News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by user_50123890 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:48AM (#20996618)
Not just open-source maintainers but also moderators.

A bad thing about moderators is that nowadays they tend to be immature teens, it's one of the reasons Reddit content quality has been going down in the past few years.

It also creates some moral questions, as companies with giant revenues are outsourcing their internet janitor duties to naive unpaid child labourers

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by drei109 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:55AM (#20996714)
In my experience with moderators on Reddit, is that they are power driven adults who still act like teens.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by rhizome on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:57PM (#20997400)
It's the Stanford problem, but not everybody succumbs to the allure of power. We see it pretty much everywhere, like on IRC, where power-madness is an expected consequence of giving someone ops in a channel. You win some and you lose some, moderation isn't "set it and forget it," you have to remove some and acquire others from time to time.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by mrmuagi on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @05:39PM (#21000352)
> moderation isn't "set it and forget it," you have to remove some and acquire others from time to time.

A great point. Succinctly, the moderators need moderators.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by falcolas on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:37PM (#20997200)
The sad thing about aging - the body and mind (metaphysical mind, not the brain itself) don't necessarily age at the same rate.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by moron4hire on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @02:19PM (#20998417)
When I first got on the internet 20 years ago, moderators were all teens, too. But I didn't notice because I was also a teenager. Then I grew up, and those mods for too, and we all went on to different things. Going back to the forums, it's just a different set of teens. It was always immature. What changed was that I matured.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by jen_h on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:20PM (#20996997)
I think (mainstream) Reddit content is something completely different; more like big clumps of PR firms employed by corporations and lobbying groups bitbotting around with nation states, all fighting and agreeing with each other and trying to build false consensus. Source IP analysis there is probably pretty interesting.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by jamiequint on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:26PM (#20997071)
Yeah, that's not even remotely true.

Have you ever worked with a PR firm or talked to folks that work at one. Have you ever worked at a large company, or talked to people who manage social media at one? They are very far from this level of coordination. Most can't even manage to deploy a properly measured ad campaign, much less some kind of op sec driven Reddit content campaign.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by michaelt on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:44PM (#20997262)
It's possible 99% of PR/marketing firms don't have armies of Reddit/Twitter bot accounts, while at the same time the 1% that do make up a big power base on Reddit.

There are plenty of companies doing things like SEO and suchlike that build up networks of websites/content farms, and bots to comment on blogs and suchlike. Not much of a jump from bots commenting links on blogs to bots commenting more subtle messages on Reddit.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by jamiequint on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:37PM (#21001990)
There is no 1% of PR firms that have Reddit/Twitter bot armies, that's a crazy conspiracy theory.

There are also plenty of companies that are "doing things like SEO" but none of them run networks of interconnected websites that they all control or content farms because those tactics stopped fooling Google over a decade ago.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by notduncansmith on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:36PM (#20997178)
This. You don’t need to orchestrate mob-like behavior on Reddit, it’s already full of people who like mobbing. The most outside interference you need is (maybe) privately stoking a few radicals to action and letting them inspire the rest of the mob.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by mopsi on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:53PM (#20997354)
I believe redesign is the single largest contributor to Reddit's decline. It went from text-based site (like HN is at the moment) to image-based site.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by jen_h on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @02:00PM (#20998185)
You can get around this, though via https://old.reddit.com and, in Preferences, disable thumbnails, image previews, and "allow subreddits to show me custom themes."
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by mopsi on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @03:59PM (#20999441)
Sadly, that doesn't change how others see the site: they're still guided towards consuming and contributing image-based content.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by onemoresoop on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @05:09PM (#21000112)
You can get around it for now. They may pull the plug
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by nitwit005 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:15PM (#20997614)
I assumed from the headline that this would be about moderators. Given how major sites depend on them, and how many forums there are strewn about the internet, the total man years of free labor must be enormous.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by volkk on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:56AM (#20996717)
i see your point, but it also brings about something like where certain people see quality degrading, and go off to make their own subreddit/community like /r/truereddit or /r/truetruereddit, etc.

it's an interesting phenomenon and am curious as to whether its better this way, or actually making things worse.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by TheCapn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:14PM (#20996931)
I think if things worked purely that way and everything was completely transparent it would be fine but there's a few things that muddy the waters

1) Moderators create alternate accounts and gobble up offshoots. They'll either have multiple mod accounts so they can "step down" and pass power to themselves when opinion rallies against them or they straight up seed themselves throughout reddit as moderators to dozens of communities

2) How do you spread the word when moderators have final word on what's posted in the "main" subreddit? Say there's an uprising in some obscure fandom and fans want a new place to correlate outside of the moderator's rule; how do they spread the word to the community efficiently that they exist when there's only one main hub for that fandom currently and the moderators silence anything (often with the AutoMod) that reference the new community?

---

I think public moderation in general is good. But the tools for the community to branch out are often lacking and when moderator power-tripping crosses a line there's no outlet for members to reach Admins who will objectively weigh the facts and act on complaints.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by helpPeople on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:13PM (#20996921)
Or worse, a corporation secretly pays mods to let spam pass and delete dissent.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by cheez on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:07PM (#20996854)
Edit: very interesting that this post is getting downvoted. I didn't even say anything controversial, just that banning people is bad. Exactly the danger we face online, which will eventually get into broader society.

I got banned on a platform for saying a public figure was physically attractive to me. Prior to that, I had engaged in a perfectly factual discussion about certain statistics that were in favor of a particular political position. There is no doubt in my mind that I was flagged for having a political position (to clarify: I didn't actually have the position, I was just posting statistics that supported that position).

I like HN's approach to moderation. You don't ban the person unless they are really unreasonable. You flag the comment, disappear it from the thread and tell them to behave. I also like Gab's approach which is: if it's not illegal and you don't like it, then just block them from your feed.

The wholesale banning of people for single statements that are generally taken out of context is emblematic of cancel culture and it isn't surprising to me that "hacker news" is more nuanced and understands that people are not one statement or one act.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:14PM (#20997593)
> I like HN's approach to moderation. You don't ban the person unless they are really unreasonable. You flag the comment, disappear it from the thread and tell them to behave.

That does happen, but HN also silently rate-limits and downrates comments for people that have been flagged as troublemakers by the mods.

I'm currently rate-limited on HN to no more than five comments in a period of, I think, several hours. Trying to post more often produces a cryptic error message that I honestly thought was a bug. I eventually messaged the mods and was told that I must have done something disruptive (they couldn't tell me what) and they'd restore my privileges if I'd promise to stop doing that (which I can't do in good conscience without knowing what "it" was). I received no warning before this began.

They said the obfuscation was necessary because, if I were a troll or a spammer, I'd just create a new account or three if I realized I was being restricted.

I don't claim to be a perfect commenter. I know I've let emotion get the better of me on occasion, and it's fair to want to rein that in. But I think it's clear from my history that I'm posting in good faith, at the very least. Treating me like a malicious abuser benefits no one.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by cheez on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:34PM (#20997856)
Interesting. I guess I haven't yet gone against the opinions of the moderators so I haven't yet faced this problem.

I guess gab is the way to go. Block others from your view if you disagree, not from the platform.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by teddyh on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:56PM (#20998127)
I am, I have come to believe, in the exact same situation as you, except that I have never contacted the moderators. My account is even almost exactly the same age as your account. It’s very disheartening to hear that contacting the moderators, which I have considered doing, will apparently accomplish nothing.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @03:01PM (#20998894)
It's worth a try, anyway. You might get a different mod with a different response, or you might be okay with making a non-specific promise to behave better.

(The error I get is "You're posting too fast. Please slow down. Thanks.", if that sounds familiar.)

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by teddyh on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @04:25PM (#20999683)
Yes, that’s the message I get too.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by wayoutthere on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:49PM (#20997322)
Don’t kid yourself — moderation is done with an editorial goal in mind, and HN is no different. There are plenty of topics about which the mods will shut down discussion. It’s just that HN’s moderation is more consistent and less emotional/political than your average subreddit.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by cheez on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:08PM (#20997508)
That wasn't my point. Editorializing is fine, what is problematic is outright banning.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by erikpukinskis on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:31PM (#20997123)
You can treat it like an “emblem of cancel culture” and if you’re right.

It’s also an emblem for “people doing things other people don’t like and getting ditched for it” but which emblem you choose to see is up to you.

That’s kind of the power and the weakness of emblems.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by jerf on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:41PM (#20997228)
There is, I think, a fairly sharp line between you deciding you don't want to interact with someone in some particular forum, and someone else deciding you can't interact with someone.

That line is not the line between "good" and "bad", necessarily. I'm just saying it's a relevant difference that shouldn't be blurred away.

Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by cheez on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:46PM (#20997287)
I'm sorry but I don't see any dichotomy in the two situations you've described. Cancel culture is literally people getting ditched because some people didn't like what some people did. That is, sticks and stones may break my bones but words are terrorism.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by erikpukinskis on Thursday September 19, 2019 @02:28PM (#21019067)
I didn’t claim a dichotomy I said they’re both true.
Re:The Internet Relies on People Working for Free by irrational on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:41PM (#20997225)
I see it as emblematic of weak people who don't want to ever be exposed to anything disagreeable. Why can't the whole world be sunshine and unicorns?