Backpropagation, which most researchers will agree is an AI algorithm, is a "simple algorithm".
So are many other AI algorithms, some of which are simple enough to be understood so well that most people don't recognise them as AI anymore: search algorithms like depth- breadth- or best-first search, game-playing algorithms like alpha-beta minimax, gradient descent/ hill climb, are the examples that readily come to mind.
I think the above article and your comment are assuming that, for an algorithm to be "AI" it must be very complicated and difficult to understand. This is common enough to have a name: "the AI effect". A few years down the line I bet people will say that "this is not AI, it's just deep learning".
There's no reason for AI algorithms to be complicated. Very simple algorithms can create enormous complexity, even infinite complexity. The state of deterministic systems with even a couple of parameters can become impossible to predict after a small number of steps if they have the chaos property. Language seems to be the application of a finite set of rules on a finite vocabulary to produce an infinite set of utterances. Complexity arises from very simple sources, in nature.
As time rolls on and we see more articles like this one calling out the "AI BS" - which I agree should be called out...
I worry that a new "winter" will set in, and funding will be cut, and research towards how biological neural networks actually work vis-a-vis artificial neural networks will suffer.
Because from what I understand, we currently don't know how such biological networks actually "learn" - because there isn't a "mechanism" for backpropagation to occur.
IIRC, there's still questions on how information is propagated through biological networks; our artificial representations of them are constrained to approximately a single dimension of the real thing (and even that doesn't capture the biology, thus the idea of "spiking neural networks") - but there may be other avenues of information diffusion that are important as well, still to be revealed in the biological makeup.
We know for certain we are missing something fundamental, when even if you could scale up some of today's best deep learning systems to data center scale won't approximate anything close to what goes on in the human brain, given the size and power constraints.
Figuring this out could be set back, when funding becomes scarce once more.
AI might end up the same, enter a winter. people will talk about how silly endevours into AI where, but a few companies will really figure it out and a huge explosion will occur and people will wonder how anyone did anything without AI. something like that
for those who forgot what that winter was like: 1999 2:10: your not a pure internet company... (insinuating thats bad) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GltlJO56S1g&t=316s
.com bubble burst somewhere March, 2001
2002 2:22: netflix represents one of the few success stories of an otherwise desolute tech sector https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBLAwGhyV5k
2004 who in their right mind brings a company to market in the doldrums of august in a down tech... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxOoeCHc47Q
That seems sufficiently “black-box-ish” to me?
Back-propogation is not an "AI" algorithm.
You are ironically doing exactly what this article is about.
My comment is making an entirely uncontroversial statement: that "backpropagation is an AI algorithm". Not that "backpropagation is AI". The latter could be taken to mean that backpropagation is itself artificially intelligent, that it exhibits some kind of intelligence (leaving aside for the moment the fact that we have no agreed upon definition of "intelligence", artificial or otherwise). If I understand your comment correctly, this is the interpretation you make of my comment.
However, what my comment says, and this should be clear from the context ("most researchers will agree"), is that backpropagation is an algorithm from the field of research that is known as AI.
In that context, "AI", "Artificial Intelligence", is the field of research that investigates methods to construct "AI", "Artificial Intelligence(s)". Backpropagation is a component of one such method, neural networks.
I think then that the confusion, which is also discussed, and exhibited, in the article, stems from the fact that the same word is used to describe both "artificial intelligence" and the field that researches artificial intelligence.
And I hope this clarifies the confusion.
Just saying "no it isn't" is just not helpful or useful.
You are the example it is making.
There are no accepted definitions of these terms. Are they meaningless?
AI that does not include backpropagation or logical deduction or GA's or optimisation is... is... magical thinking. AI without the nuts and bolts from the last 50 years of work is meaningless. The article is heartfelt, and we all agree with the tenant that people pretending that they are using AI when they are really using a database isn't a good thing, but if you take any current system look right down inside it all you will find is a Shannon type implementation of church-turing.
https://bagrifoundation.org/anicka-yi-la-biennale-di-venezia...
If this is what you are talking about, I'm disappointed that the work is crap. She also won the Hugo Boss prize in 2016. This is a highly respected award in the art world.
The art world isn't doing a good job understanding AI. Part of this is media hype causing people to be misled. Another part is the cognitive tools artists have developed to understand the world are inappropriate for understanding these technologies. For this work to be believable by technologists there would need to be some kind of demonstrable scientific rigor involved. There is none here, but people from the art world who are evaluating these things don't notice it is missing.
My Postmodern Adventure
by Chip Morningstar [email protected] 5-July-1993
"Academics get paid for being clever, not for being right." - Donald Norman
That's because real art, like anything (engineering, piano, sports) takes years and years of hard work to perfect the skill which gives the ability to translate your ideas into something beautiful and self-explanatory (when you don't need to be expert to "understand the meaning" as it is with masters like Michelangelo).
A great example is when Henry Moore saw Michelangelo and started to cry and confessed the only reason he makes such statues is because he knows "he will never be able to create anything as beautiful as that"
Perhaps he would if instead he worked on things that are hard.
It's hilarious how modern art lives on creating documentaries, popularizing an "artist" then selling art for investment while fooling people by using shaming tactics like "you just don't understand art" or "that was not the point artist was trying to make"
If the artist has to explain her work in words he should have chosen literature as a form of expression for clearly she failed using her current means to do so.
I can't agree with the idea that art has to be technically difficult to be "real." If a simple, abstract sculpture gives me more joy than a portrait from a great master, that doesn't mean my understanding is defective. (Nor is yours if you disagree.) Meaning isn't limited to what the creator says it is, either.
People are obsessed with nailing down a precision definition of "art," and it always turns out to be "the stuff I like, but not that crap you like."
On technical level. I disagree. There's a difference.
A piano player that plays a flawless Beethoven, is not Beethoven because there's a difference between the ability to compose and ability to play a composed piece.
And so it is with your analogy of Da Vinci vs. forgery.
Interesting. Citation?
I personally love this epic ownage: Normal Rockwell painted a Jackson Pollack inside of his own realistic painting. https://triviahappy.com/articles/norman-rockwell-made-fun-of...
He later claimed the reason he's "inspired" by "sumerian" art is that "he feels greco-roman art is over-represented.
The anecdote is from Moore's exhibition in Krakow, it was discussed there. I will get a precise source in 2 days and post it here.
Do you believe the scribbles are "amazing scribbles"?
A key problem is that AI is a very wide and vague concept.
What she might have is a simple "expert system", which a lot of systems called AI in the 80s were and many today probably are too, monitoring the inputs, and she may have programmed that initially in its knowledge acquisition phase with the aid of a machine learning arrangement. That would qualify as "using AI" depending on which interpretation of "AI" you are working by. An expert system can be called a rudimentary AI, and could be implemented as simple combinatorial logic if new learning during operation is not needed.
The remaining circuitry was way to simple for the claimed functionality. Basically a DIY arduino on a bigger PCB with a few leds.
Around the inner frame there was transparent silicone how her “sensors” should be able to get through that layer of see-through isolation without beeing seen themselves is beyond me.
This is why I think it is a work of fiction. I don’t know whether on purpose or because they thought nobody will notice. I certainly found it to be an interesting commentary on AI :)
It is possible, for instance, to implement a small neural network on a regular Arduino; a simple google search for "arduino neural network" should yield some information. It would be a small step from there to interfacing such an implementation to something else as part of an art project.
Again, I am not doubting your story; I just wanted to point out that what appears to be a simple system could very well have an actual artificial intelligence aspect to it, even given the seemingly unreasonable processing constraints of an Arduino.
I was recently asked to make a very simple introduction to AI. It made me think a bit as I have been annoyed at the confusion between ML and AI that is so frequent nowadays.
I proposed that AI started with Turing's hypothesis that brains are Turing machines and that AI was the field that tries to bring human capacities to computers.
My next slide says "AI is not really a field. It is more of a goal and a theme. And now a set of techniques used in many different fields."
AI in books is impossible in 2019.
I don't cringe, but then again, my boss is really happy with the AI program I built. Maybe its time to change definitions or terms.
You should not change definitions/terms, but rather introduce new definitions/terms if you want to express something different.
Nah, I prefer having something to keep me cynical and disappointed every time another "cutting-edge AI" application comes out. As a research community, we should be held accountable for our failures to achieve the real shit, the full-on Charles Stross vision.
Is that incorrect though? I think a lot of people here are making a lot of assumptions about a very vague and ill-defined term. To me it seems like AI is just a way of saying that a program is capable of making decisions. There is no implicit tie-in to machine learning or neural networks or anything like that. These decisions can come from 5 lines of "if" statements (as is the case with most video game AI).
100% this!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Treachery_of_Images
It's like The Treachery of Images but in reverse.
This is an AI/mind
c'est un cerveau / une intelligence artificielle
I downvoted one of your comments that was essentially a cut-and-paste of this comment here; I have noticed that you have done this more than once here within the comments.
Please refrain from doing this; it seems to add nothing but noise to the conversation. If you believe your commentary has merit within the context of the thread at hand, do your best to restate that opinion in an original manner, not by simply copying and repeating the exact same statement.
I hope this explanation clarifies why I downvoted you; I believe your comment does have merit to the discussion as a whole, but posting it once should be enough to reach the audience with it's intended message.
It is however an uphill battle when these 80% systems offer such immediate gains. We really need governments to be informed and active.
An evaluation process, it's very common here in Sweden. I mean how much money can you really loose in six months? You can kick that shithole straight out day one if that's your perogative. It's a good deal for both parties.
You see people trying to shoehorn ML into many such system though, and there is money in it, which is why people are chasing it to have it on their CVs.
Like the noSQL hype of a some years ago it'll settle down and people will gravitate back more towards the right tool for the job (which will sometimes be ML based, but often not, just as "noSQL" is sometimes the right tool or right enough). ML will survive where it is the best tool for the job, or at least where it can be genuinely useful and not significantly sub-optimal.
> our problems are CRUD at modest scale.
I see some of our client base looking into ML and "Big Data", and I despair a little because they often fail badly at getting "little data" correct. It is actually part of the sales pitch for ML: let the AI filter out the crap in your inputs and give you something approximating a decent answer as output. They'd be much better served working on fixing the data sources or using more traditional cleansing methods, but that seems like harder work compared to the new magic some consultant is extolling. ML isn't a magic bullet, but it is currently being sold as one.
All of tech is magic to the non-tech people.
There was a metal frame holding two glas plates with ventian sediment inbetween (sand, soil, mud). In the center there was another metal frame which formed a hole. There also were to PCB boards with ATMEGA micro controllers.
In the text the artist claimed she controlled the biome of the soil with an AI using various sensors and pumps.
This was clearly a fake, as you could see nothing like that on the PCB.
Accidentally (?) she managed to create the best representation of AI I have seen in art: all that counts is that you call it AI even if it is a simple algorithm. AI is the phrase behind which magic hides and people love magic. Everything that has the aura of “humans don’t fully understand how it works in detail” will be used by charlartans, snake oil salesmen and conmen.
If even artists slap “AI” onto their works to sell it, you know we are past the peak now.