As for emotive press stories about dead animals being the only reason people care. Did you know that the average human meal contains microplastics now? That your body contains microplastics right now?
"About 50% of a CO2 increase will be removed from the atmosphere within 30 years, and a further 30% will be removed within a few centuries. The remaining 20% may stay in the atmosphere for many thousands of years." --IPCC AR4
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2005/03/how-lo...
Plastics are a visible but small part of our environmental damage. Plastic straws doubly so.
EDIT: To be clear I am not saying that it is harmless to release lots of CO2 I am saying that we can't compare pollutants by simply looking at the gross tonnage released.
https://aem.asm.org/content/77/22/7962
I expect they'll be common well before 10,000 years. It's certainly an easier problem than getting CO2 out of the atmosphere.
Typically all you need to do to keep microorganisms from eating something is keep it dry. We tend to do that for laptops anyway.
Besides, the assertion wasn't that plastic would still be useful for everything. It just wouldn't be useless.
Plastic vs fuel is not an either/or thing: they're both problems. We probably can't eliminate either of them completely, but we should try to cut back on both as much as we can.
A tax on plastic packaging would be a very good idea.
Even if you take every plastic and drop it into a bin, you're either going to burn it or dump it. Most of the plastic trash in the US is also just shipped to other countries with more lax laws so they just either burn it or dump it. Until we have a proper process for disposing plastics safely and cleanly, we must reduce using it in the ridiculous way we're using it. Single-use plastic bag should never be used if you have a way to use a reusable cloth bag instead.
Because people in the first world won't stand for modern incineration plants. The NIMBYs who would personally be negatively affected spread FUD about a .00001% increased chance of getting cancer or some crap like that.
Burning trash in general is a damn good way to get rid of it. You're left with ash which takes up a fraction of the space and is much easier to contain than the original trash product. Sure, it emits some nasty stuff but when you run an incinerator in the first world you can scrub that out of the exhaust. When you ship that stuff to the 3rd world you lose oversight of what happens to it.
> The solution [is] enforcing existing laws against littering
That's the classic industry argument: it's not their fault if there is pollution, it's the end users that irresponsibly throw stuff away. Ignoring their heavily-funded lobbying to avoid plastic reduction laws and minimize recycling obligations.
Vermont was planning to introduce laws to require reuse of drinks bottles in the 1950s. Coca Cola, Philip Morris, Budweiser and others clubbed together to form and fund "Keep America Beautiful" to advertise and lobby for the problem to be landed on the consumer instead of the businesses that created the problem.
The solution is putting blame back on the producers, where it belongs. Require them to own that externality they created. Oh, and discouraging litter.
I'm having a hard time imagining somebody justifying flying more/further because they aren't using plastic straws in their day-to-day life.
Surely we can work to improve the world on multiple fronts at a time, and if single-use plastics present themselves as both unsustainable long-term and a low-hanging fruit (compared with air travel) in terms of sourcing replacements, then it's reasonable that people would seek to make that small change independent of what is happening in the rest of their lives.
I find this trend of slapping "virtue signalling" on all but the most lofty goals to be a bit disingenuous. It must assume that there is one section of society that is empowered to make all of these changes and that by choosing to pursue single use plastics they suffer the opportunity cost of not developing an alternative means of rapid transport or improved environmental law enforcement.
A single-use-plastic tax which truly takes into consideration the cost of enforcement / cost to the environment and landfill / depletion of a finite resource would have the same effect, sure. I'm not convinced it would escape the "virtue signalling" label, though.
We need to do lots of things, this particular thing is easy to do so we should do it.
I don't buy the argument that because we aren't doing other things that we should not do this too.
You can use the same logic to never do anything at all.
The best thing about these bans is they are very visible and raise awareness, giving you the critical mass you need to solve other issues too.
I think it's more likely to reduce the chance of solving other issues because it uses up people's mental charity budget. Humans are not naturally utilitarian, and good causes compete with each other based on emotion. There's a huge risk of scenarios like this:
>Save the poor orphan puppies!
"Sure, they're cute. Take all the money."
>Repair the historic building!
"Eh, I guess it's important. Here's a small donation."
>Feed the starving children in Africa!
"Didn't we do that already? Not my problem."
>Prevent the death of billions through climate change!
"I'm sick of all these demands. I'm going to start rolling coal just to spite you."
We need to focus on numbers, not emotion, and the numbers don't justify the backlash.
Same way than having shorter circuits to reduce transport, or packaging at the end of the chain, or even smarter selling unpackaged good is a much smarter way to deal with transport pollution.
I love this backlash and I'm really happy to try to my small contribution
https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/06/90-of-plastic-polluti...
We would be way better of funding cleanup efforts in these rivers.
Plastic straws improve quality of life? Give me a break.
what about people who do neither.
Single use plastics are responsible for big savings in food waste and transport (which is still almost entirely fossil fuel based). They improve people's quality of life for a very small cost in oil. The only significant problem is a small minority of people disposing of them improperly, and the only reason people even care about that is because of emotive reporting showing dead animals (nobody cares about all the animals killed by air pollution and climate change).
The solution isn't banning single use plastics, it's enforcing existing laws against littering. Enforcement can be funded by a tax on the plastics.