News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by timwaagh on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @03:05PM (#20033255)
why are people so afraid of huawei? they are just a telco. they provide infrastructure. sure they can snoop on unencrypted traffic, but thats not their core business. so who cares if the 5g is american, russian or north-korean. if i were the us, i'd be afraid of 1. google and 2. facebook. their business is actually spying and selling that information. these know more about americans than any other company. they see data that is actually sensitive and encrypted. just because they are american companies, does not mean they will not leak to foreign intelligence entities. heck those are very likely on their client list already.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by elorant on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @03:39PM (#20033557)
Because they allegedly have strong ties to the Chinese government. So theoretically they could build backdoors to critical infrastructure used by ISPs and other network providers.

As for you main argument, we can worry both for Huaewei and Google/FB. It's not either or the other(s).

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by JohnJamesRambo on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @05:05PM (#20034399)
I don't think it is "strong ties to the Chinese government" as much as it is "literally the Chinese government." If you can imagine how uncomfortable other nations should be having the Chinese government running their next gen 5g telecom infrastructure everything makes a lot more sense. It's not just the USA that is refusing to use Huawei. Japan etc. have said hell no.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/zakdoffman/2019/04/20/cia-offer...

https://www.scmp.com/tech/tech-leaders-and-founders/article/...

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by anonymouslambda on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @05:09PM (#20034438)
So where is the actual evidence? Why won't the CIA present it publicly? Or should we just believe the CIA that it has this "evidence"?
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by merpnderp on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @05:48PM (#20034755)
There might not be any evidence. It might simply be the possibility of an update with backdoors/military payloads that gets pushed worldwide moments before a shooting war begins, or as a way to paralyze the world when negotiations become heated.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by DiogenesKynikos on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @08:53PM (#20035918)
Huawei is a private company. The logic of this argument is that no Chinese company whatsoever is reliable. There's literally nothing Huawei can possibly do to allay the fears of people who take this attitude.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by jorblumesea on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:22PM (#20036042)
I don't think anyone who knows anything about China believes "private company" means anything in that country. The founder was literally a PLA and a huge amount of private ventures have deep ties to both the CCP, either in funding, talent or both.

It's not a coincidence that APT steals IP and "somehow" Chinese companies have advanced 20 years in research.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by ssnistfajen on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:56PM (#20036223)
Ren Zhengfei retired from the PLA before he founded Huawei. I don't see people accusing companies founded by US veterans of being "literally the US government". Yes the PRC is a single-party authoritarian state, but it has a whole set of laws defining private companies vs state-owned enterprises.

The only concern about Huawei is that it cannot disobey Chinese government orders issued against Huawei's will. (Sounds familiar? All those companies that dropped Huawei due to an US government order? How so many were being apologists for Google because "Google didn't have a choice"?) Saying Huawei is "literally the Chinese government" without providing proof and asking us to simply follow the rhetoric by suspending all disbelief is a very lazy and dishonest tactic.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by powerapple on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @02:19AM (#20037282)
I believe. How many former PLA members in China right now? It is a job. How is it different from someone worked in U.S. Army before? It basically tells that you know nothing about China.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by throwaway557824 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @02:29AM (#20037333)
Huawei was looking to sell to Motorola, but then Motorola backed out.

I don’t think a company that is “literally the Chinese government” would be sold to a foreign company.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by DiogenesKynikos on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:29PM (#20036066)
"Private company" means a lot in China. The state-owned enterprises operate very differently from the privately owned businesses. Tencent and Alibaba are dramatically different from state-owned enterprises.

> The founder was literally a PLA

Along with literally millions of other Chinese people. Being in the PLA when he was young means next to nothing.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by asdff on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:59PM (#20036242)
My concern is that even if the boardroom in Huawei and every single employee all the way down operated in good faith, there is nothing from stopping the Chinese government from taking control of the technology if they wanted to. This is a government that is currently operating concentration camps.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by powerapple on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @02:22AM (#20037293)
The concern is legit. That's why Huawei is the most audited telecom equipment provider. Also that's why U.S. has hacked into Huawei years ago. I am pretty sure if there is anything, it would have surfaced years ago. In a way, the whole thing has made Huawei more reliable than other provider if you object monitoring from U.S. government.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by DiogenesKynikos on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:45PM (#20036459)
Every company is subject to pressure from their country's intelligence agencies. If an American company is ordered to spy on its customers, there's little it can do. This happened with Lavabit, which Edward Snowden used as an encrypted email provider. The US government forced the founder of Lavabit to hand over the website's SSL private key.

If you're afraid of a foreign country using its technology providers to spy on you, you have two options:

  1. Don't use technology from that country.
  2. Only use technology from that country that you are confident you can audit.
There's nothing Huawei can do, beyond what it's already done (offer to open up its tech for audits by foreign intelligence services), to allay the fundamental fears you're expressing. In the same manner, there's almost nothing American companies can do to allay the fears of foreigner countries (or US citizens, for that manner) that their tech won't be used by American intelligence agencies. The logical conclusion of this is that every country must develop its own technological base, and that's not a future I want to live in.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by xxgreg on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @06:11PM (#20034932)
Fixed that for you: "Because they have strong ties to the Chinese government. So they refuse to build backdoors for the NSA".
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by pergadad on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:45AM (#20038600)
There is a longform article on Huawei which I can't find right now, but essentially it suggested that Huawei's ultimate authority is a "workers committee" which ultimately is controlled in turn by the Party.

That said, it's really not a stretch. To give just one example: There are strong suggestions that Microsoft got NSA money to buy Skype, principally so that MS would revert Skype to a server-based model and take encryption out. Whether this case is true or not, it seems pretty certain that the US government makes use of national players. And it would be incredibly far fetched to even imagine the PRC not doing the same thing.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by T-A on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:08AM (#20038722)
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by hrktb on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @04:53PM (#20034285)
I am not sure about how we should feel about Huawei, but by this line of argument nobody could lay undersea cables or get anyone to use them.

From the article:

> The leader in the global undersea cable market is SubCom of the U.S. Japan's NEC and Europe's Alcatel-Lucent

Each of these have strong ties to their respective government and could build backdoors.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by est on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:13PM (#20036318)
> Because they allegedly have strong ties to the Chinese government

Do you know which telco companies have more connections to the Chinese government? Every other Chinese company. Even Foxconn which manufactures your iDevice has Communist representatives in their management.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by rb808 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @05:48PM (#20034758)
Someone posted this link the other day. https://zeihan.com/my-way-or-the-huawei/.

If enough people have a cold war mentality strategically it makes some sense. Combined with the chance to annoy the Chinese govt in the middle of a trade war, Trump will love it.

Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by spectramax on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @03:36PM (#20033535)
I think you forgot about the Chinese government who is interested in siphoning and censoring information.
Re:Huawei’s Ace in the Hole: Undersea Cables by anonymouslambda on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @05:07PM (#20034412)
Yes, here is the voluminous evidence that we have presented that Huawei spies for the Chinese government. /s

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_surveillance_disclosure...