News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by dreamcompiler on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @08:10PM (#20882676)
Fire truck driver here: People crash into parked fire trucks and ambulances and cop cars all the damn time. That's why we park the Big Red Truck at an angle behind the accident -- so that when the 2-ton car crashes into the 30-ton truck, the car will bounce off and the people behind the truck (us) won't be injured.

I don't disagree that Tesla's software is partly to blame here, but the null experiment also has a lousy track record.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by FireBeyond on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:20AM (#20884284)
As another fire engine driver (now officer), this is why more and more departments are employing "blocker engines", old decommissioned, stripped engines to provide this security, without risking a $500,000 engine to $1.5MM tiller.

Also, anything that fails to assume that emergency traffic may be at a vastly differing speed from other traffic, or that emergency lights should _almost exclusively result in an autopilot disengagement_ (because their behavior should but is not always entirely predictable, particularly to a machine without sufficient context and/or experience) is to me inherently poorly designed.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by dreamcompiler on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:28AM (#20885356)
> As another fire engine driver (now officer), this is why more and more departments are employing "blocker engines", old decommissioned, stripped engines to provide this security, without risking a $500,000 engine to $1.5MM tiller.

Very interesting idea! You wouldn't even need a dedicated bay for it because who cares if it gets faded in the sun or rained on? An old tender that still holds water would be perfect for this.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by jakobegger on Thursday September 05, 2019 @07:23AM (#20885606)
Even better would be a truck with an impact attenuator [1] in the back. Those have the potential of saving the life of whoever crashes into it.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impact_attenuator

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by drdeadringer on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:17AM (#20885322)
> this is why more and more departments are employing "blocker engines", old decommissioned, stripped engines to provide this security, without risking a $500,000 engine to $1.5MM tiller.

That's pretty clever. I don't know why I didn't think of that myself.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:06PM (#20882978)
This one time I go stopped at a fruit fly control point on the border between South Australia and Victoria, near Bordertown.

The person staffing the control point indicated with hand signals for me to stop on the highway in the lane I was in.

So I slowed down to walking speed and pulled off the highway into the car park next to the office.

The agent then lectured me about not following instructions and that she could fine me for disobeying.

I then calmly explained to the agent the reason I didn't stop in the lane on the highway: drivers of cars and heavy vehicles are known to have a terrible habit of not seeing other vehicles stopped on the road.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by atoav on Thursday September 05, 2019 @01:48AM (#20884169)
Interesting, I am pretty sure in Germany they do just that: they drive with you to the next exit. They have a huge display that tells you to follow.

At least according to my anecdotal evidence.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by de_watcher on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:34AM (#20884929)
In EU you've usually got an entire always empty "emergency stop" lane on the right side.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by bkor on Thursday September 05, 2019 @05:13AM (#20885097)
The shoulder is still not to be used for a police stop. You should only stop there if there's no alternative. A police wanting to stop you is not an emergency; the nearest exit is close enough. Same for a lot of other situations.

Further, in Netherlands an ambulance is not allowed to use the shoulder at high speed. Meaning, they'll prefer driving on the normal lanes (even if a bit crowded) over the shoulder.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by Already__Taken on Thursday September 05, 2019 @08:30AM (#20885947)
These are getting removed in the UK to be opened as an extra lane, with overhead sings warning you to get out of it if there's a stranded vehicle.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by tim333 on Thursday September 05, 2019 @09:51AM (#20886624)
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by londons_explore on Thursday September 05, 2019 @09:32AM (#20886468)
This is currently being argued in court... There's a good chance the plans will be reversed.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by ed_balls on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:34AM (#20884932)
In my country the police cannot stop you on the highway. They have a sign at the back of the car saying "Follow me" and stop at the nearest parking. The speed limit is 140km/h.

I guess it's a bit safer when the speed limit in Australia is 110km/h

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by newnewpdro on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:19PM (#20883586)
It always blows my mind when a highway patrol scolds me for not stopping immediately on the side of the road, instead pulling off at the first exit/intersection to make it safer for us.

I'd estimate it's about 10% of the time. But on the contrary, I've also had them express appreciation for doing the same thing.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by cortesoft on Thursday September 05, 2019 @12:29AM (#20883838)
Jesus, how many times have you been pulled over that 10% of the time is more than once!?
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by newnewpdro on Thursday September 05, 2019 @12:52AM (#20883929)
There was a period of a few years where I drove a track-prepped race car on the street daily, with out of state plates for emissions reasons, and it resulted in a lot of police encounters.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by SOLAR_FIELDS on Thursday September 05, 2019 @01:26AM (#20884077)
Has there been any studies of this? I think it’s well known that if you drive a sports car you get pulled over more often, but I drive a beat up pickup in the south of USA and almost never get pulled over even though I’m frequently 5-10 MPH over the speed limit. Would be interesting to see pickup vs a normal mid range sedan vs sports cars in numbers. Maybe throw in out of state plates as an extra variable.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by Washuu on Thursday September 05, 2019 @01:51AM (#20884185)
I drive a Subaru WRX STI which is one of the most expensive to insure vehicles due to it be one of the most ticketed and crashed vehicles. I have never been pulled over while driving it. I have been pulled over in my Wrangler many times while obeying all laws, but never had a ticket from it.

https://insurify.com/insights/car-models-with-the-most-speed...

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by cardiffspaceman on Thursday September 05, 2019 @01:06PM (#20888713)
Sports cars are sometimes easier to track and that makes them easier to successfully pull over. I asked a cop about this after he pulled me and my red Stealth over for having a missing corner on a sticker on my license plate.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by xboxnolifes on Thursday September 05, 2019 @12:28PM (#20888287)
I don't know exactly where you live, but around me 5-10 MPH over is still 5-10 MPH under what even the police go.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by lysp on Thursday September 05, 2019 @03:50AM (#20884697)
What I notice in Australia is when police want to pull someone over will often follow behind a car with their lights turned off until there is a safe area to pull over - then will turn on their lights. This might be a few minutes down the road.

Some people will immediately see lights flashing and pull over straight away without checking for a safe location, so by delaying their lights - it removes that out of the equation.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by alufers on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:43AM (#20884967)
Could you explain what a "fruit fly control point" is, i can't find anything about it on Google and it seems interesting to me as I am not an native English speaker. Thanks.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by scarejunba on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:56AM (#20885036)
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by Simon_says on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:47AM (#20884421)
It's not the staff's fault. They're not working there because they display great independent thought.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by bg24 on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @10:49PM (#20883457)
I was going at 30-40mph in the right lane on a 4-lane all empty highway, when a gentleman flies at 60-70mph and hits us right behind, goes 360 turn with us and we hit the wall. Everyone survived without any medical incident (other than that I do panic and respectfully avoid those fliers now-a-days). Relevant because: - I hope my sprinter (size of mini truck, with upfittings) had an autopilot in the front/rear to speed up or divert to save an accident. - +1 to your parking angle. The other driver survived because he hit us at an angle and skidded full circle to minimize the impact. Of course, that helped our life as well.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by smogcutter on Thursday September 05, 2019 @12:04AM (#20883760)
This... sounds like it’s on you. If this is in the US, the “flier” is going the normal speed of the road, and you’re driving dangerously slowly.

It’s hard to tell that something directly in front of you is approaching. It’s just not something our brains are good at, compared to detecting lateral movement. Especially when it’s so unexpected. One of the first things they tell you in motorcycle safety class is that “constant bearing, decreasing range” situations are extremely dangerous.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by FireBeyond on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:23AM (#20884302)
He mentions being in a truck, but it's a Sprinter, which unless it's dangerously overloaded, should be able to manage more than 30mph up a freeway hill.

Australian driving law/principles state that "drivers should drive at the _maximum_ possible speed that is: within the speed limit, and safe for the conditions". Notably absent in this is "within your ability" as if you're not capable of safely driving on all roads, the balance of probabilities says you probably shouldn't be driving on _any_ roads.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by gnicholas on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:25AM (#20884315)
GP said "highway", not "freeway". In some parts of the country/world, these refer to different types of roads.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by jakobegger on Thursday September 05, 2019 @08:50AM (#20886103)
But... regardless how fast the speed limit is, you should never expect the road ahead to be clear! A Sprinter is a huge vehicle, if you don't see that ahead of you, you must be severly distracted...
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by smogcutter on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:26PM (#20889459)
Less so than you might think. We’re just plain slower to detect things that are growing larger than objects traversing our vision. Especially without context clues like brake lights or other slow traffic, approaching at 40mph doesn’t give you a lot of time to correct.

Ultimately yes, it’s the other driver’s fault because it’s always your job to not hit things in front of you. But OP made his vehicle into a hazard.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by tom_ on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:13AM (#20884815)
There is no such thing as dangerously slowly - the fault lies with people that aren’t leaving enough room to take evasive action given their speed.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by bkor on Thursday September 05, 2019 @05:17AM (#20885113)
You'll be fined in The Netherlands for going too slow. They're not waiting for dangerously slow, way slower than any other traffic is enough.

Example (Dutch, use Google Translate): https://www.rijnmond.nl/nieuws/124541/Flinke-boete-voor-te-l...

A truck got a fine of 1500 EUR. The example was dangerously slow (eventually 40km/h), not just slow.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by imtringued on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:47AM (#20885445)
So I will be fined if I follow the speed limit, which is way slower than any other traffic?
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:59AM (#20885509)
No, but you will if you drive significantly slower and obstruct traffic flow.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by tom_ on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:52AM (#20885466)
The fines are probably to discourage this behaviour and improve traffic flow slightly. But I'd be surprised if the law uses the term "dangerously slow", or anything similar.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by Frondo on Thursday September 05, 2019 @09:20AM (#20886369)
Many state roads post minimum speeds as well as maximum speeds (usually it's 40 or 45 mph, where the maximum is 65mph or 70mph), because there is in fact such a thing as driving dangerously slowly.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by gbrown on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:05PM (#20883535)
The other driver was clearly 100% totally at fault, but I'm just curious: why were you going 30-40 on a four lane highway? Where I live that's at least 25 below the speed limit.

Here it's mostly tractors and other farm equipment driving at those speeds.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by gnicholas on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:23AM (#20884305)
In some parts of the US, the word "highway" is used to refer to roads (sometimes quite wide) that have stop lights and with speed limits around 40 MPH. I grew up in northern California, and we call roads without stop lights "freeways" and roads with stop lights "highways". There are various other terms, of course (e.g. "expressways"), but these are the most common generic descriptors.

I wouldn't assume that the driver going slowly was much under the speed limit, if at all.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by michaelt on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:30AM (#20884913)
Which is understandable when you consider there were "highwaymen" in the 1600s when the highways had nothing faster than a horse.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by bg24 on Saturday September 07, 2019 @12:15AM (#20901745)
I should have clarified. 4-lane expressway, signals were about 0.5-1.0 mile apart. All lanes clear. Mid night.

It was NOT a freeway.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by gbrown on Thursday September 05, 2019 @08:12AM (#20885846)
Makes sense, the usage is colloquially different in the Midwest.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:41PM (#20883669)
Maybe going up a hill? They did mention they were driving a truck, it’s easy to have vastly different climbing speeds in that case.

Also, I would often go less than 20 down a pass during the winter because I didn’t have snow tires or chains, and was passed by plenty of locals doing 60+ because they were equipped for it.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by dahfizz on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:15PM (#20883578)
Yeah, that seems dangerous. There is usually a hard 45mph minimum on the highways near me.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by saalweachter on Thursday September 05, 2019 @08:13AM (#20885852)
I'm never going to to discourage people from driving slow, because our monkey brains have shit reaction times and perception, and KE increases with the square of velocity, but if you're traveling well below the normal speed of travel, put your flashers on. In many places this is mandated for a certain amount under the limit.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by cardiffspaceman on Thursday September 05, 2019 @01:14PM (#20888777)
In my view the wreck isn’t made worse so much by absolute magnitude of one momentum vector as by the magnitude of the difference in momentum vectors.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by dahfizz on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:07PM (#20889317)
You have to consider that after a wreck, both cars have to come to a stop one way or the other.

Imagine being rear ended while you are stopped at a stop sign. The difference in momentum is small and there is no significant damage.

Now imagine going 80mph down the highway and someone going 81mph hits the back of your car. Still a very small difference in momentum, but your car is very likely to lose control and roll or hit other cars. It's not always the initial impact that does all the damage.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by saalweachter on Thursday September 05, 2019 @03:23PM (#20889926)
To put it another way, every collision you are in is also a collision with the Earth, which masses a lot more than you and wins every exchange of momentum.

Conveniently, your delta-v with this massive body you don't want to run into is also the one conventionally reported for your speed.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by imtringued on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:38AM (#20885404)
The difference is if an AI fails to handle a certain situation then it will fail every single time. With humans there is a random element and a small fraction end up failing.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by stedaniels on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:55AM (#20885487)
But to an AI, a certain situation has millions of data points, it's very rare for a certain situation to reoccur. Similar types and classes of situations? You betcha. But they'd be handled based on other data points as well.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:58AM (#20885503)
Then it's not an AI but just complicated if-statements; if it was more like a real AI then it would learn from the experience. The core premise of AI is that it's learning and improving all the time, not that it does the exact same thing every time.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by LoSboccacc on Thursday September 05, 2019 @08:39AM (#20886018)
you don't want that either, because you want to quality control the changes to behaviour. see for example first generation Forza drivatars, that learned from other online player unconstrained and became insufferable assholes
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by elaus on Thursday September 05, 2019 @06:52AM (#20885467)
But situations are never "the same". The input (camera images, sensor data) will always be (slightly) different and – in this example – might just lift the confidence of "this is a truck standing on the road" over the threshold.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by tim333 on Thursday September 05, 2019 @09:55AM (#20886653)
In practice Tesla's thing only seems to have crashed into a fire truck a couple of times against I imagine a large number of misses.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:37PM (#20883657)
On Beijing’s third ring road one time, I saw a lady being stopped by a cop for some reason (rare, cops never pull over anybody there), she got into her car and promptly rammed into the police car directly in front of her (on accident I assume). I think she was having a bad day or something.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by nabdab on Friday September 06, 2019 @12:24AM (#20893049)
The argument that Tesla is not fully to blame because people also fails seems fundamentally flawed. A human driver at fault cannot avoid blame by simple asserting that other human drivers also make similar mistakes.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by navigatesol on Thursday September 05, 2019 @08:47AM (#20886085)
>People crash into parked fire trucks and ambulances and cop cars all the damn time.

Autopilot is supposed to be safer than humans, not equivalent to the worst drivers.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by alkonaut on Thursday September 05, 2019 @02:12AM (#20884258)
No TMA vehicles? I haven't seen an accident without TMA here, I think no one is even supposed to go out to the accident before the TMA is in place.
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by smt88 on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @08:30PM (#20882790)
The null experiment is the human driver of that particular Tesla, not an average of all drivers
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by schiffern on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:48PM (#20883185)
So if the crash didn't involve "the human driver of that particular Tesla" but instead was an identical incident with a different Tesla driver, we wouldn't be having this conversation? Because that seems highly improbable.

This particular driver isn't what makes the story special or newsworthy. The nature of the incident is. Our choice of statistical cohort should reflect this data selection effect, ie "all Autopilot miles driven," not "all miles driven by <person's name>."

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by smt88 on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:29PM (#20883630)
I disagree because we're comparing what this individual driver would have done without a feature advertised as Autopilot.

I'm a partner in an auto insurance company, and most of our no-accident records will stay that way, statistically speaking.

If this driver had a one in a billion miles chance of crashing and Autopilot (with an inattentve driver, as they all tend to be) had a one in a million miles chance, then Autopilot is decreasing safety.

At a certain level of safety, Autopilot would make everyone safer, but it's definitely not there yet.

Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by chingjun on Thursday September 05, 2019 @03:21AM (#20884569)
How do you know that this individual driver has a one in a billion miles chance of crashing? By statistics from other human drivers I assume?
Re:Tesla’s Autopilot found partly to blame for 2018 crash on... by smt88 on Thursday September 05, 2019 @04:24PM (#20890360)
I didn't say that I knew. I was only disputing the relevance of defending individual Tesla crashes by saying that Tesla's are, on average, less likely to crash when on Autopilot. You can't compare Tesla drivers on Autopilot to all drivers -- you have to compare them to themselves, or you have an extraneous variable.

Fatal human accidents are on the order of 1-10 every billion miles of driving in the US, yes. Tesla Autopilot crashes seem to be much, much, much more common.