mastodon that claimed Git was a "major barrier for people of color" or some other nonsense. Meritocracy is dying here.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by pzone on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @01:29AM (#21056845)
That kind of talk always seems downright racist to me.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by htns on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:21PM (#21055874)
Yeah, I wouldn't put anything under a "GPL or any later version" for the time being.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by harry8 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:13AM (#21057039)
Writing anyone or any organisation a blank cheque is problematic. Even if they are perfection personified now, will they be in the future? Will it be run by none of the same people? Will they have an entirely different agenda to the one you agree with?

If you can't know these things with sufficient certainty, definitely pick your license. Then only change it deliberately for your own purposes with your own goals and ideals driving it.

Devils advocate: maybe gpl will never have a later version you could possibly disagree with as it's too important to too many people just like you.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by new_realist on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:06PM (#21055780)
OSS predates Stallman, and will outlast him. His contributions are overstated, as is the benefit of Free Software, generally, as compared to more permissive licenses.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mistrial9 on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:50PM (#21056037)
I met with Stallman once, in a room of two dozen people, around Stanford in 1987 or so .. I can tell you the "OSS" or whatnot you are referring to, existed in a very different world then. Stallman had a twenty minute talk, which was a strict and tightly worded explanation of the significance and reasoning behind his proposals. It was very much the utter opposite of a two line throw-away judge-and-jury declaration of conclusion, as seen above.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flippinburgers on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:17PM (#21055855)
Free Software is transparent science. I don't see how you could argue that the benefit is overstated. Ideas are built on one another and that is precisely how advancements are made. What he pushes for is extremely important.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by garmaine on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:51PM (#21056045)
The term “open source software” was invented by Christine Peterson in 1998 (edit: thanks!) to distinguish from GPL-style free software.

Open source (inclusive of both) never really had any traction outside a few limited domains until the GNU project.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by schoen on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:49PM (#21056321)
> invented by Christine Peterson in the early 90’s to distinguish from GPL-style free software

Invented by Christine Peterson in the 90s, yes (though it was 1998); to distinguish from GPL-style, no. The Open Source Initiative immediately listed the GPL as an Open Source license, and the FSF had already described permissive licensing as free software (as distinct from copyleft licensing).

https://web.archive.org/web/19980119061702/http://www.fsf.or...

> The X Window System illustrates this. The X Consortium releases X11 with distribution terms that make it non-copylefted free software. If you wish, you can get a copy which has those distribution terms and is free. However, there are non-free versions as well, and there are popular workstations and PC graphics boards for which non-free versions are the only ones that work. If you are using this hardware, X11 is not free software for you.

https://web.archive.org/web/19981201223102/http://www.openso...

> GIMP

> Gnome

> Linux

> Open Source is a marketing program for free software. It's a pitch for `free software' on solid pragmatic grounds rather than ideological tub-thumping. The winning substance has not changed, the losing attitude and symbolism have.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ekianjo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:07AM (#21056435)
If it's a marketing name, it completely misses the essential point that it's about Freedom, not the "open" part of it.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by schoen on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:47PM (#21062104)
That's what FSF and OSI most disagreed about at the time!
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ekianjo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:01PM (#21064020)
Yeah, and it's a relevant point to disagree on :-)
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by schoen on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:28PM (#21064819)
Absolutely!
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by UserIsUnused on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:22AM (#21058011)
>losing attitude Good ways to talk.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by ekianjo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:06AM (#21056431)
> OSS predates Stallman

If you are talking about the term OSS, then you are completely wrong. It came long after "Free Software" was coined and was named differently to mark a different movement.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by msla on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:25PM (#21055890)
> His contributions are overstated, as is the benefit of Free Software, generally, as compared to more permissive licenses.

That's certainly what companies which made their fortunes out of taking software out of the commons and turning it into products want people to think. Enough programmers don't want to be turned into unpaid employees that copyleft licenses have substantial uptake.

Also:

> OSS predates Stallman, and will outlast him.

... refusing to see a distinction between OSS and Free Software? Neat rhetorical trick.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by msla on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:08PM (#21084953)
The downvotes without replies are proof I've hit a nerve, and am saying things others cannot stand because they cannot refute them.