News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by groundlogic on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:42PM (#20706883)
Finally an IPO I want to buy into. Technical fundamentals matter.

Edit: I mean that in the software/service way, not the economical way, in case there was any confusion.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dsl on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:02PM (#20707146)
> Technical fundamentals matter.

Centralization of the entire internet behind a single entity is a _bad_ thing for people who care about technical fundamentals.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by macinjosh on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:44PM (#20707631)
Exactly! I don't why Internet folks fall into this trap time and time again! It's probably simply because it is an easy and quick way to tell your boss your website is protected consequences be damned.

I can imagine the next Edward Snowden will reveal the intelligence community's direct line into the traffic running over Cloudflare's infrastructure. Cloudflare is providing DNS and HTTPS services on a massive scale which means they can essentially MiTM any of their customers on behalf of the government.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by JakeTheAndroid on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:30PM (#20708183)
It depends on the topic of discussion. If we are discussing the viability of a company, and trying to project long term success, then this is all good news.

If you are discussing whats best for society and how these businesses impact those things, then this could be alarming news.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dmix on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:41PM (#20708897)
There's a big shift towards privacy happening now. If Cloudflare came out a decade ago I'd also be in their camp. But the risks are too high and developers are starting to recognize that Cloudflare is far from free and comes with long terms consequences for the health and resiliency of the internet.

I appreciate how they pushed HTTPs widely. But now that's Let's encrypt exists there's no excuse.

Ill also never forgive them for making Tor completely unusable for accessing any normal website. It's almost impossible to pass the security checks and if you do another one is coming once you switch IP. I understand Tor is a niche product but it's an important one for activists and other persecuted people. And it will only continue to grow in importance as the dictators all learn how to do NSA style mass surveillance.

The DDOS stuff if the harder problem to solve and I don't know enough about it to judge the competition's ability to offer it safely and privacy friendly way.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by JakeTheAndroid on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:01PM (#20709064)
I mean, that's like your opinion or whatever, sure. But this S-1 filing is about if they are a sustainable business. And none of what you touched on would seem to have any serious impact on their business model.

The Tor stuff feels way over blown to me. I worked at CF while it was a problem, and was an avid Tor user at the time. It was a terrible user experience, but it wasn't completely Cloudflare's fault. They didn't target Tor users, Tor exit nodes have terrible IP rep which is an industry standard for risk rating IPs. ReCaptcha had some functional issues that could not be solved by Cloudflare. And lastly, site owners did next to nothing to support their Tor visitors even once dedicated options were available via the IP Firewall. This seems like hyperbole, especially as JGC was avid about getting this resolved, and was very public with the discourse. Companies don't do things perfect all the time, and it seems extreme to hold CF purely responsible and hold onto that anger for something that's long been resolved.

In the end, everything in this S-1 is promising for people interested in tech businesses, which is what many people are praising. They already generate a profit, their operation costs are reasonable, etc.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by kingbirdy on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:35PM (#20710744)
> They already generate a profit, their operation costs are reasonable, etc.

They don't turn a profit, and their operating costs are growing sharply. From the S-1:

> As we continue to invest in our business, we have incurred net losses of $17.3 million, $10.7 million, and $87.2 million for 2016, 2017, and 2018, respectively.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dmix on Friday August 16, 2019 @01:13PM (#20717211)
There's always a compromise with privacy that people are willing to ignore in the short term, but I'd rather bet on long-term trendlines than people's laziness today.

Their business model of taking over and centralizing whole sections of internet will continually cause a backlash. They only have a percentage of all traffic today and it continues to increase. And apparently so does their willingness to not be a neutral service provider as we saw with 8chan, which is in stark contrast to their policy towards the LulzSec hackers and plenty of other "bad guys".

I'm sure Cloudflare will continue to be a good business in the short-term, but that should never be the relevant metric for any business. But it will become more and more obvious to everyone the bigger they get.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by Dylan16807 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:05PM (#20710931)
> Ill also never forgive them for making Tor completely unusable for accessing any normal website.

Is the privacy pass extension an invalid fix for the problem?

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by est31 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:53PM (#20707736)
> Centralization of the entire internet behind a single entity is a _bad_ thing

They do the opposite. They enable small website owners to survive on the internet without having to use vertically integrated services like cloud offerings.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dsl on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:58PM (#20707803)
I'm not sure you fully understand the problem. If I hit the big red button and just shut Cloudflare off, millions of websites drop off the Internet. It is a massive single point of failure, and as you point out, a vertically integrated service (DNS, DDoS protection, WAF, proxying, etc).
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by est31 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @06:08PM (#20710196)
I have said that it's not a vertically integrated service. Others are. Like S3. Or GCP. Cloudflare makes it possible to avoid the big clouds and do your own hosting or to use a smaller hosting company.

As for the millions of websites going offline. Surely, Cloudflare has tons of customers. It's an internet scale company. If they act sloppy and have tons of downtime a competitor might take over. If it's hard to architect a DDoS protection service in a robust way then that's just the world we live in. But I think you should appreciate that Cloudflare sells DDoS protection (their core product atm) without selling you a big package like http serving or root servers.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by _bxg1 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:24PM (#20708123)
DNS is far from centralized and DDoS protection is something that small websites would have no ability to do on their own. It isn't just a convenience thing, it's a literally-impossible-without-scale thing.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by tracker1 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:26PM (#20708762)
DNS for sites protected by cloudflare are on cloudflare's DNS afaik.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by llama052 on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:42AM (#20712232)
That's optional and has been for awhile now I believe, you can CNAME from your own DNS provider. While that does rely on their DNS for that one record, it means you still have control to changeover if need be.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by tracker1 on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:40PM (#20718912)
And, that doesn't change the point... the website protected by cloudflare still controls the effective dns for that site. The lookups are controlled, and CF is a mitm vector.

A client deployment of an app, that the client had behind cloudflare was making 80ms API requests take 8 seconds. It's not always great.

I'm not saying that there aren't alternatives, and that people have to use Cloudflare... but there really isn't much in the way of an alternative at even a similar level of support and price on the low/introduction side of things. The issue regarding recaptcha can be REALLY annoying, especially on a non-google browser.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by _bxg1 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:42PM (#20708903)
Right but there are plenty of other options for DNS providers.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by tracker1 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:58PM (#20709594)
There are... but as CF correlates to a significant portion of internet traffic and DNS lookups, it's not like the original point is invalid.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by labawi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:07PM (#20708562)
DDoS protection is something that small websites should not need.

Current circumstances are a sad and unfortunate state of the internet.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by makomk on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:20PM (#20708703)
Not only that, Cloudflare has helped to ensure that DDoS protection is something that every website needs. Under normal circumstances, all the shady DDoS-as-a-service providers would DDoS each other off the internet and leave everyone else in relative peace. However, Cloudflare kindly provided them all with free, world-class, no-questions-asked DDoS protection to ensure that they could continue operating their business of destroying sites that didn't use Cloudflare.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by _bxg1 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:43PM (#20708912)
This doesn't make any sense at all. What are you basing it on?
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by makomk on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:58PM (#20709037)
See for instance https://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/01/spreading-the-disease-an... or more recently https://www.secureworldexpo.com/industry-news/does-cloudflar... - this has been going on for years and is officially permitted by Cloudflare policy. (The reason why these booter services need such good DDoS protection is that knocking the competition offline makes for good business - it's a great demonstration of effectiveness and cuts off their business at the same time. In the pre-Cloudflare era those services were locked in an almost continual war against each other.)
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by llama052 on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:44AM (#20712242)
Look at any big cloud provider or CDN and the same can be said. If you don't have a DR plan in place to bypass a CDN provider in a downtime situation then you're doing something wrong. (assuming it isn't a hobby project)
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by lhill on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:14PM (#20708650)
I'm not sure you fully understand what Cloudflare does.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by tracker1 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:25PM (#20708745)
It's really both. I think the biggest issue that some have is that Cloudflare has no real competition at this point for those that cannot afford the more expensive options. And combined with that, they control a very large portion of internet web traffic and are in a position where they could potentially be heavily influenced by government actors.

I'm not saying that it's happening, or even that it is the biggest concern for most. But it should be a bit of a concern to some, and one may want to think about if they really want to use them in this context. It's a matter of knowing and evaluating all of the risks involved.

Does it really matter for a static blog that only publishes a few articles a week? Not so much.

Does it matter for a media company that publishes articles a government doesn't like and initiates contact through it's website? Probably.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by gmanley on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:33PM (#20707491)
If you are just using the basic service for a firewall/DDOS protection and CDN there doesn't seem to be much lock in. If other competitors come along, and they undoubtedly will if Cloudflare proves the value of the market, it should just be a matter of switching your DNS records to said competitor. Maybe I'm not imaginative enough, so please share if I'm not thinking of something, but it doesn't seem like their market share makes it harder for other competitors, they aren't monopolistic.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by madeofpalk on Thursday August 15, 2019 @05:02PM (#20709634)
You realise that Cloudflare is nowhere near a monopoly, right? They might be the most 'household' CDN, but they're far from the first or biggest
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by auslander on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:41PM (#20708896)
> the entire internet behind a single entity

You're giving CF too much credit. They are very small fish, as it seems from the S-1. But still dangerous because they MITM while operating for free at loss, so don't reuse passwords and logins between sites.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by gmanley on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:40PM (#20710777)
They handle about 10% of web requests according to this blog post: https://blog.cloudflare.com/why-we-terminated-daily-stormer

If we trust that metric, it seems significant to me. Not what I would call small fish.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by auslander on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:47PM (#20711165)
Small animals tend to puff to look bigger :) 10% of whole internet on a budget of 50-80M / year is hard to believe.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by smallbigfish on Friday August 16, 2019 @01:33AM (#20712434)
US ISPs make you think that internet traffic is like gold ;). I get tens of terabytes here in Europe for 10€.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by groundlogic on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:08PM (#20707225)
Yeah, from a citizen perspective I agree. C'est la vie. Our governments need to work against this via legislation.

It should not be up to Matthew Prince to decide who to block. He has demonstrated his inability to function as censor in a very visible (and frankly embarassing) way.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by mschuster91 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:43PM (#20708308)
> He has demonstrated his inability to function as censor in a very visible (and frankly embarassing) way.

How? There have been exactly two cases of "censorship", and that is the Daily Stormer and 8chan. One is an utterly vile peddler of antisemitism (literally named after a Nazi paper) and conspiracy theory, and one was linked to at least three terroristic attacks. If it were not white supremacists but Islamists, it would be closed down in an instant and no one would bat an eye.

If anything, Cloudflare seriously lacks (like Facebook and Twitter) policing their customer base.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by tidepod12 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:00PM (#20708486)
>If it were not white supremacists but Islamists, it would be closed down in an instant and no one would bat an eye.

This is ironic since Cloudflare has famously been under fire because Prince specifically decided against removing ISIS websites from Cloudflare and vehemently defended his decision that Cloudflare should not be censoring anyone.

Prince himself even agrees with the parent comment, and he goes into pretty good detail in his blog post here [1] about why companies like Cloudflare should not be able to make the decision to remove websites, and that it should be left up to governments. I guess he got overruled on that stance when it came to 8chan, though.

1: https://blog.cloudflare.com/why-we-terminated-daily-stormer/

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by buildzr on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:53PM (#20707026)
I'm sure it's just in my head, but it feels like the first tech IPO in several years where there actually seems to be a viable business model.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by dsl on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:08PM (#20707229)
> where there actually seems to be a viable business model.

It has carried them this far, but the real money will be when they turn to advertising (which investors will eventually figure out and insist on).

Remember all the crazy marketing data ISPs wanted to collect, then we pushed everyone to move to TLS? Well Cloudflare unwraps TLS for all their clients and is in a position to collect all the same data.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by mikeyouse on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:59PM (#20707107)
Zoom stands out in this category too. Random blog on Medium, but the points all stand:

https://medium.com/@alexfclayton/zoom-ipo-s-1-breakdown-1192...

Growing >100% YoY, profitable, generating cashflow, NPS above 70, just an all around solid business.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by thinkloop on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:10PM (#20707243)
Zoom has very little defensible tech, it's more about packaging/marketing. Cloudflare is very difficult to duplicate.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by steve19 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:21PM (#20707371)
Not true, Zoom has developed and deployed very sophisticated malware which would be hard to replicate on purpose or through incompetence.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by pjkundert on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:03PM (#20707881)
You would think...

But, every competitor that I’ve tried to use is a train wreck. Zoom just works. All the time, every time.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by erichurkman on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:22PM (#20709253)
The fact that Zoom has gotten software engineers to _like_ Zoom is a testament. Most engineers I know detest almost all video conference solutions. Hangouts eats batteries for breakfast, Cisco products are clunky and expensive, Skype is ancient, etc.... but Zoom just works.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by ec109685 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:18PM (#20707339)
Zoom has network effects. If a company has deployed zoom in their conference rooms, talking to non-zoom shops stinks.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by sciurus on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:24PM (#20707398)
> Cloudflare is very difficult to duplicate.

Unless you're one of their many competitors, like, say, AWS. From the S-1:

"Our current and potential future competitors include a number of different types of companies, including:

• on-premise hardware network vendors, such as Cisco Systems Inc., F5 Networks, Inc., Check Point Software Technologies Ltd., FireEye, Inc., Imperva, Inc., Palo Alto Networks, Inc., Juniper Networks, Inc., and Riverbed Technology, Inc.;

• point-cloud solution vendors, including cloud security vendors such as Zscaler, Inc. and Cisco Systems Inc. through Umbrella (formerly known as OpenDNS), content delivery network vendors such as Akamai Technologies, Inc., Limelight Networks, Inc., Fastly, Inc., and Verizon Communications Inc. through Edgecast, domain name system vendors services such as Oracle Corporation through DYN, NeuStar, Inc., and UltraDNS Corporation, and cloud SD-WAN vendors; and

• traditional public cloud vendors, such as Amazon.com, Inc. through Amazon Web Services, Alphabet Inc. through Google Cloud Platform, Microsoft Corporation through Azure, and Alibaba Group Holding Limited through Alibaba Cloud. "

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by nezgar on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:43PM (#20707608)
>"on-premise hardware network vendors..."

Wow, they grammar goofed "on-premise" 33 times on their filing. (should be on-premises)

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by ksec on Friday August 16, 2019 @02:34PM (#20718147)
Not sure why the above getting downvoted, unless On-Premises is wrong? ( Honest Question, I have always used On-Premises )

Edit: And Now I am getting downvoted for asking a question.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by nezgar on Friday August 16, 2019 @04:06PM (#20719182)
"on-premises" is indeed correct in this context.

"premise" is a thought or idea. "premises" is a location, like your servers can be "on-premises". Completely different meanings.

I hear lots of people these days mistakenly saying "on-premise" during hybrid-cloud conversations and in documentation when they really mean "on-premises". (And yes, looks like I've been down-voted for my first hacker news comment too.)

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by ksec on Saturday August 17, 2019 @08:33AM (#20723699)
It just means the quality of HN is downgrading very rapidly.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by Areading314 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:59PM (#20707100)
This is a sure sign that:

* You won't get allocated any shares

* Trading will start at a ridiculously high valuation, maybe 10x sales or more

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by groundlogic on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:11PM (#20707260)
GOOG and FB also seemed overpriced a week after their respective IPOs.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by antcas on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:01PM (#20707128)
Zoom and Twilio as well.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by jmtulloss on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:17PM (#20707331)
Also fastly, which has the same business model
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by jonas21 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:26PM (#20707423)
How about Slack, PagerDuty, Zoom, Crowdstrike, or Pinterest? These were all in the last few months.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by adventured on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:42PM (#20710788)
You can also add DocuSign (last year) to that list. They're heading toward a billion in annual sales and they offer a straight-forward and useful service.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by groundlogic on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:55PM (#20709566)
Exactly - relatively little technical depth.
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by jonas21 on Friday August 16, 2019 @01:05AM (#20712343)
I was responding to buildzr who wrote:

> I'm sure it's just in my head, but it feels like the first tech IPO in several years where there actually seems to be a viable business model.

The companies listed above have what appear to be viable business models. I didn't intend to comment on technical merits, but I think you may be underestimating the technical depth of what some of these companies are doing.

Re:Cloudflare S-1 by groundlogic on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:58PM (#20707093)
It's quite refreshing, right?
Re:Cloudflare S-1 by PatrolX on Thursday August 15, 2019 @12:43PM (#20706892)
Ditto, I'm excited about this one.