News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 25, 2019 @05:54PM (#20795847)
> this is not really different from the standard description

It is. It’s the difference between picturing a rocket propelled by expanding gases versus a vessel thrust forth by Newtonian dynamics.

It is correlation versus causality. Loans cause deposits. Deposits correlate with loans. This discrepancy is the source of money supply estimation error.

$1 deposited doesn’t create $5 in loans. $5 in loans prompts about $1 in reserves. The difference in these models explains the interbank market, per se and in terms of rates; reserves as a stochastic versus deterministic phenomenon; bank runs and much more.

Loans create deposits. Not the other way. Modern banking makes sense once you internalise this difference.

Re:Germany in Uproar as Negative Rates Threaten Saving Obses... by kgwgk on Sunday August 25, 2019 @06:14PM (#20795965)
If your point is that the actual money issued by the central bank (M0) does not necessarily result in the monetary supply that could be potentially produced according to the minimal reserve requirements that’s obviously true.

Banks are not forced to loan out as much as they could, they have a choice. And because the system is not working at “full capacity” the central bank cannot control the money supply adjusting the minimal reserve requirements. They use other mechanism like short term rates (including through the interest the Fed pays on reserves since 2008).

“Loans create deposits” is of course true in the standard description as well. If banks create money (by lending out, if they want, excess reserves) that necesarily means that the total amount of deposits increases. Because the total amount of deposits (plus the relatively less important amount of physical money in circulation) is what we call money!