News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WeWTF by dlgeek on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:16PM (#20725009)
> Adam also owned the rights to the "We" trademark, which the firm decided they must own and paid the founder/CEO $5.9 million for the rights. The rights to a name nearly identical to the name of the firm where he’s the founder/CEO and largest shareholder.

Really? How is this sort of shenanigan allowed?

Re:WeWTF by marcinzm on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:29PM (#20725092)
Adam controls the majority of voting right to the company and the board (made up of VCs) doesn't want a messy legal fight since they stand to lose money if We tanks. So a moderate amount of graft is tolerated since the alternative is less desirable.
Re:WeWTF by dooglius on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:44PM (#20725209)
Breach of fiduciary duty can be a criminal matter in addition to a civil one.
Re:WeWTF by amluto on Saturday August 17, 2019 @02:38PM (#20725527)
I am not a securities lawyer (or any other type of lawyer), but: if this all blows up, I believe that self-dealing by the executives is an excellent way for creditors to pierce the corporate veil.
Re:WeWTF by devcpp on Saturday August 17, 2019 @04:56PM (#20726314)
>Adam controls the majority of voting right to the company

This alone should be a massive turn-off for investors, nevermind this kind of personal eccentricity that makes this absolutely insane.

Re:WeWTF by erikpukinskis on Saturday August 17, 2019 @05:41PM (#20726595)
I don’t think majority ownership is necessarily a turn on or a turn off. There are cases when a bunch of minority shareholders would be chaotic and prevent the company from making long term bets. There are also cases where minority ownership would allow for stability while cycling through executive turnover and experimentation.

Which situation you are in, and whether shareholders would be turned off by majority ownership, is context specific.

For example, I think SpaceX would be a less attractive stock if there were only minority stockholders, and having Elon as the majority holder makes it more likely to succeed at going interplanetary, rather than just milking a traditional orbital business model.

If your investment thesis depends on a bold bet like that, a single majority shareholder you trust would be a comfort.

Re:WeWTF by Breza on Saturday August 24, 2019 @10:22PM (#20790958)
For the SpaceX example, I actually think they'd be better off focusing on the orbital launch market. The dream of affordable and reliable access to space dates back to the 50's and still hasn't been fully realized. In my opinion, that's a bigger deal than trying to get SpaceX to put a payload beyond orbit.

I agree with your larger point though.

Re:WeWTF by codeisawesome on Saturday August 17, 2019 @07:06PM (#20727015)
SpaceX isn’t a public stock though?
Re:WeWTF by erikpukinskis on Saturday August 17, 2019 @11:21PM (#20728029)
It still has investors, and shares.
Re:WeWTF by navigatesol on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:32PM (#20725113)
This guy has become a multi-hundred-millionaire by renting out office space under a business model that appears to make no financial sense. Because "tech company". It's utterly bonkers.
Re:WeWTF by marcinzm on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:38PM (#20725163)
It's basically a modern ponzi scheme as I see it. The VCs make money at the expense of people who buy post-IPO.
Re:WeWTF by wpietri on Saturday August 17, 2019 @02:07PM (#20725354)
Yeah, I think WeWork is at best the next Groupon: something that was made to seem just plausible enough at the time that the financiers made a bundle, but that rapidly turns into a minor-league business as the shiny wears off post-IPO.

And that's at best. But I think a collapse is more likely. Uber may also be losing a ton of money, but they have enormous pricing power over their major raw materials, namely individual drivers and their cars. But WeWork is renting space from hard-bitten landlords run by professionals, and those companies have plenty of alternative tenants if they don't like WeWork's terms. At some point I think there's going to be a mismatch between their short-term income structure and their long-term obligations to the space owners, and then it's going to be a big old mess.

Re:WeWTF by baby on Saturday August 17, 2019 @03:50PM (#20725938)
I fail to see the comparison with Groupon. Most people who have used Groupon have mixed reviews about the product, it worked sometimes but most of the times it didn't.

WeWork on the other hand seems like they have a solid product?

Maybe they are not profitable, and maybe the business model makes no sense and will never be profitable. In that sense then maybe you are right?

But in the mean time, the product they are selling works for their customers and there is high demand at the current price point (which is already insane imo).

Re:WeWTF by netsharc on Saturday August 17, 2019 @04:51PM (#20726274)
To expand on your 3rd paragraph, maybe that's the Ponzi scheme, with big investors playing along:

1. Start a shiny business that attracts customers. Never mind that you're losing money per customer.

2. Get some big investors. You are now valued at 2-digit-billion dollars.

3. Talk about IPO. The general investing public has heard about your shiny service/product because the news talks about how shiny and hip you are (are MSNBC just idiots so easily distracted?) and the public are about to bite!

4. IPO. Big investors cash out. Mom-and-Pop investors lose money.

5. Profit! For you and your big investors.

Re:WeWTF by csande17 on Saturday August 17, 2019 @06:07PM (#20726718)
See also: MoviePass, which failed somewhere between (2) and (3) because they were a little too obvious about doing (1).
Re:WeWTF by baby on Saturday August 17, 2019 @05:39PM (#20726589)
This makes me wonder, how many companies in a similar position (great product with a good demand) have failed and shut down to the misfortune of its customers?

I see similar talks about Uber, and yet I can't imagine such a product failing due to the number of happy customers.

Re:WeWTF by striking on Saturday August 17, 2019 @05:56PM (#20726672)
https://thehustle.co/Doughbies-cookies-shut-down/ is one that I know quite a few people feel strongly about.
Re:WeWTF by baby on Saturday August 17, 2019 @08:09PM (#20727275)
It sounds like it was mostly about the founders not wanting to continue maintaining a business that was not a unicorn. There was someone else on HN that posted about a similar company but decided to buy back equity and continue maintaining it.
Re:WeWTF by enjo on Sunday August 18, 2019 @03:28AM (#20728772)
In a Ponzi scheme you commit fraud. You make false claims about returns, and then use downstream investors money (enticed by those false claims) to pay off upstream investors to keep the scheme going.

This is a stock sale. The "mom and pop investors" buy into it with full knowledge of what they're buying. It might be a bad investment, but I don't see where the fraud comes in? I'm not convinced that WeWork is a sustainable business which is why I won't invest in it. Others might disagree.. we'll find out down the road who is right.

Re:WeWTF by wpietri on Sunday August 18, 2019 @02:11PM (#20731823)
I think that's why they said "modern ponzi scheme".

And no, mom-and-pop investors don't have full knowledge, not like insiders do. The fraud would come in if the insiders are being anything less than perfectly honest about current condition, future prospects, or their expectations.

Of course, this might not rise to the level of criminal fraud. But when you look at something like Groupon, which fell 90% quite quickly, and which had insiders taking money out early on, it's reasonable to suspect that at least some insiders knew what they were selling to the public was dubious, but did it anyhow.

Re:WeWTF by wpietri on Saturday August 17, 2019 @08:35PM (#20727397)
The comparison is that Groupon was exciting and hot at the time of the IPO, allowing investors and insiders to hype it and make a very profitable exit. But it turned out not to be great long term for a variety of reasons, so the stock price quickly fell (it's trading at something like 90% off peak).

Groupon is still a functioning business, of course, with something like $2bn/year in revenue. And WeWork might end up a functioning business as well, just like its competitors. But I think its best case is to end up like those competitors, which all have thin margins and look like regular old businesses, not profit fountains like Google, etc.

Re:WeWTF by sroussey on Saturday August 17, 2019 @02:57PM (#20725646)
Don’t underestimate the power of bankruptcy law, which is a plausible outcome. This is partly why real estate companies have lots of entities to use as firewalls and as leverage.
Re:WeWTF by fragmede on Saturday August 17, 2019 @02:55PM (#20725628)
If there's a recession that hits WeWork, those alternative tenants will also dry up, for the same reason. Companies won't want to justify a large capex investment into new office space, and cancel pending contracts for space that hasn't been built out yet.

Comparatively, the money WeWork's customers spend on WeWorks would be considered opex, for those whos budgets are big enough for the distinction to be material.

Is WeWorks hacking corporate America's budgeting practices, doing what AWS did for rack space?

Re:WeWTF by wpietri on Saturday August 17, 2019 @08:22PM (#20727342)
I think you're mixing up a couple of issues.

If a recession hits, or even if there's just a glut of rental office space because other players overinvest, then WeWork may not be able to fill their spaces, which they've mostly committed to on long-term leases. Their costs are fixed in the short term, but their revenue could be highly variable.

It's true that in the longer term the market for large blocks of space follows economic cycles, so if they are looking to expand during a recession, they can get a good price. But why would they do that? Since their business model is all about flexibility, they will be harder hit by recessions than both property owners and other people who need large blocks of space.

Re:WeWTF by laurentl on Saturday August 17, 2019 @03:48PM (#20725926)
The alternative tenants would also presumably rent the building rather than buy it outright. So it would still be opex.
Re:WeWTF by aeyes on Saturday August 17, 2019 @04:26PM (#20726128)
Don't underestimate the amount of time and money it takes to actually make an empty office space usable. And that isn't the worst of it. If you have a fast growing company you'll be moving or expanding your office space at least every other year. Or you can pay for lots of unused space.

With something like WeWork I can just come in no matter if I have a 10 or 100 person team.

Were I work we have moved the HQ 3 times in 4 years with substantial cost. We now have a couple of international locations and all of them are under WeWorks roofs. We are glad to not be dealing with the office burden abroad.

Up until 100 employees in the same location, I'd chose WeWork any day and concentrate on my product. I have been to lots of CoWork spaces, they all don't work long-term and are only good for fairly small teams. WeWork on the other hand is also good for bigger teams.

Re:WeWTF by projektfu on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:46PM (#20725218)
If it goes where I think it should, then it’ll be the IPO subscribers holding the bag.
Re:WeWTF by avip on Saturday August 17, 2019 @04:17PM (#20726075)
That's not fraud, that's business as usual. We are selling to willing buyers at the current fair market price
Re:WeWTF by hestefisk on Saturday August 17, 2019 @04:58PM (#20726332)
Where is the Ponzi scheme element?
Re:WeWTF by sameers on Saturday August 17, 2019 @04:21PM (#20726102)
I believe it's "because on-tap kombucha." That's their secret sauce, or secret juice, if you will.
Re:WeWTF by juliusmusseau on Saturday August 17, 2019 @02:56PM (#20725641)
This is a classic due-diligence item during early funding rounds - up there with "does the company actually own its domain name or do one of the founders own it"?

I suspect either due-diligence caught it and decided to live with it after some negotiation, or they missed it - oops!

Re:WeWTF by konschubert on Saturday August 17, 2019 @03:04PM (#20725687)
No, they just decided later to re-name the company from WeWork to We - and then they needed the new brand name
Re:WeWTF by juliusmusseau on Saturday August 17, 2019 @03:26PM (#20725799)
The founder already personally owned the trademark to "We" well before they made that decision? That's lucky.

In that case wouldn't he simply have to divulge that fact early on in the decision-making process? "Guys, maybe I should recuse myself on this decision since I'm in a bit of a conflict..."

Re:WeWTF by 6nf on Saturday August 17, 2019 @05:37PM (#20726580)
He has majority voting rights, he's the one making these decisions.
Re:WeWTF by JumpCrisscross on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:30PM (#20725105)
> How is this sort of shenanigan allowed?

Investors gave Adam virtually unchecked power over their capital.

Re:WeWTF by n-exploit on Saturday August 17, 2019 @01:22PM (#20725045)
The Tragedy of the Commons 2.0™
Re:WeWTF by Apocryphon on Monday August 19, 2019 @06:17PM (#20742325)
The Tragedy of the Creative Commons
Re:WeWTF by DannyBee on Saturday August 17, 2019 @08:03PM (#20727251)
It usually is not. But delaware