A world where we buy endless cheap junk from China and ship cash out of the country to pay for it is far richer one for everyone[1] than one in which we need to make all the junk at our labor rates. Why? Because all that cash is coming right back into the country as investments.
It's like shopping at a store which decides the best use of their income is to lend it right back to you so you can buy more stuff.
[1] Especially the chinese, of course, who have lifted their nation out of abject poverty in barely over half a century. But we win here too relative to the isolationist scenario.
That's video game logic.
My alternative point was that an authoritarian yet peaceful government is less a threat to humanity than Mao's genocide-scale famine. The chinese are oppressed, the PRC is an unfair dealer on the world stage, yet this is still a preferable situation to watching literally a billion people starve. The PRC government can be simultaneously the larges geopolitical "threat" to the world community and the architected of the single greatest improvement in the human condition of the last century.
The world is complicated, and not easily reduced to buckets of good guys and bad guys.
This is rich. In modern times, how often has China intervened in the affairs of a foreign state? I am writing this from America btw.
Often. North Korea on a regular basis, Vietnam, their relations with Taiwan are a mess that needs books to cover, and their relationship with Russia over Russia's eastern border is, at best, unpleasant. I'm sure a little google-fu would reveal more. They're a world power. Interfering with other countries is part of that package.
This does not automatically follow--and, in fact, I would argue against it.
GE had to "insource" their hot water heater manufacturing to continue to wring out cost savings--and discovered that they had forgotten how to design and build hot water heaters.
That is fairly strong evidence that keeping this stuff in China benefits China to the detriment of other countries.
I am okay for paying a not insignificant amount extra on my goods to keep the knowledge of how to make them in the domestic area.
To what products does this logic not apply? What do you consider "domestic"? This sounds like an argument against the whole idea of trade in the abstract[1].
The basis of the theory of trade, frankly the whole point of trading at all, is that some people can make or get stuff more cheaply than other people, and that by "trading" those items with people who need them for stuff we want we all win.
I mean, fine. If you don't believe macroeconomics, I guess I can't do anything to convince you. Just recognize that, well, you sound absolutely crazy. This is flat earth scale nuttery.
[1] It's not, of course. And the "domestic" is the giveaway. You don't like foreigners getting uppity, and you're willing to comparatively impoverish yourself to keep them down. I, for one, am horrified at the oppressive antics of the PRC but still think that the last few decades of growth are a good trade relative to the literal famine of the 60's.
I'll bite that bullet. I don't believe macroeconomics. Microeconomics is pretty solid; that's the part of the field that's actually grounded in reality. Macroeconomics is like SETI; in the absence of the ability to carry out much in the way of meaningful experiments, it's mostly people just taking what we emotionally want to believe, and garnishing it with equations until it tastes like science.
That is a strawman against the argument and not brought forward in good faith. And macroeconomics does include the reality of countries using taxes to create a disincentive for consumption. Just like they do for domestic markets. There are a lot of these taxes in place from both sides.
Not saying the employment of taxes is generally a good idea. I wouldn't think they are with the intention to limit technology transfer, but there are certainly valid reasons.
If your base assumptions are wrong you can be very wrong in very consequential ways for a very long time. Economic specialisation as an inherently positive process is in fact a higly dubious propostion[0].
> The more specialised a country is, the higher its welfare will be, and specialisation via free trade will promote growth in all countries... It is a beautiful story. Unfortunately, disinterested empirical research by data scientists strongly suggests that it is in fact a fantasy: the wealthiest countries are not the most specialised economies, but the most diversified.
[0] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318021429_Trade_and...
Again, this is textbook macroeconomics that no one seriously argues with. It's possible to make an argument for a specific externality about a specific product or market (trade in Europe vis a vis UK exit from the EU, or the example above which was, hilariously, home appliances), it's absolutely insane to try to generalize that to "we shouldn't trade for anything we can make ourselves".
Key drivers of the economy, like housing, exist in their present form to due explicit and implicit subsidy. I think China is more like the US then we care to admit, except they think on a longer timescale.
If you add in the GDP component of the financial and defense industries, you are looking at a massive overhead of markets managed by implicit or explicit government enforcement (or lack of it) for the benefit of a small elite. This is similar to China, but the Chinese have strategic vision for their economy; in the US it is managed by random allocation of lobbyist dollars.
This is not true.
To construe 'finance' a just some arguably unnecessary or inefficient 'overhead' in the economy belies a basic lack understanding of what that industry actually does.
It's often opaque to outsiders, but banking is a real value creating part of the economy, and it's also right at the foundation of it.
Also, 'defence spending' is a normal part of every economy, and it has existential impact for all of us.
Consider for a moment that US forces keep most international waterways open for everyone to use, even economic rivals, and even military rivals (!) so long as there's no war. The Suez Canal, Panama Canal, and other critical areas would instantly be under the control of nefarious regional forces if there were a power vacuum.
Now, the US has an overt policy of controlling what interest rate is charged.
So the banking system is a free market in the sense that theoretically participants could choose to leave if they wanted to. However, there is also a very overt layer of government decision making and control. The government putting a finger on the scale in a very fundamental way.
Exactly how that compares to China is difficult to judge - whatever it is, I argue it isn't very capitalistic. Capitalists are supposed to go broke when they lose money and given how low interest rates are they are more likely to refinance themselves with a new loan. The damage that has been doing to wealth creation since the GFC in around '08 is profound.
It is hard to say how much worse China's approach is. It isn't as clear cut as China's Government vs 10,000s of Capitalists - in which case I'd favour capitalism by the numbers. The US government is hamstringing the ability of its own economy to organise around profitable ventures. Instead it is encouraging Ubers and Lyfts.
You say this as if China were innocent in manipulating banks to control their banking system. This is not true. [1]
>The US government is hamstringing the ability of its own economy to organise around profitable ventures. Instead it is encouraging Ubers and Lyfts.
I disagree with this. I believe the Ubers and Lyfts (and Teslas) are caused by investors wanting to get in on the ground floor of the next Apple. To support your argument, please explain how the US Government is preventing its own economy to organize around profitable ventures. You may use citations.
1. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/22/china-banks-record-lending-s...
My gosh man, healthcare is going to be 1/3 of the world's economy in 30 years anyhow, as we all get a little older.
Insurance is a financial product which we have a hard time thinking about in tangible terms, but it's generally very value creating.
And so is education, often. FYI US exports about $25B a year in Education to foreign students.
China is rocking hard because of the wake we're leaving.
I can ask the same thing about any other country. What is truly unique? Eben the nuclear bomb involved atomic theories that were developed in Europe.
Just look at the first one: papyrus was in use for nearly 5000 (five thousand!) years in Ancient Egypt and all over the Mediterranean before paper was conveniently invented by Cai Lun.
The term paper itself is actually derives from "papyrus".
It's really not any different with the rest of those claims.
Is it that paper is not an improvement over papyrus? This clearly does not stand.
Or that paper was not invented in China but in the classical world? This is contradicted by archaeological evidence.
Or that somehow the fact that the word paper is derived from papyrus in English means that it was invented by the west?
It really amounts to claiming to have invented the entire field of metalworking, when all that's invented is the casting process, whereas everyone was using forging techniques before then.
Disingenuous.
It's very difficult to see what you're actually trying to argue here. Chinese civilization generated a large number of important inventions, including (but obviously not limited to) the stirrup, paper, gunpowder, silk, the compass and paper money. It's about as silly to try to deny this contribution as it would be to deny the contribution of the Greeks to civilization.
I always find it funny/sad that Easterners in addition to suriving the crimes, have the extra task of educating the Western populations of the crimes committed in their names.
I expect you've noticed that every single country that is a victim of modern Chinese espionage was directly involved in destroying the chinese economy during the 19th to early 20th century.
US, UK, Japan, France, Germany, Russia (a few of the top offenders).
These nations can't simply commit a bunch of crimes, get rich, change the rules, then expect to be protected from past actions.
They do it all the time. When will the Chinese Communist Party pay for the famine which killed 2-6% of the population (lower bound is based on official government figures)? Probably never is when.
Right now the US administration is limiting the trade talk within trade talk, avoiding politics. However, if the trade talk really falls apart, I have no doubt the conflict will escalate and politics will be openly involved.
Sanctioning china for "values" is as absurd as china sanctioning the US for "values". How would everyone react to china sanctioning the US or Europe for invading much of the middle east and north africa. Everyone would laugh.
Also, sanctions are acts of war at best and war crimes at worst. Economic sanctions exist to starve and hurt the population to punish the government. By any objective measure, it is a war crime and crime against humanity. "Luckily", rules and laws don't apply those with the greatest weapons.
Also, I highly doubt most of china's people would side with the US against their own government. No more than we'd side with China over the US government. That's not how people work. Especially if foreign government are attacking your own government.
Either we go to war with them or we decide to live with them. China has 1.4 billion people. The idea that we'd pressure them to act a certain way is ludicrous. More than anything, it'd probably have the opposite effect.
Every week there's another article about a new way Chinese citizens are circumventing their government's censorship. Nobody likes being kept under heel. And I seriously doubt the concentration camps would have widespread support - most likely their existence is censored from the rest of the population altogether.
They wouldn't be siding against their own government, they'd be siding against the authoritarian communist party. They'd be choosing things they really want (economic growth) in exchange for the ending of actions they either don't care about or dislike. The CP is already in a precarious balance, trying to maintain strength without turning the general population against them. Some in China already wish it would bend to the sanctions. The above kind of deal would raise the pressure on the party, weakening the tumor sitting on top of a major new contributor to the world economy.
But I agree with you about nobody wanting to be kept under anyone's heel. Do you know any chinese history? Do you know whose heel's they think they've been under for 200 years? The west's heel. Nationalism and economic growth is how the chinese government maintains power and I don't see that changing anytime soon.
As for the "concentration camps", I'm guessing the support depends on how it is framed. If the chinese government frames it as punishing separatist terrorists, I'm betting it will have as much support as japanese internment had in the US.
Also, the authoritarian communist party is their government whether you like it or not. Considering the economic growth that china has experienced, I'm betting the party and the government has enormous support amongst the population. And in any confrontation with a foreign government, the people almost always rally around their government - authoritarian or not.
Finally, "some" in china might want their government to "bend to the sanctions", but I'm guessing the vast majority of chinese don't. Also, historically, governments tend to fall when they appear weak, especially in relation to a foreign power. Also, you are conveniently ignoring the fact that there are "some" in the US who think we should "bend to their sanctions".
If you think that chinese people are going to side with a foreign government against their own ( authoritarian or not ), then you really don't know history or human nature.
I don't know what you're talking about; the US is the least-censored country on earth. You can't even pull provable, inflammatory falsehoods off of Facebook without people crying censorship here (which is its own problem).
> there have been articles of china's demise for decades now
I'm not talking about its demise. Quite the opposite. I'm talking about its people being smarter and more worldly than they get credit for, despite president Xi's very best efforts to the contrary. It has academics who are regularly imprisoned for criticizing the government and advocating for personal liberty. Scores of people cheat around the latest propaganda app (https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/07/world/asia/china-xi-jinpi...). People use GitHub, for lack of better options, to exercise some small amount of free speech (https://www.npr.org/2019/04/10/709490855/github-has-become-a...).
There's a will. Chinese people don't want this kind of country. Many of them have just given up fighting it. We could help.
> I'm betting it will have as much support as japanese internment had in the US
Japanese internment has been looked back upon as one of the greatest human rights transgressions the U.S. has ever committed. It wasn't at the time, of course, but that can't be helped. It's also beside the point. I'm not saying "America is good and China is bad". I'm only saying, Xi's ruling party is bad. America has done some bad things too. It's still doing some bad things, like what's happening at the southern border.
Maybe what you don't grasp is that Americans are free to criticize their own government. We can have our own sets of values. I have a pretty low view of my own country right now. That doesn't mean I can't also point out China's problems and America's opportunity to do something about them. Of course, I also have very little faith in my government to take that kind of opportunity right now.
Once again, you harp on censorship. I'm against it too. But what does that have to do with what we are talking about? I don't like censorship in the US but that doesn't mean I'm going to support the chinese government over the US government. For some strange reason, you seem to believe that just because people don't like their own government, they'll support foreign governments. That's not how life works. Every citizen in every country has gripes against their government, but that doesn't mean they would welcome foreign intervention in their own country.
And if the chinese people don't like their government then let them deal with it. Not sure who you are or what your agenda is that you think "we could help". Who are "we" that we have to interfere in other countries?
I'm american. I complain about the government, the establishment press and censorship all the time. What are you? You seem to claim to be american but want to "help" the chinese people overthrow their government. And for someone who claims to be american, you seem to claim to know how the chinese think and want. I suspect chinese people know what chinese people think and want. It's as strange as a chinese person saying they know what americans think and want. How would they know?
Moralising is a habit of those who lack the strength and/or will to get what they desire through other means. The West dethroned its warriors and elevated its priests; China is dethroning its priests and raising up its warriors. Time will tell which class of leader shall overcome, but history is pretty clear about what kind of societies rise or fall.
> Moralising is a habit of those who lack the strength and/or will to get what they desire through other means.
America isn't a very good world citizen in 2019. I honestly wouldn't take issue with a different world power taking the lead if its ruling party weren't even worse. But rest assured, the people in charge of China right now are indeed worse. And my own country's problems don't change the atrocities that they commit.
Socialism is a deeply religious belief. It has its priests (professors, journalists, entertainers), its churches (campuses, museums, protests and benefit rallies as outdoor/big tent revival analog), its core beliefs predicated on faith that unite the fervent and ostracize the skeptical (diversity is always beneficial, climate change is the fault of the successful, racism is original sin, privilege creates winners and losers in spite of actual value, religions of the oppressed are blameless, etc.), and its intangible and perpetually just beyond The horizon utopia. In every important way, socialism is a religion. It has a general hate for "gods" which functions as a smoke screen for the incorporation of American Protestantism into its modern day Progressive skin suit.
You can see the energy of the faithful when technical questions are provided emotional responses, when differing opinions about generalities are met with personal assertions regarding psychological well being ('burn the hetetic' transmogrified into 'you need medical attention because you have (x)-pathy), and, always everpresent in Leftward arguments,appeals to authority that the one appealing doesn't recognize.
US-style “democratic socialism” isn't consistently, except perhaps from a cladistic viewpoint; a lot of it is substantively social democracy which is more of an ideological commitment to the modern mixed economy then an actual socialism.
> and socialism always finds a way to murder people and increase poverty in the name of equality.
I think (assuming you are arguing in good faith) you are falsely generalizing from Leninism and it's descendants with socialism. While at least cladistically a subset of socialism, Leninism and it's offshoots is a narrower and particular subset from which generalizations about the broader set cannot validly be drawn.
> Socialism is a deeply religious belief
No more or less than capitalism is.
>isn't consistently This is the beautiful thing about socialism. It need not be perfect, or even dominant. It just needs a foothold. From there, it is purely a game of time. Put another way, socialists wait for other viewpoints to come around to theirs (Christianity, Academe, Business) or disappear. They do not become Less Left.
>cladistic Ah. See you too are a person of depth. Yarvin's work on the neo-Protestant clade is exceptional but not for the faint of heart. I recommend Spandrell's Bioleninism piece.
>falsely generalizing A salient point. Where are the gulags of the social democrats? Where are the legions of thought police? Where are the desperate informers turning in their neighbors? I know this will be an ugly statement, but I believe the mass murder inclination of socialists is more than saitiated by rampant abortion. It fulfills the same methods and motivations of Holdomer and any other incident of mass death from Lenin or Stalin or Pot or Mao; the greater good. People often forget that the motivations behind the mass death perpetrated by these men and, more importantly, their regimes always had a logical source, for some definition of logic. Socialism doesn't cause mass murder; it justifies it. And to the socialist society, the justification is always good.
>socialist religiosity So what? Capitalism is faith in the selfishness of man. Socialism is faith in the rightness of good. Cargo Cults use the same parts of their brains for reasoning as Catholics. The question, for me, is not the How, but the What. More directly, To What End and For What Purpose. Objectively, the merit of capitalism vs. the merits of socialism a matter of historical record. Put another way, the same god concept that causes a genocide can also cause, quite literally, science. Equivocation has its value, but in the frame of your chosen context it is relatively valueless.
I point out the religiosity of socialism not to say it is singular, rather to demonstrate that it is typical.
Disagree. Capitalism is faith in the fairness of man. Each person in a capitalistic society has the same opportunity to take advantage of the free market and create their own wealth in a way that doesn't infringe upon the rights of the rest of the people in that society. These rights are guaranteed by the society, regardless of person.
Socialism (such as that in China) does not afford its citizens such equal rights. In fact, the Chinese government has very recently instituted controls which allow them to have a high degree of control over the rights a particular Chinese citizen can exercise. These rights are allowed, regarding person.
> In 2014, former CIA and NSA director Michael Hayden said in a public debate, “We kill people based on metadata.”
> According to multiple reports and leaks, death-by-metadata could be triggered, without even knowing the target’s name, if too many derogatory checks appear on their profile. “Armed military aged males” exhibiting suspicious behavior in the wrong place can become targets, as can someone “seen to be giving out orders.” Such mathematics-based assassinations have come to be known as “signature strikes.”
1. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/how-...
What are the aspects of the current economic relationship with China that are beneficial to the US, and what are the aspects that are harmful.
What policies should it adopt to manage its relationships with China while maintaining its values. Whether it should act unilaterally to achieve those objectives, or coordinate with its allies.
What are the near-term and long-term consequences of Cooperating with China vs. Competing with China in a new cold war, considering China's power will likely rise in comparison with the US's.