We have ongoing human rights violations in the US. I'm not saying The United States is on equal moral footing with The People's Republic of China. I'm saying that both have a terrible track record, and claiming one is vastly superior is a reflection of your nationalism.
Having been in both the US and China, I cannot think of more similar countries at the individual level for day to day activities, and when comparing local district governments. People still want to eat, get rich, and be happy, all as conveniently as possible, with minimal obvious intrusion from others. Only above that (and the US constitution is definitely a federal-level document) are there noticeable differences.
It's a real shame, there is a lot of innovation on both sides that would be wonderful to combine. Hong Kong is missing its chance by focusing on its conglomerates.
I don't know how good you know about Chinese government. But I think you made a mistake about the purpose of the investment and building by Chinese gov. The rail network is not "for the public good", at least it's not the major reason. It's for keeping GDP growth rate looks as high as possible otherwise no one/country can buy the over-produced industrial products like concrete and steels after subprime mortgage crisis.
> The assumption you're making here is that democracy is the better more "modern" way.
Democracy is not perfect but I am sure CCP is much worse.
This is Debate-able. If it's worse, it's not that much worse.
>I don't know how good you know about Chinese government. But I think you made a mistake about the purpose of the investment and building by Chinese gov. The rail network is not "for the public good", at least it's not the major reason. It's for keeping GDP growth rate looks as high as possible otherwise no one/country can buy the over-produced industrial products like concrete and steels after subprime mortgage crisis.
Isn't improving GDP a public good? What's better in your opinion? Bailing out a bank and letting the execs go on a vacation or building rail infrastructure?
But I get what you're saying. I would say for public rails it's both GDP and helping people move across the country. Cities with rail are way more efficient than cities without.
Public works projects happen all the time here. This is such a silly argument.
> No whataboutism will change the fact that it is controversial whether democracy or centralized control is better.
No, it's not.
Is there actual statistics? The only source I found is from GlobalTimes which is clearly a mouth piece for China. The numbers also seem to be self reported. I trust it less than I trust the GDP numbers from China.
Safe is one thing. But what happens if you do get into trouble. Do you trust the authorities there? Last I heard, even the police chief has unknown sources of income.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2019/08/14/chinese-poli...
So it’s one thing to say it’s safe. But when in trouble, I still trust the system elsewhere.
All mentions to homosexuality in criminal law were removed in 1997. In 2001, the Chinese Society of Psychiatry declassified homosexuality as a mental disorder. However, such change is yet to be reflected by the regulations of National Health and Family Planning Commission,[20] a government branch that controls all regulations of health care services in China, which has resulted in psychiatric facilities and psychiatry education textbooks across the country still de facto considering homosexuality as a mental disorder and continuing to offer conversion therapy treatments.[1][21][22] Transgender identity is still classified as a disorder despite laws allowing legal gender changes.
Also from this story https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/2097292/why-...
A 2013 Pew Global Attitudes Project survey found that 57 per cent of those polled in China believed that society should not accept homosexuality
CCCP?
> China does not have freedom of speech but in a way neither does the US.
A radical and undefended claim. In what way is this true? You never say.
> did edward snowden have freedom?
Yes he did. Then he broke the law and ran away from the consequences of his actions.
> It's just another regime.
A single-party regime with no term limits on executive power is a stark contrast with a representative democratic federation designed with a multitude of checks and balances on its own power structures.
> you still have to use the products that China made for you because you as a country do not have the technical ability to manufacture the same products
False choice between Chinese products & domestic. No reasonable person believes that China is the sole manufacturing presence on Earth. There are a multitude of other options. China, however, does need the US -- the largest free market on the planet.
> Just like how the slaughter of millions of people by the nuclear bomb dropped on hiroshima by the united states does not define the united states as a country, neither do the protests of hong kong define China.
Those two things are indeed important, defining characteristics of the two countries you describe. One of them was an act of world war decades ago. The other is current events, the result of an illegal act of oppression by a dystopian communist state, heavily indicative of what China is today.
Right and the government is paying me to say this on HN of all places.
>A radical and undefended claim. In what way is this true? You never say.
I thought this was obvious. Snowden did not have freedom of speech to reveal that the government was spying on its own citizens. You do not have the freedom of speech to threaten others. You do not have the freedom of speech to lie and slander about someone, it is literally in the law and people can sue you for this. Literally the law in the united states controls your speech using the justification of "security." China uses the exact same excuse. Is it a valid excuse? in both cases, I'm not sure. Definitely the US is more lax on these laws then China overall, but the atrocities done by the US on snowden is only one aspect of a country and it does not define the entire regime or its people.
>A single-party regime with no term limits on executive power is a stark contrast with a representative democratic federation designed with a multitude of checks and balances on its own power structures.
Right, vs. a government where people in power can (and are regularly) bribed with corporate money. Checks and balances in the united states is a check written as a bribe with a balance of over a million.
>Those two things are indeed important, defining characteristics of the two countries you describe. One of them was an act of world war decades ago. The other is current events, the result of an illegal act of oppression by a dystopian communist state, heavily indicative of what China is today.
Yeah the wholesale slaughter of millions of innocent civilians during wartime is excused with a couple of decades vs. a fucking protest happening right now can't be excused and must be used to define an entire nation and its people. That's not the point. The point, is the united states was never defined entirely by the bomb. You still are a country separate in culture and identity from a nuclear bomb or imperfections within the government.
China is largely the same thing. However because they are economic rivals with the US the media largely magnifies the things they do. You really need to go and live their to see that it's not as horrible as the media makes it out to be.
The LGBT person above feared for his life. That's next level brain washing right there.
Straw man. No one has accused you of this.
> You do not have the freedom of speech to threaten others.
You have defined freedom of speech in a way that merely assists your argument. No one should expect the freedom you describe.
> Checks and balances in the united states is a check written as a bribe
Undefended baseless hyperbolic claim.
> slaughter of millions of innocent civilians during wartime is excused with a couple of decades
Straw man. I made it clear that this act is definitive of the USA just as Chinese government's present day actions are definitive of it.
> The LGBT person above feared for his life. That's next level brain washing right there.
No idea what you're talking about.
In summary, your thread rapidly devolved into a political flame war, I am sorry to have ever engaged with you, and I am done now.
Wow, if you regret engaging why the heck do you have to engage again then run away with your tail between your legs.
>Straw man. I made it clear that this act is definitive of the USA just as Chinese government's present day actions are definitive of it.
If this action defines you then you need to be executed. Literally for the murder of thousands. It's a war crime. Be glad it doesn't define the country or you.
>Undefended baseless hyperbolic claim.
Like your entire argument.
>You have defined freedom of speech in a way that merely assists your argument. No one should expect the freedom you describe.
I have defined it the way it's defined in english. If no one expects the freedom then there is no freedom in the first place. Your definition of freedom is a very specific subset, exacting and detailed, while mine is literally the dictionary definition of freedom and speech.
>Straw man. No one has accused you of this.
You literally said that I'm spreading propaganda rather than my opinions as if I'm trying to deliberately manipulate. Governments usually do this hence it's assumed that's what you implied. Either way, if anything your insidious response is probably what caused this whole thread to devolve into a flame war.
You aren't done. You never will be. I'm the one done with you, permanently.
Stop using the term strawman when your entire argument is a strawman.
Stalin took the USSR from an pre-industrial economy to an industrial superpower in a couple of decades.
I do not consider either Stalin or the USSR an exemplar, but many people said very similar things about the Soviet Union, as you are saying about China, but I don't think history has validated the idea it was an exemplar.
"A brain needs washing if there is a problem, just as clothes need washing if they're dirty and a kidney needs washing if it's sick," said Jiang Yudui, chairman of the Beijing-friendly China Civic Education Promotion Association of Hong Kong, according to news reports. Jiang's comments in July came at the same time that tens of thousands, including many parents pushing their children in strollers, took to the streets to protest against the plan.
No I do not. That's just what you teach to your citizens. When the US took over Puerto Rico, kids there damn well learned English, the American history, the national anthem, and the star spangled banner in school. Do you call that assimilation? Or is that OK because it's the US that did it?
If that's not assimilation, then I have no clue what the term means.
> "Or is that OK because it's the US that did it? "
If your argument relies on all Americans being hypocritical sycophants of the American government, it's a bad argument. Criticism of America is mainstream in America. One can be American and be critical of the American government, just as one can be Chinese and be critical of the Chinese government. In fact there is ample reason for both to be critical of both.
EDIT: Actually do not call it assimilation. Learning Mandarin as a shared language does not mean eradicating Cantonese, and most Hongkongers are ethnic Chinese and share much of the same culture, there's nothing to assimilate.
Wiki: Cultural assimilation is the process in which a minority group or culture comes to resemble a dominant group[1] or assume the values, behaviors, and beliefs of another group.
Mandarin is a dialect, just like Cantonese.
China has been actively trying to eradicate Cantonese but mainly backfired. In Guangdong, no less.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guangzhou_Television_Cantone...
So yes, it is assimilation when you force your dialect on others.
> most Hongkongers are ethnic Chinese and share much of the same cultuRe
I beg to differ. Mao destroyed a lot of cultural relics during the Cultural Revolution. Things that used to be wide spread such as idol worshiping is no longer seen in China and only in Hong Kong. Hong Kong resembles more of the traditional China culture than China does today.
Mandarin in Hong Kong as far as I know would've been strictly in addition to, not instead of Cantonese, much like learning English in Quebec.
So again, not assimilation.
> Mao destroyed a lot of cultural relics during the Cultural Revolution.
The relics may have been destroyed, but (most of) the people lived, some still living. Culture doesn't die with the relics, it lives with the people.
> Things that used to be wide spread such as idol worshiping is no longer seen in China
It's certainly less wide spread now, especially in big cities. But it's still common in small towns and villages. Dive deeper next time you visit China.
I would have to disagree with this. Those people are in their 70s now. And without relics, there is no anchor for cultural values.
Cambodia did the same thing and it has been a disaster to their culture.
The destruction of the relics was on purpose. Hence “cultural” revolution.
> its stated goal was to preserve 'true' Communist ideology in the country by purging remnants of capitalist and traditional elements from Chinese society, and to re-impose Mao Zedong Thought as the dominant ideology within the Party
It was a deliberate attack on Chinese culture to solidify Maos power.
Your statement sounds too much like marketing speak without any substance. I think I heard it before. Oh yeah: Thor Ragnorak. It is low effort.
Relics without the people are pretty meaningless. There's very little you can learn about the ancient Egyptian culture even with all the preserved relics.
Sadly we lose tradition, heritage, and culture with the passing of every person. That's universal, Cultural Revolution or not, east or west. But personally I've seen new relics and artifacts recreated after the end of Cultural Revolution, so all is not lost.
> Your statement sounds too much like marketing speak without any substance. I think I heard it before. Oh yeah: Thor Ragnorak.
Well if it's cliche it's only because it's true. BTW never saw that movie, or any of the recent Marvel junk.
Give me a break dude. Are you free to criticize your government or not? I freely criticize mine, and you should do the same.
But we are talking about Hong Kong here. And it has been a model of restraint here, if you are being honest with yourself.
Puerto Rico is a poor example, especially since they seem to want to be inducted into the U.S. officially as a state! Hong Kong does not seem to share the same sentiment with Beijing.
No it is not. It's only assimilation if you aim to wipe out the local language and culture and replace them with your own.
So it's not assimilation in either case, Puerto Rico or Hong Kong, as the US did not attempt to eradicate Spanish, nor is China trying to eradicate Cantonese.
People who accuse China of assimilation are surely smart enough to know the difference. The thing is, they have already made up their minds, China is evil no matter what it does.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puerto_Rico
History does tend to repeat itself, doesn't it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statehood_movement_in_Puerto_R...
And don't put gibberish Cantonese scripts as an example, it's called 白字 which means illiterate writing style. You can type that online in forums and IM, SMS to friends but it's not something official nor standard. Should Ebonics be taught in schools instead of standard English?
Spoken Cantonese is a different language from spoken Mandarin, with different grammar and vocabulary, and when you write them down you get correspondingly different written languages. That written Cantonese hasn't undergone a formal standardization the way Mandarin did in the early 20th century doesn't make written Cantonese gibberish, just not fully standardized. And written Cantonese isn't only used for memeing on forums or text-speak, it's also widely used for casual writing in newspaper columns or in advertisement, or to authentically transcribe spoken Cantonese (rather than paraphrasing in Mandarin). See also:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Written_Cantonese
https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/index.php?s=written+ca...
[Edit: That kids were (and perhaps are) taught to read and write in Mandarin at school using Cantonese sound values, rather than writing in Cantonese, also doesn't say all that much about Cantonese as a written language. Rather, it demonstrates that Hong Kong is a diglossic (well, polyglossic) society.]
Completely wrong. A Chinese character is more or less equivalent to a word in English/French. Are all the words the same in English and French? Can you look at French text and know what it's saying if you didn't speak French already? Someone who speaks only Cantonese can read and understand text written by Mandarin speakers without any issue. The reverse is less true, see below.
> Spoken Cantonese is a different language from spoken Mandarin, with different grammar and vocabulary, and when you write them down you get correspondingly different written languages.
Wrong again. They use largely the same grammar and vocabulary.
Because Cantonese is ancient Chinese, over the years they have lost track of what semantic characters to use for some of the Cantonese words.
Tracking down which semantic character corresponds to which Cantonese word could be done if there's enough interest and funding for such work. Once the mapping is done, you will be able to write down Cantonese and have it understood all over China.
Since the work hasn't been done, you can only write down Cantonese with the help of some phonetic characters, which denote only pronunciation but not meaning. It's not gibberish, but neither is it proper written Cantonese. EDIT: Even in its current form, written Cantonese is still 80% intelligible to Mandarin speakers.
Most Chinese characters are monosyllabic, and most Chinese words are polysyllabic consisting of multiple characters. A Chinese character is a morpheme, and it also happens that many common words are also single character morphemes.
> Someone who speaks only Cantonese can read and understand text written by Mandarin speakers without any issue.
Because we've all been taught to read and write in Mandarin from the very beginning of our education. Again, Hong Kong is a diglossic society.
> They use largely the same grammar and vocabulary. Because Cantonese is ancient Chinese, over the years they have lost track of what semantic characters to use for some of the Cantonese words.
They share a lot of grammar and vocabulary (...but not all of it) because they share a language ancestor. Cantonese is not ancient Chinese, but it's a descendant that conserved a lot more consonants than Mandarin (and a lot of sound merger is actually happening right now in Hong Kong over the last 100 years, but it's commonly derided as "lazy sound").
> Once the mapping is done, you will be able to write down Cantonese and have it understood all over China. Since the work hasn't been done, you can only write down Cantonese with the help of some phonetic characters, which denote only pronunciation but not meaning. It's not gibberish, but neither is it proper written Cantonese.
See [https://books.google.ca/books?id=pFnP_FXf-lAC&pg=PA51] for a description of common strategies for writing Cantonese. Phonetic borrowing is one strategy, and the most common one, yes, but that's no different than characters in standard Chinese, the vast majority of which are a radical with a semantic category (but not a complete meaning) + a phonetic component.
A Mandarin-only speaker can decide for themselves how intelligible that colloquial Cantonese exchange on page 52 is, what with the difference in vocabulary and grammar.
Most modern Chinese words are polysyllabic, but these words are the same in Cantonese and Mandarin. Your comparison to English and French is still false.
> > Someone who speaks only Cantonese can read and understand text written by Mandarin speakers without any issue.
> Because we've all been taught to read and write in Mandarin from the very beginning of our education.
I doubt that. Suppose you were only ever taught written Cantonese. I believe you'd still be able to read Mandarin writings, simply because you would still recognize all the words.
> They share a lot of grammar and vocabulary
So they are not so different after all.
> Phonetic borrowing is one strategy, and the most common one, yes, but that's no different than characters in standard Chinese, the vast majority of which are a radical with a semantic category (but not a complete meaning) + a phonetic component.
Phonetic borrowing, or other ways of making up new characters, might not have been necessary. If we could be bothered to trace the origin of a made-up Cantonese character and find the original Chinese character.
For example, 冇 is wholly unnecessary when we already have 無.
Even with the lazy approach of making up Cantonese specific characters willy nilly, I counted only dozens of them from the Wikipedia article you linked. So how different is Cantonese really from Mandarin, besides the pronunciation?
However, spewing blatant lies about your own language, culture, or heritage invites only ridicule and scorn from honest people who know any about Hong Kong and China.
Is there anything I said that's factually untrue? Or are you afraid of the truth?
The treaty is dead. The people still in the streets have other agendas that have nothing to do with rebelling against "assimilation".
Here is that agenda, also known as the 5 demands:
1. Kill the extradition bill. Done.
2. Retract use of the word “riot” to classify the protests.
3. Release and drop charges for protesters who have been arrested.
4. An inquiry into the widespread, well documented police brutality.
5. Universal suffrage.
In other words, they want their right to peacefully protest & vote for their leaders. To claim they have such rights already would be to ignore their words and their plight entirely.
https://www.vox.com/world/2019/8/22/20804294/hong-kong-prote...
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/59nbp5/hong-kong-stabbing...
Uninformed opinions are cheap, StarTrek is fun, downvoting is easy. But the truth, that pesky truth, is just so darn inconvenient...