News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by mistersquid on Sunday July 21, 2019 @11:45AM (#20491837)
Unequivocally, yes.

The disabled should be able to access online resources in a way that is functionally equivalent to an able-bodied person’s experience.

And yes, such accessibility should be protected by law.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by Misdicorl on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:08PM (#20491966)
I agree with you in theory, but I think this gets hairy pretty quick.

Should the requirement apply to a personal blog? What if that person is associated with something important and publishes interesting/useful information on their blog? What if they sell things? What if they only sell things by mail order and the site is just an ad? What if they have ads?

Level headed enforcement is one important aspect, but I feel like good legislation is really hard here.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by liability on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:25PM (#20492065)
Nobody has made me install a ramp to my front door, because I don't operate a business open to the public out of my home. So I'm not too concerned.

(That said, I would sooner make my blog accessible to the vision impaired than make my home wheelchair friendly. Web accessibility is trivial unless you go out of your way to do fancy shit with style sheets and JavaScript, or unless you do dumb shit like put important text in images with no alt-text (just... why??))

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by Misdicorl on Sunday July 21, 2019 @01:19PM (#20492402)
But the line between 'the business' and personal is often blurry. Must Elon Musk's tweets satisfy these requirements? What about a senior software engineer's blog which goes into some detail on a Google cloud outage?
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by liability on Sunday July 21, 2019 @05:56PM (#20493911)
Telsa and Elon both explicitly told the SEC that Elon's twitter account may used for official company messaging, making that an unambiguous example.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by Misdicorl on Sunday July 21, 2019 @02:07PM (#20492717)
To really drive the point home- what if both the engineer and Google earn money from the blog because it runs AdWords?
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by liability on Sunday July 21, 2019 @05:57PM (#20493915)
The de-adification of non-commercial websites would be a great outcome!
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by worldofmatthew on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:29PM (#20492091)
The biggest issue are screen readers which often work awfully with modern web standards.

On top of most web designers being unable to test with them just to high cost.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by floren on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:32PM (#20492106)
I don't know that the problem lies with modern web standards so much as modern web practices. I don't think there's anything in the HTML5 standard that makes screen readers shit the bed, but pervasive Javascript certainly can.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by worldofmatthew on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:44PM (#20492181)
Many accessibility tools shit the bed on CSS.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by tyingq on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:18PM (#20492025)
US airline websites have had to be accessible for quite a while now via a DOT directive. I agree some thought needs to be put into a rollout, but we do have some precedent.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by DanBC on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:12PM (#20491992)
Most law draws a distinction between something purely personal, and something done commercially.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by Misdicorl on Sunday July 21, 2019 @01:20PM (#20492409)
My point is that the line gets blurry on the internet really fast
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by beatgammit on Sunday July 21, 2019 @02:43PM (#20492935)
Precisely.

What if I decide to put ads on my personal blog because I've noticed that I have enough readers to make that make sense? Am I now a business? What if I decide to sell a plush design I made because people kept asking about it? Let's say that it becomes so popular that I choose to make a business out of it, at which point do I need to start making my website "accessible"? Is it when I file for a business license, or when I reach some amount in sales?

Personally, I don't understand the "accessibility as a right" crowd. Yes I want the web to be accessible to people with disabilities, but I don't think it makes sense to force people to cater to any particular group. Perhaps it makes sense as a requirement for publicly listed companies, and absolutely for any government entity or entities that receive government funding, but not for the average person or small business owner, and the internet blurs the line between individual and company.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by buro9 on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:47PM (#20492202)
if company and (company.headcount > x or company.revenue > y) then must_support_all_people end
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by dbg31415 on Sunday July 21, 2019 @02:06PM (#20492708)
This is the best way to put it.

But... What if they are 95% headcount and want to do 80% compliance? It just gets fuzzy fast.

And think of Amazon Prime... I love that I can order something and it comes the same day, or next day. That same level of service isn't offered in Sydney, or Rural North Dakota... would we require that of Amazon? Seems crazy.

So the extrapolated argument there is, "You can order a pizza on the phone, why do you need the app?" Likely some app-focused discount code the potential customer is trying to invoke. Seems like a lot of hassle for $2 off the pizza.

Or, again, Rural North Dakota, where you can't get a fast internet connection... is Netflix required to serve that area? I mean... can't we say, "We're only going to service people with a fast connection, modern OS, and who are willing to install our DRM plugins?"

I think it's OK for businesses not to treat everyone exactly the same is all I'm getting at. And, as a small business owner, I want to be able to deny my services to people who I don't want to be associated with -- and I'm OK with them telling their friends I wouldn't serve them. Just because I run a business shouldn't mean I have to be a slave to anyone with a dollar.

Should Ford have to make a car for people who are blind? Should NASA have to retrofit the ISS with wheelchair ramps? I mean... there is a line somewhere, and I think it's fine to leave it with the business owner -- they generally aren't going to do anything that hurts their business.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by ratsmack on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:12PM (#20491994)
I agree as long as it can be done without degrading the experience for everyone. Most importantly, it needs to be implemented by people with the knowledge of what is possible instead of a being designed by the bureau of wishful thinking.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by jimktrains2 on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:39PM (#20492150)
I'd argue that ada compliance in the real world is a boon for everyone. Especially for people with temporary disabilities, chronic pain, joint or muscle issues, the elderly, people with children, people will strollers, people with luggage, &c. Accessibility, in my experiences, is rarely at odds with aesthetics or degrades a person without disabilities experience. I cannot think of an example of the later, but I won't go as far as saying it never happens.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by DuskStar on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:20AM (#20495710)
Accessibility is great! As long as it doesn't end up with situations like MIT taking down a ton of old lecture videos because they didn't have the funds to add captions.

There's a lot of real-world situations where mandating accessibility would result in closure. There's no way to make Angel's Landing [0] wheelchair accessible, for instance. (this is very common in the US's national parks, to the point that I'd bet that 3/4ths of them have at least one such trail/location) With situations like that, your choices are to keep it open for some people, or for no people.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angels_Landing

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by DanBC on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:35PM (#20492131)
Accessible design improves the experience for everyone.

eg It's not just visually impaired people who hate fucking tiny fonts in light grey on a bright white background.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by threezero on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:06PM (#20491959)
There should be some balance for practicality. If you sell cars, you shouldn’t have to be accessible to blind people who can’t even drive them. The only thing Dominos did wrong in my opinion is not provide the same discounts to everyone.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by orbital223 on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:09PM (#20491980)
A blind man shouldn't be able to purchase a car for his son?
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by DuskStar on Monday July 22, 2019 @02:03AM (#20495653)
How the fuck am I supposed to provide an equivalent experience for someone with a severe mental disability? Or for someone with Completely Locked In Syndrome? [0] Some accommodations just aren't possible.

That's not to say that efforts shouldn't be made. Just that requiring perfection will eliminate everything if perfection is impossible.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locked-in_syndrome

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by matz1 on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:40PM (#20492160)
I agree but not if it add burden to the business operator.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by SolaceQuantum on Sunday July 21, 2019 @01:06PM (#20492316)
I disagree. It should definitely be on the business's responsibility to not discriminate. It is the cost of doing business.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by matz1 on Sunday July 21, 2019 @02:48PM (#20492960)
Then a lot of business operator would not support it and hopefully will even fight for the law to be changed.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by mruts on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:45PM (#20492182)
I would say unequivocally no and it shouldn’t be enforced at all.

So, like, if someone is brain dead, the website needs to pay for a new brain for them? What you’re saying doesn’t make any sense, online or offline.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by SolaceQuantum on Sunday July 21, 2019 @01:08PM (#20492332)
"So, like, if someone is brain dead, the website needs to pay for a new brain for them? What you’re saying doesn’t make any sense, online or offline."

Genuine question- we have a well established disability law field with decades of law and examples of the limitations and coverage of ADA. Why are you coming up with a random example?

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by mruts on Sunday July 21, 2019 @03:33PM (#20493196)
Maybe because governments aren’t all the same and not everyone comes from the same country?

What you mean we, kemosabe?

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by pseudalopex on Sunday July 21, 2019 @08:22PM (#20494576)
The article and the first comment were about a particular country. Or you could pick any other country with disability laws.
Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by gowld on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:03PM (#20491946)
Why don't we have government relay services for websites?

What is the functional equivalent to a picture of food?

If this opportunistic enforcement-for-profit goes unchecked, and business and the public discover that the ADA bans providing any services that rely on vision, hearing, or limbs, the ADA won't last long.

Having a disability sucks. Not all disabilities are curable. Banning the use of abilities is not a solution that will be tolerated.

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by ncallaway on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:45PM (#20492185)
> Banning the use of abilities is not a solution that will be tolerated.

I can’t think of any serious proposal ever during the fight for accessibility where this was proposed or seriously considered as an option.

Wheelchair cuts in sidewalks don’t prevent you from stepping on the curb. Elevators to spaces that are otherwise only accessible via stairs don’t remove the stairs.

Ensuring a website works well with assistive software doesn’t mean the website can’t work for users that don’t need assistive software.

Where does this concern come from? What proposal are you worried about where we would ban the use of abilities, or what percent in the application of the ADA do you think warrants this concern?

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by michaelmrose on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:52PM (#20492226)
>Why don't we have government relay services for websites?

This is like doing away with wheelchair ramps and replacing it with government employees who will show up and carry the wheelchair up stairs.

Firstly it shifts the burden from the business to providing websites the impaired can use to all of us and it does so in a way that multiplies the costs in a virtually unbounded fashion.

Instead of a business doing the work once we will be expected to open our wallets every time and forever when someone wants to do something on the web where a rapidly increasing share of all business is done.

>What is the functional equivalent to a picture of food?

A well crafted textual description of said food which many times is already somewhere below said food anyway?

Re:Do protections for people with disabilities apply online?... by cco on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:08PM (#20491971)
A description of the food, is this a gotcha?