News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by crazygringo on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:15PM (#20739059)
For both wired and wireless, it's time for legislation to address exactly what it and isn't permitted with regard to advertised speeds, throttling, and total usage -- both with respect to users, and with respect to peering.

It's not just an issue of policy, but one of transparency too.

It's a fact of life that more people will want to consume data than a network can support. So where are we going to make the cut? Diminish everyone's usage proportionally? Provide a guaranteed minimum? A minimum per minute, per hour, or per day? Prioritize traffic based on type? Implement caps? Allow people to pay for more speed, higher caps, or both?

Some of these will be better or worse for different users. But since people often have little or no choice over which carrier or ISP they use and switching can be expensive, this is exactly where it makes sense for policy to be made democratically, as with utilities. And publicized.

When I pay for a carrier, I want to know what I should be able to count on, and what I can't count on.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by dec0dedab0de on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:02PM (#20739493)
When I pay for a carrier, I want to know what I should be able to count on, and what I can't count on.

I can't up vote this enough. I think false advertising really needs to be clamped down on across the board, but when it's something I understand the nuances of it really gets to me.

Why do companies find it so difficult to just say what it is they are selling in clear concise language, without being purposely misleading, or hiding things in fine print?

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by lrem on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:30PM (#20741505)
What false advertising? The ad clearly reads "up to 50mbps" and the 1.1mbps the copper in your neighbourhood allows is indeed positively in the 0-50 range!

Damn I hate consumer ISPs, with a few small exceptions.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by lugg on Monday August 19, 2019 @07:19PM (#20742600)
We cover false and misleading advertising with the same laws here in Australia.

ISPs are required to give estimated primetime speeds you can expect for a given plan.

E.g. for my 100mbs plan, they tell me that in my area, I can expect 82mbs during evening peak.

We also have some ISPs who are being transparent about over provisioning and even go as far as stopping selling into an area until they acquire more bandwidth into a node.

More on topic, this is being caused by companies milking their old networks unwilling to upgrade.

I suspect it is due to execs believing their underlings when they're told their network upgrades were supposed to alleviate capacity problems at a great cost.

Fact is, usage is evolving, go to somewhere like south Korea and YouTube streaming 4k on your phone during your commute is the norm. People have the bandwidth there, and they use it.

Here, people don't have the bandwidth, so they don't, but they would.

ISPs don't seem to realise this and think it's a select few ruining the service for the whole with their pesky streaming. When really it's just changing customer needs and reluctance to serve.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by NullPrefix on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:55PM (#20742186)
Why is the bill not "Up to $50" though?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by Swizec on Monday August 19, 2019 @07:24PM (#20742629)
To be fair I have Comcast and pay for "up to 1Gbit" but on the weekend late at night when everyone is asleep I get 1.5Gbit.

Of course during the day when people actually use the network it's down to 0.5Gbit, down to 0.3Gbit during prime Netflix hours.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by clairity on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:26PM (#20740334)
> "Why do companies find it so difficult to just say what it is they are selling in clear concise language, without being purposely misleading, or hiding things in fine print?"

because it's more profitable?

it's a pretty direct line between the pressure to produce profits and lying to people to get it, particularly as it gets harder to produce profits through honest means.

remember that capitalism entices participants with profits to spur innovation, not to indulge the profit-taking itself, so any temporarily profitable enterprise should attract interest and drive down profits as competition enters the industry. so professional managers (e.g., executives) sometimes (often?) choose to lie & cheat to lengthen the period of profit-taking.

it's inexplicable that we accept that as normal, as if holding people & companies accountable for their words would stifle commerce and descend us into a totalitarian dystopia. instead, such accountability would only mean that getting filthy rich would be harder, while attaining comfortable wealth would be unchanged, if not more attainable.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by stochastic_monk on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:55PM (#20740637)
When I pay for compute on AWS, I get an SLA with guarantees. Why are citizens afforded any less?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by dboreham on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:31PM (#20742009)
You do realize that AWS SLA is about as much BS as the "unlimited" cell data plans we're discussing here, right?

All it says is that if they fail to deliver service, with a bunch of exclusions that make it very unlikely they will ever do so, then you get to not pay for that service that you didn't get.

http://aws.amazon.com/compute/sla/

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by TheCoelacanth on Monday August 19, 2019 @09:39PM (#20743173)
That is very much more real than what you get from an ISP. If an ISP doesn't meet the advertised bandwidth, at best you get an apology. More likely you get nothing. You definitely aren't getting a refund for the service you didn't get.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by krageon on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @07:15AM (#20745582)
> with a bunch of exclusions that make it very unlikely they will ever do so

I think the meat of their argument was that they have weaseled it in such a way that you're not getting what you expect unless you read all the fine print. Then it turns out you get basically nothing. From that point it's not a stretch to say the situation has not improved when compared to consumers: They also get nothing.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by rayiner on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:21PM (#20740901)
You can pay for a fiber line with an SLA, etc. They cost hundreds to thousands of dollars a month, even in downtown areas with several business fiber providers to choose from.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by mattnewton on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:07PM (#20740758)
Because AWS is competing for savvy customers, and US telecoms increasing look like a cartel.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by usrusr on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:34PM (#20739793)
> When I pay for a carrier, I want to know what I should be able to count on, and what I can't count on.

You can absolutely count on any wireless transmission happening on a shared medium. Inconveniencing one high volume user to keep up service quality for dozens of low volume user is a perfectly rational business decision. As for transparency: well, good regulation is not easy, particularly when support for trying is not very strong.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by sixothree on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:36PM (#20739824)
Strange that in 2019 YouTube is considered "high volume user".
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by 14 on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:26PM (#20739726)
It's a fact of life that more people will want to consume data than a network can support.

Is this actually true or is it just a matter of the isp not building the needed infrastructure required? Because if it is just an infrastructure issue then I would question why they choose to not expand to a better service. Is it because they can get away with providing crappy service as many people only have a single choice of what isp is available in their area? I highly agree with your final statement and it’s true people just want to know what they can count on and not play the guessing game.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by crazygringo on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:44PM (#20739919)
It's a matter of economics.

An ISP could build the required infrastructure to support everyone's peak desired simultaneous usage... but then they'd probably have to quadruple (or worse) what people are paying for it just to break even, which the market wouldn't support, so they'd go out of business.

The same way restaurants could invest in enough space to handle all demand for Friday nights and Valentine's Day... but would go out of business because they couldn't keep it full enough to pay the rent the rest of the week/year.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by plopz on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:40PM (#20741068)
Didn't we already give the ISPs money to upgrade their infrastructure? Something like $400 billion.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by rayiner on Monday August 19, 2019 @08:03PM (#20742800)
No we didn’t: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556.

Even if that number wasn’t fictional, even by its own narrative it applies to money supposedly paid to telephone companies for fiber deployment. The gist of the argument is that by promising to build fiber, telephone companies got regulators to let them increase phone charges and depreciate phone infrastructure faster than otherwise would have been the case. That’s where the $400 billion comes from.

These arguments are all based on the peculiarly of his telephone service was regulated before 1996 (and in the authors view the way it should have continued to be regulated—even though all of Western Europe went away from this sort of rate regulation around the same time the US did). That has nothing to do with cellular, which was always regulated under a totally different regime, and was built more than a decade after these events.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jessaustin on Monday August 19, 2019 @06:44PM (#20742465)
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by Balanceinfinity on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:47PM (#20739953)
Basic laws of supply and demand state that when you charge a fixed price and permit unlimited usage at that price, usage will approach infinity (that is, when the marginal price is zero). Everyone with a fixed price, unlimited usage plan has no incentive at all to restrain use. The wireless carriers cannot provide infinite service (the bandwidth simply doesn't exist).
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by usrusr on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:10PM (#20740168)
Take any public space. Now imagine it at it's peak density, when it is as crowded as it gets, maybe due to a once-a-decade event. Now imagine installing cells in sufficient density to avoid any oversubscription on that day. This density will never happen.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by nerdponx on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:28PM (#20739748)
It seems to be mostly true for most infrastructure (especially roadways), so it would be weird if it weren't true here.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by gruez on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:15PM (#20740223)
>Diminish everyone's usage proportionally? Provide a guaranteed minimum? A minimum per minute, per hour, or per day? Prioritize traffic based on type? Implement caps? Allow people to pay for more speed, higher caps, or both?

In the case of limited bandwidth, the "fairest" way would be to enforce a moving average cap. The most economically efficient way would be some sort of dynamic price system[1].

>But since people often have little or no choice over which carrier or ISP they use and switching can be expensive

In the context of this thread (wireless carriers), isn't this moot? I get how there are local ISP monopolies for residential internet, but the whole country has good access to all the major carriers.

[1] instead of getting 5GB, you get 5,000,000 "bandwidth credits". If a cell tower is below capacity, each megabyte of transfer only costs a nominal amount of credits (200). But as capacity approaches 100%, it costs more and more (up to 10000, or more). We could even have a total free market similar to bitcoin network fees where customers can enter a bid. If your bid isn't high enough you're limited to 2g speeds, or get no data at all.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by dylan604 on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:19PM (#20741927)
And how is this indicated to the user? At least the ride hailing apps displayed their "surge pricing" before you used the service. As I'm traveling through town and being handed off to different cell towers, am I going to see a pop-up saying the current rate on this tower is XXXX amount and allow me to accept or not? The flexible invisible cost is just not a good thing for end users
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by gruez on Monday August 19, 2019 @09:42PM (#20743185)
>As I'm traveling through town and being handed off to different cell towers, am I going to see a pop-up saying the current rate on this tower is XXXX amount

Is there a reason why this can't be done? Have a carrier app that you can use to check the current rate, and that sends push notifications when the rate exceeds a rate that you've set. You can even do this through SMS so it doesn't take up any bandwidth.

>and allow me to accept or not?

Allow the user to set a maximum rate. If the current rate exceeds that rate, cut off data access. Allow the user to reactivate data or change the maximum through the app or through SMS.

>The flexible invisible cost is just not a good thing for end users

I never said it was the best approach, just the most efficient approach from a microeconomics point of view.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by casylum on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:30PM (#20740977)
But then carriers would have a financial motivation to not upgrade tower capacity. The more congested - the more money they make.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by gruez on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:01PM (#20741260)
True, but only if they hold an monopoly. If there's a competitor, customers would switch to the cheapest option and they'd lose all their bushiness. If they're a monopoly, well... you're already hosed because they could also infinitely raise prices and there's nothing you can do.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by crazygringo on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:58AM (#20747090)
> but the whole country has good access to all the major carriers

That's why I said switching can be expensive. If you discover bad internet speeds a month after you signed a standard 2-year contract with a carrier, what are you going to do?

Even if you pay that, you may need to pay for a new phone because of incompatible networks.

Not to mention the PITA of transferring your number.

(Similarly even if you have multiple ISP's, you may need to pay $$ for installation, a new modem, etc.)