- they can be wrong
- there most likely is no god
The absolutist nature of these discussions and the near deification of a bunch of well-meaning but ultimately fallible humans has me puzzled. There is no way that the people that wrote up the constitutions of the various still functioning (to greater or lesser extent) democracies had the foresight to deal with 100's of years of technological progress.
That said, I think rooting rights in somebody's mythological figures isn't a good idea. And "natural" in this case isn't much more meaningful. It's fine rhetoric, but it's not a very strong conceptual model.
Equally, you have every right to set up a website to say whatever you want. That doesn't mean the people who provide the infrastructure behind that website have to continue to host your platform, it doesn't mean other peoples internet providers have to allow access to your website, and it doesn't mean search providers have to list your website in their results.
Freedom of speech worked really well when the largest audience you could get was the people in your local tavern, but it doesn't scale to a global internet without some adjustment. Just like your other example of the right to self defence - the idea of taking arms against a tyrannical government made perfect sense when everybody had muskets, but it doesn't really scale when the tyrannical government has drones and nukes.
Freedom of speech worked really well when the largest
audience you could get was the people in your local tavern
Even then, even before printing presses or the written word itself there were major, major limitations.- You were never allowed to "say whatever you like" in the name of committing fraud
- You were never allowed to "say whatever you like" in terms of threats; I don't know any society that would tolerate a person standing outside his neighbor's home and screaming death threats
- etc.
I make this somewhat pedantic point because the idea of "free speech with limits" is not some kind of modern idea that represents a watering-down of the lofty ideals upon which modern nations were founded, which is why many people seem to object to it. There were always necessary limits to free speech; the right to free speech has never trumped other peoples' rights not to be threatened, killed, defrauded, etc.
Such societies did and do exist, but usually they are good examples of why we limit hate speech. Nazi Germany and the US South during the KKK’s peak are a couple easy ones to reference. Both of those are examples of societies without free speech that still allowed speech that most societies do not.
Except for enticing violence, fraud or etc.
In Europe, you can get in jail if you say hateful or discriminatory things. We want to keep our society more decent (although cracks are forming).
The freedom of speech indeed doesn't mean that others must facilitate you or listen to you.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olefVguutfo
We should designate a copy of archive.org as critical infrastructure.
What many folks (often, seemingly willingly) fail to understand is that those rights were never intended to be parsed in a naive, simplistic way that supersedes the rights of others.
The most obvious example would be speech that causes others to be killed: you have a right to free speech, but other people also have a right not to be killed.
That's why you can't yell "FIRE!" in a crowded movie theater and cause a stampede that kills people, etc.
There are many other examples of free speech that infringe on others' rights.
Call free speech a "natural" right if you wish, whatever that means to you, but only a fool would think that either the Founding Fathers or basic human decency and sense dictate that free speech is meant to exist in some sort of vacuum independent from any and all other rights.
Uh, your history classes have really failed you. These rights weren't novel, they were explicitly enshrined in the English Bill of Rights in 1689. Some of the other rights (particularly debtors' rights) date back to the Magna Carta in 1215.
> That's why you can't yell "FIRE!" in a crowded movie theater and cause a stampede that kills people, etc.
For the record, you're citing a 1919 US Supreme Court case that has been overturned. The current standard for free speech in the US is Brandenburg v Ohio [1], which holds that it is constitutionally-protected free speech to advocate violent overthrow of the government. Only speech that amounts to incitement of "imminent lawless action" is prohibited. Note, of course, that the freedom of speech only applies to the government's ability to restrict speech for its content (which, in the US, is extremely limited); the ability of private parties to choose whether or not to provide a platform for speech is considered freedom of association and does not rely at all on any of these decisions.
[1] For what it's worth, the actual speech given by Brandenburg is basically the same sort of speech you'll find in these manifestos.
It wasn't about giving freedom to the people, but shifting power from the monarchy to parliment.
The freedom of speech enshrined in the English bill of rights also isn't remotely comparable to the USA idea. It was about parlimentary priviledge - the ability for MPs to have freedom of speech while within parliment. It was about the freedom of parliment to debate and vote without interference from the monarchy. (Parliment can and does impose its own limits on freedom of speech within the chamber and MPs have been literally removed from the chamber for things they've said).
The UK has never had freedom of speech. We even had an official censor (Lord Chamberlain's Office) until 1968. Blasphemy was illegal until 2008, and wasn't just a legacy law which had been forgotten, but there were convictions for it right the way through to the 1990s at least.
Uh, your history classes have really failed you. These rights
weren't novel, they were explicitly enshrined in the English
Bill of Rights in 1689. Some of the other rights (particularly
debtors' rights) date back to the Magna Carta in 1215.
Sure. That's why I qualified my statement: "not entirely new" and "fairly novel" rather than "entirely novel" because I'm aware that the U.S. Constitution is not the first time these notions have appeared in law. It was specifically an attempt to head off a pedantic reply such as yours. For the record, you're citing a 1919 US Supreme Court case
that has been overturned. The current standard for free speech
in the US is Brandenburg v Ohio [1], which holds that it is
constitutionally-protected free speech to advocate violent
overthrow of the government
You're simply incorrect. The justices' opinions in this case specifically agreed with this particular instance of prohibited speech, even referring to it directly.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio#Concurrenc...
Finally, Douglas dealt with the classic example of a man
"falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic".
In order to explain why someone could be legitimately prosecuted
for this, Douglas called it an example in which "speech is
brigaded with action". In the view of Douglas and Black, this
was probably the only sort of case in which a person could be
prosecuted for speech.
More to the point, please understand: this ruling specifically addressed inflammatory (no pun presumably intended) speech.This was not a comprehensive ruling on speech in general. It was an influential ruling on speech specifically meant to rouse others to action.
There are innumerable other types of speech this ruling did not address. Libel, threats, etc.
Forget about folks' educations failing them; your misconceptions could have been avoided with a simple Wikipedia visit. On the bright side, this experience reminded me to make my annual donation to Wikipedia. Obviously it's a sorely-needed resource.
I have no idea what you're trying to argue anymore here, because you seem to be both arguing that the concept of free speech was a radical invention of the American Revolution and that the fact that it predates the American Revolution is "pedantic."
(If you really want to be pedantic, the modern concept of expansive First Amendment rights is actually novel, but dates to the mid-20th century, when SCOTUS started interpreting these rights very expansively and setting up series of very stringent tests. I rather assume that the founding fathers would have been horrified at the depths that Brandenburg v Ohio went to protect offensive speech; it's certainly more radical than is the case in most countries even today).
> You're simply incorrect.
The statement "shouting fire in a crowded theater" is a reference to Schenck, where the justices used that as the example of why advocating against the draft was not constitutionally-protected speech, motivating the "clear and present danger" test that was explicitly overturned by Brandenburg's "imminent lawless action" test.
In other words, Brandenburg v Ohio was quite explicitly saying that the bar for what speech is considered so dangerous as to lose its constitutional protection should not be set at a level that is merely upsetting to people but rather at the level where it is at the literal cusp of violence.
> There are innumerable other types of speech this ruling did not address. Libel, threats, etc.
Of course not. But for the kind of speech that is in question, namely these white supremacist manifestos, it is exactly the case that rules.
As they say, I can explain it to you but I can't comprehend it for you. You're on your own now.
Any argument otherwise should be met with harsh skepticism because you could be actively trying to oppress us again or accidentally enable some future people in power to be able to.
Any argument otherwise should be met with harsh
skepticism because you could be actively trying to
oppress us again or accidentally enable some future
people in power to be able to
It works both ways.Russia's social media operations utilized (and is surely still aiming to utilize) our relatively permissive climate of free speech to sow discord within America and deepen our divisions.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/17/us/politics/takeaways-rus...
So, there you go - there's "people in power" using free speech to weaken/oppress us.
So you should be able to criticize the king/ president but does it mean you should say anything that pops in to your mind? Defending racist and other hate speech with the first amendment is a banalisation of the first amendment.
It's just that many of my fellow Americans choose to interpret our constitution in a simplistic, childish, and frankly incorrect way.
Our constitutional rights (including free speech) were never meant to be interpreted in a vacuum, irrespective of all other rights.
Our courts have certainly never interpreted things that way. Our courts have always weighed each individual, constitutionally-mandated right against other rights.
No, the founding fathers specifically said that freedom of speech is a God given right and not something which the government gives to a person, instead the government simply recognizes that right. They specifically said freedom of speech is a "Natural" right.
Right to clean water is not a right, right to education is not a natural right in their terms. Right to speech, right to self defense are natural rights.