News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by gruez on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:15PM (#20740223)
>Diminish everyone's usage proportionally? Provide a guaranteed minimum? A minimum per minute, per hour, or per day? Prioritize traffic based on type? Implement caps? Allow people to pay for more speed, higher caps, or both?

In the case of limited bandwidth, the "fairest" way would be to enforce a moving average cap. The most economically efficient way would be some sort of dynamic price system[1].

>But since people often have little or no choice over which carrier or ISP they use and switching can be expensive

In the context of this thread (wireless carriers), isn't this moot? I get how there are local ISP monopolies for residential internet, but the whole country has good access to all the major carriers.

[1] instead of getting 5GB, you get 5,000,000 "bandwidth credits". If a cell tower is below capacity, each megabyte of transfer only costs a nominal amount of credits (200). But as capacity approaches 100%, it costs more and more (up to 10000, or more). We could even have a total free market similar to bitcoin network fees where customers can enter a bid. If your bid isn't high enough you're limited to 2g speeds, or get no data at all.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by dylan604 on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:19PM (#20741927)
And how is this indicated to the user? At least the ride hailing apps displayed their "surge pricing" before you used the service. As I'm traveling through town and being handed off to different cell towers, am I going to see a pop-up saying the current rate on this tower is XXXX amount and allow me to accept or not? The flexible invisible cost is just not a good thing for end users
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by gruez on Monday August 19, 2019 @09:42PM (#20743185)
>As I'm traveling through town and being handed off to different cell towers, am I going to see a pop-up saying the current rate on this tower is XXXX amount

Is there a reason why this can't be done? Have a carrier app that you can use to check the current rate, and that sends push notifications when the rate exceeds a rate that you've set. You can even do this through SMS so it doesn't take up any bandwidth.

>and allow me to accept or not?

Allow the user to set a maximum rate. If the current rate exceeds that rate, cut off data access. Allow the user to reactivate data or change the maximum through the app or through SMS.

>The flexible invisible cost is just not a good thing for end users

I never said it was the best approach, just the most efficient approach from a microeconomics point of view.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by casylum on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:30PM (#20740977)
But then carriers would have a financial motivation to not upgrade tower capacity. The more congested - the more money they make.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by gruez on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:01PM (#20741260)
True, but only if they hold an monopoly. If there's a competitor, customers would switch to the cheapest option and they'd lose all their bushiness. If they're a monopoly, well... you're already hosed because they could also infinitely raise prices and there's nothing you can do.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by crazygringo on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @09:58AM (#20747090)
> but the whole country has good access to all the major carriers

That's why I said switching can be expensive. If you discover bad internet speeds a month after you signed a standard 2-year contract with a carrier, what are you going to do?

Even if you pay that, you may need to pay for a new phone because of incompatible networks.

Not to mention the PITA of transferring your number.

(Similarly even if you have multiple ISP's, you may need to pay $$ for installation, a new modem, etc.)