News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:23PM (#21056183)
You are okay forgiving people as long as their "net impact" is positive? Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:37PM (#21056266)
In general, yes. Murder is a very peculiar case that is hardly suitable to be the benchmark for building our intuitions about trading off harm in general: human lives are not fungible, murder is not reversible, the victims do not generally get a meaningful way of influencing how the murder impacts them etc., all properties that do not apply in the case of being put off a pursuit like FOSS. (Even then, we're sometimes okay accepting murder to save more lives: e.g. the Allies' actions in WWII are considered a heroic even with nearly a century of historical distance) Arguably, the progressive argument for {affirmative action, inverted burden of proof in Title IX, ...} also amounts to "accept some harm if the net impact is positive"; few people claim that these policies will not result in some people being rejected from positions they deserve or punished for crimes they did not commit.

Some countries are more explicit about this and actually constitutionally single out matters of life and death as being prohibited from being traded off against each other (e.g. Germany), i.e. the state is not allowed to play in trolley problems. The corollary is that the state, and most everyone, finds it okay to trade off other harms: you can for instance choose to build an airport that will drive down the value of some people's homes and expose them to considerable noise in order to give convenience and good business to a large number of people. I think discouraging some women from participating in FOSS is much closer in quality of harm to "your home is now worth half as much and you have to put up with the noise of planes flying overhead everyday" than "you die a painful and untimely death".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:42AM (#21056632)
Also notice how it is almost always okay for "women" to be discouraged and counted as collateral damage. The fact that you do that tells me a lot.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:42AM (#21058883)
> Also notice how it is almost always okay for "women" to be discouraged and counted as collateral damage.

Quote one person in this thread who said that it wouldn't be ok if it affected men instead. Or just one person implying that.

You're assuming a lot here. If anything, I think it's likely less people would care if a bunch of men were alienated, since there's already so many of them in the field in the first palce.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:41AM (#21058463)
> "women" to be discouraged and counted as collateral damage

this never happened though.

According not to me, but to Thomas Lord (if you don't know who he is, go and check)

> One remarkable thing about the FSF at that time, when we worked out of dinky spare offices on the campus of MIT, was the degree of participation by women. In the tiny society that was then the FSF, women were more prominent than I had seen in Silicon Valley, or acadamia prior.

https://archive.is/7qepC

And it says a lot about the amount of fabrication going around.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:50PM (#21056329)
Wow I've seen everything on HN to protect RMS. The Allies action was to counter gratuitous aggression and persecution of large swathes of people. Are you telling me RMS has had the same experiences in his life to warrant his egregious behavior ?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:57PM (#21056375)
I don't think my leap from murder to war was greater than your leap from some gauche remarks during a talk in the '90s and a handful of emails lawyering about word choice that might have put some people off working in the speaker's discipline to murder. Other than that, what exactly is your point? At no point did I imply that rms's life history should be compared to the Allied intervention in Europe; I merely brought it up as as an example that proves there is no such thing as a universally accepted rule against trading off murders and people saved.

("Wow, I've seen everything on HN to attack RMS. (...)")

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by mav3rick on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:41AM (#21056623)
If any other person did this, especially someone from FAANG etc. you'll be out with your pitchforks. The double standard is so real.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:52AM (#21058980)
Let's accuse strangers of double standards based on our assumption of how they'd act. That seems like a constructive way to have a discussion!
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:13AM (#21061052)
I do want FAANG to threaten me that they will kill themselves if I don't go on a date with them.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by pjmlp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:37AM (#21057163)
That is what armies happen to do all the time.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flatb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:01AM (#21060232)
Can you explain, in general, how armies and war are ethically relevant to Richard Stallman threatening coworkers to kill himself if they don't go on dates with him, or asking them to lay down topless on a mattress in his office?
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by pjmlp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:06AM (#21060305)
I was answering to "Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?".

Armies don't have much issue with that ethical question.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by donatj on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:04AM (#21056418)
Yes? lol. Why does everything always come to the Trolley Problem?

I think anyone who was ever in favor of any war would agree that sometimes a death is justified when it saves many more?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by JamisonM on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:20AM (#21056505)
It is not the Trolley Problem, you seem to misunderstand the issue. There is no binary choice here, it is not comparable.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by 4bpp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:44AM (#21056645)
There is one: (1) let Stallman keep his position and inspire/encourage one set of people, while discouraging/putting off another; (2) remove Stallman from his position, foregoing both the inspiration/encouragement and the discouragement/putting off.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by donatj on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:53AM (#21056681)
> Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?

That is a yes or no question. That is literally a binary choice. Yes or no - is murder OK if that murder saves more than one person.

That is literally the Trolley Problem.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by bitofhope on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:53AM (#21057872)
That wasn't really the question, though. There was nothing there about saving lives _by_ murdering someone. It's more like "is it ok do do bad things if you've built up good karma beforehand by doing more good stuff".
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by DarkWiiPlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:59AM (#21059031)
Nope. That's a strawman right there.

The question is, is it acceptable to tolerate someones bad deeds because the benefits of doing so is greater than the harm.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by JamisonM on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @03:56PM (#21074639)
It is not the Trolley Problem because the literal question is "Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before?" and that is not the Trolley Problem, that is the "letting someone off the hook for present and future misdeeds based on past good acts."

It just isn't the same thing.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by knolax on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:31PM (#21056239)
That's not a good analogy because murder are both one time actions. Punishing a murderer who saved before doesn't prevent more people from being saved. A more apt example would be granting clemency to a highly talented surgeon specialized in an operation nobody else can do.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:39AM (#21058453)
> Is it okay for someone to murder a person if they saved more than one life before ?

Murder is a crime.

Where is the crime here?

It is ok to let go a "fuck you" if that persons did good before.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by flatb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:57AM (#21060187)
> Where is the crime here? The analogy is between a good thing not cancelling out a bad thing. The police are not involved. There isn't a crime. He has been pressured for making people very uncomfortable in pursuit of his sexual interests, which is a perfectly good reason to reprieve someone.

He has been accused, by several independent parties, of, among other things:

-Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office.

-Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

-Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by lostjohnny on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:12PM (#21061695)
> He has been accused, by several independent parties, of, among other things:

Who, exactly?

> -Asking female coworkers to lay down topless on a mattress in his office. > -Threatening a colleague to kill himself if he/she didn't go on a date with him.

Sooooo, your entire analysis is based on legends circulating since the 90s about a weird man who was even told to be scared by plants?

For reference, Thomas Lord, creator of GNU arch (think about Git before Git), who worked for FSF for a long time said

    One remarkable thing about the FSF at that time, when we worked out of dinky spare offices on the campus of MIT, was the degree of participation by women. In the tiny society that was then the FSF, women were more prominent than I had seen in Silicon Valley, or acadamia prior. 


    p.s.: In the closet-sized "office" Bushnell, McGrath, and I shared for a time we did have some spider plants as part of a running silly joke. They did not actually scare RMS away **OF COURSE** and he usually had helpful criticism and advice of our efforts, from my point of view. 
> -Posting up signs in his workplace along the lines of "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)".

Can you tell an inside joke when you see one?

p.s. all of us have being young and done some innocent stupid shit, the kinds young people do, like having stupid signs on the door. It doesn't make any of us a criminal.

[dead]
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by craigsmansion on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:07AM (#21068770)
> your narrative of sexism in the software industry being a mostly made-up issue

Is this what this is all about? Stallman has approximately 0 sway in the "software industry".

I'm sure it is a real problem, but Stallman is neither the cause nor the solution to it. I would look into how paying high salaries for unethical work would attract abusive people, and one shouldn't want to work in those industries in the first place.