Just as a disclaimer, I've read the guidelines and know them well.
It's also off topic. Whimsical off-topic digressions can be interesting, but generic rhetorical ones are never interesting. Those discussions have been repeated countless times already, thus are predictable, thus are tedious, so we ask people to avoid them. The more generic a subject, the more shallow its discussion—and when it's angry as well, that's much worse. Angry plus shallow equals riler-upper, which is close to flamebait.
I understood your point and I'm not trying to prolong the discussion. However, I consider the implication that my comment was entirely devoid of a point a bit unfair, so I'll try to rephrase.
I think there is no good argument to be made for stripping away the privacy of citizens, with the implication that it's okay since they are somehow less important than businesses. The fact that this is now getting somewhat regularly proposed is scary and a danger to liberty. To me, Barr's statement reads as a long-winded way of saying "it's not too bad if we punch holes in your encryption because your systems weren't secure to begin with and you're also not that important since you are just consumers". My point was to call this out explicitly and try to invalidate it as an argument for breaking encryption.
>The right of large business enterprises to be secure in their employees, locations, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the large business enterprises or things to be seized.
Who do I (continue to) donate to in order to express my opinion that this is inexcusable? EFF?
Donate directly to the open-ecosystem cryptographers, and seek a technical solution whenever a political solution is impossible.
I often base my vote, when all the candidates in a given election have similar policies, on how they refer to people.
Use of "Consumers" loses my vote instantly. "Taxpayers" is a yellow flag - if used in specific situations that involves concern over major public funds going to private businesses (like building a stadium for a pro sports team) I'll let it slide but otherwise it only raises suspicion in me. But if a politician consistently uses "citizen", I'll give them a little mental gold star.
I used to hate the word consumer too (I don't love it now either) but honestly basing your vote on it seems like a really coarse way to distinguish between good and bad candidates...
I was referring to its use in the context of an election, which is often limited to the citizenry (in any democracy).
Also, where I live, public figures who use the word "citizen" to refer to ordinary people often don't use it in the literal sense of the word when discussing public-interest matters. They're often using it to emphasize the responsibilities and rights that all people have in relation to the broader society. In other words, where I live it's not often used in an exclusionary xenophobic way, but instead in an inclusive common-purpose way that emphasizes our shared humanity. The xenophobes here tend to prefer "taxpayer".
In the US some states or cities allow non-citizen legal residents to vote in some state and local elections (SF for examples allows non-citizen residents to vote for school boards)
The irony, I guess, being that the xenophobes probably intend to raise a distinction better delineated by the word "citizen".
Heck, the President and many members of Congress, the military, intelligence services, etc. use an iPhone. Maybe let's think about that before we stick a backdoor in that piece of "consumer" technology.
But with extra software that isn't on the iPhones ordinary consumers get, to implement and enforce the government's security policies for its officials.
Corporations are people too. Groups of people, ganged together and agreeing to do big and enormous things to other big, enormous groups of people, is how we get into the corporate nightmare.
The spirit of the individual is what needs to persist in all of this. If you want privacy, you have to be willing to gain it and maintain it yourself.
We are not consumers, we are people - but we can be consumed as well as any other resource. To stay ahead of that, produce!
However, when I read the word "consumer" in pronouncements like this, it seems like something else. The people using it usually don't mean it in a way that implies they are themselves consumers. They mean it in a class-forming way. The only way I would personally be able to refer to other people in this way would be to become the controller of a large global corporation and to be willing to exploit and submit others for my personal gain. This is not something I would ever want to do.
It's a very weird contortion of logic to say something like, "Only people can be the subject of a legal instrument; We need corporations to be the subject of a legal instrument; We must make corporations people."
I mean, we have control over the underlying premise here. We can change it. Maybe that makes some people less angry. Maybe that makes it easier to reason about corporate issues without accidental conflation of the subtly different aspects of "person".
That patch in has had grave consequences.
A liability shield is a fantastic invention for capital owners, because when things go pear shaped, they can leave the rest of us holding the buck.
Most of us aren't capital owners, in any meaningful sense, though.
This is an interesting book looking at how legal structures may have held back otherwise very advanced cultures in the middle east:
https://www.economist.com/business/2011/01/27/the-crescent-a...
It refers to this book:
If you look at the developing world, the situation is even bleaker.
So, as far as ownership structures of capital go, for 95% of the population, it is a rounding error.
Also, damages that required liability doesn't just magically disappear, if you fail to pass it on to a company's owners.
The harm that caused the liability has already been done, the shareholders have already been paid from the profits of it - but the victims aren't getting compensation for it. In any just world, these profits would be clawed back.
That's still investment. Make up your mind on if an investment implies criminal and financial liability or not.
>and won't be receiving a lick of pension upon retirement.
That's because pensions aren't very popular in the US. You should look into IRA's, 401ks, etc to understand how the current working class has to prepare for retirement. Pensions (at least the ones that used to be popular in the US offered by companies) are complete garbage for the very reason that they can be raided.
>The harm that caused the liability has already been done, the shareholders have already been paid from the profits of it
No, it's actually pretty rare for modern companies to immediately issue all profits to shareholders as dividends.
>In any just world, these profits would be clawed back.
Well the company gets hit with a huge fine and all of the shareholders (and bondholders in bankruptcy) lose their investment. It's very rare to find a company that did something illegal long enough to generate 100% dividends to cover the initial shareholder investment and then get caught and wiped out.
"Humans and corporations are both persons" is kind of facile- corporations don't have quite the same set of rights that humans do.
I'm kind of on the fence about this. My counterargument to your comment is that the iPhone, Google search, global shipping, oil production, etc. could not be created by individuals. These things exist because huge groups of humans organized into things called "businesses".
Protecting businesses is like protecting the economies of states. There are massive effects for lots of people if businesses are not treated well. So yes, businesses get special deals sometimes. Unfortunately, this is a slippery slope, and people often fall down it.
To me, the truth in your comment is that US culture tends to give credit to CEOs for the efforts of all the other people in the organization. And this can be easily conflated with all kinds of other issues like "fines are just things that are illegal for poor people".
Businesses are a good and necessary concept, but that does not mean they are above the people. Businesses are servants of the people and of society.
To get back on the topic at hand, businesses should definitely not get special allowance to use some technology that "ordinary" people are outlawed from using. That is a path to disaster.
This very American attitude of separating "business enterprises" from "consumers", which to me sounds like separating the noble and important from peasants or cattle, is utterly sickening. I am not a "consumer", I am a person and I deserve and demand more privacy and freedom than a corporation.
We are not consumers, we are people.