News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by treydey on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:07AM (#20145047)
Can anyone explain the strategy like I'm 5? I'm confused by his answer.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by kickopotomus on Monday June 10, 2019 @07:42PM (#20151949)
It might make a little more sense with the numbers. WinFall was a typical lottery game where you choose 6 of 46 numbers[1]. As with most lottery games, there is a jackpot payout but there are also payouts for matching 3, 4, and 5 of the numbers. The odds breakdown goes like this[2]:

  Result | Odds
  -------------
  6 of 6 | 1 in 9,366,819
  5 of 6 | 1 in 39028.41
  4 of 6 | 1 in 800.58
  3 of 6 | 1 in 47.40
  2 of 6 | 1 in 6.83
The issue with WinFall is that when the jackpot increased past $5MM, the expected value of the non-jackpot winnings becomes favorable to the player. I.e. a 5-of-6 matching ticket might normally yield $4,000 but may yield >$20,000 for a "Roll-down" game. So if you go out and buy 200,000 tickets for the roll-down game (assuming all tickets are different and numbers are selected at random), you should expect to have 5 5-of-6 tickets, 250 4-of-6 tickets, 4,219 3-of-6 tickets, and 29,283 2-of-6 tickets. The combined winnings of all of those tickets makes it profitable.

[1]: https://www.mass.gov/files/documents/2016/08/vv/lottery-cash...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lottery_mathematics

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by treydey on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @04:47AM (#20153830)
This is what I was looking for! Thanks.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by em-bee on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @01:06AM (#20153130)
so in each game the money that is not won is collected in the pool until the pool is bigger than the overall cost for all tickets?

and in other games this doesn't work because they are 'winner-takes-all'?

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by Piskvorrr on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:21AM (#20145100)
If nobody wins the big jackpot ("guess all the numbers") for some time, parts of it are given to the smaller winners ("guess a few of the numbers"). In this case, which happened once in a while, it became more likely that you'll win more than you have bet. Usually this means you'll win some $50; they have bet many, many times, and won $50 times many.

Doesn't work any more, rules have changed so this way of winning was removed.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by tylerhou on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:23AM (#20145109)
But which set of tickets do you buy?
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by Piskvorrr on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:39AM (#20145169)
From the article, it seems that it doesn't matter, they're random. (Or were random, apparently it's over now, doesn't matter.)

To make up an example:

Let's say that betting $1 in some way has a 4% chance of winning, and the payout is 20x bet, so if you win on one ticket, you get $20. So, you buy a lot of tickets (say 1000), and you pay $1000. Most of them don't win anything, but 4% of them win $20; $1000 x 4% x 20 = $800; you have won some, but you have $200 less than you started with. Not a good deal.

However, if nobody wins the jackpot, it is distributed amongst smaller payouts, which changes the equation: still 4% chance, but payout is now $30. Again, you pay $1000, buy 1000 tickets, most don't win anything, but the 4% that do, you get $1000 x 4% x 30 = $1200. You have $200 more than you started with. Profit! Of course, this will only work if you buy many tickets; buying one or two, you're unlikely to win anything at all.

The actual numbers were different in these cases, but the general principle is the same.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by soneil on Monday June 10, 2019 @01:19PM (#20148739)
> Of course, this will only work if you buy many tickets; buying one or two, you're unlikely to win anything at all.

That's the important part here. You can always win the lottery if you can buy enough tickets. To match all (n) numbers, you need to buy one ticket for every possible combination. To match (n-1), you need to buy a lot less.

But in a normal game, the cost of doing so is more than the payout. So if I have a dollar-game "guess a number between one and ten", and you can win $6 - it's not worth buying ten tickets, even if it guarantees you a win. But if I say "one day only, double the winnings!" - now $10 guarantees you $12 back.

The odds don't change, just the profitability of them.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by eridius on Monday June 10, 2019 @04:00PM (#20150211)
In a normal lottery, if the pot gets large enough, even with the normal rules the "expected payout" of a ticket becomes higher than its list price. It's just that the chances of actually winning are so astronomically low that you'd have to be Jeff Bezos to stand a good chance of winning your bet (i.e. being able to buy enough tickets such that your chances of winning are worth the play, and then especially being able to absorb the loss when you lose anyway because it's still random).

What's interesting with the rolldown mechanism is not just that the "expected payout" of a ticket becomes worth more than its price, but that the number of winners is such that you can actually reasonably expect to turn a profit by buying a modest number of tickets.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by amelius on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:32AM (#20145383)
That requires a lot of faith in the fairness of the particular lottery.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by jarfil on Monday June 10, 2019 @08:30AM (#20146104)
Official lotteries are usually heavily regulated and audited to ensure they comply with their published rules. These are state lotteries we're talking here, not random gambling websites.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by loblollyboy on Monday June 10, 2019 @07:40AM (#20145718)
A. Any lotto requires faith. B. Selbee didnt put all his money in initially. C. The parent comment is just explaining a concept w a hypothetical example
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by phkahler on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:05PM (#20150847)
All of them. They bought 1100 to ensure that every combination of some size was in their set of tickets.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by tylerhou on Monday June 10, 2019 @08:09PM (#20152071)
I don’t think 1100 tickets is enough to cover all combinations of 4 numbers, but I don’t know the original lottery number range so I’m not sure.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by diminoten on Monday June 10, 2019 @03:44PM (#20150070)
They apparently announced when this was going to happen, so it was more about timing than buying specific tickets.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by emerongi on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:38AM (#20145165)
The jackpot grows off of people losing money. Once people have lost enough money ($5M), the chances of winning the money with a single ticket are raised, however you can no longer win the whole $5M with a single ticket - the money is now distributed over a larger pool of tickets.

After that it becomes a good bet, because you can bet smaller amounts, but still win more than you put in initially - you're profiting off of people who lost money before you.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by chrismcb on Monday June 10, 2019 @07:18AM (#20145587)
Someone can always win the whole 5M. It is just that if the prize for large enough and no one win, then the amount of the small prizes increased. It was a way to keep the total payout low.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by bsaul on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:19AM (#20145088)
Even weirder is the statement that the State that organized the lottery made more money thanks to them buying massive amount of tickets ( or maybe it was the publicity around the first newspaper article that triggered more interest, and so more participant in general ?)
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by Piskvorrr on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:24AM (#20145117)
I understand the opposite: the State didn't lose any money, (but didn't make any money from these people winning, either); it made money from lottery as usual, but not from these people. (There's an implication that more people in general bought tickets, didn't win, and so the organizer made money from those - but it's not entirely clear.)
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by thaumasiotes on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:50AM (#20145208)
The state makes money from every ticket purchased. The lottery simply pays out a fixed percentage of ticket revenue. More ticket sales means more money to the state, regardless of whether those tickets, when purchased, had an expected positive or negative return.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by pliny on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:07AM (#20145278)
If the ticket has an expected positive return for the buyer, then the state must be losing money.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by Piskvorrr on Monday June 10, 2019 @09:38AM (#20146593)
The ticket only has an expected positive value return under certain limited circumstances, not all the time (i.e. when jackpot has not been won for a time). State is not losing money in total - just moving around the distribution of prizes, but the sum total remains constant.

If anyone would be losing money here, it would be a hypothetical winner of the jackpot - but as the jackpot is only redistributed when there is no such winner for some time...

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by chrismcb on Monday June 10, 2019 @07:25AM (#20145634)
The prize pool losses the money, not the state. This was a mechanism to keep the overall prize pool from getting too large. Of one person won the main prize, then they would get a car majority of the prize pool. Otherwise the prize pool was essentially distribute among all the players. Yes technically if enough people played, they could have spent more than the prize pool, but, if enough people played, then the chance that one person won goes up as well.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by progval on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:24AM (#20145350)
It has an expected positive return only on the days there was a Rolldown.

Money came from people who played on days there wasn't one.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by diminoten on Monday June 10, 2019 @03:49PM (#20150118)
No, because the payout for the state (the amount they planned on losing) was always the same. The amount was "lost" regardless, it just depended on if it went to one big winning ticket or hundreds/thousands of smaller winning tickets.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by eridius on Monday June 10, 2019 @04:04PM (#20150244)
For this to be true, every additional winning ticket purchased must result in a net loss to the state. But it doesn't, every additional winning ticket purchased is money going to the state. The losers in this case are the other people with winning tickets, because their payouts become smaller¹.

¹Well, given one assumption about how the game is run. The other assumption is that the 3- and 4-number winning tickets have a fixed payout calibrated such that this doesn't fully exhaust the pot, and in this case the "loser" for each additional winning ticket is whoever wins the full pot next time as the pot will be lower than it would otherwise have been.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by zaroth on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @12:11AM (#20152957)
I think in this case the winnings were fixed and the surge in sales in Rolldown days would cause the pot to be drawn down much more, meaning a longer delay before the next Rolldown day.

So Rolldowns probably became less frequent, but otherwise the lottery made their money and everyone took home exactly the winnings they would have in that particular game.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by zawerf on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:29AM (#20145370)
I feel like mathematically, you must be right. One of the sides must be calculating their expected value wrong.

For example I can offer to pay a $3 jackpot (split across winners) for a $1 game for guessing heads or tails. If more than 3 people play the game, I make money. For each player, the naive way to calculate expected return is $3 * 0.5 + $0 * 0.5 - $1 = $0.5. So the players also think they are making money. But once you account for jackpot splitting, that "expected value" isn't positive anymore. To calculate this correctly, the player (who has less information) need some way to model the distribution of the number of other players.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by thaumasiotes on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:40AM (#20145418)
> mathematically, you must be right. One of the sides must be calculating their expected value wrong.

He isn't right. The state doesn't work with expected values in any way. Money comes in via ticket sales, some of it goes into the state budget, the rest goes out as lottery payouts. There is no element of chance in any of that.

As you point out here and I point out elsewhere, the expected value of a ticket for the purchaser depends on the total number of tickets sold, which has been mostly elided from the discussion. In fact, it's mostly irrelevant as to this past event; at the actual ticket volumes, returns really were positive on the days in question.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by pliny on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:56AM (#20145484)
The way the game is presented in the article is that the low payout numbers are fixed (so a 3 match on a given rolldown game pays out $50 regardless of how many winners there are). This is consistent with the state lotteries I know. In this scenario every ticket sold causes the state to lose money, on average.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by chrismcb on Monday June 10, 2019 @07:13AM (#20145555)
No. Every ticket sold causes the prize pool to lose money. The amount the state makes increases.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by zawerf on Monday June 10, 2019 @07:24AM (#20145627)
It's a zero sum game. If one side is positive, the other side must be negative.

If jackpot isn't paid out, state gets (ticket_sales), players in total gets (-ticket_sales).

If jackpot is paid out, state gets (ticket_sales - jackpot), players gets (jackpot - ticket_sales). The winning players get ((jackpot - winning_ticket_sales) / num_winners) each, the rest gets (losing_ticket_sales).

Either way the expected value for an individual player is always the opposite sign of the expected value of the state.

The interpretation that people might be using is that: when the tickets sold is low, it's positive expected value for the players. When sales cross the jackpot, it's positive expected value for the state. But then it becomes negative value for the player! There's no point in time where both sides are winning.

(And of course that interpretation is pretty meaningless because you don't want to calculate the expected return based on the current number of tickets sold. You want the forecast of the eventual number of tickets sold. The state never really loses, even at the start because they have a pretty good idea of what this number will be in the end)

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by kd5bjo on Monday June 10, 2019 @07:41AM (#20145722)
It’s a zero-sum game, but there are 3 parties: the state general fund, the prize pool, and the players. By regulation, a fixed percentage of each ticket sale goes to the state general fund and the rest goes to the prize pool. Also by regulation, all the money that goes into the prize pool must eventually be paid out to players.

The unpaid prize pool getting too big can cause problems for the operator: there may be accusations by the regulator that it’ll never be paid out, or it could be stolen or mismanaged leaving the operator insolvent because they no longer have the funds they are required to give to players.

A rolldown event is the operator choosing to increase the payout schedule to an expected win for the purpose of reducing their liability of unpaid prizes; tickets having a positive expected value is the entire point.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by zaroth on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @12:13AM (#20152962)
Swarming the rolldown day would just have the effect of diminishing the prize pool faster, and therefore a longer delay before the next rolldown day.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by Piskvorrr on Monday June 10, 2019 @09:56AM (#20146749)
Actually, the state doesn't seem to enter into the equation at all, that's a red herring. State gets (ticket_sales - prize_money), sure. This amount is predetermined by the rules (usually "X% goes to state, 100-X% goes to prize pool). From here, the only changes happen in the way that the prize pool is distributed to winners: part goes to jackpot, part goes to smaller prizes; if jackpot too large, recalculate with a larger part going to smaller prizes. The amount that state is paid out is never influenced by this.

Example:

In round 1, state sells tickets for 100 ($, $thousand, $billion, doesn't matter). 50% goes to state, 20% goes to jackpot, 30% goes to smaller prizes. State gets 50, jackpot is 20, prizes of 30 are paid out.

Round 2: sell 100, get 50, jackpot 20+20 (from last round), prizes of 30 are paid out.

Round 3: sell 100, get 50, jackpot 40+20, prizes of 30 are paid out.

Round 4: sell 100, get 50, jackpot 60+20, prizes of 30 are paid out.

Round 5: sell 100, get 50, jackpot 80+20=100, recalculation triggers, new jackpot 0, prizes of 30+100 are paid out.

Round 6: sell 100, get 50, jackpot 0+20, prizes of 30 are paid out.

Note that in every round, the amount that state receives is independent of the relationship between jackpot and other prizes.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by JoeAltmaier on Monday June 10, 2019 @10:01AM (#20146788)
minus 5% for 'administration' which is outrageous. Its a fixed cost to administer the lottery. Should not be a percentage.

And is anybody calculating the taxes on the prize, which also goes to fed/state?

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by Piskvorrr on Monday June 10, 2019 @08:21PM (#20152122)
I have no idea what the exact numbers are. I have tried to illustrate how the temporary increase in the smaller payouts has no bearing on how much the state makes, yet it makes the game temporarily profitable. Obviously this still needs to be profitable for the players after taxes, expenses and whatnot, otherwise it would be a complete non-story: "person does not get richer playing lottery."
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by toyg on Monday June 10, 2019 @09:07AM (#20146358)
From what I understand, money paid out was calculated after removing state profit from sales. So the state always profited, whether prizes were paid or not. It was effectively a per-ticket tax.

What changed was the distribution of winnings among players and operator. If everyone had cottoned on the “winning strategy”, the prize would have simply been divided in smaller and smaller parts - at some point, the winning strategy would have become a losing one - and the operator wouldn’t get to keep any “unclaimed prize”, only whatever fixed per-ticket fee they might have applied.

That’s precisely what the rules aimed for, btw. They wanted to unload prize money at higher rates over a certain threshold, for their own reasons - and they did. It just so happened that a small number of players benefited disproportionately more than others, because they played smart.

Imho the operators chickened out - as long as their profit model allowed for all prize money to be really given away, they could have continued, maximizing their overall revenue. However, if “keeping some of the prize money” was part of the expected operator profit, then yeah, it couldn’t be allowed to go on.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by soneil on Monday June 10, 2019 @01:32PM (#20148859)
The simple correction is that the pot doesn't live in your pocket. And the lottery don't offer a fixed jackpot, they offer the contents of the pot.

So a realistic correction of this, would be that for each $1 game, 50 cents goes in the pot, 50 cents goes in your pocket. If 3 people play and all 3 win, their payout is 50 cents. Obviously 50/50 odds lead to a disappointing game for the players - a bigger pot needs lower odds - but either way, the house never loses.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by steventhedev on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:45AM (#20145441)
For that particular round of the game, yes.

Overall? No, unless the game is very badly designed.

The whole situation arises from rolling over the losses between rounds, which "sweetens" the pot for intelligent players. It's also a good way to inflate your numbers if you know that your game might get cut next year (e.g. it might be better to show turnover of 100mm and payouts of 90mm than turnover of 10mm and payouts of 8mm).

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by thaumasiotes on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:47AM (#20145448)
> It's also a good way to inflate your numbers if you know that your game might get cut next year (e.g. it might be better to show turnover of 100mm and payouts of 90mm than turnover of 10mm and payouts of 8mm).

...wouldn't that be better under all possible circumstances? Would you rather have $10 million or $2 million?

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by steventhedev on Monday June 10, 2019 @08:16AM (#20145989)
whooops!

100mm with 99mm payout vs 10mm and 8.5mm payout then...

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by thaumasiotes on Monday June 10, 2019 @06:36AM (#20145402)
You're not thinking about this the right way. The ticket doesn't have a positive expected return as a structural feature of the lottery. It has a positive expected return conditional on the total number of tickets sold being less than a fixed value.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by M2Ys4U on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:52AM (#20145219)
Are state lottery ticket purchases taxed? That'd also bring in a chunk of change.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by jarfil on Monday June 10, 2019 @08:56AM (#20146277)
That is correct: since these were not usual players who abstained from playing, but rather casual players who bought extra tickets just on rolldown, while the State got a cut from every ticket sale, they were effectively pouring extra money into the lottery, increasing the State's income.

Even if they re-invested their previous winnings, that would be twice (or more) that the State would get its cut from the same money, still increasing its income.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by Double_a_92 on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @02:56AM (#20153467)
The money was "stolen" from the person that would have won the jackpot. The maximum jackpot was just smaller, it didn't make a difference to the lottery who actually won that money. They could say that the jackpot will be split among everyone that has exactly one number right in the next round, and still make profit.
Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by losvedir on Monday June 10, 2019 @08:28PM (#20152148)
* Expected value of the lottery tickets is normally negative. (You pay $1, you expect on average to get back less than $1).

* At a certain point, if the jackpot grows too large, the game switches to a new "windfall" mode where the expected value is actually _positive_ to bleed off the jackpot. (You pay $1, you expect on average to get back more than $1).

* The couple and the MIT students only played during the positive expected value times.

Overall the game still makes money for the state, it's just it has two distinct regimes, and the people playing during negative-EV essentially bankroll both the state and the positive-EV players.

Re:Couple wins millions using lottery loophole by martin_b on Monday June 10, 2019 @05:41AM (#20145176)
There is a great lecture about it from The Royal Institution https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZTKuMBJP7Y