News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by wsc981 on Sunday July 07, 2019 @07:24PM (#20378680)
Ghadaffi wanted to create an African currency as well [0]. I wonder if the African countries will now succeed. I feel it will definitely be in their interest as it seems currently France has control over African monetary policy [1] which (I feel) could still be considered some form of colonialism.

---

[0]: https://medium.com/@evantaxi/6-years-ago-today-the-us-helped...

[1]: https://www.theeastafrican.co.ke/news/africa/CFA-franc-Franc...

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dragonwriter on Sunday July 07, 2019 @07:30PM (#20378712)
> France has control over African monetary policy

As your own source notes, France does not control the policy of either of the two separate CFA franc zones, but does have preferential access to resources resulting from the deal setting up the currency arrangement, which is the actual benefit it gets from the deal.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by licnep on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:02PM (#20378865)
But the CFA being pegged to the euro, means that the countries adopting it can't really do monetary policy, like countries in the eurozone can't
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by JetSpiegel on Sunday July 07, 2019 @09:00PM (#20379112)
At least Eurozone countries get a seat at the Eurogroup meetings and the European Council. African CFA users don't even get that.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by seszett on Monday July 08, 2019 @02:48AM (#20380430)
Isn't it very common for a currency to be pegged to another, though? Dozens of currencies are pegged to the EUR or USD, and the two CFA francs are not very different, except that the French treasury is legally bound to guarantee free convertibility between CFA franc and euro, unlike say the US federal reserve with Cuban peso.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by skgoa on Monday July 08, 2019 @07:40AM (#20381850)
Yes, it is common. There are even countries that officially adopting a currency they do not control, e.g. Croatia uing the euro. But this has the very real drawbacks that the previous comments mentioned.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Double_a_92 on Monday July 08, 2019 @02:01AM (#20380232)
The pegging is not forced on them. It's their own national bank which buys and sells tons of Euros to keep the exchange rate stable.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by vkreso on Monday July 08, 2019 @03:44AM (#20380721)
Exactly, its an autonomous response towards the market. Stability is always preffered in human decision making.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dragonwriter on Monday July 08, 2019 @12:51PM (#20384320)
> It's their own national bank which buys and sells tons of Euros to keep the exchange rate stable.

The two CFA franc zones have zone central banks (which aren't exclusively controlled by countries in the respective zone, since France has a seat on each), it's not individual national central banks issuing currency or managing the peg.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by pinkfoot on Monday July 08, 2019 @03:22AM (#20380596)
It also means their corrupt governments cannot monetise their debt and destroy their currency, savings, pensions, and ultimately economy.

Like Zimbabwe did.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by RobertoG on Monday July 08, 2019 @07:20AM (#20381741)
That's nonsense. Zimbabwe (like the famous Weimar republic, by the way) had a extreme fall in the real productive capacity of the economy (1). Inflation was going to happen nevertheless the monetary policy they adopted.

(1) - http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=3773

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by pinkfoot on Monday July 08, 2019 @11:25AM (#20383534)
Nope, the fall in capacity followed the destruction of the currency and the end of the rule of contract law.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tim333 on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:16PM (#20384604)
Googling briefly it seems

>Food production halved in the 1990s as a result of [Mugabe's] decision to strip white farmers of their land and hand it to members of the black population who, in many cases, had no farming experience.

before the inflation kicked off. https://news.sky.com/story/how-zimbabwes-economy-has-collaps...

Same brilliant policy in Venezuela pretty much.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by piokoch on Monday July 08, 2019 @03:51AM (#20380761)
We will see. Right now when Spain buys oil from Norway (EU member and European Economic Area member) they (have to?) use US Dollars, which is insanity from the perspective of both countries.

Ghadaffi wanted to trade oil for Euros and we all know how it end up.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by navigatesol on Monday July 08, 2019 @09:08AM (#20382374)
>Right now when Spain buys oil from Norway (EU member and European Economic Area member) they (have to?) use US Dollars, which is insanity from the perspective of both countries.

Instead of converting from Krone to Euros and vice versa, you convert into the largest, most stable, most liquid currency on the planet. What is insane?

>Ghadaffi wanted to trade oil for Euros and we all know how it end up.

Ah yes, Ghadaffi, Sadam Hussein...good men overthrown because they wanted to "trade oil for Euros".

Wait; why couldn't they again? What, precisely was stopping them from dealing in Euro, besides the seller or buyer of oil demanding to be use USD? Right, nothing.

The idea that the US forces people to trade in USD as opposed to it working out that way because it's a stable currency of a powerful nation is a fallacy that won't die. Just like within the country, you are free to trade in whatever the hell currency you want...if you can find a willing counter-party.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by poiuyt098 on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:14PM (#20384580)
> Wait; why couldn't they again?

Due to getting hanged, shot, or stabbed, probably.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by alex_duf on Monday July 08, 2019 @05:02AM (#20381092)
I'm not sure if you're referring to Gaddafi's death, but there's strong suspicion he's dead because he talked a bit too loudly about financing the campaign of Nicolas Sarkozy

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/mar/20/nicolas-sarkoz...

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tim333 on Monday July 08, 2019 @12:42PM (#20384215)
He did a lot of things to piss off a lot of people. It's hard to pick out one particular one.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tim333 on Monday July 08, 2019 @12:38PM (#20384165)
They don't have to use dollars. I'm sure Norway would accept Euros. They may well use dollars for convenience as it's the most common currency for oil trading.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dotancohen on Monday July 08, 2019 @07:04AM (#20381667)
I'm glad to see this mentioned. Ghadaffi had big plans for uniting Africa, which would have been horrible for the Europeans who have been plundering the continent for centuries.

I've always felt that was the real reason the he was ousted. Other national leaders, both in and outside Africa, have done far worse than him yet have never been invaded.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Angostura on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:05AM (#20381989)
Ghadaffi's relations with the Europeans had actually improved substantially in the run-up to the civil war. Even the UK was moving to normalise relationships, which was a pretty big deal given the bombing of the plane over Lockerbie.

It was the Arab Spring and internal strife which kicked off Ghadaffi's downfall with the events at Benghazi getting the international community - lead by France, ISTR involved.

The UN kicked Libya off the Human Rights Commission, following a report by Amnesty documenting warcrimes on the government and rebel sides and it all degenerated into a nasty civil war. I don't think it is correct to say that he was "ousted" by Western forces in any particularly meaningful way.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by j0ba on Monday July 08, 2019 @09:19AM (#20382451)
Hillary Clinton seemed to think the US ousted him .. https://youtu.be/mlz3-OzcExI
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Angostura on Monday July 08, 2019 @12:17PM (#20383961)
And the context of those 6 words is? It could easily be her ridiculing a claim that American forces waltzed in and killed him (which they didn't from what I have read)
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tim333 on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:06PM (#20384484)
I'm skeptical that uniting Africa would be horrible for Europeans. Most of the interaction I've seen in my lifetime has been trying to help them - overseas aid, band aid and all that. We weren't fans of Gaddafi's dictatorship and sponsoring of terrorism but that's another issue.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tozeur on Wednesday July 10, 2019 @04:08AM (#20400073)
And why do you think aid is sent? To help feed little black kids? Nah, it’s to exert influence and propaganda.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tim333 on Thursday July 11, 2019 @10:46AM (#20411895)
Can't say I'm an expert on all of it but as David Cameron put it

>I would say it is not only a moral obligation that the better-off countries have to tackle poverty in our world when we still have over a billion people living on less than a dollar a day, but it's also in our interests that we build a more prosperous world.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by skgoa on Monday July 08, 2019 @07:38AM (#20381838)
> which would have been horrible for the Europeans who have been plundering the continent for centuries.

For european corporations and shareholders, that is. It would probably be better for the majority of people, because higher stabilityand prosperity in Africa will result in fewer refugees, which results in fewer issues with rightwing nutjobs.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by jotm on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:04AM (#20381983)
I dunno, the fact that he was an authoritarian quasi dictator akin to Putin might've had something to do with it. He destroyed and oppressed anyone who opposed him, shelled civilians in the civil war, and let's not forget his personal guard, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazonian_Guard , which was straight out of a supervillain handbook.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by alluro2 on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:41AM (#20382199)
I agree, but if you read about him a bit "wider", including periods before and some time after he came into power, it does seem like there were some really good things there that he tried to do, both in Libya and broader region (which were not in the interest of foreign powers, though). Afterwards, you start to see elements of insanity and paranoia and things getting much worse, but it does seem to an extent that those were a result of the hostile environment around him and maybe of failure to do things more "normally".
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by growtofill on Monday July 08, 2019 @07:38AM (#20381839)
Given that decolonization ended more than 40 years ago, "the Europeans who have been plundering the continent for centuries" are either dead or retired. How is African countries reaching an agreement would be horrible to anyone, including them?
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by jonahrd on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:28AM (#20382107)
I believe dotancohen is referring to other forms of colonialism that have existed since decolonization: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neocolonialism
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by alluro2 on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:35AM (#20382153)
The notion of individuals being responsible for exploiting Africa and them being dead meaning the exploitation no longer exists is like saying USA ceased to exist when founding fathers passed away.

Newer history of Africa is almost exclusively defined by consequences of external manipulation, driven by financial interests.

In general, you can look up the definition of "neocolonialism".

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by rayiner on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:49AM (#20382252)
That’s true to an extent, but “almost exclusively” gives very little agency to the people. India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh were colonies until the middle of the 20th century.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dangerface on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:32AM (#20382133)
> "the Europeans who have been plundering the continent for centuries" are either dead or retired.

Thats not how political dynasties work.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Razengan on Monday July 08, 2019 @02:21AM (#20380325)
Whatever happened to Libya? How are they doing now? Who are the people [really] in power there?

There was a lot of brouhaha in the mass media about "liberating" them, then nothing.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by lenkite on Monday July 08, 2019 @02:31AM (#20380373)
It is now a nation in continual civil war between a warring bunch of factions. People are desperate to emigrate from there and a lot of area is controlled by human traffickers. This is the end result of military intervention against Gaddafi. This was a nation that had free health care for the public. A lot of people are dying daily, but you don't hear about it since international journalists are afraid to enter the area - they will be taken as hostages by one group or another immediately.

Instead of waging War, international negotiation for the succession of power with guarantees of safety should have been performed painstakingly - with lots of carrots offered, but there are just too many warmongers in the US and even the UN.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by notahacker on Monday July 08, 2019 @04:54AM (#20381050)
When one faction rules out negotiating any outcome that doesn't involve Gadaffi's removal (and doesn't have much unity beyond that) and the other faction is Gadaffi and his loyalists that don't want to move, the chances of negotiating a peaceful transition were always going to be slim. Revolutions often don't have happy endings. Libya had free healthcare, but it also was also the fiefdom of a dictator who said that those who didn't love him didn't deserve to live.

Not every violent conflict has to be the fault of the US and the UN, and the argument they ought to have intervened more to stabilise the country afterwards is at least as plausible as the argument that they intervened too much. (The conspiracy theory that Western intervention had something to do with Gadaffi's gold dinar idea doesn't have much to rest on either. Round about the time Gadaffi was talking up one of the oldest ideas in Islam as part of his vision for Africa and not getting anywhere even when he was the African Union president, a Malaysian state actually introduced one and was roundly ignored, even by the Malaysian government.)

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by lenkite on Monday July 08, 2019 @07:08AM (#20381684)
If you have to choose between one evil and another - its probably better not to choose at all. Non-intervention would have been the best policy to follow here. Hysteria raised by journalists should not be the primary motivating factor for waging war. No one did the cost analysis for lives ended by anarchy and extra-ordinary poverty and suffering caused by complete national economic breakdown.

This is just my personal opinion - but military intervention should be only used for self-defence and the defence of one's allies. And for nothing else.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by newsgremlin on Monday July 08, 2019 @11:52AM (#20383749)
It's not our fault, until we get involved. This faux crusade of democracy our politicians use as justification just reeks of imperialism, destablising these countries so they are no longer able to sustain any form of government without a puppet government backed by our nations.

In a democracy we as the electorate like to pretend we have no involvement in this decision making, yet we pride ourselves on the system of government that apparently represents 'the people' the most. "Don't blame us, it's just our government!"

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by powerapple on Monday July 08, 2019 @02:39AM (#20380403)
International journalists weren't afraid of reporting other things they don't have access of though.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Symbiote on Monday July 08, 2019 @03:22AM (#20380595)
There's an article on Libya every 2-4 days in the Guardian.

Most are about the migrant crisis, but the rest are about the ongoing war.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/libya

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by eaurouge on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:42PM (#20388042)
Libya was in the midst of a civil war before the UN military intervention you referred to. In fact, the military intervention occurred mere hours before Gaddafi's plans to obliterate Benghazi could be implemented. The military intervention was a no-fly zone to prevent Gaddafi's forces from killing civilians [0]. So people are dying daily, not because of a UN intervention, but because Gaddafi's ouster created a vacuum that resulted in a power struggle. Note that the only other alternative would have been for Gaddafi to retain power at the cost of significant loss of life.

The other point is that the people desperate to emigrate are non-Libyan Africans using Libya as a port of departure. These people have suffered rape, mutilation etc at the hands of the various warring factions.

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_...

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Grue3 on Monday July 08, 2019 @06:38AM (#20381525)
>This was a nation that had free health care for the public

Oh well, that's alright then. Does Mussolini get a pass because he made trains run on time?

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by lenkite on Monday July 08, 2019 @07:27AM (#20381785)
Mussolini was invading other nations. Which nation was Gaddafi invading ? If Mussolini wasn't carrying out invasions, he would have definitely got a pass.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Xixi on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:35AM (#20382150)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chadian%E2%80%93Libyan_conflic...

Albeit long before being removed from power.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tim333 on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:26PM (#20384727)
There must be a better way of dealing with murderous dictators. Though it's politically incorrect these days there might be something to said for something like the old British colonialism in those cases where you go in and take over the country under foreign governance for a while. Maybe governance by some UN body rather than Brits and for a limited time, say 10 years, followed by elections.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by vkreso on Monday July 08, 2019 @03:39PM (#20386025)
I agree. It is about time we move more towards less autodestructive international power communication.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by jotm on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:05AM (#20381992)
Same with Ukraine, the media stopped caring as there's no "news", just another ongoing conflict.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dmix on Monday July 08, 2019 @12:35PM (#20384127)
Ukraine is at least way more stable than Libya is… There’s still serious violence going on in Libya all the time.

Ignoring Libya is more of a regional thing as well. Being seen as part of the middle east / North African mess which the whole American public got their fill of for two decades.

If there was still airstrikes happening in Ukraine it’d certainly get more coverage than Libya.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Tuna-Fish on Monday July 08, 2019 @09:28AM (#20382503)
They enthusiastically tried democracy for a while, but quickly learned that it doesn't really work when the country consists of many factions that have no shared values. After multiple weak coalition governments that could get absolutely nothing done, in the last elections many of the previously governing parties were voted out in an election that had a turnout of 18%.

This lead to the start of the second Libyan civil war. The newly elected House of Representatives, (from now on, "Tobruk government") wanted to take power, but the parties that lost the elections refused to yield it, passing a measure that granted them temporary special authority, and formed the "National Salvation Government". The various Islamist groups in the country declared that neither government represented them, and took the black flag as many different factions, most important of them being "The Libyan provinces of ISIL" and "The Shura council of Benghazi revolutionaries".

The war from then on had many twists and turns, with the UK, US, France, Russia, Turkey, Egypt, Chad, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Algeria, Jordan, Belarus, Italy, Germany, EU, Qatar and Iran supporting a faction or another at any time. The only really consistent part of this was that the western powers were stumbling over each other to bomb ISIL and other Islamists.

The end result was that a shrewd Libyan-American warlord named Khalifa Haftar (his tagline being that he fought with and against every major faction at some point or another) essentially took over the Libyan National Army (LNA) and the Tobruk Government (they still exist and maintain all the trappings and procedures of democracy, but do so in a building where the security is provided by Haftar, and would never go against his will), and conquered most of the country, including most of the economically significant oil and water resources.

Haftars winning strategy was largely realizing that the western powers would support anyone fighting Islamists, so instead of directly challenging his main opponents, he cleared out all the Islamists he found and took their territory. He might have "encouraged" areas that would not otherwise have flown the blag flag to do so, before crushing them.

He had a lot of western support on the way, but his policy of not taking Islamists prisoner and just having them summarily executed seems to have cooled those ties. Since 2016, he's been courting for Russian support, and seems to have gained it.

If you asked this question in early April, I'd have said that it seems like Haftar will be the next Gaddafi, as his forces were finally moving on the capital and the remaining territory not held by him, but this offensive seems to have failed because of strong Turkish support. LNA withdrew for a time, and Haftar ordered LNA to target any Turkish ships, companies and arrest Turkish nationals found in the country. It seems like he's building up for attempt two.

Also, Haftar is 75 years old, and no-one has any clue what would happen to his forces if he died.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by tim333 on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:43PM (#20384922)
Thanks for the summary.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by VvR-Ox on Monday July 08, 2019 @06:18AM (#20381425)
They won't and probably they never will on their own.

The west still controls the most powerful entities in Africa and also the Chinese are pushing forward with their "belt and road" strategy.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by eaurouge on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:22PM (#20387958)
Please see notahacker’s comment below for some much needed clarity in this thread. Gaddafi had become a laughingstock on the continent well before Arab Spring. His grand vision was an Africa with him as king. There was zero chance that he would have been able to build a coalition around his currency.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dmix on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:00PM (#20378857)
>> A French official sits on the boards of both central banks, which suggests France retains at least some influence over the decision making process.

>> Participation in the currency is voluntary.

>> In 2018, Guinea was the largest country of origin [for European migration], followed by Morocco - both former French colonies that don't use the CFA franc. Cote d'Ivoire and Mali are the only countries of origin using the CFA franc that have contributed significantly to migration across the Mediterranean, accounting for 14.4 percent of the total last year.

The data in the article runs counter to the complaint against CFA currency, that it causes poverty and therefore migration into Europe. Two of the highest migration sources were ex-CFA members who now use their own currency and only 14.4% came from CFA members. Ending CFA is not some panacea.

But that said I very much favour local control of currencies in almost every case as it's one of the great benefits of global capitalism being (voluntarily) given away by these countries. Currencies and market value should be tied closely to local market conditions rather than orchestrated and centrally balanced across a massive network of countries with stark economic differences.

Trade deals (plus reducing protectionism and corporate welfare in general) are sufficient to lower barriers to entry into markets which is where it pays off to be liberal and global. Giving up control of your currency should be at most a temporary measure when local state bodies aren't stable enough to have a healthy market. Not some long term arrangement. Inefficiencies of currency conversion are problems that can be solved by healthy financial markets (futures) and technology.

Plus there are better examples of bigger economies having a strong monetary influence over smaller countries governments without the whole colonial image that putting a European bureaucrats directly on central banks gives off. The best example is governments taking on massive amounts of foreign loans - which is still in de jour for some reason. For ex: China controls significant amounts of debt across Africa and Latin America which is arguably a stronger lever of influence than France has in Africa.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by yyyk on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:41PM (#20379019)
"The data in the article runs counter to the basic complaint against CFA currency, that it causes poverty and therefore migration into Europe. Two of the highest migration sources were ex-CFA members who now use their own currency and only 14.4% came from CFA members."

You're assuming the main cause of migration is poverty, that people from poorer countries emigrate more, and that since emigration is lower the countries are less poor.

The former might be justified, but the two latter arguments are definitely false[0], in fact 'richer poorer' countries have larger emigration!

"Just the opposite: Those richer countries have three times the average emigration rate of the poorer countries.... Somewhere roughly around $7,000–$10,000 per capita, there is a turning point: Emigration from the average country starts to fall with greater economic development, as we might expect. Today’s poor countries are generations away from that level."

So the data cited does not contradict the CFA criticism that it causes countries to be more poor than they otherwise would be. Another criticism might wonder what 'voluntary' means with such power differential and historical relations.

[0] https://www.newsdeeply.com/refugees/community/2016/10/31/dev...

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dmix on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:43PM (#20379031)
I'm not assuming anything. That was the evidence provided by OP's sources. The other examples in the article were posed as questions, not data. Otherwise my comment is largely anti-CFA and foreign controlled currencies.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by yyyk on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:55PM (#20379083)
If I have misattributed, I am sorry.

Still the 'poverty leads to migration' theory is not quite true (in fact arguably the reverse in these particular circumstances), and therefore the fact some CFA countries have less emigration than some ex-CFA countries does not show that they are less poor or that the CFA is beneficial compared to non-CFA case.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by drieddust on Monday July 08, 2019 @12:32AM (#20379905)
I agree with your premise and I think there are two main reasons for this behavior.

Firstly even to migrate you have to have access to information and brain cycles to process it. Real poor are too busy to have that kind of time at hand.

Secondly even illegal immigration requires spending some money upfront and of course poor don't have it.

If you in the middle income range, it does make sense to move up the ladder by immigrating to a better place. If you are super rich, you can just buy citizenship.

Nothing is fair in life it seems.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by TazeTSchnitzel on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:34PM (#20378995)
CFA Franc countries can't leave because 1) France holds their foreign reserves so France holds the upper hand, 2) France actively works against countries trying to leave.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by barry-cotter on Monday July 08, 2019 @01:27AM (#20380121)
Countries have left the CFA Franc so it’s obviously possible. If France had held onto their foreign reserves I imagine that would have been mentioned somewhere so I doubt it’s true.
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by seszett on Monday July 08, 2019 @03:14AM (#20380562)
Half of the reserves of each CFA franc country have to be deposited to the French treasury - which is responsible for ensuring that euros can be exchanged for CFA franc, so obviously it has to hold a significant amount of CFA.

They can be withdrawn whenever the country leaves the CFA franc. But in the recent past, countries have been more eager to join than to leave.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by dmix on Monday July 08, 2019 @10:46AM (#20383155)
> But in the recent past, countries have been more eager to join than to leave.

Hmm. That’s a strange form of colonialism

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by kiliantics on Monday July 08, 2019 @08:06PM (#20387889)
just because a few rich/powerful people at the top of the country benefit from it and therefore actively embrace it, doesn't mean it's not colonialism
Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Xixi on Monday July 08, 2019 @09:07AM (#20382365)
Nonsense: many countries have left the CFA Franc (like Guinea, Madagascar and Mauritania), and others have joined (like Equatorial Guinea or Guinea-Bissau). Some have left and joined again (like Mali). I wonder if you have actual example of France actively working against countries trying to leave? Or even a pointer to countries trying to leave?

I'm not competent to judge whether the CFA Franc is a good currency or not for the countries using it. No doubt it is a compromise with good sides and bad sides. The obvious good side being that it certainly makes trade easier within the CFA Franc zone. The obvious bad side is that the Euro top priority being fighting inflation, it can hinder exportations from countries that are not very competitive. A complaint often heard about the Euro from European countries (especially France, sweet irony).

Hopefully African nations will manage to create their very own currency, and will manage it well.

Re:African leaders launch landmark 55-nation trade zone by Retric on Sunday July 07, 2019 @08:34PM (#20378992)
For nations with lower GDP’s there is significant overhead to using their own currency. It’s often more harmful than beneficial.