News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by rdl on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @08:15AM (#2027654)
Aside from the ease of sound suppressing them, and the small size of the weapons, there is a reason some of the best hit squads in the world use the .22lr!

Admittedly, a .22WMR is pretty much a different animal than the .22lr. Out of a rifle, it would have probably been a through and through, assuming a FMJ bullet -- you'd probably get 2000fps for a 40gr. A JSP might not have, and out of a Ruger Single Six, it's a lot closer to a really hot .22lr rifle.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by bwhite on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @11:26AM (#2028262)
Sound suppression is largely a function of relatively slowly bleeding off the gas that results from combustion. There is not much powder in a 22lr (22 long-rifle) round, which is why it is easily suppressible. I can make no particular comment as to the frequency of their use by the best hit squads in the world.

The subject of the article was shot with a 22WMR (Winchester Magnum Rimfire) round. This round can use the same bullet as the 22lr round but contains lots more powder.

The velocity of the bullet leaving the barrel of the firearm depends on how fast the charge contained in the casing wants to push it and how much the barrel wants to slow it down due to friction. Almost all rifles barrels are between 16.5" and 24". For a average 22WMR round shooting an 40-grain (unit of mass) bullet out of a mid-length rifle barrel one would expect the bullet to leave the barrel at around 2000 feet/sec. The deceleration caused by friction can be altered by changing the exterior-most material of the bullet: a full metal jacket (usually lead totally encased by copper) is potentially slicker than a jacketed soft-point (only partially encased, with the tip exposed).

A Ruger Single Six is a type of handgun. The story describes a single-action revolver, which the Single Six is not, but let's ignore that. It comes in barrel lengths of 2.75", 4", and 6". Out of a 4" or 6" barrel, the 22WMR has about 1400-1600 feet/sec of velocity. This is roughly comparable with the upper (or hot) range for a 22lr fired out of a rifle barrel.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by Zak on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @12:19PM (#2028472)
The story describes a single-action revolver, which the Single Six is not

The Single Six is, in fact a single-action revolver. See manufacturer's product page: http://www.ruger.com/products/newModelSingleSix/firearms.htm...

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by bwhite on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @09:00PM (#2030258)
+1. My brain read Security Six. I think I suppressed a mediocre Single Six experience and foregrounded the delightfulness of the Security Six.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by commandar on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @12:21PM (#2028481)
> There is not much powder in a 22lr (22 long-rifle) round, which is why it is easily suppressible.

Also, .22LR ammunition is generally subsonic outside of hotter loadings. This avoids the characteristic supersonic crack of higher velocity cartridges.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by roel_v on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:19PM (#2028712)
My gun shop sells .22LR ammo, and at a premium, a subsonic version (or at least, cartridges in boxes marked as such). Of all the .22LR ammo I've shot, none of it was marked subsonic and all claimed to provide supersonic muzzle velocities. Wikipedia seems to claims that 'regular' .22LR is supersonic (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.22_Long_Rifle#Subsonic). Do you mean that most cartridges don't make their stated muzzle velocity and that in practice most .22LR is subsonic?

(as an aside, subsonic ammo is looked at suspiciously around these parts. since it's mostly used for poaching; when used with a home-made suppressor on a rifle, it's very quiet, like you say, in large part because of the lack of sonic boom).

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by Jetlag on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:24PM (#2028736)
Muzzle velocities are usually listed for rifle length barrels, sometimes absurdly long rifle length barrels to boost the numbers. 22lr out of a handgun length barrel will fall quite short.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by mgarfias on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:48PM (#2028830)
Most manufacturers have quit playing those games. They generally (if you look) tell you what kind of weapon they were tested with, or barrel length failing that.

Doing a bit of googling, the .22LR doesn't gain much velocity beyond 14" barrel length, and loses less than 200fps from a 4" barrel vs the 14".

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by commandar on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:57PM (#2028865)
> and loses less than 200fps from a 4" barrel vs the 14".

Well, given that .22LR out of a rifle length barrel is less than 200FPS above subsonic speeds, that kind of plays right into what he was saying.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by roel_v on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:31PM (#2028756)
Yes that's true, I was thinking about rifles only, but indeed for handguns it would be different.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by mgarfias on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:43PM (#2028808)
Sorry, but .22 Long Rifle is generally loaded supersonic from the test fixtures, even in the standard loadings. A pistol (assuming a 6" bbl) is really close to supersonic, if not a bit over. It'll vary by weapon and air density.

Now, you could use one of the other rimfire variations (.22 Short, .22 Long, .22 CB) which generally will fire from a .22 LR chamber. These would most likely get you subsonic velocities.

Another thing to consider when shooting a pistol vs a rifle and comparing sound signatures is that a pistol will eject more unburnt powder into the air around the muzzle as its had less barrel length to burn said powder.

As far as suppression goes, there are four main components of the sound signature of a gunshot:

1) muzzle blast - the expansion of deflagrating powder in the atmosphere as it exits the barrel.

2) sonic crack - the bullet creating a shockwave through the air. Can be avoided by using subsonic cartridges/loadings.

3) the weapons action - at the very least the firing pin's impact on the primer. This is louder than you'd expect.

4) the bullet's impact - very much louder than you'd expect. A rifle bullet impacting flesh is a very loud slap. Imagine dropping a large boneless beef roast on a tile floor from a few meters up.

Of these bits of the gunshot, only 1) can be addressed with a suppressor. And it does make shooting much more pleasant. You can generally avoid most ear protection shooting suppressed, even with supersonic ammo (you won't be in the shockwave so no need to worry about it).

I personally have fired rather large rifles without ear protection, and its generally not real pleasant. I really wish that there was no NFA and we could buy suppressors like some countries (New Zealand comes to mind). A .22 suppressor there is something like $40NZ, here you're looking at $4-600, a $200 tax stamp, and a 6month wait for the BATFE to do a background check that the FBI does in less than a week. Oh, and you can't let your wife/kid use it without being in violation of the NFA unless you have it owned by a trust where the family memebers are trustees.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by commandar on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:55PM (#2028857)
I'm just going on chrono numbers I've seen in the past, e.g. http://www.hipointfirearmsforums.com/Forum/index.php?topic=3...

The only stuff that's consistently making supersonic out of the list is the high velocity stuff. Even Remington Golden Bullet (which Remington advertises as "high velocity" according to the box I have sitting on my desk) falls short of supersonic from pistol length barrels.

I guess the fairer thing to say would be that .22LR is borderline but it drops below supersonic pretty quickly once you start shaving barrel length.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by bwhite on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @09:03PM (#2030268)
As the saying goes, if OSHA were in charge suppressors would be mandatory.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by jacobolus on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @10:56AM (#2028134)
Your post is nearly indecipherable for a non-expert.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by Bud on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @12:14PM (#2028449)
I'm not an expert by any stretch and know virtually nothing about firearms, but I was able to decipher "fps" (feet per second), and 40gr (a 40-grain bullet). As for the other jargon, .22lr and .22WMR are pretty obviously types of weapons and were readily googlable in about 5 seconds.

I don't really see a huge complexity issue here.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by zachrose on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @11:50AM (#2028355)
I never expected to hear that on HN.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by ax0n on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @12:27PM (#2028513)
Indeed. The front page is riddled with all kinds of alphabet soup. FSM, LLVM, RegExp just to name a few. I'd kind of assumed that most of us here have learned to cope with unfamiliar terms either by dismissing or researching them.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by jarin on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @04:58PM (#2029556)
If you spend any time whatsoever in the military you get this weird superhuman ability to guess acronym meanings. True story.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by cynicalkane on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @12:37PM (#2028548)
It's reasonable to assume "hackers" reading "Hacker News" are expert enough in hacking to decipher computer talk, but unreasonable to assume they're expert enough in guns to decipher gun talk.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by hugh3 on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @12:48PM (#2028599)
Ah, but there's an interesting point here on the social acceptability of non-expertise.

If you post some expert-level stuff about physics or microbiology or linguistics or early Medieval French poetry then most people won't understand it but nobody will complain because they're ashamed (well, at least slightly) of their ignorance on these subjects.

On the other hand if you post some expert-level stuff about guns or football or Justin Bieber then people will complain because they're proud of their ignorance on these subjects. Being an expert on those subjects marks you out as part of a group which some people here don't want to be seen as being part of, so folks are quite proud to proclaim their ignorance on these subjects.

Of course, go to another corner of the internet and it's all switched around.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by cynicalkane on Wednesday December 22, 2010 @09:42AM (#2031406)
I'm really kind of floored that my simple little post seems to have been so contentious. People seem to have interpreted my comment as something to the effect that gun talk shouldn't be allowed. All I meant to say, however, was what I said--that a lot of people are simply not going to understand dense gun talk.

I don't think your comment is true, either. I'd be very surprised if most people here were ashamed, even slightly, of their ignorance on any given 'nerd' subject. Very often, the top comments in a story are either explanations or requests for explanations followed by explanations, maybe followed by more requests for clarification. I also bet I can find more people here proud of their ignorance about say, Haskell monads, than about guns, judging by how loud they are about it.

Finally, Justin Bieber is a subject of a different nature--his prominence in culture is disproportionately higher than his importance, so people usually don't want to hear about it. Not a fair comparison.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by roel_v on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:22PM (#2028726)
Funnily enough I posted just this (albeit in a more biting tone) last week, in an instance involving Justin Bieber (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1982494), and was getting up/downvoted for a while just like you are until the upvotes won out in the end ;)
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by mquander on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:05PM (#2028661)
It's also reasonable to assume "hackers" reading "Hacker News" know how to use Google and Wikipedia to learn about things that they are interested in but don't understand, instead of asking others to dumb down all conversations to suit them.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by ax0n on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:08PM (#2028670)
There are so many different kinds of hackers here, that I'd almost have to disagree. There aren't many folks here who could tell me all I wanted to know about Haskell, asymmetric encryption, the finer points of being a non-technical founder and the different strengths of various revision control systems. But all of us see stuff like that here every day. We either ignore that which we do not understand, or we look it up.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by JonnieCache on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:33PM (#2028763)
Surely there aren't many gun hackers in the world though? At least, not for very long...
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by mgarfias on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:52PM (#2028849)
What the heck? There are millions of us. There are several industries revolving around people who "hack" their weapons. Whether its a new handguard on your AR-15, or buying 10 lbs of gunpowder there are people that can help you out.

In fact, I'd say that there are more of them, than hackers.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by JonnieCache on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @02:24PM (#2028965)
I was more thinking of DIY firearms/firearm modification. That would seem very dangerous to me.

It is quite common for criminals in the UK to "re-bore" replica or deactivated weapons. It is also very common for these guns to backfire, killing the shooter.

The idea of gun hacking simply put me in mind of these sad occurrences.

I'm not suggesting anyone is a mouth breathing redneck, or an inept criminal for that matter, lets put it this way: when I think of some of the things I've hacked in the more conventional sense, I wouldn't feel safe if those things had been potentially lethal :)

EDIT: before anyone else brings this up, it has just occurred to me that the category of "potentially lethal" includes every object in existence, especially cars, which people love to hack and I would never anyone accuse of being reckless for hacking. So feel free to disregard my whole point.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by ars on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @03:56PM (#2029358)
Gun hackers in the US are far more familiar with guns than those in the UK. Also you can get higher quality parts for guns in the US (no need for replica or deactivated stuff).
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by CapitalistCartr on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @05:31PM (#2029653)
To understand the difference between you Brits and us Yanks, please Google "anvil shooting".
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by ax0n on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @02:07PM (#2028905)
I'm one. And the guy who replied to you before I could has the right idea. There are also pyrotechnics hackers in general, too, many of which really get a kick out of almost any kind of projectile or explosive device. We're not all mouth-breathing rednecks. See also: Metalstorm.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by ams6110 on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @02:56PM (#2029096)
Admittedly, a .22WMR is pretty much a different animal than the .22lr. Out of a rifle, it would have probably been a through and through, assuming a FMJ bullet -- you'd probably get 2000fps for a 40gr. A JSP might not have, and out of a Ruger Single Six, it's a lot closer to a really hot .22lr rifle.

I think I have just experienced what a non-technical user feels like when talking to a hardware geek.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by dkarl on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @02:42PM (#2029026)
I heard a story, possibly an urban legend, that the Israeli army had classified a particularly underpowered .22 rifle as a "less lethal" weapon so they could use it to shoot protesters, juvenile rock-throwers, and other targets with which they were supposed to exercise a certain amount of restraint. Soldiers then measured their marksmanship by how lethal they could be with this "less lethal" weapon until the government was forced to correct the "mistake."

This is a pretty ugly story that would have gratifying appeal to many people on either side of the issue (I heard it from a conservative guy who was grinning with glee at the supposed cleverness of the Israelis) so there's a good chance it's an urban legend. Confirmation or refutation would be welcome.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by philwelch on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @04:47PM (#2029518)
"a story, possibly an urban legend, [about] the Israeli army"

In other words, "anti-Semitic libel"?

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by dkarl on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @06:13PM (#2029788)
Not necessarily. In the context I heard it in, it was anti-Palestinian.

P.S. To go further, the guy who told me the story was planning on buying such a gun if he could confirm it, just to have a conversation piece. Plus the story sounds perfectly in line with the bizarre results you get when bureaucrats are asked to classify things.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by PostOnce on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @11:14AM (#2028205)
Got any sources for that hit squads claim? Sounds fascinating. I'd read more.

Relatedly, the world doesn't have enough good spy movies.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by roel_v on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @01:28PM (#2028748)
There is an infamous book called 'Hitman' published in the 1980's I believe, published by Paladin Press, that claims to be a manual on how to be, surprise surprise, a hitman. It recommends using a .22 for its ease of suppressability. It's a rather stupid for the rest, but what made it famous is that someone committed a murder in the way described in the book and after that the published was sued and the book got taken off the market. See http://www.francesfarmersrevenge.com/stuff/archive/oldnews5/... .

I don't know anything about hit squads using .22, but in the (rural) area I'm from, .22 rifles are known as poachers rifles because when used with subsonic ammo and a homemade suppressor, they are very quiet.

That said, I'm not sure that hit squads are very concerned with being quiet. That Iranian virus expert that got killed the other week was blown up, the Israelis that killed the Hamas leader a while ago didn't even wear disguises and were filmed full frontal. From the targeted killings that make the news, being 'subtle' doesn't seem to be a consideration.

Oh and drug dealers who kill people don't care about being silent, either. All high profile shootings of the last few years in my area were with heavy caliber weapons.

Re:Getting shot by a handgun by gcr on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @11:40AM (#2028319)
You must have a pretty sweet graphics card to get 2000 FPS.
Re:Getting shot by a handgun by ramchip on Tuesday December 21, 2010 @05:23PM (#2029628)
He must have thrown his graphics card very hard to reach 2000 FPS.