The question is: Should we cat power to 5% of the customers now, or let the whole electrical grid stall, resulting in zero power for anyone.
Netflix also would never intentionally break my FireTV box, which I use to watch Netflix, just to ensure that I have a backup in place (which I don't, because I don't care THAT much about Netflix availability).
[edit] Now that I think about it...the purpose of the Netflix server farm is also to provide reliability to the customer, so it's actually comparable to a certain degree. It's just that the possible outcome of a mitigation failure in the Netflix server farm is limited to some people not watching Netflix for a few minutes, while the possible outcome of a power outage even for residential customers are usually far worse, let alone industrial or health customers. This allows Netflix to take the limited risk of intentionally breaking internals in their infrastructure, because the worst that can happen is them having to excuse themselves to some customers for a service interruption. Also, no one expects them to submit a report describing how it came to those interruptions, so they don't need to admit that they were the result of intentional self-inflicted disruptions (which sounds really crazy and irresponsible to pretty much all consumers out there). With electrical grid operators, the stakes are infinitely higher, and they are legally required to investigate any bigger problems and report details about their origins to both government authorities and customers. And you can be sure that "oh we just intentionally dropped 5% of the network to see if we get a full blackout or if our failsafes work" would not be an acceptable excuse to any of these two.
Unfortunately, some quick research[1] suggests this isn’t the case, and actually it’s just a contractual obligation of the power companies to disconnect enough demand to bring power use back down. The amount they need to disconnect is banded by the frequency the grid is at, and apparently done at the substation level.
Some industries/applications such as infrastructure, hospitals, airports, etc, is supposed to be set up to never disconnect in these scenarios, but it seems this failed.
I wouldn't be surprised if we could do better in the volume of demand we could reduce on demand, especially with smarter technology, though. At some point the question is whether the extra complexity and infrastructure is cost-effective to avoid once-a-decade events on the scale of this one, which probably 90% of the UK would never have noticed unless they read the news...
I'm not sure if the grid is already doing this, but they should trigger failures randomly, including Low Frequency Demand Disconnection schemes from time to time to ensure that all downstream systems are also ready (like the hospital someone mentioned that had an issue with the backup generator, or the trains that stopped working when the frequency failed). A bit like caos monkeys in dev environments.