To me, it feels like Google's entire strategy behind reCaptcha is to make it harder to protect your privacy. We've basically given up on the idea that there are tasks only humans can do, and to me V3 feels like Google openly saying, "You know how we can prove you're not a robot? Because we literally know exactly who you are." I don't even know if it should be called a captcha -- it feels like it's just identity verification.
I don't think this is an acceptable tradeoff. I know that when reCaptcha shows up on HN there's often a crowd that says, "but how else can we block bots?" I'm gonna draw a personal line in the sand and say that I think protecting privacy is more important than stopping bots. If your website can't stop bots without violating my privacy, then I'm starting to feel like I might be on the bots' side.
For the irony, I'm still logged into GMail and it still works perfectly, as basic HTML, even with google.com forbidden to run scripts. But it's the flippin' reCaptchas all over the place that make me temp-allow google.com, and then a reload later, temp-allow gstatic.com and reload again. Only then I get to use someone else's site normally, and I can disallow again... it's irritating. And then, this.
BTW that page plainly says the scores are samples and not related to reality. Refresh a few times and watch it change. 0.3, 0.7, and 0.9 seem to be my lucky numbers. I see everyone else getting those and 0.1.
Please stop reading things into it oh it's too late. Maybe they suddenly started seeing this page hundreds of times in the referrer and added that bit afterward, I don't know.
If anyone wants a fun weekend project, I would love for there to be a few public sites I can reliably check my production score on.
I'm not sure it matters though, since I'm just ignoring most sites that use reCaptcha now. For sites I can't ignore, I've taken to emailing them with my requests instead -- recently I tried to use Spotify's internal data export tool and it wouldn't let me past. If you're not going to let me use a website to manage my existing account, then your support team can do it for me.
Maybe some browser extension can monitor the score and tell me what it currently is on each page load, when reCaptcha is used on some website. I'd just keep reloading, until it's good, and then try the captcha.
Changing the FF content policy from Standard to Strict appears to have no impact on the score.
Opening in a Private window drops it to 0.7 for me. I have a bunch of add ons allowed in Private Browsing, so not surprised it only dropped a little.
Of course, if you have 3rd party frames and scripts disabled globally via uBlock, it doesn't even load.
[edit] tried in a private window and got the same score.
In my main FF window with UBlock + Resist Fingerprinting, logged into a ton of Google accounts, I also got 0.1
Going to guess that without fingerprinting data they are probably going to give you a 0.1.
so why are they having you solve image puzzles if they know that they are going to fail you? even if they know that you are human...
The problem is that they aren't trying harder for users who aren't logged in.
That's on you, not Google.
Using Chrome, even incognito and with uBlock I get 0.7
(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻. F you, Google, this is blatant bullying, technically unjustifyable abuse of your stranglehold over the whole web platform.
On FireFox with uBlock on and logged into my corporate gmail I get 0.9, switching to a private tab I get 0.7. This is with every privacy setting turned on in the FF options.
This is essentially going to let Google gatekeep the web if you aren't using their services.
How can I get better privacy settings?
I wonder how many people here are using a VPN or accessing from a non-western country -- I'd bet those are much bigger factors
FF incognito window not logged into Google account: 0.7
FF incognito window not logged into Google account through VPN: 0.3
FYI I have uBlock, pi-hole and a bunch of privacy widgets enabled
Come on, how is everyone in this chain so blind. It's literally in bold and the single largest block of content on the page:
NOTE:This is a sample implementation, the score returned here is not a reflection on your Google account or type of traffic. In production, refer to the distribution of scores shown in your admin interface and adjust your own threshold accordingly. Do not raise issues regarding the score you see here.
Please see the sibling comments (that were there before yours) where this is already being discussed, before being insulting.
>the score returned here is not a reflection on your Google account or type of traffic
I got random scores as well. It looks like this is just a sample of the data structure that the service returns, not the actual score.
looks like it is a demo of the API for people wanting to consume it. knowing what the payload looks like is not useless at all in this case.
I'm also logged into google and fb which also doesn't affect my score. Only shows how broken their algorithm is :(
edit: just tried it with chrome and my score jumped to 0.9! So definitely not my ISP. It's just my browser that Recaptcha doesn't like. If you put two and two together that's really evil shit, even for Google!
Almost unused Chrome installation, also without addons: 0.7
Privacy Badger and ABP on my work (less-locked-down) Mac.
// TODO: add impressive-looking math
if (signedin && trackedEverywhere) {
return 0.9
} else {
return 0.7
}
I think we give Google way too much credit for their talent. This is the same company that didn't feel like finishing their website for two decades and subsequently stole $75 million from their users even when Google knew [1].The same company that somehow still doesn't reconcile amounts owed and just keeps the money when they randomly-ban users and hide behind fake support emails, but they did feel like paying $11 million to keep that away from scrutiny [2].
[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/google-emails-adtrader-lawsu...
[2] https://www.searchenginejournal.com/adsense-lawsuit/248135/
And in keeping with recent revelations on Google's manipulation of search results, I think they have really gone beyond the pale. I un-archived my old iPhone two days ago and went back to iOS after the James O'Keefe/Project Veritas revelations. I now cannot, in good conscience, use anything Google. I always knew about the tracking and all that because, after all, they are an ad company. I'm now in the process of moving all of my domains over to Fastmail, which I've used since 2002. I'm using Qwant, Startpage, and DDG for search. FF for browser with many about:config tweaks and several add-ons.
Sunlight is the very best disinfectant. People have a right to know if searches are being manipulated to one side.
I could have sworn I'd never signed in to Chrome using my google account, but I guess I must have mistakenly signed in to gmail or something.
I use FF as my main browser, only ever drop back to Chrome sporadically, or when I really want tabs to be completely isolated (there are some annoyingly CPU/power intensive stuff I do from time to time, and I can just renice Chrome while I get on with other stuff.)
Chrome 69 tricked users into signing into the browser, myself included - https://lifehacker.com/how-to-disable-chromes-automatic-sign...
That was the last straw to uninstall Chrome from all my devices and I've been a happy Firefox user ever since. Well, except now reCAPTCHA hardly ever works.
Honestly... if it's the same team that did ReCaptcha 2.0, this is a team that pulls out all the stops. Per https://github.com/neuroradiology/InsideReCaptcha ... they implemented a freaking VM in Javascript to obfuscate the code that combines various signals. There's a lot going on here that's likely highly obfuscated and quantized before it's displayed to us.
EDIT: non-paywall link for [1] in the parent post: https://outline.com/aA7HS5
Brave isn't particularly "unusual", and is even based on Chromium - surely this is Google blatantly punishing non-Chrome users?
I get a 0.7 on Chrome with no account logged in and uBlock Origin installed.
Same browser, same plugin but incognito it's 0.1.
Papa google needs my data to trust me. Makes complete sense but still interesting that you can affect your score by giving in.
> error-codes": ["score-threshold-not-met"]
Not sure if happy or not happy with that. I will conclude happy enough.
Linux, on VPN, Firefox. Not logged into any Google services. Cleared caches (still same IP), no difference.
Chrome: .9
Safari: .7
Firefox: .1
I have adblock running on all three, and I use containers on Firefox.
In incognito mode in chrome, I sometimes get 0.9 and sometimes 0.7 when I reload.
I guess this is a 0 for me then
Safari macOS with the same adblocker: 0.7
Firefox macOS with a lot of adblockers: 0.1
Then I remembered that I put this in my /etc/hosts a few weeks ago and forgot about it.
127.0.0.1 google.com
127.0.0.1 www.google.com
[Edit] So if nothing shows up for you on that page, check for that. Also I just generally recommend it. Google has some unethical practices and duckduckgo.com is pretty good.
I get .7 on my iPhone, I’m guessing that my liberal use of Firefox containers and the cookie auto-delete extension on my desktop will give me a much lower score and cause me to have to jump through extra hoops at websites that implement it, just like the reCaptcha V2 does.
Edit: I also got 0.7 on Firefox with strict content blocking (which is supposed to block fingerprinters), uBlock Origin, and Cookie AutoDelete. I get 0.9 from a container which is logged into Google.