News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:10PM (#20794065)
I like getting interest on my savings as much as anyone, but it is kind of weird how we just expect the price of storing money to be negative. No other storage service works this way. I can’t put a bunch of furniture in a warehouse and not only pay nothing, but receive a percentage of the value each month.

I understand why it often works this way for money, but I don’t see why this must be the natural order of things. The price of storing money in a bank will be the underlying cost of doing so, minus the proceeds the bank can make from your money, plus some profit margin. Nothing says this sum must be a positive number.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by abernard1 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:32PM (#20794233)
'No other storage service works this way. I can’t put a bunch of furniture in a warehouse and not only pay nothing, but receive a percentage of the value each month.'

The distinction is that your savings in a "storage" scenario are yours exclusively. That is not how it actually works. Banks lend out your "stored furniture" to get a return. Due to fractional reserve lending and the fungibility of currency, the illusion of you being able to receive your stored furniture back is preserved.

But there is never actually a scenario where there are truly idle resources--capital is always utilized at some ratio, and that ratio is independent of consumer behavior. The bank is investing on behalf of their customers.

As banks can only invest based upon the deposits of their customers, I think it is actually extremely unreasonable for customers to have to pay for the privilege in the form of a negative interest rate. That's not "natural" either. Guaranteed checked deposits is the only reason that this swindle can occur.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:41PM (#20794298)
> it is actually extremely unreasonable for customers to have to pay for the privilege in the form of a negative interest rate

You’re paying for access to a checking account, an electronic payment mechanism.

Savings should be invested, not stored with banks. That’s the nudge ZIRP and negative rates provide. Forcing investment decisions into the hands of the savers over banks’ lending managers. Decentralising the economy’s pool of investing decision makers.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by abernard1 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:50PM (#20794366)
I understand the nudge, but my comment was qualified by a statement that is essentially "savers are already joint investors in the operations of a bank." On principle, receiving a guaranteed negative return for providing an investor your own capital is very unnatural.

With regard to fees: the only reason banks charge them is due to the fact they believe that the possible returns from low income customers will never match their cut of the investment. The fact that this interest rate also applies to high income customers exposes the "what about fees" argument. This is about incentivizing moving capital out of the safer investments that bank make (homes, relatively light personal loans, modest business loans) into equity markets. As true "savings" rates in the form of completely unallocated capital is low, my guess is this is pushing on a string.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:32PM (#20794619)
> savers are already joint investors in the operations of a bank

And highly privileged ones. First in line. Guaranteed by the government.

If savers want to be pari passu with the bank’s capital, they can buy bank bonds and stock. Those yield well, even in the EU.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by wongarsu on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:02PM (#20794445)
There is lots of capital that an individual can't reasonably invest. Even if I live paycheck to paycheck then I still on average have half my salary in my bank account. As an individual that's just my working capital, but as a bank I can take advantage of the fact that some people (in Germany) get payed on the 1st and some on the 15th, meaning there is some constant amount of money that can be invested.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by pgwhalen on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:52PM (#20795839)
>As banks can only invest based upon the deposits of their customers

This is not strictly true, read about the money multiplier myth. As another (much more informed than I) HN commenter put it, banks think about constraints on lending in terms of the cost of money, not the quantity of money.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by 19870213 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:17PM (#20794110)
You could rent your furniture out I suppose. That's basically what we were doing with our savings, the bank can use the deposits to fund mortgages and we get some interest on our deposits from the returns on investment the bank made.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by psadri on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:39PM (#20794284)
There is a difference - the money that’s stored in the bank is not just sitting there. It is lent out with an interest to people who need to borrow money and earns the bank an income. The banks want your deposits because it lets them earn money. To compete with one another they offer interest bearing deposit accounts.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by 345218435 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:13PM (#20795259)
that‘s a nice theory.

what actually happens is, when you borrow money, they put the numbers into your account and the negative on their balance sheet. that‘s the basic process of money-creation in a fiat system. out of thin air. debt-based on top so that nobody ever gets away.

but yeah, everybody likes to believe that the amount of money in the system represents goods and services.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Zhenya on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:27PM (#20794197)
This is because banks lend against their deposit value (in many multiples).

So if you give them $1, the bank can now lend $5 (without actually having it) and then make many times that $5 in interest.

So sure, they will pay you a little, so they can make a lot.

At least that's how it works today.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:37PM (#20794274)
> So if you give them $1, the bank can now lend $5 (without actually having it) and then make many times that $5 in interest

Sigh

This is not how it works. (It’s a common misconception, however.) Loans create deposits, not the other way. Most money is created by banks, not the central bank or mint [1].

From a consumer perspective, imagining a bank as taking your $1 and lending it out five times is okay. But systemically speaking, it’s a misleading model. The truth is the bank created $5 in loans, and through that $5 in deposits. About $4 of those deposits were then spent and ended up in other banks or bank accounts as deposits.

The loan always comes first. The BoE has a good primers on this [2].

[1] https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/how-is-money-c...

[2] https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by kgwgk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:55PM (#20795523)
> The truth is the bank created $5 in loans, and through that $5 in deposits.

But for that the bank needs to hold $1 (or whatever) in reserves, so either they had excess reserves already (because “someone gave them $1, the bank can now lend $5”) or they a) get new deposits, b) get them from another bank (i.e. the money comes from previous deposits elsewhere) or c) new money is created by the central bank.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:41PM (#20795780)
The loans are created first. At the end of the day, if reserves are inadequate, they are borrowed. This creates the overnight interbank market.

Because a dollar dealt results in a deposited, this system is self-reinforcing.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by kgwgk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:45PM (#20795802)
But this is not really different from the standard description: you deposit an incremental $1 (cash or a loan) into the banking system and the banking system can loan out $5 (edit: in fact, 0.9$ at first) when it decides to do so. Banks can create this new money “multiplying” deposits (or the central bank intervention is required to create “extra” money).
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:54PM (#20795847)
> this is not really different from the standard description

It is. It’s the difference between picturing a rocket propelled by expanding gases versus a vessel thrust forth by Newtonian dynamics.

It is correlation versus causality. Loans cause deposits. Deposits correlate with loans. This discrepancy is the source of money supply estimation error.

$1 deposited doesn’t create $5 in loans. $5 in loans prompts about $1 in reserves. The difference in these models explains the interbank market, per se and in terms of rates; reserves as a stochastic versus deterministic phenomenon; bank runs and much more.

Loans create deposits. Not the other way. Modern banking makes sense once you internalise this difference.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by kgwgk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:14PM (#20795965)
If your point is that the actual money issued by the central bank (M0) does not necessarily result in the monetary supply that could be potentially produced according to the minimal reserve requirements that’s obviously true.

Banks are not forced to loan out as much as they could, they have a choice. And because the system is not working at “full capacity” the central bank cannot control the money supply adjusting the minimal reserve requirements. They use other mechanism like short term rates (including through the interest the Fed pays on reserves since 2008).

“Loans create deposits” is of course true in the standard description as well. If banks create money (by lending out, if they want, excess reserves) that necesarily means that the total amount of deposits increases. Because the total amount of deposits (plus the relatively less important amount of physical money in circulation) is what we call money!

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by numakerg on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:59PM (#20794424)
So the bank levies a micro tax on all holders of the currency with the expectation that their investment in the receiver of the loan will yield a better return?
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:24PM (#20794574)
> the bank levies a micro tax on all holders of the currency with the expectation that their investment in the receiver of the loan will yield a better return?

No.

Banks compete for deposits and compete to lend. The spread between those rates must pay the bank’s costs, cover its risks and turn a profit. When central banks reduce the return on safe assets banks hold, their income from lending to the government goes down. The banks thus seek to replace that income with other lending. Unfortunately, everyone in the system is doing the same thing. This competition forces lending rates down.

Savers are competing for investments next to the banks. There are lots of them crowding into bank deposits; this lets those banks lower the rate they pay. (Nobody forces savers to deposit Euros only in German banks.)

This is a system of feedback loops. Nobody is charging a tax, though banks may charge a fee for a service it costs them to provide. Depositors are free to take their business elsewhere. And entrepreneurs who think they can do better are free to launch competing financial services.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by numakerg on Sunday August 25, 2019 @03:31PM (#20794977)
>Therefore, if you borrow £100 from the bank, and it credits your account with the amount, ‘new money’ has been created. It didn’t exist until it was credited to your account.

If that £100 is spent into the economy but is not returned, did the total volume of available £100 not increase, reducing the buying power of any £ stores? Perhaps it is not a tax because it isn't used directly by the government, but it is a burden that such a lender can enforce upon currency holders with the authority that is given to it by the organization controlling the currency.

>entrepreneurs who think they can do better are free to launch competing financial services.

Entrepreneurs cannot lend out money they never had. How difficult is it for a new company to obtain a piece of the volume of money that the currency regulator deems available for creation within a timeframe?

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:43PM (#20795796)
> If that £100 is spent into the economy but is not returned

Loans create deposits. The only way the deposit isn’t returned is if capital is destroyed.

> Entrepreneurs cannot lend out money they never had

With a banking license, yes. They can.

Once you have a banking charter, you can lend to your heart’s content. At the end of the day, you borrow to make your reserve requirement. (If you’re deficient, you die.)

Lending creates deposits. Not the reverse.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Zhenya on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:30AM (#20797866)
Thanks for the clarification and additional commentary below; great to learn something new.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:30PM (#20794217)
You’re the second reply who seems to think that I have no idea how banks actually work or why they can often pay interest. Did you just skip my second paragraph, or what’s the deal?
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Zhenya on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:34PM (#20794250)
I read your second paragraph.

There is almost a zero-cost to storing the money and as the account size grows the cost to transact on this account per dollar of storage also approaches zero.

Meanwhile the lending power of the bank multiples by large whole numbers.

They aren't storing your bills or gold coins.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by floatingatoll on Sunday August 25, 2019 @02:04PM (#20794456)
“Zero-cost excluding the cost of insurance” is more precise here.

Bitcoin is zero-cost^ to store for any dollar amount. So are gold bars.

Insuring them against theft and loss is not zero-cost.

A shovel for burying gold in your yard is cheap (high capex, low opex), but if a sinkhole opens up and eats your gold, you’re probably out of luck. A hard drive for your Bitcoin is cheap (high capes, low opex), but if a lightning bolt burns your house down and you aren’t paying for offsite backups, you might be out of luck.

What degree of loss do you wish to insure against (accident, damage, theft, loss) — and what percentage of your money are you willing to spend on that?

^ “I bury coins on my land” seems zero-cost, but it just means that you’re paying property tax to insure against treasure hunters uncovering your hoard with a metal detector. External costs need to be accounted for.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:43PM (#20794311)
Yes, costs are low, but so is the potential revenue from loans right now.

I never said anything about storing bills or coins.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:47PM (#20794344)
> so is the potential revenue from loans right now

Broader interest rates are low, too. The revenue potential for banks is limited. Particularly European ones.

European banks have failed to compete for investment opportunities. Negative rates push that onus back onto savers.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Isinlor on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:24PM (#20794165)
Banks are not storing money. Banks lend money. They store only some ridiculusly small amount (something like 5%?) and lend everythig else. So in case everyone wants to get they money back bank goes bankrupt, because they don't have that money. They would need to force on moment notice that money out of people they lend it to.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:28PM (#20794198)
I’m well aware of how banks work. See my second to last sentence in which I describe how the price of storing money in a bank is set and why it can be negative.

Banks are definitely storing money. They’re just not storing physical currency. They mostly store money in various financial instruments such as loans, which provides them with some revenue. If that revenue is sufficiently high, they can make all their money this way and set a negative price for their money storage services. But there’s no natural law that says the revenue potential must be that high.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Dylan16807 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:28PM (#20794199)
Well either something has gone wrong with the money-lending part, so it's not making enough money to pay interest... or there's a terrible lack in competition and banks are keeping all the profits.

It would be nice to blame the latter but there seems to be evidence toward the former.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by Dylan16807 on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:20PM (#20794130)
Yeah. And an important consequence is that there is a natural cap on how low rates go, as banks put their vaults to use.

Also with inflation the real rate of sub-percent interest is already negative, so a below-zero rate is more psychological than anything. The difference between inflation and inflation+1 isn't transformative.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by jonatron on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:21PM (#20794141)
Physical space is expensive in many places. 64 bits of disk space is cheap everywhere.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by shultays on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:54PM (#20794384)
Why price of storing electronic money differs in between 1$ or 1000$ though? Only difference is a few bit flips in a bunch of databases.

Generally you already pay for a fee for your account/credit card.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by mikeash on Sunday August 25, 2019 @01:58PM (#20794418)
Fraud risk is higher, which means the cost of insurance is higher.

I think this cost actually goes up more than just proportionally, too. Criminals will preferentially target higher value accounts, and they’ll make off with more when they do, so the risk increases more than linearly.

In any case, not all costs are fixed.