News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by panpanna on Saturday July 20, 2019 @06:59AM (#20485110)
Yeah, that is the real question.

Google already has special deals for companies that lowers the 30% fee significantly.

(I think even 2-3% fee is too much for doing basically nothing, but that is another discussion).

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by bscphil on Saturday July 20, 2019 @07:09AM (#20485146)
> (I think even 2-3% fee is too much for doing basically nothing, but that is another discussion).

My guess is that the play store fee works more like a tax on a closed ecosystem than a price for a service. For example, when the government needs to pay for a more expansive healthcare bill, they may decide it makes more economic sense (or is more politically viable) to raise the additional funding through a tax that doesn't go back to most of the people who receive the benefits. So maybe they raise capital gains taxes, etc.

Likewise, while Google is an ads company, and running Android does benefit them some in that regard (e.g. ecosystem lockin), they're not running it as a charity. Android being given away for free, and many phones being subsidized, both benefit a lot of people, and because Google has more or less complete control of the market, they've decided the best way to pay for it is to tax the Play store, instead of charging those people for the benefit.

They important thing I'm trying to point out here is that they could do it differently - they could charge for Android, or require subscriptions to use more of their services, but they've decided the best way to monetize is through the store. In this case, the question of whether the fee is "reasonable" for what Google provides to app developers isn't quite as significant as it would be were Google simply providing a product on the free market.

But in this case I suspect you're both right, anyway, and this likely has more to do with data collection.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by microcolonel on Saturday July 20, 2019 @09:25AM (#20485599)
> a tax on a closed ecosystem

It's not a closed ecosystem anyway, I think. As far as I can tell, all the devices that officially have Google Play, also allow other applications to install APKs; now in a very fine-grained and straightforward way (as of Android 9).

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by maccard on Saturday July 20, 2019 @07:16AM (#20485165)
Google certainly aren't doing nothing - 30% includes hosting, bandwidth, patching, some amount of marketing, payments, fraud. Whether it's worth 30% is a different discussion, but to say they provide no value is just sily.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by ulfw on Saturday July 20, 2019 @02:02PM (#20487299)
Agree on everything except patching? What does Google patch on say a netflix app?

30% is ridiculous for Apple and Google. It's an arbitrary number that they could get away with when the Appstore came out nine years ago and everyone ran with it ever since.

I don't know what a fair amount is. But I doubt it's in the two digits.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by jayd16 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @06:41PM (#20488782)
They provide auto-update polling and patching functionality.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by bobsil1 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @08:05PM (#20489096)
Fair is probably less than credit card co’s for base payment functionality, i.e. < 2.5%, plus some for editorial, autoupdates, decent admin UI, review.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday July 21, 2019 @04:38AM (#20490486)
You're forgetting that these stores act as merchants of record. They are not just payment processors. They handle VAT internationally. They do all the billing and compliance for you.

You just have one large customer in one country instead of thousands/millions in many different jurisdictions each with its own tax and consumer protection laws. That's worth more than 2.5% but it's not worth 30%.

I would say fair is somewhere between 5% and 10%, considering they also provide some distribution infrastructure on top of payments, billing, taxes and compliance.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pjmlp on Saturday July 20, 2019 @03:21PM (#20487740)
If 30% is ridiculous, what to say about J2ME, Symbian, Blackberry and PocketPC rates of former operators stores?
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Nullabillity on Saturday July 20, 2019 @03:58PM (#20487960)
Can't speak for BB, but J2ME, Symbian, and PocketPC never had any centralized store that everything had to go through.

Well, I guess Symbian got N-Gage and the Ovi Store towards the end, but they never tried to lock it down against third party sources.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by scarface74 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @09:18PM (#20489354)
No the stores were run by the carriers. Sprint and Verizon had an App Store before the iPhone was introduced where they sold a third party J2ME apps. Those carriers took a 70% cut.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Nullabillity on Sunday July 21, 2019 @07:32AM (#20490875)
I suppose it might have been regional, but that was never the case here. You would just download the jars (or cabs) directly from the developer. The only cut would have been the ~2% credit card processing fee.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pjmlp on Saturday July 20, 2019 @05:50PM (#20488597)
True, but my point was how much they charged developers for being there, not how many were available.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Nullabillity on Sunday July 21, 2019 @07:33AM (#20490880)
Wat? My point was that they weren't even in the equation. Who cares what they charged if everyone went straight to the source instead?
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pjmlp on Sunday July 21, 2019 @09:35AM (#20491248)
The source being the carriers shop and scummy online shops listed on newspapers getting paid via SMS codes, which one would need to pitch before they would even consider taking their royalties.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Nullabillity on Sunday July 21, 2019 @03:46PM (#20493269)
No, the source being the developer's website. Not everything has to be a walled garden.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pjmlp on Sunday July 21, 2019 @05:32PM (#20493801)
Somehow I lived a different alternative universe regarding J2ME, Symbian, BlackBerry, PocketPC app stores.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Nullabillity on Monday July 22, 2019 @01:12PM (#20500081)
I guess it may have been a regional thing. Or maybe you're thinking of Qualcomm's BREW?
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pjmlp on Monday July 22, 2019 @01:31PM (#20500269)
Qualcomm wasn't available in Europe.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by stinky613 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @03:29PM (#20487788)
Well, the install base is way bigger for Android, and the general state of patching in 2019 is far more frequent than it was when older platforms were operating.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pjmlp on Saturday July 20, 2019 @05:53PM (#20488607)
Hence why it is way cheaper than it used to be back then.

When Apple announced 30% cut, mobile devs where cheering, because many providers were charging way above 50%.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Paul-ish on Saturday July 20, 2019 @11:13AM (#20486203)
Also they develop the Android platform.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by addicted on Saturday July 20, 2019 @11:36PM (#20489822)
If Google stops developing the Android platform, who is gonna suffer? Not the app makers. It’s gonna be Android, and Google, entirely.

Developing The Android platform is a benefit for Google, not for the app makers.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by kzrdude on Saturday July 20, 2019 @08:23AM (#20485338)
And app review and oversight
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by shiftpgdn on Saturday July 20, 2019 @09:21AM (#20485574)
Don't kid yourself. The Google play store is absolutely jammed full of malware and scam apps.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by andybak on Saturday July 20, 2019 @11:19AM (#20486248)
However they spend a considerable amount of money trying to stop those. It's fairly irrelevant to the preceding poster's point whether they succeed or not.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by danShumway on Sunday July 21, 2019 @06:58PM (#20494211)
No, how much money or effort Google spends is irrelevant to the value they provide.

If Google came up with a magical technique to get rid of all malware on their app store that didn't cost them a dime, you could still argue that they're adding value to justify the 30% cut.

If Google spends a billion dollars to get rid of all the malware on their app store, and it doesn't work, and using the app store is not significantly less dangerous than sideloading apps, then they're not adding any value to justify the 30% cut.

Note that I don't think Google's efforts are completely fruitless. At the very least, they seem to help with taking down duplicate apps, and that's something. But whether or not moderation is valuable only depends on whether they succeed or not -- their effort is irrelevant.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pmart123 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @12:52PM (#20486866)
It seems like an incumbent app should would likely want app stores to suffer from a lack of policing and degradation, whether they are paying 3%, 5%, or 30%. The less app stores are trusted for safety, the lower the friction there is to just use the established Netflix, Tinder, or Spotify app.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday July 20, 2019 @01:47PM (#20487220)
How much? What percentage of their 30% take do you think they're spending?

<1% ?

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Avamander on Saturday July 20, 2019 @12:17PM (#20486600)
Don't kid yourself it wouldn't be absolutely unusable without them.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by on_and_off on Saturday July 20, 2019 @04:33PM (#20488194)
Really ?

With nobody to filter out impersonators and repackaging of an app with added malware ?

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by raverbashing on Saturday July 20, 2019 @09:31AM (#20485630)
Apple does proper reviews (some by self-interest sure, but their reviews are thorougher and include a bit of basic design/usability)

Google will probably approve anything that's not an obvious malware but not much more than that

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by panpanna on Saturday July 20, 2019 @11:34AM (#20486362)
That is mainly marketing talk and had been disproved multiple times.

For example Chinese hackers added hidden code to 34 legit apps totaling 500 millions downloads and Apple didn't notice a thing.

https://www.macrumors.com/2015/09/20/xcodeghost-chinese-malw...

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by mstolpm on Saturday July 20, 2019 @01:10PM (#20486977)
2015 - You really need a four year old news to support your claim?
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by panpanna on Saturday July 20, 2019 @01:20PM (#20487050)
2019 - big Korean publisher is caught red handed engaging in click fraud in background. Apple never noticed this, it was detected by researchers analyzing their Android apps.

Happy now?

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by FussyZeus on Saturday July 20, 2019 @06:38PM (#20488773)
Was the click fraud occurring on iOS as well?
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by Retric on Saturday July 20, 2019 @08:55AM (#20485465)
2% would likely not cover credit card transaction fees let alone their other costs. Even low transaction fees generally look like 2% + 10c. Making the situation even worse for 1$ apps. On top of that they need to pay for development, hosting, fraud detection etc.

The ecosystem may be better off with something like 20c + 20% transaction fees. But, a flat percentage needs to be surprisingly high just to breakeven.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by panpanna on Saturday July 20, 2019 @09:25AM (#20485601)
I highly doubt Google is paying 2% per transaction to Visa.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by sidlls on Saturday July 20, 2019 @10:33AM (#20485952)
Don't know why you're being downvoted: Google had immense bargaining power with Visa (and the others). It might be a stretch to say they aren't paying 2%, but it's unlikely they're paying 3-5% + $0.30 flat per transaction (typical fees for small merchants going through a merchant bank payment processor, PayPal, etc.)
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by asciident on Saturday July 20, 2019 @03:26PM (#20487771)
I doubt they have any negotiating power. Negotiations are always based on leverage, and second-best option. They have none of those. What can they theaten? To not take Visa or Mastercard in the Play Store? That they'll only take checks my mail?
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pmontra on Sunday July 21, 2019 @04:08AM (#20490437)
They can sell prepaid cards, like their gift cards. However it's not as convenient.

They can start their own currency, but only facebook is going that way and it takes a long time.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by leesalminen on Saturday July 20, 2019 @11:38AM (#20486384)
They certainly won’t be paying less than interchange though which in my world averages 2.35%
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by hadrien01 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @03:19PM (#20487727)
Interchange fees in Europe are capped to 1.15% online and 0.2% on payment terminals, and I'm sure Google, Amazon, and other big companies are able to negociate better fees
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by pcr0 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @10:11AM (#20485852)
There are a lot of credit cards that offer cashback rates between 1-2%. I'm certain Visa is not eating that so Google (and other merchants) must be paying.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by snuxoll on Saturday July 20, 2019 @11:25AM (#20486292)
Most credit card companies also get paid a lot of money in interest, it’s not like they rely solely on interchange fees for rewards programs.

Yes, you shouldn’t float a balance on your card - but the average person often does.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by jakobegger on Saturday July 20, 2019 @09:56AM (#20485761)
And don't forget foreign exchange fees, which add at least another 2% to purchases in foreign currencies. (One bank used to charge me a ridiculous fee of 8% just for currency conversion from USD to EUR)
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by on_and_off on Saturday July 20, 2019 @04:32PM (#20488179)
>doing basically nothing

Handling publication, payments, giving exposure and direct access via the play store, approving the apps, rejecting impersonations, the play store platform actually does a lot of stuff.

I agree that a 30% fee is a lot and probably way too much, but claiming that they do nothing is just ridiculous.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by tomcam on Saturday July 20, 2019 @12:25PM (#20486665)
How do you handle support and fraud issues for less than 2%?
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by callalex on Saturday July 20, 2019 @01:22PM (#20487057)
With google the answer seems to be “what support??”
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by muro on Saturday July 20, 2019 @03:10PM (#20487685)
For example the support you contact to get your money back if the app doesn't work. I did that and support did return my money. It was a long time ago, maybe now that's automatic with refunds within 15 mins or what it is.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by makkesk8 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @01:58PM (#20487275)
> (I think even 2-3% fee is too much for doing basically nothing, but that is another discussion).

Yea 2% fee is too much because bandwidth is free.

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by jayd16 on Saturday July 20, 2019 @06:45PM (#20488803)
If it's that easy, Amazon's store would be doing very well but it's simply not that easy.
Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by julian_digital on Sunday July 21, 2019 @08:28AM (#20491047)
"Google already has special deals for companies that lowers the 30% fee significantly."

Source?

Re:Tinder Bypasses Google Play, Joining Revolt Against App S... by onetimemanytime on Saturday July 20, 2019 @11:31AM (#20486342)
My guess: probably 5% is cost, staff to review, maintain ecosystem, credit card fees, customer support etc etc.